NutriSystem Food Reviews

On the NutriSystem diet plan, you don’t have to worry about measuring portions, counting calories, or hunting all over town for the specific foods suggested by the dieting book you just bought. No, NutriSystem takes care of everything for you.

About once a month, if you are using the regular plan, 28 days worth of meals (for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and snacks) are delivered right to your home. And each meal is not only low in calories, but designed to help your body burn fat faster. Dieting and losing weight doesn’t get much easier than this.

But exactly how good are the NutriSystem meals? I decided to go ahead and order a month's worth of meals just to check some of them out. So if you are looking for some honest Nutrisystem food reviews, here are my conclusions. For a review of the program overall, check out my NutriSystem diet review for more details.

Jjust as with any company that offers a wide variety of food dishes, there are both hits and misses. Previously, the biggest complain about NutriSystem meals is that for many dieters, they just taste too salty. This tends to be a hazard of shelf stable foods that is hard to avoid. But with the new NutriSystem Select program, there's a lot more variety offered and in addition to the regular NutriSystem meals that don't require refrigeration or freezing, you now have the option of selecting some great freshly frozen meals.

In my opinion, foods that are cooked and then immediately flash frozen before delivery tend to taste a lot better than foods that are designed to sit on your shelf for several weeks before you get around to throwing them into the microwave.

Some NutriSystem Select Foods
Some NutriSystem Select Foods

NutriSystem Select Menu Reviews

While I have not tried every NutriSystem Select item, they are a big improvement over the regular NutriSystem foods, in my opinion. So far, I have not hated any of them, with the exception of the Shrimp Alfredo. And that really is probably more about me. I just can't deal with frozen little shrimps. I love shrimp, but they have to be extremely fresh and I prefer nice giant shrimp!

It is too bad that you can only get a week's worth of the NutriSystem Select items with your full monthly supply of food, but then the cost may get a bit prohibitive otherwise. And honestly, I don't mind most of the regular NutriSystem meals and they sure are quick and easy. But let's talk about NutriSystem Select's menu.

When you first order, you get an extra week's worth of the ice cream sandwichs. And oh yes, are they tasty. But for me, they led to a bit of cheating, as eating just one is not really enough. So I can definitely recommend these, as long as you have more will power than I do.

As for the regular meals, I definitely have a few faves. Topping the list is the meatball parmesan melt, the chicken quesadilla and the glazed chicken tenders. I recommend cooking the chicken tenders in the oven if you have the time as I think they taste better that way rather than microwaved.

I also have a few breakfast faves – the ham and cheese omelet is surprisingly tasty for a packaged egg product and I like the toasted ham and cheese. Okay, is that really breakfast? It is for me! If you like to carb load for breakfast, then you have your choice of homestyle pancakes and golden French toast. I'll be sticking to protein however.

Now for the regular menu.

NutriSystem Meatload & Mashed Potatoes
NutriSystem Meatload & Mashed Potatoes

The Regular NutriSystem Menu

Meatloaf and Mashed Potatoes

This dish is a favorite amongst those following the NutriSystem diet. This is another comfort food many diets force you to give up. And, when you are eating this NutriSystem meal (with its wonderfully seasoned meatloaf, thick mashed potatoes, and creamy tomato sauce), you might have to remind yourself that you aren’t cheating on your diet. The meatloaf in this dish can taste a little bit salty and I strongly recommend that you not add any more salt until you taste it. Overall though, I thought this was pretty decent and would eat it again.

Macaroni and Cheese

Who doesn’t love macaroni and cheese? It is probably one of the major comfort foods. And, while most diets force you to give it up, NutriSystem has its own version of macaroni and cheese. And opinions on this one are mixed.

Some people love this dish of pasta and rich cream sauce. Others don’t. A lot might depend on the macaroni and cheese they grew up eating. This will probably not taste like the macaroni and cheese your grandma used to make. However, you might find it tasty in its own right. Me personally? Not a fan. My favorite macaroni & cheese is made from Alton's Brown's Stovetop Mac & Cheese recipe and as far as I'm concerned, I'd just rather go without if I can't have that.

Cranberry Orange Pastry

If there’s one thing you don’t have to worry about giving up on the NutriSystem diet, it’s dessert. NutriSystem offers many different kinds of sweet treats, and one of them is their cranberry orange pastry. This is the perfect snack for between meals. Get yourself a cup of coffee and a good book, and you’re set.

Chocolate Cake

Any chocolate lover will be glad to know that NutriSystem’s chocolate cake is a hit. Having to give up things like chocolate is one of the big reasons people find it difficult to stick with other diets. But, with the NutriSystem diet, you can keep your sweet tooth, and love of chocolate, satisfied. The truth is, sweets and desserts are probably one of the easiest things for any company to get right when they are trying to make a diet product. But since the taste is quite close to the "real thing" you may want to avoid the chocolate cake if it triggers cravings. I generally try to avoid most desserts on any diet, even if it is a low calorie or low fat dessert. I find that instead of providing satiety, they make me want to eat a whole box full of them.

NutriChocolates

They can’t all be winners, and NutriChocolates prove that old saying true. The idea behind it is definitely a winner. Chocolate candies that you can eat while on your diet? That is definitely not a bad idea. But NutriChocolates don’t quite fit the bill. Not that they are inedible. Some people will probably like them, especially if they aren’t expecting it to taste like fine chocolates. To me, they taste like dusty cocoa powder. Blech.

When it comes to NutriSystem meals, this is just the tip of the iceberg. NutriSystem offers a wide variety of meals and snacks. As you taste each one for yourself, you will find that some taste better than you imagined, while others don’t taste as good as you had hoped. But most find that the number of dishes they enjoy far outweighs the number of dishes they don’t care for. And the ones they like are more than enough to keep them satisfied, on their diet, and losing weight.

More by this Author


Have you tried NutriSystem? What do you think of their food? 11 comments

Mychal 5 years ago

tried nutrisystem in 2005, gave away most of the food cause it was soy based and tasted like soy, yulch...

have not tried to new stuff yet


embitca profile image

embitca 5 years ago from Boston Author

Mychal, I never tried Nutrisystem that long ago, but I think their food is much better now. Especially the frozen entrees. They are my preference when it comes to Nutrisystem. I'm not much for the shelf stable stuff, but that depends on what it is.


Jeff Rahim Bronner 5 years ago

hi! thanks for the great review. i'm two days into my nutrisystem diet, and i've lost a few lbs so far. i may switch to the select program instead of the pre-packaged one where my favorite part so far is the salad i make to go with my little microwaveable meal. sticking to it so far, though!


Missamy 5 years ago

I know what you are saying about that taste. But that was the old food. The new prepackaged food is good and doesn't have that weird taste. The Sweentend O's, Chili, Homestyle Beef with Mashed Potatoes and Honey Mustard Pretzels are my favorite. I stay away from pasta lunches with white sauce because the sauce doesn't thicken up.


Symbol 5 years ago

I'm on the system now and LOVE the food! I agree with the white sauce not thickening up. There are only a few things I don't care for very much - the meatloaf with tators cuz of the sauce, the eggs taste a little funny, and the cheeze puffs are 'heavy' probably due to all the protein. My favorites are the Italian wedding soup, the pizza's are awesome, and the cajan (sp) rice and sausage - and of course all the desserts :-) I ordered years ago too and the food was not good at all,,,,it has changed completely though and next month i'm ordering the select foods.


Carol 5 years ago

The meat loof an mashe potatoes to me uneat able. What's wrong ? The sauce is terriable. Change the sauce and would be good.


lisa 5 years ago

i just tried NS for 3 days...i called and got my money back! the food is awful!!!i mean i could live with the tiny size of the meal but when i can't even finish what little food i've got because it taste so bad i was hungry all the time and spent to much time thinking about when the next meal was. i will go back to the atkins diet where at least i lose weight fast ill miss the carbs but its worth it i lost 7lbs in 1 week on atkins should have stayed with it.


JUDY A 4 years ago

am 3 days INTO THE NS DIET AND AM VERY DISSAPOINTED.

JUST HEATED UP THE MEATLOAF AND POATOES I ENDED UP HAVING A BOWL OF CEREAL..EVEN MY DOG DIDN'T WANT IT..

THE MUFFINS AND BAGEL ARE DRY AND BLAND AND THE POPCORN

HAS A TERRIBLE ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR...THE FOOD LOOKS GOOD IN THE PHOTOS BUT NOW ADAYS THAT CAN DO JUST ANYTHING IN PHOTSHOP..I AM SENDING IT BACK AND GETTING MY MONEY BACK.

LEAN CUSINE HERE I COME


Becca. 4 years ago

I tried NS and I thought the Meatloaf with mashed potatos was GROSS! I couldn't even tell the difference of texture between the meat and the potatos! My favorites are the Zesty Herb Snack Mix, Honey Mustard Pretzals, Sweet and Sour Chiken, the Pizzas, and the Cajun rice and sausage! The rest was really nothing to brag about.


Kelly 4 years ago

I recently started nutrisystem and I am dissapointed. I find the breakfast and lunch bars to be the most appetizing category. Some of he soups (ham and bean) are decent but I found the rest of the meals almost inedible.


Mary 4 years ago

I have only tried a few things so far. I am not on the plan officially but caught a clearance sale at my local Big Lots so stocked up and went to town for a week. I gained a lot of weight over the summer so thought to myself, " why not". I heard the food was not very good but I could stick it out for a week after all good food is what got me in this mess in the first place. lol Surprisingly the hotdog is ok- I am not a hotdog fan anyway but it seemed like I could eat this one. FAIR WARNING- The chicken breast was sickening! It had a catfood smell and taste to it. I actually had to wash my mouth out and brush my teeth three times after eating it. (Well BTW I don't really know what cat food tastes like but you get the drift) I actually loved the spicy Zest snack bag. Cereal and hamburger patty were OK. All in all the food is not that tasty but it was really cheap at Biglots like 14 to 40 cents a serving piece and I have lost 4 pounds in one week. I know 2 pounds is healthier so I will have to eat some more food this week. I would not do this probably full blown since it appears too expensive for not great food.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working