create your own

Alcoholism - Alternatives to AA

74
rate or flag this page

By Aqua


Alternatives to AA

The highly regarded Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) is the largest and most widely known self-help organization for alcoholics in the United States. There are approximately 53,665 AA groups and 1,213,269 members in the U.S. and around 2,000,000 members worldwide (AA Fact File 2007 [latest available]). These numbers can only be approximated because, due to its nature, AA has never attempted to keep formal membership statistics. AA has a wide following and the organization has helped many people who suffer from alcoholism.

Despite the impressive numbers, AA is not the best choice for every alcoholic. For example, minorites are under-represented in AA. According to AA's own literature, 85.1% of the members are Caucasian, with the next largest group, African American, at only 5.7% (AA Membership Survey 2007 [latest available]). These membership statistics do not accurately reflect the actual demographics of those who suffer from alcoholism. Even though they might want to seek help, this can make it very difficult for minorities to feel comfortable in the AA environment.

An emphasis on spirituality or religion also contributes to AA not being suitable for every alcoholic. This is absolutely not to say that AA requires its members to be "religious", however, AA literature and some meetings do cite the use of "God" or a "Higher Power". Some people have no problem with this, while others are completely put off altogether. Unfortunately this can translate into some alcoholics not seeking the help they need.

Despite these points, AA is a highly regarded organization, and since 1936 it has provided followship to many alcoholics, assisted with their recovery, and helped them to achieve, and maintain, sobriety. However, the AA way is not the only way. Here are some other groups for alcoholics that you might not be as familiar with.

Alcoholism Self-Help Resources


Are You an Alcoholic?
Are You an Alcoholic?

Self-Management and Recovery Training (SMART) - The cornerstone of SMART is a four point program to help the alcoholic learn motivational strategies, how to cope with urges, utilize problem solving skills and learn how to create balance in their lives. There are over 450 weekly face to face meetings around the world, and over 16 online meetings per week. The SMART website also offers an active forum for members.

Rational Recovery (RR) - RR was founded in 1986 by Jack Trimpey, LCSW, a recovering alcoholic. RR focuses more on a concept, as opposed to a program. RR is very private, there are no steps, no sponsors, no public disclosure. RR emphasizes rational self-examination, traditional individual and family values and the healing of family and personal relationships.

Secular Organization for Sobriety (SOS) - founded by James Christopher, a recovering alcoholic, and the son of an alcoholic, SOS is an alternative recovery method for those who feel out of place with other 12 step programs. SOS takes a completely secular approach to recovery and maintains that sobriety is not related to spirituality or religion.

Women for Sobriety (WFS) - as the name implies is an abstinence based self-help group for women alcoholics. WFS was founded in 1976 by the late Dr. Jean Kirkpatrick, Ph.D., a recognized expert on alcoholism. Dr. Kirkpatrick founded WFS based on her personal experience and on the belief that the treatment needs of women alcoholics are different than those of men. note: It appears WFS now has a Men for Sobriety group as well.

Each group has pros and cons that must be carefully considered and each group offers a unique perspective. Some individuals find it beneficial to participate in two groups concurrently. For example, some women belong to WFS online but also attend AA meetings in orders to get some face to face time with other women alcoholics, especially if there are no WFS meeting in their area.

Alcoholism - Importance of Getting Help

The bottom line is that there are multiple resources available to those who want to get help for alcoholism. No one way is the only right way. There are no wrong ways to seek help. The important thing is just to choose one and try it out. If it is not a good fit then try another. There are also local resources available through your community. Treatment centers are also widely available. Some treatment centers offer both in patient and out patient programs. In addition, medications like Naltrexone are used to reduce alcohol cravings in some patients.

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Anonymous  says:
3 months ago

although AA helped me reduce my heavy drinking it also made me feel guilty . I am not comfortable in large groups and the God thing certainly put me off.

Aqua profile image

Aqua  says:
3 months ago

Yes, this happens to a lot of people which is why I was hoping to educate folks that there is more than one way to get support if they have an alcohol problem. Whichever way works for you individually - is the best way :)

lorlie6 profile image

lorlie6  says:
3 months ago

Aqua~

First off, thanks for this thoughtful and informative Hub. I was thrilled to find it here since I am a recovering alcoholic with some real trepidation with regard to AA.

My sobriety date is June 24th, 2008, but I did not attend AA for a number of weeks, having had a negative prior experience with some of the members of the organization. I was uncomfortable with some of the cliques that existed.

Well, Aqua, it is happening once again, and I think I am beginning to see the pattern.

I consider myself a spiritual woman so that is not at issue for me personally, but a certain group hypocrisy has unnerved me once again. I underwent hip-replacement surgery a month and a half ago and required (!) pain medication to undergo and recover from the procedure. Other than for the procedure itself, this was frowned upon by a certain group of members, even though I took the meds according to the prescription instruction. I have felt discarded ever since.

Others have confirmed my suspicions, so it's not social phobia rearing its ugly head!

I intend to look into the groups that you have listed, always remembering that people will be people, but in AA it does seem to be institutionally embedded.

Aqua profile image

Aqua  says:
3 months ago

lorlie - thank you for the comment. One place I recommend you look into is WFS (Women for Sobriety) They have a large online presence so you can participate right from home should you choose to. They also have literature and a type of "program" which is fundamental as well. WFS's program is based on empowerment - not surrender, which is a critical distinction for some people. I think people are fortunate these days with the internet being a tool we can use. I would recommend giving WFS a try and if you feel as though you also need actual meetings, try the other groups listed and see if there are any in your area. Fortunately, there's more than one way to get help these days.

lorlie6 profile image

lorlie6  says:
3 months ago

I think I will give WFS a look first thing in the a.m., I am particularly intrigued with the empowerment take on sobriety that you have mentioned.

Thanks again,

Laurel

Aqua profile image

Aqua  says:
3 months ago

I hope you will find WFS of value. btw: Congrats on your sobriety date! :)

Tony Ballatore profile image

Tony Ballatore  says:
3 months ago

Hello, Aqua

I found your article while searching for recovery related listings. Good job. I would like to make one comment as I am an addiction counselor who is trying to help people recover by using a client centered approach; that is: not following a dogma, chart, map, or ritual. Each client is unique. My comment is regarding the common use of the word spirituality as though it only applies to religion and a belief in the supernatural.

Because there is no tone & body language in posted comments, I would ask you and any other reader to understand that I am not being argumentative with this posting, but merely clarifying (I hope) a common misconception. I support you and your article completely. It is well written and valuable. Here is an excerpt from my workbook for people facing the challenges of recovering from a substance addiction:

What is Spirituality?

There are as many definitions of spirituality as there are people. My understanding of the word is that it is an ongoing effort to try and understand one’s self and individual significance in relation to everything else.

It is made up of many parts: The search for self-awareness, the desire to understand the way in which all things seem to be connected, one’s values and ethics, the search for purpose and meaning, the need to serve...

Religion and spirituality are not the same thing. Religion is a set and system of beliefs. Spirituality is an ongoing search for understanding; a journey. Religion might be seen as a place and spirituality as a path. Your path might lead you to religion, spirituality is definitely a part of all religions, but religion is not a part of all spiritual journeys.

Thank, Aqua. I will be taking the time to read your other articles and comments.

Kind regards,

Tony Ballatore

Aqua profile image

Aqua  says:
3 months ago

Hi Tony - thank you very much for sharing your insight and making the above comment. I couldn't agree more that "spirituality" and "religion" are not necessarily the same thing for everyone - although for *some* individuals they are. I am a big fan of your client centered approach to treatment. There really is no "one size fits all" treatment approach because obviously every individual is unique and the reasons for the substance abuse issues are therefore, unique as well. I think we are in complete agreement in the way we look at treatment. Thanks again for your contribution - I appreciate it and please stop by any time!

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

*Disclaimer*

I do not in any way recommend or endorse any one particular group or alternative over another. It is up to you to decide which, if any, of these groups or organizations are the right choice for you.

Alcoholism in the News

working