How to Make Mashed Potato Stuffing - A Recipe to go with Turkey at Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving, or any time of the year

I have always loved Thanksgiving and the meal that comes with that. In my recollection, there has not been one Thanksgiving without some kind of stuffing. I wanted to share an adaptation of a recipe that was shared with me that actually includes mashed potatoes in the stuffing! Granted we almost always have mashed and/or sweet potatoes as well at Thanksgiving Dinner, but this may still be a fun unique twist. Let it not be limited to Thanksgiving, as you can have turkey and stuffing at other times of the year as well.

Ingredients for Mashed Potatato Stuffing

Ingredients:

Five to Six cups of mashed potatoes (just plain potatoes, not prepared with extra milk, butter, etc.)

Six cups of cut up day old white bread (though wheat will do, or even use another favorite bread)

Two and one half cups of onions, chopped

1 whole cup of fresh parsley (if you absolutely can't get fresh, you can substitute much less of dried, but it takes a lot from the recipe.)

One cup of chopped celery leaves

Three to Three and a half Tablespoons of butter, melted

One teaspoon Pepper

One and half teaspoon Salt

Mixture of pinches of thyme, garlic and onion and any other favorite spices for turkey stuffing

Dash of Cayenne Pepper (optional)

One Tablespoon of all purpose flour

3/4 cups of egg (or egg substitute, but I like to use egg whites)

One cup of milk

One Turkey (of course! Approximately 12-14 pounds. If larger or smaller, adjust accordingly)


Instructions for Stuffing the Turkey

1.  Combine your potatoes, bread pieces, onions, celery leaves, parsley, butter, salt and pepper and any other spices into a large bowl. 

2.  In a smaller bowl, beat the egg and add the flour together.  Stir in your milk.

3.  Pour second mixture into into the potato mixture and mix this up well.  (If you filling seems pretty dry, add just a little bit of milk to it at a time until it is not too dry.)

4.  Before sticking your turkey in the oven, stuff it with the stuffing mixture.  Tie the drumsticks of your turkey together to kind of close it up.  Place your turkey in a roasting pan, on a rack.  (Later we cover up the turkey with a foil tent, so it doesn't get too done in certain parts.

5.  Bake the turkey at 325 degrees for four and a half to five hours, or better yet use a meat thermometer that eventually reads 180 degrees.  This prevents loss of juices from needless pricking or poking of the turkey.  You can baste the turkey as needed with the juices. 

6.  Let the turkey rest when you take out of oven.  Never cut into it right away or you will lose juices and you will think the turkey is dry (for a reason!) 

Makes about 10 to 12 Servings. 

More by this Author


Comments 17 comments

PhoenixV profile image

PhoenixV 5 years ago from USA

Yum this sounds different and good !


oceansnsunsets profile image

oceansnsunsets 5 years ago from The Midwest, USA Author

Thanks Phoenix!


Pcunix profile image

Pcunix 5 years ago from SE MA

Yes, we started adding mashed potatoes thirty years ago, Your recipe is similar to ours, except we also add cut up mushrooms.

You can also cook this outside of the bird. As we can't possibly get enough into the bird to make everyone happy, we do it that way.


oceansnsunsets profile image

oceansnsunsets 5 years ago from The Midwest, USA Author

That is cool, Pcunix! I love both mashed potatoes and stuffing, and think that is a great idea. The cut up mushrooms sound like a must, so those will have to go in to the stuffing too. As for the number of people, we often have to cook more than can fit into the turkey, so cooking on the outside is a great alternative.


Lady Guinevere profile image

Lady Guinevere 5 years ago from West Virginia

Oh I loooove Mashed Potatoes and I may try this this year! PCUNIX--how long do you cook yours and is it in a cassarole dish?


oceansnsunsets profile image

oceansnsunsets 5 years ago from The Midwest, USA Author

Thanks Lady Guinevere!


Pcunix profile image

Pcunix 5 years ago from SE MA

Yes, a casserole dish or a covered cake pan. For two inch thick, maybe twenty minutes at 300 degrees covered and then move it up under the broiler uncovered to brown the top just a little.

Everything we put in is precooked. We sauté and season the celery and onions separately and then mix it in. If it is too dry, we add hot skim milk.


Lady Guinevere profile image

Lady Guinevere 5 years ago from West Virginia

Thanks a bunch!!


oceansnsunsets profile image

oceansnsunsets 5 years ago from The Midwest, USA Author

Pcunix, thanks for sharing your version of how to make even more of this potato stuffing.


Lady Guinevere profile image

Lady Guinevere 5 years ago from West Virginia

You should put it in your hub and say that it is from PCUNIX. I always liked the sharing aspect of Hubpages and people in general.


Pamela99 profile image

Pamela99 5 years ago from United States

I have never heard of making this type of stuffing but it sounds really good. I am bookmarking this recipe and I will try it in a hen first since my husband is injecting and frying the turkey this year. Thanks for sharing a great new recipe.


oceansnsunsets profile image

oceansnsunsets 5 years ago from The Midwest, USA Author

Pamela, I think that is a great idea to try it in a hen first, then you can know if its something to do on a bigger scale perhaps later on. Thanks for your comment!


oceansnsunsets profile image

oceansnsunsets 5 years ago from The Midwest, USA Author

Hi Lady Guinevere, I did kind of just do that above in the comments. I love the idea, good ideas there for sure! Open to more as well. Glad you are going to try it and let us know how it turns out if you can. I would love to know if you do the "out of the turkey" version of the stuffing!

I also like the sharing aspect of hubpages and in general like you said.


Scott Perreault 4 years ago

Yum, very similar to my family's stuffing, been doing it for geberstions but we do add Bell seasoning for that savory edge.


oceansnsunsets profile image

oceansnsunsets 4 years ago from The Midwest, USA Author

Scott, thank you for your comment. :) I have never tried that seasoning, but I will have to look into it!


tiffany delite profile image

tiffany delite 3 years ago from united states

thanksgiving is my absolute favorite holiday! thank you so much for doing this hub...it sounds so yummy that i think i just might try it at our thanksgiving this year! blessings...


oceansnsunsets profile image

oceansnsunsets 3 years ago from The Midwest, USA Author

Hello Tiffany, how wonderful to hear that Thanksgiving is your favorite holiday! Collecting recipes for my favorite holidays is something I have loved to do for some time. Thanks for taking the time to stop by and comment, and my apologies in delaying in response. Hope your holidays were wonderful!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Do you like Stuffing?

    • Yes
    • No
    • I am not sure if I like stuffing
    See results without voting
    Click to Rate This Article
    working