Bruce Bueno de Mesquita's Crystal Ball
77
11-5-09 NYT Book Review "The Predictioneer's Game"
- Nicholas Thomson's Review of Bruce Bueno de Mesquita's "The Predictioneer's Game"
Self interest is central to Bueno de Mesquita's analysis and predictions: Yes, you read that correctly. On Page 15 of The Predictioneers Game, Bueno de Mesquita equates Mother Teresa with the likes of Mohamed Atta.
Bruce Bueno de Mesquita's Crystal Ball
Until reading "Is Iran going to build a bomb?" in today's NY Times Magazine I'd never heard of Bruce Bueno de Mesquita. Since the subject of the article is of more than passing interest to me, it was the first article I read. Also, The name Bruce Bueno de Mesquita caught my eye. I've provided a link to this interesting article below.
Bueno de Mesquita is a professor of applied game theory at New York University and a fellow at the Hoover Institution at Stanford University. He is also a consultant to the CIA whose predictions are usually more accurate than those of CIA staffers. Since the early 1980s the CIA has hired Bueno de Mesquita to perform more than 1,000 predictions.
How does he make the predictions? Not with a crystal ball but rather he analyzes the issues at great length, gathering information about the individuals who are likely to influence the event under study--about their attitudes on the issue and their estimated power to influence the particular event. He assigns numbers to the players from 0 to 200 and plugs the information into his computer where he applies his proprietary game theory software.
On the issue of the likelihood of Iran building a nuclear bomb Bueno de Mesquita identified 90 individuals and organizations with an interest or influence on the question, ranging from Khamenei, Amahdinejad and Iranian hardliners to the U.N. to the U.S. to Israel and assigned each a number between 0 and 200, with 0 representing "no nuclear capacity at all" and 200 representing a nuclear test. Bueno de Mesquita then pushed the button his computer, and out popped the answer.
The outcome changes over time, beginning at 160, indicating likely bomb making, but declines over time to 118, meaning that Iran will not make a nuclear bomb.
The NYTimes Magazine article linked below provides considerably more detail on how Bueno de Mesquita reached this conclusion and on his career as a modern Nostradamus. It's a fascinating story.
The result
Will Iran Get the Bomb?
- Is Iran Going to Build a Bomb?
Can Game Theory Predict When Iran Will Get the Bomb?
The New Nostradamus
- The New Nostradamus | GOOD
Michael A. M. Lerner talks with the man who is putting the “science” back in political science.
Bruce Bueno de Mesquita predicts what Iran's going to do.
- Bruce Bueno de Mesquita predicts Iran's future | Video on TED.com
TED Talks Bruce Bueno de Mesquita uses mathematical analysis to predict (very often correctly) such messy human events as war, political power shifts, Intifada ... After a crisp explanation of how he does it, he offers three predictions on the future
Wikibio for Bruce Bueno de Mesquita
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
Me too. Thanks for your comment.
Self interest is central to CIA consultant Bueno de Mesquita's analyses and predictions:
Yes, you read that correctly. On Page 15 of “The Predictioneer’s Game,” Bueno de Mesquita equates Mother Teresa with the likes of Mohamed Atta.











Doc Snow says:
3 months ago
I sure hope he's right on this one!