Are Men or Women Better Leaders?

74
rate or flag this page

By NYLady

I'm sure you've all been participating in the same discussions these days as I have -- mulling over John McCain's choice for a vice presidential running mate, Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, on the heels of Sen. HIllary Clinton's conciliatory speech at the Democratic National Convention; chewing the fat over the news that Palin's 17-year-old daughter is pregnant and unwed; reviewing Palin's stands on abortion, creationism in the schools, and sex education. If you're like me, some of the discussions have been heated enough to fry an egg.


Sarah Palin
Sarah Palin

Who's On Top?

So it was with great interest that I read the results of the Pew Research Center's latest Social and Demographic Trends survey, "Men or Women: Who's the Better Leader," which polled respondents about the leadership characteristics they see in men and women. And when it comes to honesty, intelligence and other character traits that the public values highly in leaders, guess which sex came out on top?


Women First in Leadership

You're right -- the public believes that women overwhelmingly have the character traits that make great leaders, with women rating higher than men in these characteristics:

honesty

intelligence

compassion

the ability to be outgoing

and creativity.

Men and women were rated equally ambitious and hardworking, while men only scored higher than women in the category of decisiveness.



But Here's the Rub...

But the survey of 2,250 adults also unveiled a paradox on the subject of gender and leadership.

In spite of scoring higher on all those leadership traits, only 6% of the respondents taking the Pew survey said that, overall, women make better political leaders than men. About 21% said men make the better leaders, while the vast majority (69%) said men and women make equally good leaders.

Why this paradox?

Here's what the Pew Center folks say:

"In an era when women have made sweeping strides in educational attainment and workforce participation, relatively few have made the journey all the way to the highest levels of political or corporate leadership.

Why not? In the survey, the public cites gender discrimination, resistance to change, and a self-serving "old boys club" as reasons for the relative scarcity of women at the top. In somewhat smaller numbers, respondents also say that women's family responsibilities and their shortage of experience hold them back from the upper ranks of politics and business."


The Right Stuff

When it comes to holding public office, respondents said they believe women are better than men at dealing with social issues such as health care and education, but gave men the edge over women in the way they deal with crime, national security, public safety, and defense.

When it comes to the skills it takes to perform public office duties, women got higher marks than men in all of the measures: standing up for your principles against pressures, working out compromises, keeping government honest, and representing the interests of the average person.

That Darn Glass Ceiling

But the fact of the matter is, as the Pew report notes, women make up only 2% of the CEOs of the nation's Fortune 500 companies and 17% of all members of the U.S. House of Representatives.

What accounts for this slow movement toward gender parity in top political positions? The Pew survey asked respondents, and 51% said Americans aren't ready to elect a woman to high office, 43% said women in politics are held back by men, and 38% said women are discriminated against in all sectors of society.


A Balancing Act

Interestingly, 27% of the survey respondents also cited the time pressure for women, who have to balance work and family, as a reason there aren't more females in public office, while 26% said that the public might not elect more women because they believe females don't have the experience required for higher office.

What Do You Think?

Men or Women: Who's the Better Leader?

  • Men
  • Women
See results without voting

NYLady Elsewhere on the Web

Print   —   Rate it:  up  down  flag this hub

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

marisuewrites profile image

marisuewrites  says:
15 months ago

I can go with a male or female leader; but here's my experience...most of the women who have "led" me, have been ruthlessly ambitious, cutthroat, and over the top power hungry, devouring all in their path. 

Now, I've met men the same, but most I have dealt with have engaged women within the group...though I have also experienced discrimination, condesending, and dishonesty...sooo I actually have not met very many good leaders in my lifetime.  Most have either started out corrupt, or became so.  Still, I remain hopeful. 

I like to think, as a woman and leader in my career, I am fair to those around me; I share the limelight, and receive and appreciate other's talents.  However, I am aware, I could be bias regarding my performance...so, I am constantly critical of my work. 

Maybe I should run for VP.  Palin lacks the ability to self- criticize from what I've seen.  LOL

NYLady profile image

NYLady  says:
15 months ago

Thanks for the comment, Marisue! My personal experience has been mixed -- some really great female supervisors and bosses and some great male bosses. I have more recently worked for males who are passive-aggressive, disengaged, etc., which has been a turn-off. But definitely I give mixed reviews to both sexes. I'm also very concerned about Palin -- I've read up on her and found that many people call her ruthless. Beauty-queen ruthless -- know what I mean?

Thanks again!

Julie-Ann Amos profile image

Julie-Ann Amos  says:
15 months ago

Nice hub, shame the bar chart is too small to read! I'm also up for the hubnuggets vote, so as long as a woman wins, may the best hub win!

NYLady profile image

NYLady  says:
15 months ago

Thanks, Julie. May the best woman win. I will check out your hubs as well, and I'll join your fan club. I'm a bit of a newbie at this, but I'm enjoying it. Any pointers you can lend would be appreciated.

Julie-Ann Amos profile image

Julie-Ann Amos  says:
15 months ago

Don't ask me I'm only 3 weeks old! But only too willing to help if I can! OK mutual fan clubs it is!

jahvon johnson  says:
16 hours ago

i really think men are better leaders because women are to soft when it comes to making harsh decisions

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working