create your own

The Little Dancer and Ballet in Art - An impression of light, music and movement

89
rate or flag this page

By Amanda Severn

The Little Dancer by Edgar Degas, Musee D'Orsay, Paris. Photograph by Bruin, coutesy of Flickr and Wiki Commons

Would you like to write on HubPages?


An impression of light, music and dance, the art of ballet

It is June 2009, and I'm standing in the Musee D'Orsay in Paris with my 14 year old daughter, gazing at a statue of another 14 year old, a little dancer cast in bronze but wearing a tutu of antique tulle, with a faded pink ribbon in her hair. My girl is instantly in love with the slight, boyish figure before her. In a flash, her camera is out, and she is feverishly snapping from all angles. "She's so beautiful, Mum. Look at her skirt - it's real fabric, and her ribbon. And, oh, she looks so sad. Do you think she was uncomfortable standing like that for so long? Mum, can we get a postcard of her?" I nod. Yes, of course. We can get a post card, and a fridge magnet, and a tee-shirt too if you want. And yes, she does look sad. Ballet dancers must work very hard, and I believe this little dancer had a harder time than most.

We move on to the paintings and later we sit in a cafe looking at our photographs and postcards, and the book, in French, about the little dancer.

Marie was a ballet student at the Paris Opéra, where Degas often drew and painted. Degas's first sculpture of her was in a reddish brown wax. The figure was nude to begin with, but. he soon dressed her in clothing made of real fabrics - cream-coloured silk for the bodice, tulle and gauze for the tutu, and silk slippers. He finished his waxwork with real hair tied with a ribbon, and when it was first exhibited, contemporaries were taken aback by the unexpected realism of the piece, and they were moved by this vivid portrayal of the pain and stress of ballet training as endured by such a young girl. For forty years, the wax original stood in Degas' studio, then, after Degas' death, his heirs decided to make bronze casts of it. In these later versions, the models are completely bronze apart from the dancer's gauze tutu and silk ribbon. Less than thirty copies were made, and examples of them can now be seen in some of the world's most prestigious museums.

And the little dancer? Well her story did not end quite so happily. Poverty prevented Marie from finishing her training, and it has been suggested that she eventually drifted into a life of petty crime and prostitution. It is sad to think that her image is one of the most coveted and valued in the history of art, and yet she herself was destined for a life of hardship and degradation.

Ballet Dancers on the Stage by Edgar Degas, 1883

Ballet Dancers on the Stage by Edgar Degas, 1883. This picture is in the Dallas Museum of Arts. Image courtesy of Wiki Commons
Ballet Dancers on the Stage by Edgar Degas, 1883. This picture is in the Dallas Museum of Arts. Image courtesy of Wiki Commons

Ballet Dancers on the Stage by Edgar Degas, 1883

Edgar Degas (1834-1917) was one of a group of artists who have become known as the French Impressionists, though he prefered to describe himself as a realist. Although he associated himself closely with the Impressionists, both in his social life, and as an exhibitor, he eschewed their practice of painting 'en plein air', and would often use photographic reference material for his work. The influence of photography can clearly be seen in his many paintings and pastel drawings of ballet dancers at the Paris Opera, and this picture, with it's unusual cropped composition, is a good example. Note the strong diagonal made by the dancers, and the feeling that you are viewing them from a box at the wings of the stage. The footlights illuminate their legs and tutus, yet there is shadow above and behind.

Dancers in Pink, by Edgar Degas, 1884

Dancers in Pink between scenes, 1884 by Edgar Degas. This painting hangs in the Ny Carlsberg Glypotek in Copenhagen. Image courtesy of Wiki Commons
Dancers in Pink between scenes, 1884 by Edgar Degas. This painting hangs in the Ny Carlsberg Glypotek in Copenhagen. Image courtesy of Wiki Commons

Dancers in Pink by Edgar Degas- a splash of glorious colour

The dancers in this gorgeous oil painting are resting between scenes. They are in full costume, and their rose-pink outfits are a delight. Degas' loose and Impressionistic style perfectly suggests the suppressed excitement and air of anticipation. Once again, the unusual cropping of the picture space hints at the influence of photography.

The Dance Class by Edgar Degas, 1875

The Dance Class by Edgar Degas, 1875. This Oil on Canvas hangs in the Musee D'Orsay in Paris. Image courtesy of Wiki Commons
The Dance Class by Edgar Degas, 1875. This Oil on Canvas hangs in the Musee D'Orsay in Paris. Image courtesy of Wiki Commons

The Dance Class by Edgar Degas, 1875

Strong diagonals in the composition lead the eye to the grey haired dance instructor leaning on his stick as he addresses his students. The dance studio is large and airy, but the girls already appear warm from their exertions and the dancer in the foreground with her back to us, is fanning herself, whilst her seated neighbour is stretching her head back. There's a tiny dog peaking around a dancers legs in the foreground. I wonder if Degas put him there for amusement, or whether he belonged to a dancer?

The Dancer by Pierre-Auguste Renoir, 1874

The Dancer by Pierre-Auguste Renoir, 1874, oil on canvas, hangs in the National Gallery of Art in Washington. Image courtesy of Wiki Commons
The Dancer by Pierre-Auguste Renoir, 1874, oil on canvas, hangs in the National Gallery of Art in Washington. Image courtesy of Wiki Commons

Renoir's Dancer, 1874

Renoir (1841-1919) and Degas were contemporaries on the French art scene in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, and their work was often exhibited side by side, so it is no wonder that they would frequently choose similar subject matter. Renoir's painting of a dancer, completed in 1874 is more posed and serene than Degas' dancers. Her tulle skirt contrasts only slightly with the subtle colours of the background, and only the black choker and the bangle on her left wrist detract from the harmony of the composition.

The Dressing Room by Willard Leroy Metcalf, 1885

Image cortesy of Wiki Commons
Image cortesy of Wiki Commons

An American Impressionist

Willard Leroy Metcalf (1858-1925) was born in Lowell, Massachusetts. A precocious talent, he was fortunate enough to receive one of the first ever scholarships from Boston’s Museum of Fine Art., His restless nature, and love of travel later led him to accept a magazine commission to illustrate articles on the Southwest American Indian Zuni tribe, and he is well-known for the portraits and sketches he completed on a further expedition led by anthropologist Frank Hamilton Cushing.

In 1883, Metcalf's restless spirit took him to France where he studied painting at Paris’ Académie Julian. He formed a friendship with the French Impressionist Claude Monet and for a while acted as a tutor to Monet's children. The influence of the Impressionists is very evident in this delicious painting of Dancers in their dressing room, which was completed in 1885, and is currently in a private collection.


 

Before the Ballet by Pierre Carrier-Belleuse, 1896

Before the Ballet by Pierre Carrier-Belleuse, 1896. Image courtesy of Wiki Commons
Before the Ballet by Pierre Carrier-Belleuse, 1896. Image courtesy of Wiki Commons

Before the Ballet, 1896

Pierre Carrier-Belleuse (1851-1932) was the son of the famous 19th century sculptor Albert Ernest Carrier-Belleuse. He studied under Cabanel and Galland at the Ecole des Beaux-Arts and first exhibited at the Paris Salon in 1875. An impressive, prolific and versatile artist, his works are frequently reproduced and often appear at auction. This delicate image of a ballerina fastening her shoe is one of many paintings of dancers by Carrier-Belleuse.

The Ballet Lesson by Pierre Carrier-Belleuse, 1914

The Ballet Lesson by Pierre Carrier-Belleuse, 1914

This painting by French artist Carrier-Belleuse was completed some 18 years later than the one above it, and I think this shows. The earlier painting is more Impressionistic, whilst this one is very chocolate boxy and reflects a change in artistic taste. My feeling is that M. Carrier-Belleuse was able to adapt to the times, even as a mature artist his work was still evolving.

The Russian Ballet by Auguste Macke, 1912

The Russian Ballet by Auguste Macke, 1912. Image courtesy Wiki Commons
The Russian Ballet by Auguste Macke, 1912. Image courtesy Wiki Commons

Talent destroyed by war

 Auguste Macke (1887-1914) was a German artist, the son of a building contractor. He was born in Meschede, Germany at the tail end of the 19th century, and travel to France and other European countries allowed his burgeoning talents to be exposed to influences as varied as Impressionism, Post-Impressionism, Expressionism, and Fauvism. This result edin a body of work that was often experimental, but always a delight. Sadly this young, promising talent was snuffed out, as he lost his life at Champagne in the very early stages of World War One.

This painting of the Russian Ballet was completed two years before his death, and it has real freshness and exuberance.

Sketch for the costume of Iskander, for the ballet, Le Peri, by Leon Bakst, 1911

Sketch for the costume of Iskander for the ballet, Le Peri by Leon Bakst, 1911. Image courtesy Wiki Commons
Sketch for the costume of Iskander for the ballet, Le Peri by Leon Bakst, 1911. Image courtesy Wiki Commons

The man with designs on ballet

Leon Bakst (1867-1927) achieved fame as a theatrical costume designer. He was a Russian artist, born in Belarus. Originally named Lev Rosenberg, he adopted his grandmother's sir-name as he began to make a name for himself in artistic circles. As a close friend and associate of Sergei Diaghilev, he became increasingly involved with the Ballet Russes, and worked on both set and costume design, as well as providing striking illustrations for books and periodicals of the time. His highly decorative style was much admired, and he later also turned his hand to teaching. His most famous pupil was Marc Chagal.

Some of Degas's ballet paintings and pastel drawings with a musical accompaniment

The Little Dancer by Edgar Degas on display at Joslyn Art Museum, Nebraska

More of Edgas Degas' beautiful paintings and pastel drawings of ballet dancers set to music


News about ballet from around the globe

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Russ Baleson profile image

Russ Baleson  says:
2 months ago

Really enjoyable, thank you. I loved the Little Dancer. It must have been an incredible experience to see it.

knell63 profile image

knell63  says:
2 months ago

I always love your art hubs, you always put such interesting subjects and images together.

diogenes profile image

diogenes  says:
2 months ago

Bitter-sweet story. Your littlun must be a peach.

Regards, Bob

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Hi Russ. Yes, it's a great work of art, and it certainly attracts a lot of attention. Whoever took the decision to cast in bronze from Degas's original wax figure was definitely on to something. There are further copies in some of the world's great museums including the Metropolitan, and the Philadelphia Museum of Art. Having said that, I'm more than happy to stick with the Musee D'Orsay to get my fix, as there so many other fantastic art works there.

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Thanks Knell for your kind words. Art is such a pleasure to write about, and it's nice to see how different people tackle the same subject.

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Hi Bob, my girl absolutely is a peach. She must be to put up with me dragging her around all the art galleries! LOL!

IslandVoice profile image

IslandVoice  says:
2 months ago

Art and Ballet, ballet and art, two of my favorite subjects. This is one fabulous hub. I really enjoyed it. Thanks!

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Thank you Island Voice. I'm glad you liked it!

Hello, hello, profile image

Hello, hello,  says:
2 months ago

There is definitely something special about that statue. Thank you for sharing. Great Hub

creativeone59 profile image

creativeone59  says:
2 months ago

Thank you for your artistic hub, and all the trimmings of gay Paris. creativeone59

adamsinspired  says:
2 months ago

This was an especially lovely hub!

Shalini Kagal profile image

Shalini Kagal  says:
2 months ago

As always Amanda, your art hubs enthrall! Loved all the ones you featured there - but The Little Dancer is special - I don't know whether it's the Musée d'Orsay or just Paris. It's incredible - the pain that you see on her face!

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Hi Hello,Hello, CreativeOne and AdamsInspired,

thank you all for stopping by and commenting. It's good to see you all here!

Hi Shalini, the Little Dancer is in the Musee D'Orsay which is on the banks of the Seine in Paris. It is my most favourite art collection anywhere, and the Little Dancer is only one of the many treasures there. (Manet's Olympia, and le Dejeuner sur L'Herbe, numerous Van Goghs, Renoirs and Picassos - just fabulous paintings, and some great 3D work too.)

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus  says:
2 months ago

Lovely, Amanda! Did you know there is a book about The Little Dancer? I bought it for my daughter, who had a similar reaction when she first read the book and then was able to see the statue when visiting the Md'O with her big sister last year. You might add the book to your amazon list. It is a great gift for those little dancers in our lives. http://www.amazon.com/Degas-Little-Dancer-Laurence

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

We did see the book there - they had it in the museum shop. I offered to get it for my daughter, but she wanted the French book that she found which had other Degas pictures in it, and also this gives us a chance to practise a bit of French together as we try to translate it (LOL!). The other book is very sweet though, and definitely a good suggestion, as you say, for all those little dancers in our lives.

Shalini Kagal profile image

Shalini Kagal  says:
2 months ago

Hi Amanda - one of my favourite places too :)

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Hi Shalini, you have excellent taste, but then I never doubted that anyway!

BrianS profile image

BrianS  says:
2 months ago

The little dancer story is quite special, seems so many talented people end their lives in poverty only to be discovered after they are gone in one way or another, perhaps on this occasion she was the subject but still very sad.

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Hi Brian, that's certainly often the case in the arts. Sometimes it seems that people have to die before they get true recognition. It's not much of a prospect for an artist! LOL!

RNMSN profile image

RNMSN  says:
2 months ago

oh Amanda this is fanastic!!the little dancer is one of my favorites...cannot tell you how many times I have copied her :) yes I admit it...I copy...but degas is not easy to capture...I often felt that the little dacer was sad because the ballet instructor was letting her have it! her poor fingers laced so tight, the face turned up, the second position stance...shes alive/I have aways wanted to hug or pat her, tell her

"it's a now-now"

Marisa Wright profile image

Marisa Wright  says:
2 months ago

Some lovely pictures. The sad story of the little dancer doesn't surprise me - ballet was a less than savoury occupation in those days!

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Hi RNMSN, I didn't know that you were an artist too! You're full of surprises! The little dancer must have got so stiff holding that pose for Degas, although I suppose at 14 she would still have been very supple. She does look as though she's suffering.

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Hi Marisa, you're right about dancing being a not-so-nice occupation in those days. The little dancer posed nude for Degas, and of course that would be considered quite shocking now, but dancers had a certain reputation back then, and as many needed to supplement their income whilst training, modelling was one way of doing it, and of course being 'nice' to the opera patrons was another.

aaronswriting  says:
2 months ago

as beautiful as these pieces are, and the work that the artists put into creating them, the dancers themselves put themselves through excruciating pain to look that beautiful, if justice truly wants to be done, one should seat themselves at the ballet.

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Hi aaronswriting, I agree that seeing the ballet in person bears no comparison to looking at a picture of it. Still, art is my own particular passion, and it's wonderful that one art form can at least express some essence of the other.

Jess Killmenow profile image

Jess Killmenow  says:
2 months ago

As in "A Chorus Line", the Broadway musical, '...everyone is beautiful at the ballet..." One of the The Little Dancer sculptures is on display at our local Boston Museum of Fine Arts. The painting, Ballet Dancers on the Stage reminded me of Renoir because of the redhead. Perhaps there was a love triangle? Loved this hub. Thank you

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Hi Jess, the Impressionists were fond of their red-heads! The lady you mention kind of reminds me of the dancers in Toulouse-Lautrecs posters too. Perhaps she was a favourite model for these gents.

Paraglider profile image

Paraglider  says:
2 months ago

Hi Amanda - the Musee d'Orsay is my favourite art gallery. Somehow the space itself is exactly right for the exhibited works. I enjoyed your choice of familiar and unfamiliar art in this one.

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Hi Paraglider- the Musee d'Orsay is indeed the perfect space for an art gallery, and it's a fabulous building in it's own right. In fact it's hard to believe that so much trouble was taken for a railway station.

Elena. profile image

Elena.  says:
2 months ago

Hello, Amanda! I didn't know this sculpture, much less the story behind it. Poor Marie, such a hit in wax and bronze, and such a misery in human flesh.

The paintings are delicious as always, very pretty article.

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Hello Elena,

Lovely to see you here as always. Yes. poor Marie, immortalised in bronze, but destined for a sad life in the flesh. I suspect that's probably true of many of the models for famous works of art.

Catherine R profile image

Catherine R  says:
2 months ago

Wonderful hub. I have seen pictures of the little dancer but never known anything about her. This was a lovely informative read. Thank you.

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

hi Catherine, thanks for stopping by and commenting. I'm glad you enjoyed the hub.

Cris A profile image

Cris A  says:
2 months ago

Amanda

This was a virtual feast for the eyes and the mind. I love Degas, specially his series on the "blue" dancers. And I remember too watching a BBC special on the ballet dancer where it was implied that she did become a prostitute and that her mother and extreme poverty played a major role in her becoming one. And that the sculpture was heavily critised back then because of Marie's lack of "prettyness" and that her right leg is not proportioned to her other leg (it is longer).

Ah memories of the time I was all over art..so I thank for this great hub :D

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
2 months ago

Hi Cris. I'd never heard that about her leg before. I'll have to take a closer look next time I'm in the Musee d'Orsay. Degas is my favourite of the Impressionists, which is ironic since he was really a much more traditional studio artist in many ways. I've read that he was quite a difficult person to get on with, and even Renoir, who was famously amiable, eventually abandoned him.

Ann  says:
6 weeks ago

Great blog, I love the statue of the little Dancer its one of my favourites! :)

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
6 weeks ago

Thanks for stopping by and commenting, Ann.

Lyn Ferrand  says:
5 weeks ago

Hi! This is a wonderful blog! Really enjoyed reading it and loved the illustrations. I am new to all this, so it helped a lot to see your work. thanks!

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
5 weeks ago

Hi Lyn, I'm glad you enjoyed it. I very much enjoy your work too!

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working