American Idol: Season 7 Breakdown
66WHO'S GONNA WIN AND WHY - DATED 3/7/08
Now that American Idol is actually down to the "contenders", I'll break it down for you, one-by-one why none of them is gonna beat David Archuleta! Kidding. I'm actually thinking there's an upset in the making.
THESE ARE THE FUNKTUAL FACTS OF THE CASE.
- The guys are suprisingly much much stronger than the girls.
- Simon Cowell is irreplaceable if he leaves the show.
- Paula's new video is great, the song she is singing is not.
- It is not racist to laugh uncontrollably at Chikezie's name and wardrobe.
- Every time I think Randy is a total tool he does something crazy cool like reference Leonard Cohen and Jeff Buckley.
- Crossing genders and switching genres is definitely in this year.
- The loss of Danny Noriega & Jason Yeager were both significant, because they have no idea how funny they really are.
- Ryan Seacrest is very good at his job. Whatever that is.
- The band is awesome this year! Who'da thunkit?
- Every year a strong black contestant is voted off way too early and then Ryan looks in the camera and blames us.
A WORD FOR THE ALREADY DEPARTED
WEEK ONE BUMPOFF - 2/21
garrett haley most stoned contestant yet! aka Leif Frampton
colton, joanne and amy were so forgettable that I refuse to list their last names.
WEEK TWO RUBOUT - 2/28
alaina & alexandrea forgettablea. moving ona..
robbie carico Bo Bice, Chris Daughtry proved this type doesn't win.
jason yeager This Rick Astley-clone will soon be working at Disneyworld.
WEEK THREE EXECUTION - 3/6
danny noriega has probably already signed on for a reality show with Perez Hilton.
luke menard aka the married 29 yr old who sang Wake Me Up Before You Go-Go on live TV with a straight face. possible alien.
asia'h epperson this years Whitney Houston casualty. When will they learn. Same thing goes for Celine Dion (Simon) and Stevie Wonder via Randy Jackson's annual lecture "he is the greatest singer in the known world." I just wanna ask him how the singers are in the unknown world where they made him.
kady malloy haunts my dreams. She is the embodiment of what a Pop Star shouldn't be and therefore will have record contract and a shameless whore image in Wal-Mart stores by Christmas.
THE CONTENDERS???.....NOT!
I will predict the first three to be voted off in no particular order since anyone can have a bad night / good night and I'll give you the odds.
Chikezie - dude, your name shoulda been ezie or ez. Simon doesn't know any R & B songs at all anyway! (100 TO 1)
Kristy Lee Cook - unless they do country themes every week here on out, she has no shot! The only hot one too. (75 to 1)
Ramiele Malubay - the cute one, too young though. (60 to 1)
THE PRETENDERS
These are the pretenders because we want to believe they have a shot but shut up and shut up right now because they don't.
Amanda Overmeyer - The Janis lovin rocker with the great voice doesn't look like she wants to be there now that she realizes she being judged by a guy who doesn't even know a Van Morrison classic like "Baby Please Don't Go". She wants to start touring and forget about this whole thing. The shape of her head / hair style is a topic of debate in households across the globe. (50 to 1)
David Hernandez - Fantastic voice! Zero charisma! Crooked Nose! See you on broadway, kid! Possible future star of American Idol - The Musical (40 to 1)
Carly Smithson - Stop it with your feigned shock, she has no shot. Two reasons: Bad Press and Bad Coincidence. Most people know she had a record contract and lost it when her record sales were a record low. AND the funny horrible cruel coincidence is that she is an exact doppelganger of the original American Idol Kelly Clarkson. She is definitely not gonna win because she is not American and is not Kelly Clarkson. I love the tattoos though. uh-huh. (25 to 1)
Post-Idol she could score on radio if she gets hooked up with the right producer say Timbaland or Mark Ronson
Michael Johns - I think this guy has a hell of a future on the radio as well. Too bad he's on the wrong musical reality show. This guy would have been perfect to become the new lead singer of INXS! Unfortunately though dawg, you are too old to be taken seriously on THIS show. The producers already made this mistake once before and TAYLOR HICKS proved to be a hack. It's American IDOL as in teen idol. Little girls will send you home way too soon, my talented friend. "Are you ready for a New Sensation"..? (20 to 1)
THE TOP FIVE FINALISTS WILL BE..
Syesha Mercado will be come in fifth place. See Funktual Fact Of the Case #10. (10 to 1)
Brooke White will only come in fourth this year because the talent level is so much higher. She probably would have beaten Katharine McPhee or Jordin Sparks and quite possibly Fantasia as well. It's a shame. She will be the next hyprid between Lisa Loeb and Edie Brickell. If she can write a song she could aspire to the next Natalie Merchant-Joni Mitchell type or on the othe hand, she could turn into Jewel. White girl, white hair, named White. Secret first name is really SNOW. I see the invisible chipmunks. (7 to 1)
David Cook is not related to Kristy Lee Cook or either of the other two David's on the show. He does however kick ass and has a future LIONEL RICHIE cover coming to radio stations near you. He gave that song back all the dignity it was robbed of by that stupid video with the blind girl. His version of "Hello" was so good it took me ten seconds to realize what it was. The first real threat. Hate the 'Killers' hairdo though. Hate it. (3 to 1)
And now ladies and gentleman for the first time anywhere I present our AMERICAN IDOL FINALISTS David Archuleta and Jason Castro!
David Archuleta is talented beyond our comprehension at this early stage. He understands the words he is singing far better than people who have been singing their whole lives professionally. He is great at changing up the cadence of a song and tries to make important statements with the songs he chooses. "Imagine" followed by "Another Day in Paradise" obvious examples of this. Simon Cowell knows all and always speaks the truth and warned him last night, don't get too serious about yourself. It's yours to lose but be careful. Song choice is his only flaw and somebody might exploit it and I think by now we all know who it is.
JASON CASTRO WILL DEFEAT THE FUTURE MULTI-GRAMMY AWARD WINNER David Archuleta by a single vote. And that vote is coming from yours truly, DJ Funktual.
This kid with the dreads just keeps picking the best songs every time out there. WHAT A DAY FOR A DAYDREAM and then HALLELUJAH both kicked my ass.
I was spellbound as soon as he started doing Jeff Buckley. In case you don't know about the late great Jeff Buckley who's picture is in the Rock-n-Roll Hall of Fame with a quote from Linda McCartney about how she and Paul thought Jeff had the best voice they ever heard. All I can tell you is if you don't have his album GRACE (pictured below) which features 'Hallelujah' as well classics 'So Real' and 'Last Goodbye' you are missing out on one of the rarest and most gifted of singer/songwriter's of our time. Jeff was taking a break while recording his second album when he drowned in a river he shouldn't have been swimming in. There are many books about him and his father Tim Buckley who was also a famous pseudo-folk singer who died mysteriously young. Jeff Buckley can't come back to life for those of us who love him so.
But I'm here to say that his spirit is alive and well in JASON CASTRO. There is something special about this kid I can feel it. His parents raised him right. He's got looks enough to keep it tight among the teenage voters. I'm not crazy about fake dreadlocks unless you are a true believer in the Rastafari religion but I'll make an exception. He might very well be with that stoney-shy look on his face. Regardless I think JASON CASTRO is gonna shock the world like The New York Giants did in The Super Bowl.
YEAH Yeah yeah I know the kid, Archuleta will probably still win but they said the same thing about the undefeated Patriots. Besides, I can dream can't I? ......"What a day for a daydream....."
If you enjoyed this Hub give me a thumbs up and comment if you got time.
UPDATE FRIDAY 3/28/08:
THE NUMBER ONE SONG ON ITUNES FOR THE LAST THREE WEEKS IS NONE OTHER THAN JEFF BUCKLEY'S VERSION OF HALLELUJAH. The awesome power of posthumous publicity. My HUB Must have Done It!!! ;0)
Okay, only 1 of the first three I picked was correct. Chikezie is gone! While the generic Kristy Lee carries in the name of redneck voters, the little girl (what'shername) is still around.
My first two pretenders are already gone though. Amanda the Joplin girl and David the gay dancer. Now we are down to NINE!
MY NEW RANKINGS VS. MY OLD RANKINGS
Wow what a difference three weeks makes! I had them in this order to finish
9) Kristy Lee Cook 8) Ramiele Malubay 7) Carly Smithson 6) Michael Johns 5) Syesha Mercado 4) Brooke White 3) David Cook 2) David Archuleta and Jason Castro as the WINNER.............well I've had three weeks to form a new list and here it is:
9) Kristy Lee 8) Ramiele 7) MJohns 6) Syesha 5) Brooke 4) David 3) Jason 2) Carly and the new favorite is no surprise....D-Cook!
So basically I'm saying that Carly is better than I thought and both of my finalists were a little premature. I'm not changing my picks I just don't know how right I was about Castro's desire to win.
Jason Castro doing "Hallelujah"
THE MOST MUST-HAVE ALBUM OF THE 90s for me personally.
David Cook's version of "Hello" by Lionel Richie
UPDATE - THE FINAL SIX
UPDATE 4/17/08
HERE WE ARE WITH SIX WEEKS TO GO AND IT LOOKS LIKE I MIGHT KNOW WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT. NOW THAT KRISTY LEE COOK HAS FINALLY STOPPED THROWING OFF MY PREDICTION CURVE I CAN FOCUS ON MY SUCCESS!
MY FINAL SEVEN...I originally said six weeks ago...
- Jason Castro
- David Archuleta
- David Cook
- Brooke White
- Syesha Mercado
- Michael Johns
- Carly Smithson
So if CARLY goes home next week I know I'm back on track and on a roll.
MY FINAL SIX at the first update 3 WEEKS AGO was
- D-Cook
- Carly
- Jason
- David
- Brooke
- Syesha
That faint sound you hear is me patting myself on the back. :0)
MY NEW SIX AT THIS MOMENT IS..
- D-COOK
- SYESHA
- JASON
- DAVID A
- CARLY
- BROOKE
I can't wait to see which me is right as we go down the stretch. For the record I'm not changing my original picks, I'm just giving my feel for it every three weeks because it changes.
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
THE BANTER BOX
Wow, thank you rockinjoe!
What do think of my man CASTRO pulling off an upset?
Weren't you moved by Hallelujah?
I can't believe I forgot to include Jason Castro. Hallelujah was just amazing. The man is mega talented in so many ways. I think he's going to lose, though. He's not mainstream enough to become AI. He's going to have a long, healthy, happy career, without AI. You need a certain about of the evil gene to become AI and I don't think there's a mean bone in that guy's makeup.
He's a genius!
I am truly shocked that I didn't wake up this afternoon, hehe with tons of comments because seemingly everyone watches the show and I got a ton of page views.
Is it possible that I covered every nuance of the show and left them speechless?
Possible they were so offended with the very idea of someone other than Archuleta winning. Can't figure people out sometimes.
Maybe I should have waitied to release it during peak traffic hours but i was afriad if someone else was going to cover it, I might get beat to the punch.
Oh well.
rockinjoe's comment about scratching records being passe is so offensive that I have decided to shun him for at least 45 minutes!
p.s. I missed Blake Lewis because I was HUBBING!
Oh the spit on the screen...I get it.
You were talking about beatboxing.
(making beats with your mouth) I thought he was scratching turntables and you asking when it was going away...I turned white.
Blake Lewis is a talented little turd but it all comes down to songwriting. Look how long it took Justin Timberlake to learn how to write decent songs. He only has two. But still.
Blake Lewis is too soon to call. He's an anooying little bastard though I'll give you that.
I've had two Idol hubs that not only scored badly, but almost died of comment starvation. You just never know with these things.
Yeah, didn't mean to insult the art, (I WAS talkin about beatboxing) I just can't stand the cocky little bastard,
Okay joe, or anyone else out there, I got some unanswered questions here for you.
1) What does Paula take on the nights she shows up high? Pills, Vodka???
2) What did you take when you posted this BS?
I would go even further to say that the show wouldn't survive without anyone of the cast. Everyone on that show (the staff) should be considered irreplaceable.
The other two bring nothing to the table. You know how easy it is find someone who will periodically spout out, "It was kinda pitchy in the beginning but you worked out in the end dawg that was hot! LOL! (cracking myself up)
Seacrest is a smooth operator up there.
BUT a drunk has-been like Abdul? Are you seriously the type that would get her album? I know you have a fetish but please tell me otherwise. I used to hate those guys who only talked about jenifer lopez AND they actually listened to her album too. I kid u not.
Pathetic sad little people we are.. anyways..
3) What stripper scandal? News to me.
4) Do you agree on my take of the first three going home if not speak up now.
If you agree, which of the three gets the axe first????
1.) Hmmm, don't know, but I bet there's something 101 proof inside that plastic coke cup.
2.)I'm standing by my staff requirements for Idol. Take the rum out of rum cake and it's just cake. Am I saying that the judges couldn't be replaced? No, I'm just saying the show wouldn't survive without the cocktail recipe they've got going now.
3.) Hernandez was found to be a former stripper, working at a place called "Dick's" in Arizona. Video surfaced last week on the net. The producers of AI decided to let it slide.
Chikezie is going first. Next Thursday, he's history.
As far as Paula Abdul, she may be a musical has been but she's reinvented herself (however crazy that sounds) and morphed into a bigger star than she was years ago. Would I buy her album? No, but then again, I'm not in the AI 16-35 female demo, either.
I try not to take anything on the show too seriously. I believe it's fixed. I think America has very little to do with who the next Idol is. I also don't think America cares too much, either.
I would have thought that too except, if it's fixed, "why did Taylor Hicks win?"
There's NO WAY AI producers thought that they could make more money off him than K. McPhee. If she HAD won, we might be hearing HER on the radio. Instead she married an executive who's twice her age. YucK!
That whole season has interupted any theories about the fix being in.
If you want to see Jason Castro's performances, goto http://hubpages.com/hub/Jason-Castro
Okay Joe.
Here are my predictions for this week, sight unseen.
Of the first three I picked to go home I think it will be Kristy Lee.
HOWEVER, and I know this is a copout because I'm picking two people but...I am feeling more and more that the Janis chick Overmeyer does not want to do this anymore.
LONGSHOT ODDS Prediction: Amanda Overmeyer
Jason is my fav too. David gives me chills when he sings, but Jason also makes the knees go weak. If you're going to worship at the alter of any Idol, let it be the one who does it for ya.
I agree. I think Kristy Lee will go too. She's got a great voice, she's beautiful, but she's got absolutely nothing to distinguish herself from the others. Chi-queezy is toast, as well.













rockinjoe says:
2 years ago
This season is more funny than talent-oriented. I would go even further to say that the show wouldn't survive without anyone of the cast. Everyone on that show (the staff) should be considered irreplaceable.
My take?
Hernandez will not be able to overtake his stripper scandal. He'll be back to lapdancing at Dick's after next week. This guy is envious over Debbie Gibson's nose....
Chi-queasy? He's not the next American Idol. There's far better talent. Points off for holding onto Noriega like a bitch last night before the decision.
Archuletta? He's really good. He's a ringer, though. He's a previous Star Search winner. If you don't think AI is fixed, I want to sell you some land in the Everglades. Definitely the winner.
Brook White? She looked like she was going to puke before Seacrest gave her the good news last night. She's no Idol. Expect her to go home in a few weeks. This chick is way too innocent for stardom. As she sat down on the stool, she didn't congratulate anyone behind her. She's a turn off.
Kristy Lee Cook ? Who's Kristy Lee Cook? zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
David Cook: I agree with you. I never liked the Lionel Ritchie tune before I heard this guy turn it into a rock ballad. Stick a bolt in each side of ths kid's neck and you've got 2008's favorite Halloween costume.
Michael Johns- Agreed. Too Old and wrong country. I thought during Hollywood week that he flawlessly pulled off Bohemian Rhapsody. If you take on Freddie Mercury,you'd better have your crap together. (Example: Luke Menard who butchered Killer Queen. In fact, Even George Michael though that his version of "Wake Me Up" was too gay)
Amanda Overmeyer- More like Amanda Overdone. Amanda is what you get if you cross the movie "Roadhouse" with "the Rocky Horror Picture Show". She pulled off that Joan Jett song on Wednesday, but barely. She's no Joan Jett and she's certainly no Joplin.
Ramiele Malubay: I like her a lot! But, 'YOU MUST BE THIS TALL TO BE AN AMERICAN IDOL'
Syesha Mercado: I love her. I think it will be a Dead heat with Arculetta. My final 2.
Carley Faker Lying Smithson: Where does she get off trying to win this thing? She's got the best voice out of the girls but her previous record contract controversy stinks to high heaven. She's another AI ringer, but she's not American enough to win. If they threw a bag over her head, I'd like her better.
And I would like to make a comment about Blake Lewis. When is that hip hop thing, record scratching thing going away? Everytime this kid sings I have to wipe the spit off my screen.
Ok, I'm done-but I may be back.