jump to last post 1-4 of 4 discussions (9 posts)

Gyms and diets don't want you to lose weight, permanently.

  1. spellbinderdk profile image60
    spellbinderdkposted 4 years ago

    Fitness centers and diets do not want you to lose weight, permanently. They want you to lose a little and then gain it again. So you'll have to keep going to the gym or dietitian. Therefore, they make a cure / program that is hard to follow. So there is a greater chance that you fail it, and gain weight again. Then you must return to them, pay them money and try again.
    The simplest way to lose weight ...? Get more muscle, so you consumers more energy, constant, and that makes it easier to lose weight and keep the weight down, permanently.
    The only persons that cares more about diet than girls, is bodybuilders. Ask them for help, and they will tell you how to stay slim.

    1. MayG profile image85
      MayGposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Hello spellbinderdk.  I'm sorry, but I don't agree with your incredibly generalised attack on fitness centres and diets  for a minute. 

      I think fitness centres want people to become addicted to exercise, for it to become part of their life, so they keep coming back.  They want people to make it a routine, so they keep renewing their membership.  They don't assume that the minute people lose enough weight they're going to stop going.
      As for diets and dietitians- the success and reputation of a dietitian depends on people successfully losing weight and keeping it off.  Not that I'm a fan of dieting anyway, I much prefer the idea of healthy eating and increased exercise - including building muscle as you mention above, but I couldn't let your comment about fitness centres and diets go without disagreeing!

      I battled with a few extra pounds through my late teens and early twenties (even though I walked A LOT) until I started doing weights at the gym and the extra weight literally fell away, and so I do agree with your advice about building more muscle.  Although I'm not convinced this works for everybody - I think different body types can respond to different things.

    2. lav-senior profile image60
      lav-seniorposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Hi Spelbinderdk.
      I just want to say something really quickly about weight loss and fitness- it's not down to the gyms or dieticians mentality as to how someone's weight loss is maintained, it's down to the individual. Sometimes people lose weight and they forget how easily it is to regain it and accidentally and usually quite gradually fall back to their old habits which caused them to gain weight in the first place hence causing the yo-yo dieter.
      The only person's behaviour you can control is your own and that extends to blame and passing books.

  2. ftclick profile image60
    ftclickposted 4 years ago

    People you can simply cross-train or do other outdoor activities that require some type of physical ability and you won't need the gym.
    run in the sand, take hikes, bike, jog, tennis, long walks, dance, yoga, martial arts, etc.
    They do want you to stay fit since you are so much better off. From the gist of some comments it sounds like you leaning towards being sedentary. We can't be glued to our PCs, laptops, x-boxes all the time. This is one reason why the USA is increasingly obese. More fatty foods and being less active.
    I used to go to the gym but now do exercise at home or take a nice walk.

    Bottomline is if you want to take care of your body, there are plenty of other ways than a gym. I do think the personal trainers are trying to drill that necessity into you though.I  agree it is an individual thing too. Some people gain or lose weight faster than others.

    1. spellbinderdk profile image60
      spellbinderdkposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      The easiest way to lose weight, is to gain more muscle mass.
      Instead of exercise 3 hours or more very week, for the rest of your life.
      Use 2x30 minutes a week for a month or two, building up your muscle.
      And then just use 30 minutes a week keeping your muscle mass.
      The more muscle mass you have, the more energy you use being alive.
      But the gyms keep it a secret, so you have to keep training and paying them.

      1. jclaffee profile image83
        jclaffeeposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Exercise is only part of it. No exercise plan is capable of compensating for bad eating habits. Get your eating under control first, then work out a varied exercise routine that prioritizes compound movements.

    2. talfonso profile image89
      talfonsoposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      ftclick, I agree with you - I exercise at home. I do weights and speedwalking/brisk walking intervals. I also do a program called Oxycise!. Most people lost weight, inches, or both using it exclusively, but I mainly do it for stress relief (which is much needed because I'm caring for an ailing relative) and core strength. Along with good eating habits, I lost 5 or so pounds and over 5 total inches (3 from waist) doing this.

      Again, note that my only exercise isn't Oxycise!. I do that with regular exercise and healthy diet to make weight loss (in fat) effective. I know that some of you are naysayers saying that it doesn't work and it's a scam, but under said circumstances, it worked for me.

  3. ocbill profile image76
    ocbillposted 4 years ago

    I think you only see one part of the world. The US is consumer capitalism greed oriented so diet and exercising are billion dollar industries. Yet, people who are healthy looking and eat properly (healthy) live on islands and non-English speaking parts of Europe. Why?

    Answer: They use bicycles a lot more, they go on social walks, they don't eat the constant junk food sold in the US, or engage in hours of TV or video games. They have an active lifestyle which does not always mean gym workouts. Just casual activities and eating normal real food instead of processed crap.

    No, I am not one of them and I do like some junk food but there are more things to life than working out and diet that can help you stay a normal weight. Don't give in to this acceptance by obese people & the media saying it is normal and perfectly OK. Yeah, it's normal if you eat burgers and fries and other junk food to be overweight and will end up with other diseases UNLIKE others countries in the world.

    Do you create your own path or do you let society's negatives set your course? American's are supposed to be leaders and examples of success. People accepting to be fat is not an example of greatness or success but more of laziness. And economics does not play a part. Whole grain rice, beans, fruits, vegetables and water are not expensive foods to buy. People who make $400/mo in 3rd world countries can eat healthy but Americans have to eat junk food if they make the same amount, give me a break.

  4. A Troubled Man profile image61
    A Troubled Manposted 4 years ago

    I picked up P90X on Craigslist a few years back for about $60. It contains about 12 videos and a few books, one of which teaches you healthy and proper dietary habits. In a few short months, I looked liked Tony Horton and still do today, all easily done at home. Tony's da man!