I have asked on a few occasions what %-age of abortions was a real medical need, versus convenience. No answers were ever given.
Here are some interesting numbers.
http://www.johnstonsarchive.net/policy/ … asons.html
Loosely translated, it's about 7% (real need) and 93% convenience.
(Just in case anyone else was curious.)
I think you need to reexamine your definition of convenience.
Does the woman have a stable life of her own so she can be a good mother? Does she have steady income so she can provide basic necessities for her child? Will the woman be rejected by her family because of religious beliefs?
Raising a child is not simply a matter of convenience. Making the decision to keep a pregnancy is something that will affect the rest of the womans life and the life of the child, and any children that child has. There is a proven correlation between poverty, crime, drug abuse, and a host of other social ills. If a woman doesn't want to bring a child into a bad situation that should be her choice.
I doubt abortion is ever an easy choice. I wonder if those who are so ready to judge are as quick to put their hands in their pockets to help young women struggling to bring up their children in poverty.
how is any of that deemed medically necessary?
I'm really disapointed the numbers aren't even close to any level of sanity. Thanks for the reference I can't believe this is the way Americans behave, shame on all of us.
the stats are stagering its a shame . a quote for the pro choice ladys out there. youve came a long way baby
Okay. You asked and answered your own question. the hub is finished.
And why is that a surprise?
Humans tend to do things for convenience.
With all the birth control methods avalable, using abortion for conveniance is wrong
I am 100% pro-choice, but abortion should be the last resort not the first choice.
Take a look at http://hubpages.com/hub/the-romanian-tragedy
Are you crazy! Adoption way worse than abortion! We don't want good stable homes to have kids unless they can do it themselves!
yes i could have been aborted but instead my biological mother put me up for adoption and i got two very loving caring parents
Being a birth mother is not easy, but to hear adoptees who have two loving and caring parents, it sure does help. You have no idea how glad I am for you to have your family. Thank you for sharing that, Holly
yeah i'm just gald i found some1 to agree with me it seems like everybody just wants to abort and it saddens me to think that it could have been me that missed out on an awesome life
my biological mom was 18 when she had me and was getting ready to go to college and didn't know what to do but like i said earlier luckily i was adopted
Yeah God bless both of you. The amount of abortions is just sad. When you consider that a lot of families in North America have to adopt from Russia or China you kind of wonder why there are so many abortions here. A friend had to travel to Russia four times before bringing home a little girl. Do you think organizations like Planned Parenthood are talking them into getting abortions? If so your groups help for young women could be a Godsend Holly.
If Teens were counselled before having abortions, the figures might drop.
Teens see things short-term. There are lots of people who have had abortions and later in life wish they never, ever did it.
If only they had someone to talk to at the time.
Sure, adoption is an option, but you still have to live with the pregnancy, which is exactly what they don't want - everyone to know they are having a baby they don't want.
I'm NOT saying this is always the case, but in some cases. There are lots of reasons women have for having an abortion and I understand that.
I don't think anyone has a problem with adoption. I can see where it would be a difficult choice for a woman - to carry a child for 9 months and then give up the baby to someone you don't know? Sounds like a nightmare to me.
My problem is with the idea that abortions are 'convenient'. LOL!
Instead of yammering about how horrible abortion is, why don't we all try to eliminate the things that make women want to have abortions: poverty, drug abuse, lack of education/opportunities, etc.
I think that if every woman in this country knew that her baby would have proper healthcare and nutrition, a good education, and opportunities then abortions would go way down.
How about we promote good moral behavior and abstinence? Abortion is a crummy solution to a behavior that should be with in the control of a reasonable person.
I think that word covers the reasons given for the 93%.
It certainly would not be appropriate to call them necessary essential or unavoidable.
What word would you "classify" them under?
Why don't you put yourself in the shoes of a 16 year old pregnant girl, or an unmarried woman with no job prospects, or a woman who already has three kids and is struggling to make the mortgage payment every month.
Convenient? I think not.
You didn't answer my question.
What alternative word would better describe the 93%?
No matter what the (above) circumstances you quote, it's the baby that pays with it's life (forfeited) to minimize the inconvenience/discomfort/expense (whatever) of the situation.
Is the price worth it?
I think NOT.
Quite apart from the teen mother, or the drug-addicted hooker, or the newly widowed army wife, or the desparate girl raped by her father, who else did you think would find abortion a matter of 'convenience'? Life isn't always black and white. Life isn't always a bed of roses. Sometimes it's a long, hard, unrelenting grind. It's easy to pass judgement, or to talk glibly about adoption.
I admit there is a lack of support for women/girls who find themselves pregnant when it is inconvenient, but the choice for adoption is an acceptable option.
When I was a sophmore I became pregnant and the father walked when I was 3 months along. Difficult as it was, I released that child for adoption. It has been 28 years, almost 29, but we both survived my inconvenient pregnany.
Through the years I have volunteered with crisis pregnancy centers speaking with those who are inconveniently pregnant. Mostly they want to know if only a monster to give up her child, or how you cope with it years down the road. I tell them you wonder and you cry. I share with them that we both lived and try to help them choose adoption.
I have met girls who have had two or three abortions and they are so wounded and emotionally scarred having used abortion as their means of birth control.
Do I think abortion is always the wrong answer - I don't know. But I believe releasing for adoption has more survivors.
Just my opinion, Holly
You might be surprised to know that some married women get abortions too.
I ran into these statistics the other day. I found them interesting.
I found it kind of disappointing that the majority of abortions are performed on women over 20 and that only 17% are done on teen girls. (which is the group you'd think may not be mature enough to make good and sure no unwanted pregnancy occurs.
As far as adoption goes, I'm an adoptive mother; and I'm pretty proud of, and sure of, the kind of childhood/relationship with me my son has had (so you'd think I think adoption is great (which, in ways I do). Still, I've also had two children myself; and there's no way in "heck" I'd ever, ever, give away a baby I had. What an absolute "horrow show", and there would be no way to know how good the adoptive parents might be. It would just be real good if women would do a better job of making sure no unwanted pregnancy occurs. It isn't that difficult.
so better to kill it than let yourself suffer good idea
That's what you got from what I said? I just said it isn't that difficult to make good and sure no "accidents" happen. The grief that many birth mothers go through lasts for a lifetime, and many adoptees who get parents who just don't know how to manage to help them feel "solid" about being adopted go through a lifetime of mental turmoil as well. I'm guessing you haven't experienced the grief of being separated from children you have given birth to. I do, although the separation only involved their being brought out of the area by their father, who fought me for custody. I worked for over 25 years to figure out the answers to the learning problems my son (the adopted one) had in school because he had a skull fracture and a bad prenatal environment from his birth mother. Needless to say I don't think his birth mother should have aborted, by any means; but the only reason he was spared more effects of her rotten "mothering" was that he was taken away from her after he was abandoned by her. So, he got a loving mother when he was adopted; but not all adopted children do. If his birth mother had any unplanned pregnancies, I'm not sure other children (yes, all worked out well for him, but that same may not have happened if she went on and had other babies that the state didn't know about before she cracked their skull too). wouldn't have been better off if they were aborted when she was 8 weeks along.
yes that is all i got because what about when those kids who grow up have better lives and thats all i could think about.
i mean sure u have an excruciating painful childhood but then you grow up and make something out of yourself that is what life is about making something out of yourself look at all the celebrities that made something out of their terrible lives.
and yes i forgot to comment about the protection aspect and completely agree with you it's not hard to avoid these kind of accidental pregnancys and if your going to do it unprotected anyway then you'll just have to pay the consequences because that is also a part of life. just like driving while drunk you really can't stop people from doing it but you can make them pay the consequences in jail for killing that family while doing it do you follow me? i think i'm just ranting now so i should just post this and stay out of topics like this cause no1 wants to hear my opinions anyway
please don't take my above post to mean that any1 who aborts should go to jail cause thats not what i meant at all i was just comparing things
Well that is the point I was making pylos26. Families are having too hard of a problem adopting children in North America. That's why they have to adopt kids from Russia or China.
I just keep on thinking that the fee paid by those countries might have something to do with it. there is absolutely no reason people cannot adopt in america...unless of course they are of questionable character.
There is no fee paid by those countries like Russia or China. It's just the opposite, families have to pay to get them out of there. My friends are not of questionable character by any means. Of the two that come to mind one is a fire chief and the other is an accountant. One family adopted from China and the other from Russia because it was too hard here in North America. The list to adopt here is endless because of so many abortions.
Well then!!! you didn't say that in the beginning!!!...a fireman and an accountant...not possble for those guys to be anything except pillars of the community.
by Amber Musselman7 years ago
OKAY... SO I WROTE A HUB ON ABORTION AND TIMOTHY LEFT A COMMENT (BELOW)AFTER THAT COMMENT IS MY RESPONSE----- TELL ME WHAT YOU THINK AND WHO DO YOU AGREE WITH!! timothy Carpenter says:I...
by LailaK5 years ago
The 2012 presidential election is approaching! Do you think that the new presidential candidates should support or ban abortion for women of all ages? Why?
by Scott Bateman8 months ago
The abortion debate is dominated by two extremes. On the one side, "pro life" extremists insist that abortion is murder. On the other side, "pro choice" extremists insist that abortion is a personal...
by Grace Marguerite Williams3 years ago
According to Huffington Post and Reuters, the Kansas House of Representatives passed a bill on Friday, April 5, 2013 on a 90/30 vote declaring that "life" now begins at fertilization. This is after the...
by Jackie Lynnley4 months ago
I read this was true and I just have to know if it is, please! Please provide links to prove what you say. Surely we are not going to be aborting babies ready to come into the world fully developed and healthy?
by Holle Abee4 years ago
What do you think? Do you think it's okay to wait until you're far enough along in a pregnancy to see if you're carrying a male or a female? And if it's not what you want, get an abortion for that reason alone? I could...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.