create your own

AMERICAN GIRL: New Homeless Doll

80
rate or flag this page

By cosette


Gwen The Homeless Doll

Image: americangirl.com
Image: americangirl.com

Is the world ready for homeless dolls? Mattel Corporation, purveyors of all things fun and entertaining thinks so. Mattel has added a homeless doll to their American Girl collection, and has people up in arms about it, from angry parents to femininsts and even homeless advocates.

But American Girl has helped homeless organizations, children in need, and families whose parents are in prison or who are victims of floods or other natural disaters. American Girl has given new books and clothing to these organizations totalling $9 million, and provided financial assistance to organizations who provide shelter for homeless people.

So who is Gwen and why is she upsetting everyone? 


Gwen is Gwen Thompson, a little girl who lives in her mother's car. Gwen and her mother lost their home when her father abandoned the little family.

Parents are upset because they feel that Gwen's story is "too much" reality for the doll's targeted age group - 8 and up. Some homeless advocates feel that the $95 to purchase this doll would be better spent on a real homeless child instead of a doll. Still others feel that the doll trivializes the issue of homelessness.

But not everyone feels this way. Some homeless advocates feel that the doll puts a face on the homeless issue and helps raise awareness about homeless children in America.

Fans of American Girl dolls feel that the doll is worth every penny, because they are very well made, large (almost 2 feet tall), and have incredibly lifelike hair and features. Each American Girl dolls comes with a storybook, a beautiful outfit (Gwen's outfit is a modest sundress with sandals), shoes and a small number of accessories, although parents can buy tons of chaming accessories for their children's doll, including pets and furniture.

American Girl Dolls


American Girl dolls celebrate young American girls through the centuries. American Girl dolls include:

  • Kristen Larson, a pioneer girl who leaves a comfortable life to explore new frontiers.
  • Molly McIntire, a little girl who waits for her father to come home from World War II.
  • Felicity Merriman, a little girl growing up during America's Revolutionary War period.

American Girl dolls help modern girls deal with their own struggles and emotions, since their dolls may be experiencing some things they might be going through and even though their lives or circumstances may be completely different, they are still little girls like them with the same hopes, dreams and fears.

American Girl Controversy

 


The American Girl line of dolls has not been without controversy. In the past, the dollmakers have released other dolls that made people stop and ponder their children's toys:

  • Addy Walker, a slave girl hoping to win her freedom during the Civil War.
  • Kit Kittredge, a little girl caught in the middle of the Great Depression.
  • Kaya, a spiritual yet rebellious Nez Perce girl who loves nature and horses.
  • Julie Albright, a free spirit who challenges authority and traditional roles by trying out for the boy's basketball team.
  • Chrissa Maxwell, a little girl who has a hard time adjusting to a new school because of a clique of bullies aptly named "The Mean Bees".

What is American Girl trying to say? 


I think American Girl is trying to represent America and issues every little American girl faces at some point in their childhood. It is also exploring the diversity of America - hence the name "American Girl", and some dolls like Gwen raise awareness about social issues like homelessness - Issues that our children might already be aware of anyway.

While these dolls target girls age 8 and up, they encourage parents to interact with their children and share the books that each doll comes with to tell her story. Even children as young as eight are conscious of other children who might live a different life than they do, and they want to know about their world and the people in it.

American Girl dolls are just that - American Girls. These dolls represent America's history and all American girls, even ones who live in the family car - not just ones who drive Corvettes and live in dream houses.

◊This article was written by cosette and published at hubpages.com. If you are not reading this article at hubpages.com, it is a stolen article.◊

This hub is brought to you by:


Print   —   Rate it:  up  down  flag this hub

Ask a Question

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

dohn121 profile image

dohn121  says:
2 months ago

I'm not really sure how a "homeless doll" made its way into the mainstream. Are these dolls actually taking off? The Nez Perce doll Kaya is another controversial subject as that tribe was badly mistreated by the U.S. Cavalry. It just questions just how far corporations will go, unless of course these companies, such as Mattel is giving back to those who they are exploiting. Controversial yet fascinating all the same. Thanks, cosette for sharing.

cosette profile image

cosette  says:
2 months ago

thanks, Dohn. :)

lyricsingray profile image

lyricsingray  says:
2 months ago

I think your right, I think she is just that too, 'The American Doll' and every detail that represents. In the real way. Thanks for a really well written and interesting Hub. Hey, you check out your interview Hub yet?Haven't seen a comment yet LOL But got a nasty one - yikes. Back to you - thanks girl, great job as always.

paulgc profile image

paulgc  says:
2 months ago

Organisations make alot of money from controversy so i ask this question, who's kidding who?, Interesting hub,well done.

cosette profile image

cosette  says:
2 months ago

thank you for your comments, you guys!

Aya Katz profile image

Aya Katz  says:
2 months ago

Cosette, very interesting information. It probably makes sense to have an American Girl homeless doll. But... how come all the dolls have such manageable hair? No rats. No tangles. What do her clothes look like? Are they spotless, too?

Paradise7 profile image

Paradise7  says:
2 months ago

This is a great hub, Cosette. My first thought was (along with dohn, I think) "You've gotta be kidding. They'll go to any lengths to make a profit, even attempting to capitalize off the plight of homeless people." Then I (right along with dohh, I think) read the rest of the story. Hmmm. It raises awareness, especially in young kids, of how others live. Hmmmm. They DO give back some of that exhorbitant $95.00 price tag to actually help homeless people and others. Hmmm. They have other dolls presenting girls as heros in slave situations, pioneer situations, as well as homeless situations. Hmmmm. Got my attention and got me thinking on this one. I may have to re-assess that first original impression.

Michael Willis profile image

Michael Willis  says:
2 months ago

very well written Cosette.

missalyssa profile image

missalyssa  says:
2 months ago

Another great hub Cosette...Quite a controversial doll! But I think that - especially with the controversial decisions of the past - that yes, they are simply making dolls to express the American condition - the good and the ugly....Interesting...thanks!

cosette profile image

cosette  says:
2 months ago

thank you for your comments everyone.

sexylittlegirl911  says:
2 months ago

That is so cool !!!

cosette profile image

cosette  says:
2 months ago

thank you for your comment.

dtmjk profile image

dtmjk  says:
2 months ago

Are a portion of the proceeds going to support the needs of homeless children? If so, I think that this doll and the included book would be a great way to introduce children to the idea of giving back to the community.

cosette profile image

cosette  says:
5 weeks ago

hello. i am not sure about the proceeds for this particular doll, although American Girl regularly donates considerable amounts of money to homeless and other charitable organizations. thanks for your comment!

EYES CHAMbERS profile image

EYES CHAMbERS  says:
2 weeks ago

This was great to read. I had never heard of these dolls and I find them a great idea. I like your outlook on them too. It's important to express these different times in American history through childrens eyes, that way they understand early on and have a chance at being more open. I enjoyed reading this hub of yours cosette. I'm surious if they have a doll who as a little girl is marching by her mothers side in hope to women being able to vote. How cute would that be!

-EYES

cosette profile image

cosette  says:
2 weeks ago

thanks very much, Eyes.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

Do you think America is ready for a homeless doll?

  • Sure! It's a whole new world.
  • No! Keep politics out of children's toys!
See results without voting
working