The Truth About Soy

The Dangers of Soy Diet

Soy - The Antinutrient

I've seen so much hype about Soy recently claiming to be the "vegetarian protein savior."

Independent researchers paint a different picture of the innocent soy bean. I will extract the excerpts from studies which include the researcher and the institution.

Some Soy History

In November, 1999, the Third International Soy Symposium was held in Washington, D.C., sponsored by the United Soybean Board, American Soybean Association, Monsanto, Protein Technologies International, Central Soya, Cargil Foods, Personal Products Company, SoyLife, Whitehall-Robins Health-care and the soybean councils of Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota, Nebraska, Ohio and South Dakota.

Presentations by scientists funded by these organizations marked the culmination of a decade of research intended to win FDA approval and consumer acceptance of soy products such as tofu, soy milk, soy cheese, soy sausage, and estrogen-like compounds including isoflavones, genistein and diadzen.

As we all know the FDA has got our backs and has everything under control. You also know that big business has no influence what so ever on this agency (does it stink yet). Anyway, review some of the facts and judge for yourself if Soy is worth it.

Dr. Francis Crinella at the University of California described how the soybean plant lifts up manganese in the soil and concentrates it, creating levels of manganese in soy formulas that are 200 times the level found in breast milk.

A newborn cannot excrete this extreme manganese load, creating high manganese levels in the blood, liver, kidneys and other soft tissues of the body, including the brain. Manganese overload has been implicated in cases of brain damage and movement disorders.

Dr. Joseph Mercola notes in his newsletter that soy formulas contain high levels of aluminum (1,000% higher levels than cow’s milk formulas) and the phytoestrogen substance isoflavones. He says that a soy-fed baby receives the equivalent of five birth control pills’ worth of estrogen every day. These babies’ isoflavone levels were found to be from 13,000 to 22,000 times higher than in non-soy fed infants. Early onset of puberty in girls and abnormal development of testes in boys have been linked to this unnatural surge of hormones in early life

Irvine C, Fitzpatrick M, Robertson I and Woodhams D (1995). The Potential Adverse Effects of Soybean Phytoestrogens in Infant Feeding. NZ Med J, 108: 208-209.

More Reading

There are always two sides to every story. You must decide for yourself who is right and who is wrong.

But historically, when companies try to mass produce a product for profit, the priority for health always seems to get lost in the shuffle. I guess when you are trying to manufacture a product for mass consumption a few casualties is to be expected.

If you search Google you will find studies and articles that will keep you busy for years - good luck!

Searching for Good Things About Soy

Americans began adding more soy to their diets in recent years because scientific studies suggest that various soy products offer possible health benefits. These benefits include the lowering of cholesterol and reducing the risk of heart disease.

However, soy health claims are not necessarily applicable to all soy foods – just foods containing soy protein.

Therefore, only foods identified as containing "whole soy" or foods that specify soy protein, are likely to offer these health benefits.

Research is continuing on the health effects of isoflavones, one of the naturally occurring chemicals found in soy beans. It’s important to note that some people may be allergic to soy bean products.

Can Soy Reduce Cholesterol and Heart Tissue Deterioration?

In countries with high soy intake the rates of cardiovascular diseases is relatively low.

Research suggests that soy may help to prevent heart disease by reducing total cholesterol, low density lipoprotein cholesterol and preventing plaque buildup in the arteries, which could lead to stroke or heart attack.

These health benefits are also mainly attributes to the soy isoflavones and saponins. The soy isoflavone genistein may increase the flexibility of blood vessels, whereas saponins may have potential to reduce blood cholesterol.

So there you have it. The pros and cons of the soy bean. We hope you will continue the quest for the truth about soy. I guess if this were the only problem we had when it came to what to and what not to eat life would be good, but it's just another debate among many out there in food land.

For more relevant Health information visit the Health Hub.

More by this Author


Comments 9 comments

Just_Rodney profile image

Just_Rodney 8 years ago from Johannesberg South Africa, The Gold Mine City

RB11, that is why most Naturopaths specifically do not include Soy or Soy products as part of any diet.


rb77 profile image

rb77 8 years ago from Las Vegas

Nice to hear from you Rodney. That's the impression I get the research data points to more bad than good, but the lobby dollars have taken the FDA and public the other way. Hope all is well.


Just_Rodney profile image

Just_Rodney 8 years ago from Johannesberg South Africa, The Gold Mine City

RB, Yes all is well and I am starting to function again. The power of the dollar is amazing. Research can be bent to to go the way funding wants it to.


Gypsy Willow profile image

Gypsy Willow 7 years ago from Lake Tahoe Nevada USA , Wales UK and Taupo New Zealand

OMG thanks for enlightening me. I always thought soy was the wonder food. Thank goodness I didn't go down that path.


rb11 profile image

rb11 7 years ago from Las Vegas Author

Marketing is very powerful and this seems to be one area that everyone should look at deeper. Thanks


bassfishingguide profile image

bassfishingguide 6 years ago from Somewhere in the US

Great article rb11. I think that is important to mention that organically processed soy doesn't utilize hexane or any petroleum derivative. I was sick to find out that Silk doesn't produce the organic type anymore in tune of higher profits, as referenced in the book Organic, Inc. I also wrote an article about the things we didn't know about soy.


rb11 profile image

rb11 6 years ago from Las Vegas Author

Thanks, money these days overrides much of what made for a better quality of life.


NME profile image

NME 5 years ago

"Marketing is very powerful and this seems to be one area that everyone should look at deeper"

Are you suggesting that the folks who would rather see soy dissapear from supermarket shelves (e.g. The National Dairy Council, National Cattlemen's Beef Association, etc) do not have an influence on the FDA?!?

Are you also suggesting, the foods that soy is replacing (beef, milk, chicken, etc) are better for you and the earth than soy products?

Just askin'


rb11 profile image

rb11 5 years ago from Las Vegas Author

NME, There are a lot of genetically altered foods these days and for a variety of reasons, one is profits. Soy is just one of them, it's really about awareness in what we ingest for the sole purpose of staying healthy.

NME, Thanks for the comments.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working