10 Great New York City Films
70A Classic
So Many Films, So Little Time
Some of the greatest films in cinema history have not only paid homage to New York City, but in some films, New York is one of the characters, beautiful and imperfect. It was tough whittling this list down to 10 favorites, but I did so by choosing films in which New York plays a key role in the story, the cinematography and the development of characters. I chose films that, without New York as a backdrop, could not be made. Because there were so many possibilities, however, I do have a list of runners-up. Enjoy...
1. West Side Story
This film is #1 in my book, partly because it won 10 Academy Awards, and partly because it was so groundbreaking. The 1961 musical by Jerome Robbins and Robert Wise is still remarkable to watch, even if it is a bit dated. Who can resist the rooftop dance number, "America," or Tony walking along the streets of the city, singing "Maria?" The film, of course, stars Natalie Wood and Richard Beymer as star-crossed lovers from different New York neighborhoods who fight society and their families to be together. New York is an essential part of the film and the story, and composers Leonard Bernstein and Stephen Sondheim would have it no other way.
2. Manhattan
Woody Allen's tour de force film, "Manhattan," was released in 1979 and is an extraordinarily funny film about the complicated love life of a New York comedy writer. "Manhattan" is Allen's love story, though, to the city, with breathtaking cityscapes of Manhattan as the background and a score of George Gershwin music that somehow ties it all together.The film stars a hilarious Allen, Diane Keaton, and a sweet, heart-breaking Mariel Hemingway.
3. The Godfather, Parts I and II
The whole Godfather saga is inextricably intertwined with New York. In Part I, we see 1940s New York, and in the brilliant Part II, we watch the young Don Vito Corleone enter Ellis Island and struggle for survival on the mean streets of the city. Marlon Brando, Al Pacino and Robert DeNiro gave performances of their lives, with Brando and DeNiro winning Best Actor Oscars in 1972 and 1974. Both films also won the Academy Award for Best Film. The four-minute Godfather II theatrical trailer on the right is worth watching.
4. Breakfast at Tiffany's
This wonderful 1961 film starring Audrey Hepburn and George Peppard is also a love story to New York City. Audrey Hepburn's defining role was that of naive socialite Holly Golightly, based on the character from Truman Capote's novella. An interesting side note -- nearly all the exterior scenes were shot on location in New York, but almost all the interior scenes were filmed on a lot in Burbank, Calif. The Tiffany's scene, of course, was shot in Tiffany's on Fifth Avenue.
5. Midnight Cowboy
Believe it or not, "Midnight Cowboy" was once an X-rated film and won the Academy Award for Best Picture in 1969. Although later reclassified with an R rating, "Cowboy" remains a gritty film that is as much about how a city like New York can swallow you up as anything else. Jon Voight plays a Texas boy who's arrived to seek his fortune as a sexual hustler. But he becomes just another face in the crowd and befriends the thief/hustler Ratzo Rizzo, played by Dustin Hoffman in an unforgettable performance.This is a sad tale of friendship between two souls lost in a big, bad city. Check out the great trailer for the film on the right.
6. The French Connection
How could we forget Popeye Doyle, the tough New York City narcotics detective played by Gene Hackman? This 1972 film directed by William Friedkin is a fast-paced crime story with seat-of-the-pants car chases on the streets of New York. It also won multiple Oscars. The film's most famous chase takes place when a relentless Doyle uses a Pontiac LeMans to chase down an elevated train with a hitman aboard. The conductor and train operator aboard the train were actual NYC Transit Authority employees, and the chase was filmed in Brooklyn. The video shows a portion of the film's famous seven-minute car chase.
7. King Kong
Our tragic anti-hero, King Kong, met his demise, of course, in New York City. How appropriate. Kong, the fictional giant ape from Skull Island, made his first appearance on film in 1933. Since then, there have been two remakes, including my favorite -- the 2005 version directed by Peter Jackson. As we all know, once Kong is captured at Skull and taken to the Big Apple to be exhibited as the Eighth Wonder of the World, all hell breaks loose. To the right you can watch an awesome colorized scene from the original "King Kong."
8. When Harry Met Sally
This hit romantic comedy, released in 1989, teamed up director Rob Reiner, actors Billy Crystal and Meg Ryan, and the beautiful city of New York. Crystal and Ryan play platonic friends who keep avoiding their deeper feelings for each other. It's a sweet, funny film with lots of scenes of two perfect young people strolling along the streets of New York. In the video to the right, Ryan enjoys her famous fake orgasm in a scene shot at New York's Katz's Deli.
9. Saturday Night Fever
When "Saturday Night Fever" was released in 1977, it was a phenomenon. Soon, we were all flocking to the discos, trying to dance like John Travolta and buying polyester. In this conventional story, Tony Manero, a 19-year-old Italian-American from Brooklyn, becomes the hero of the local nightclub at night. Like Joe Buck of "Midnight Cowboy," Tony is desperate to break out of his stifling surroundings. The Bee Gees soundtrack is a nice extra. New York, especially the divide between Brooklyn and Manhattan, is front and center in this film. Look for the harrowing Brooklyn Bridge scene. You'll love the dated video trailer here.
10. Goodfellas
I think this film was Martin Scorsese's masterpiece. "Goodfellas" is the story of real-life mobster Henry Hill, played by Ray Liotta, his rise to power in New York in the 1950s and his fall in the 1970s, thanks to cocaine and the FBI. The film also stars Joe Pesci, who won an Academy Award for his role, Lorraine Bracco and Robert DeNiro, and all turn in great performances. The film was shot in New York and takes place largely in Brooklyn.
The Runners-Up
And here, in no particular order, are my runners-up:
"On the Town," 1949.
"Barefoot in the Park," 1967.
"Do the Right Thing," 1989.
"The Out of Towners," 1970.
"Sex and the City," 2008.
"Wait Until Dark," 1967.
"Guys and Dolls," 1955.
The "Spiderman" films, 2002, 2004 and 2007.
"Dog Day Afternoon," 1975.
"Wall Street," 1987.
"Annie Hall," 1977.
"Taxi Driver," 1976.
"On the Waterfront," 1954.
"Big," 1988.
"The Apartment," 1960.
"The Odd Couple," 1968.
"Rear Window," 1954. (Added with thanks to Mighty Mom!)
"Gangs of New York," 2002. (Added with thanks to Jim10!)
"The King of New York," 1990. (Added with thanks to Jim10!)
These Films on Amazon
|
GoodFellas
Price: $20.00
List Price: $14.98 |
|
The Godfather - The Coppola Restoration Giftset DVD
Price: $31.98
List Price: $59.97 |
|
The French Connection
Price: $8.57
List Price: $14.98 |
|
Manhattan
Price: $31.77
List Price: $14.98 |
|
Breakfast at Tiffany's - Anniversary Edition
Price: $8.99
List Price: $12.98 |
|
Saturday Night Fever (30th Anniversary Special Collector's Edition)
Price: $12.41
List Price: $19.99 |
|
Midnight Cowboy
Price: $10.04
List Price: $14.98 |
|
King Kong (Widescreen Edition)
Price: $2.49
List Price: $5.98 |
|
When Harry Met Sally
Price: $2.99
List Price: $14.98 |
|
West Side Story (Full Screen Edition)
Price: $4.80
List Price: $14.98 |
Vote for Your Favorite!
Whic of my top 10 NY films is your favorite?
See results without votingPrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
Thanks to you and hugs again!
Hi NY Lady,
I just love your film taste, the research you put in, and the loving way you write about your selections. As I read your intro I immediatly thought, "Gee, I REALLY hope she includes When Harry Met Sally" because that to me is such a paen to the city. Then I thought about it and wondered... could it have been as effective in Chicago, as other love stories are? No matter -- it made your list and I'm thrilled!
Adore Goodfellas, too.
One that I might add it Rear Window with Jimmy Stewart and Grace Kelly.
Can't wait for your holiday movie compilation!!
Hey Mighty Mom: Thanks for the kind words and for my next Hub idea! I can't believe I forgot about Rear Window. That's right -- she worked for the fashion magazine and talked about Bergdorfs. My husband was driving me crazy tonight, coming up with more movies I forgot, which forced me to keep re-editing my Hub and adding new ones to the list of runners-up. There are many great ones out there.
NYLady! That's a great list of great movies. I'm not sure that I would change any of them. Way too hard to vote because they're all good flicks.
regards Zsuzsy
I know, Zsuzsy. There are too many good ones out there! Thanks for the ocmment.
Some excellent films here, I enjoyed When Harry met Sally and Annie Hall is a film I have seen many times but Breakfast at Tiffany's is a wonswerful love story and i love a good love story.
Hey Bob: I totally agree with you there. I could watch "Breakfast at Tiffany's" over and over again. Audrey Hepburn is fabulous.
A lot of great movies. Woody Allen has a lot in New York. Manhattan is great. I ask if maybe you could add one of my favorites to the Runners up. Of course only if you like them. The King of New York has great acting by Christopher Walken as mob boss Frank White. Another film with a much older New York would be Gangs of New York.
Hey Jim: Will add yours as well to the runners-up list. I did like "Gangs of NY," but never saw "The King of NY." Thanks for the comment!
And for two women-focused movies in NY...Devil Wears Prada and the latest, THE WOMEN where Annette Beninng's character has to bend down to tell a cranky 5 year old girl, "sweetie, NOBODY hates Saks." And Jennifer Lopez' Maid in Manhattan had great street scenes, and a good look at NYC fabuous hotels, and that party in the Metropolitan! Gorgeous! Fun Hub...but think, with so many NYC movies, you'll be making many additions to runners up list!
New York, New York my kinda town. Thank you.
















G-Ma Johnson says:
15 months ago
I also liked west side story, kingkong and breakfast at tiffaney's..to name a few.. fun hub my dear thanks ...G-ma :o) hugs