create your own

Are Film Cameras Obsolete?

79
rate or flag this page

By stephhicks68

Goerz Tenax camera with a 150mm f 1:4,5 Dogmar lens and a Compur Shutter
Goerz Tenax camera with a 150mm f 1:4,5 Dogmar lens and a Compur Shutter

35mm film
35mm film
Diagram of how still film photography works
Diagram of how still film photography works

I still recall, quite fondly, my first experiences with photography at a Girl Scout camp when I was about 10 years old. I had a Brownie camera that required the operator to hold the camera mid-chest and look down into a view finder, then press the button to operate the shutter. Now, I'm not that old, but it sure seems to me that we've come a loooooong way in the last 3 or 4 decades with respect to photography.

These days, almost everyone owns a digital camera. Whether point and shoot models, or single lens reflex (SLR), most still camera models on the market do not require film anymore. Is this a benefit or drawback? What do true photographers think of the new developments?

At a photography class in 2001, most of the class was still using film cameras, even though the digital age was well underway. To me, it seemed a "pure" photography experience at the time, to discuss f-stops and aperture, while those few students were "cheating" by using digital camera features to help create unreal shots. Cropping and red-eye elimination were the first advancements of which we took notice. Then, it continued so that digital images could be manipulated to whiten subjects' teeth, brighten colors and reduce shadows. How can photographers using film cameras in a digital age, continue to showcase their talents?


Diagram Illustrating When Film is Superior to Digital and Vice-Versa
Diagram Illustrating When Film is Superior to Digital and Vice-Versa
 

The primary advantage to using a film camera, as opposed to digital, is that you'll have a record of every shot you make. Many digital camera operators review and delete shots that they do not like. But with film, you cannot do so. One of these days, you may find that this is a benefit. When the Monica Lewinsky-Bill Clinton scandal broke, the person with the film camera was the happy winner. Most of the other photographers that took pictures that day had digital cameras and had already deleted what appeared to be a meaningless photo shot. Oh.... what they wouldn't give to go back in time!

When film is developed, you receive your negatives, along with prints. In other words, a permanent record is yours forever. You can use negatives to create additional prints in the future. In the digital age, you must request a CD or DVD on which to store your images. Many people risk losing a significant number of photos that are stored on their computer's hard drives, and no where else, in the event of a malfunction.

Perhaps most significantly, use of certain film cameras and film can produce higher quality, detailed prints. With higher megapixel digital cameras being marketed now, however, the differences between digital and film prints are becoming smaller.

It is said that there are four factors that should be considered when comparing digital to film prints:

  1. Resolution
  2. Noise/grain
  3. Dynamic range
  4. Color Quality

Resolution (sharpness and detail) is improved with higher pixel counts. Some people believe that you'll need to have an 11 megapixel digital camera to produce enlargeable prints at the resolution of 35 mm film.

Noise/grain. If you want to avoid noise in your digital prints (the counterpart of grain in film prints), you'll want to invest in a digital SLR camera, as opposed to a point and shoot. Grainy, noisy images may result with higher shutter speeds.

Digital cameras generally have less dynamic range than film cameras. That is, you may get less contrast, and "flatter" prints with a digital camera. One commentator has stated, "Film responds to light with a nice "S" curve--as light intensity increases, density gradually levels off in a region known as the response "knee," which is responsible for much of the detail and beauty in the highlights of fine silver-based prints. It is absent in digital sensors, but as long as highlights aren't blown out, prints from digital sources look fine." - Norman Koren

Finally, with respect to color quality, prints usually do not suffer from being digitized. However, if you wish to make color slides, your best bet will be to use a film camera instead.

An Olympus film camera
An Olympus film camera

As technology advances, it seems likely that film cameras may be completely replaced by digital cameras. I continue to own a 35mm Pentax SLR and a Cannon digital SLR. Admittedly, the Pentax never sees the light of day. Someday, these film camera relics will be worth a lot of money. And certainly many photographers will choose to make prints using both film and digital cameras. Serious photographers may enjoy the darkroom experience of washing, adjusting and fine-tuning their work.

There isn't a right or wrong way to pursue a photography hobby, profession or passion. Chose the camera that you like, and subjects that interest you. You're sure to be happy with the end results.


Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Zsuzsy Bee profile image

Zsuzsy Bee  says:
2 years ago

Great HUB Steph; It's just been since January of this year that I started playing with a digital camera. My mind hasn't been made up yet. My 20 + year old Minolta makes some amazingly good pictures. But the convenience of having your pictures immediately to put onto the hubs has a definite advantage. I hate to see a "tradition" (if I can call it that) go the way of the Dodo.

Super-duper HUB regards Zsuzsy

stephhicks68 profile image

stephhicks68  says:
2 years ago

Thanks Zsuzsy! I agree. After taking that photography class in the early 2000s, I vowed never to go 100% digital. Yet.... as you mention, the ease and ability to quickly download photos and use them in Hubs, email them to relatives, etc. Its a real bonus.

Whitney05 profile image

Whitney05  says:
2 years ago

Steph, cool. You did a similar one as mine. Have you seen Helena's?

I did another hub on disposable film to disposable digital.

stephhicks68 profile image

stephhicks68  says:
2 years ago

Yes, I saw Helena's too! LOL! I think its interesting to read our different approaches to the same topic.

Whitney05 profile image

Whitney05  says:
2 years ago

Definitely! All three are great in their own ways. We definitely took slightly different approaches to the same topic.

PenmanZee profile image

PenmanZee  says:
2 years ago

Very insightful Steph. You did a good job of making me yearn for the good old days while at the same time appreciate the advantages of today's advanced technology.

stephhicks68 profile image

stephhicks68  says:
2 years ago

Thank you PenmanZee. Change is good and hard at the same time, yes.

helenathegreat profile image

helenathegreat  says:
2 years ago

I agree with Zsuzsy that I hate to see it go, but... digital makes it so deliciously easy... Great hub! :)

crazycat profile image

crazycat  says:
2 years ago

I still would want to have a raw camera again. This time, for professional which will have high quality pictures.

Dale G. Holmes profile image

Dale G. Holmes  says:
2 years ago

Great hub! Thanks for all the information!

monitor profile image

monitor  says:
2 years ago

About time. more power to you.

Lori Osterberg profile image

Lori Osterberg  says:
2 years ago

Great information. I'm always amazed at the number of people still in love with film. We made the switch to digital years ago when we were shooting parallel to try digital out - and the lab lost several rolls. Digital gives us more control - you don't have to send it to the lab, taking a chance they ruin it or lose it. The key to digital is backing up all the time. We have several ways of backing up everything - CD, hard drive, separate computer, off site - just to make sure we never lose those important images.

andypiper profile image

andypiper  says:
14 months ago

Nice article. I like medium format film - the look is just incredible. These days you can buy a great medium format camera for a fraction of what they used to cost and you can get incredible color and detail. Using film is a hobby though. For anything production oriented for my real estate business. digital is the greatest. Add to that most of my work ends up on the internet where cropping, color and perspective adjustments are routinely done and film is completely out!

stephhicks68 profile image

stephhicks68  says:
14 months ago

Hi andypiper, I agree that you can get some great results and have a lot of fun with traditional film cameras. Hobbyists and artists in particular should still enjoy the medium. But the advantages of digital for work cannot be overstated. The editing opportunities alone are excellent for businesses. Thanks for the comment!

agvulpes profile image

agvulpes  says:
13 months ago

Hi Steph, Great info, I have gone completely digital and haven't touched a film camera for about 7 years.

A couple of points you might like to update. 1) with memory size capacity growing at the rate it is, you  would not have to delete at camera level until you monitered your shots on the computer.

2) I could not find if you mentioned shooting in "raw" mode (the camera not you), and the advantages of this for the serious photographer?

stephhicks68 profile image

stephhicks68  says:
13 months ago

Hi avgulpes - yes, I too have pushed my film camera to the back of my closet and am totally a digital gal. You are correct that memory cards/cameras themselves do allow photographers to take hundreds of shots before filling up. I guess it depends on how long your vacation is and how often you are clicking away. In Hawaii last month, I literally took about 200 shots a day. True artists (aka serious photographers) may prefer working in the "raw" mode, as you mention. I know that my photography teacher from the late 1990s would not do anything less. I can certainly add a few paragraphs about this.... look for an update soon. :)

lafenty profile image

lafenty  says:
9 months ago

Even though digital cameras make it so much easier and convienent to take pictures, I still love the look of film, especially black and white. Thanks for your hub. I hope that film photogaphy will continue to be around for a long time.

anderbee  says:
5 weeks ago

I think digital cameras have a little farther to go before they can match the "organic" feel of a film camera, at least that's what I think.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working