Federal Government Cash for Clunkers Program - Did it Work?
54The federal government Cash for Clunkers program and the falling unemployment rate are two major economic events in the news. The expert economists and the Obama administration are elated about these stories.
1. The federal government Cash for Clunkers program ended up costing the U.S. taxpayer $3 billion. The Obama administration, auto dealers, and auto companies (including those outside the United States) are jumping up and down. According to them, this was a rousing success. But was it really?
In my opinion, the program was a failure in everything except for adding to the federal government debt.
Did it increase car sales long term? No. It simply moved long term car sales into a 2 month period when the program was operating.
On a long term basis, it did not stimulate consumer spending. Instead, the consumer cut back on other spending and put his money into a new car.
A Perfectly Good Clunker to the Trash
But probably many of those who took advantage of the federal government
Cash for Clunkers program were driving the clunker for a reason. They
could not afford the cost of a new car.
So they are taking on
more debt – something many could not afford to do. This is even though
their loan is less than if there was no government subsidy.
But
they should not worry. When they start defaulting on their auto loans,
the federal government will probably swoop down and offer them a
bailout.
2. The unemployment rate fell to 9.4% in July. It would
be great if unemployment numbers had hit a bottom and would quickly
recover.
But if you look more closely at the numbers, they are not as rosy as they may appear on the surface.
Our
economy lost 247,000 jobs in July. This is a lower number than what was
expected and what we have seen in the last several months. This is
certainly good news.
But the reduction in the unemployment rate was caused by the fact that 422,000 people gave up and stopped looking for work.
If
you look at the Job Opportunity and Labor Turnover survey conducted by
the Bureau of Labor and Statistics, only 2.9% of workers found or
switched jobs in July, a record low.
Here is my take on the overall U.S. economy.
I
expect to see an expansion in the Gross Domestic Product (growth in the
economy) in the 3rd quarter. This would end several quarters of
negative growth.
This growth might continue into subsequent
quarters. But I feel that much of this growth is being caused by the
artificial government programs such as the federal government Cash for
Clunkers program and the tax credit given to first time homebuyers.
When
these programs end, we will see a major decline in growth in those
industries. In other words, this growth in the 3rd quarter has little
to do with long term growth in the auto and housing industries.
President Obama Spends Like the U.S. is Loaded with Cash
I
feel that the economy will see some growth in the coming months. The
massive spending by the Obama administration will have a lot to do with
this. There is no way that we can throw trillions of dollars at the
economy without some economic boost.
But my feeling is that there is “no free lunch.” This is very important.
We
are spending money we don’t have. At some point, we must pay the price
for this spending. When this occurs, we will have a major contraction
in the economy and the stock market.
This massive spending is causing major budget deficits.
There are only a few ways to cover these deficits. They must be covered in order that our country pay its bills.
Borrow
the money. A major portion of the money we borrow comes from foreign
countries such as China, Japan, and countries in Europe. Already some
of these countries are starting to baulk at loaning us money. The
result will be rising interest rates. This will have a devastating
effect on the U.S. consumer and business.
We can increase taxes.
The Democrats want to “tax the rich.” However, there is absolutely no
way that this group can pay for all these deficits. Increased taxes
will affect most Americans. The result of any major tax increase will
be a downward pressure on consumer spending. This will have a very
negative impact on the economy.
Print money to pay for the
deficits. The result will be hyper-inflation. This will have a negative
impact on all Americans, especially those living on a fixed income or
investments.
Scott Hubbard has retired from 25 years as a
Chief Financial Officer in Corporate America. He now enjoys teaching
corporate professionals and network marketers how to apply attraction
marketing online and how to generate free qualified leads on the
internet.
You can reach him toll-free at 877-878-4036 or by email
at Scott@ScottHubbard-Consulting.com. You can learn more about his primary business by visiting your guide to abundant wealth.
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
Mike,
Good comment. Of course, I didn't say you can't pay debt with debt. What I did say was that if you borrow money to pay debt, this will be devastating for our economy through higher interest rates. Borrowing money to pay off borrowed money is something that could have only been dreamed up by our politicians.
If we pay down our debt by printing money, this will be just as devastating because of resulting hyper inflation.
Neither one of these approaches makes any sense. But this is the "wise" policy our politicians in Washington, DC are following.
Significant curbs on the Federal Reserve, getting rid of all lobbyists, and allowing capitalism do its job would be great steps toward solving our economic problems.
Scott Hubbard










MikeNV says:
6 weeks ago
What you mean you can't pay debt with debt? Sure you can... it's Public Policy. If you run out of money you just print more. More money means more inflation... which is of course solved by printing even more money. Right? This is the "Change" the Obama Administration has brought to America? Seems like Status Quo with more spending. You can't just hope this problem will go away. The solution is to eliminate the Federal Reserve, get back on a Gold Standard, Rid Washington of lobbyists, and get back to letting Capitalism do it's job.