create your own

Clutter Bugs

73
rate or flag this page

By Jerilee Wei



A Long Association

I've talked about fire ants, roaches, spiders, and the shooflies in my pie, but I haven't talked about the clutter bugs. Seems like I've always had one or more in my life. All of them wonderful in their own right. Guess that means I'm some sort of bug collector, or at least attractor.

If you live long enough, most of us know one, love one, loved one, or have at least heard about one or more. Thanks to a popular television series, "Clean House" here in America, we get to see some very fine examples of clutter bugs. We even get to see those nominated for the "messiest house in America." Being voyeuristic is apparently part of the American psyche.

While the show is very entertaining and even pokes fun at hoarding, the behavior can be a symptom of a serious problem. Individuals who hoard often feel the need to collect and save things that the rest of us would discard. Additionally, they will feel a stronger need than the rest of us to lay in a stockpile of "needed" items. They'll cruise yard sales, go through other peoples trash, and even dumpster dive.

The items that they need to collect often consumes their lives. They spend a lot of time sorting items, usually in an effort to find something they "know they have." The sorting, or rather moving things from one pile to another, seldom results in throwing any trash out of any significance. So valuable are their things, that they can become more and more reclusive and be very stressed if they must leave home even for a few days. Fearing that something will happen to their treasures, or that someone will break in and steal things.

My first association with a clutter bug was with my beloved grandmother, who was the primary caregiver to both me and my two siblings. Her clutter and hoarding, however, seemed on the surface -- to be within the acceptable norms of someone who just has a messy room, or a room with more stuff than room. What my siblings mistook for "messy" or "cluttered" had a deeper meaning for me, for being the oldest. I knew that before she came to live with us, her whole house looked that way. Her hoarding was kept in check by my mother who ran a tight ship when it came to a clean house.

I can speak with authority on this subject, thanks to her and a long association with the extreme clutter of others in my life that would follow her. There is a clinical name for this illness, it's sometimes called compulsive hoarding syndrome. It is a form of obsessive compulsive disorder or known as OCD.


The Neighbor Next Door

As a young bride, we were living in Washington, D.C. in the row house, my husband's grandmother had owned since the early 1900s. Next door an older man lived alone, unless you counted several large German Shepherds that were his companions in life. He had a high paying position with the government, was a pleasant man, although somewhat shy.

From the outside, his house looked like every house on the block. It was only if he happened open the front door, that you caught a glimpse of piles of newspapers and books, impeding the front entrance hall. When he died, it took the city weeks to clean out his home. He lay dead in that house for several weeks before anyone knew he had died. Six starving dogs were removed, four dead dogs had died sometime in the recent past.

Gloved men in hazard suits and gas masks cleaned out more than forty years of garbage, human excrement, and animal feces. At least the neighborhood now knew why, our block had it's own stench on hot summer nights back when he was alive. The rats and roaches all had to find new homes too.


Marrying A Clutter Bug

When I was twenty-nine years old, I was a young newly divorced mother of two. I made a disastrous decision to move one thousand miles away from anyone I knew, to start a new life. I'd been promised a job in a hospital, that once I moved there, had been filled before my arrival. Soon the meager savings I had brought with me, was spent and we were living on the edge of homelessness.

With no electricity, behind in my rent, a broken down car that wouldn't start -- I was desperate to earn money to feed and care for my children. My rescue came in disguise of a much older man, who offered me a home, electricity, and a small salary. His exact offer was, "I'll take away all of your old problems and give you some new ones" (well, he didn't lie, but that's another hub, maybe more).

This physicist, working in a think tank for a major defense contractor, moved us into one of his many houses that he claimed to be renovating. His big excuse for all the clutter that was stacked up the walls, was that he was a busy bachelor who needed a "woman's touch." My small salary and free rent was to compensate me for cleaning up the mess.

I cleaned and painted for an entire summer, while he charmed my children into championing his plead for me to marry him. The entire neighborhood applauded the clean up as it had long ago spilled into the yard, creating a public nuisance until I came along. By the time the house was cleaned and painted, junk cars, broken appliances, and building supplies were all gone. By that time, I had agreed to marry him.

Little did I know, this brilliant man, was an extreme compulsive hoarder. Years later, in the end, long after we had gone separate ways -- it was evident that his was a life long OCD hoarding problem in the extreme. What happened to the house that I cleaned that summer? He had filled again with more junk, that spilled into homemade outbuildings and the yard. Finally, he made the newspapers a few years ago, when the county seized his assets, fined him heavily, and bulldozed his several homes.

Someone Just Like Him


Hoarding Pets

The hoarding of animals is a different form of the same compulsive disorder and may go hand-in-hand with other symptoms of hoarding. Like the neighbor I described above, this type of OCD usually is confined to animals that are easily confined or concealed inside. Because of their numbers, the animals end up being neglected, infested with fleas, and living in unsanitary conditions.

Not all hoarders will limit their animal hoarding to pets, others with some land will occasionally do the same with large numbers of farm animals, such as horses.

 

Are more people today exhibiting this hoarding syndrome?

  • Yes.
  • No.
See results without voting

Symptoms of Hoarding

The symptoms of hoarding are many, here are some examples:

  • Unwilling and unable to get rid of anything
  • Constantly accumulating more unneeded or useless things
  • Piles of newspapers, magazines, junk mail, and books
  • Excessive saving of used food containers
  • Saving things that most people would discard in the trash
  • Extremely cluttered and trashy cluttered rooms
  • Difficulty with normal daily activities
  • Problems with increasing procrastination
  • Difficulty in decisions
  • A personality of perfectionism
  • A different viewpoint on organizing than the rest of the world
  • Valuing possession more than loved ones
  • Selfishness in allowing others to use objects
  • Insisting on collecting items that they "might" use someday
  • Insisting on keeping items that they "might" use later
  • Not wanting to waste anything, they will save everything
  • Hoarding animals, particularly inside the house where others can't see how many they have

 


Denial and Hoarding

Denial can be a big part of the hoarder's personality, they just don't see what the problem is. Only after others have pointed the issue out, can some of them even fathom that they have a problem. Anyone who has been accused by loved ones of being a hoarder or pack rat, should ask themselves the following questions:

  • Is the clutter in my home in many or all of the rooms?
  • If I had to get rid of everything, how upset would I be?
  • Does the clutter in my home prevent me from having people over?
  • Does the clutter in my home lead to stress (such as not being able to find the keys, phone, etc. when I'm about to go somewhere)?
  • Does it take me longer to clean things up than it should? (Example: All day to clean one closet).
  • Do I regularly put off cleaning and organizing things in my home?
  • Do I have more pets than I should? Or, do I have more pets than most people?
  • Do others, especially people who love or care for me, suggest that I have a problem or need professional help?
  • Am I frequently tardy to work or school?
  • Do I avoid things that are unpleasant to me?

Who Is At Risk?

Just about anyone could be at risk for having this problem. Some will remain only harmless disorganized pack rats (like my grandmother), while others will go to the extreme (like my former husband). The disorder is not fully understood by the medical community, in terms of knowing what causes it.

What they do know is:

  • Hoarding usually starts at an early age, just before puberty.
  • You are more likely to become a hoarder if others in your family live that way.
  • Many people don't develop this OCD until a very stressful event occurs in their lives, such as the death of a loved one, loss of everything in a natural disaster, eviction, etc.
  • They are perfectionists.
  • They have attachments to objects that are excessive compared to the rest of us.
  • Hoarding will get worse the older the person gets, if they do not get help.

Remember, these kind of disorders often are part of a bigger mental health picture -- hoarders often have other disorders, such as:

  • Depression
  • Social phobias
  • Anxiety
  • ADD

Loving the Hoarder

When someone you love is a hoarder, you can:

  • Encourage professional treatment
  • Get help for yourself from a professional, in how to cope with this issue
  • In extreme cases, when health and safety becomes a serious issue --you may need to contact other authorities, such as the: (1) Fire Department; (2) Public Health; (3) Animal Welfare; (4) Police
  • Learn how to support your hoarder with out enabling them
  • Gently raise their awareness that there is a problem
  • Don't do any cleaning for them too quickly
  • Don't throw things out against their will

 

 


The Consequences of Hoarding

The consequences of hoarding can be serious. They can include:

  • Living in unsanitary conditions
  • Unsanitary conditions that pose a risk to health
  • Not being able to bathe
  • Not being able to cook
  • Not wearing clean clothes
  • Problems at work
  • Extreme loneliness
  • Feelings of hopelessness
  • Social isolation from family and peers
  • Fire hazard
  • Illness

 

Medical Treatment for Hoarders

Unfortunately, it is not always easy to get hoarders to want to get help and when they do, the help may prove to be ineffective over the long term. The main key, is that they have to be highly motivated internally to change. Most with this OCD have little internal motivation. The best that can be hoped for in most cases, is to alleviate the problem and help them control the clutter.

There are two medical approaches:

  • Psychotherapy in the form of cognitive behavior therapy
  • Medications that reduce hoarding urges and anti-depression medications

 


Rightous Hoarders

Many clutter bugs don't believe that they are hoarders, or that they have OCD. This makes it difficult to get them the help that they need. It goes back and way beyond, the old "waste not, want not" clique that used to be a common saying. Many hoarders view their behavior as "right" and non-hoarders as in the wrong.

For The Borderline Hoarder

Some of us, might worry as we look around and ask ourselves -- "Am I on the slippery slope of becoming a hoarder?" Apparently, this is increasingly becoming a problem in the United States. The biggest component of becoming a hoarder, has to do with anxiety and feelings of loss of control.

So what do you do, if you want to live a less cluttered life?

  • Get rid of things you've kept that remind you of certain events, even know you'll never use or need them again.
  • Donate items to charitable organization, like Goodwill and the Salvation Army
  • Stop spending therapy (it doesn't work for the long term)
  • Make a hard rule with yourself: If I buy something new, I get rid of something I don't need or will never use.
  • Don't keep items that you are going to use "someday" or fix "someday"
  • Get organized or get help getting organized
  • Make a priority list

 

Help For Hoarders

The Long Association Continues

For many years now, we've had a dear friend with this hoarding obsessive compulsive disorder. We will continue to support that person whenever they are receptive to our help. And we will continue to love them, "just as they are." Having this disorder, doesn't make them a bad person, or less of a person.

Aftermath of Hoarding

Clutter Bugs in the News

  • BMC may up monthly ad, hoarding charges by 50%rediff.com2 days ago

    According to MCGM, the monthly advertisement and hoarding charges are likely to be increased by at least 50 per cent.

  • Hoarding to blame for fire death in EvanstonChicago Tribune29 hours ago

    Hoarded items may have trapped man, 82, authorities say An 82-year-old man died in an Evanston house fire Tuesday morning surrounded by stacks of old magazines, newspapers, household goods and other hoarded items, officials said.

  • Phoenixville woman charged with neglect and hoardingThe Phoenix15 hours ago

    Journal Register News Service PHOENIXVILLE — As part of the Chester County Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals' job, officials investigate complaints of pet abuse.

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Lissie profile image

Lissie  says:
16 months ago

Move every few years - my partner has a problem with keeping books hes read - but once you box them up and then pay storage charges for a few years the decision to declutter become much easier!

Jerilee Wei profile image

Jerilee Wei  says:
16 months ago

My method for books is to sell them either on Amazon.com or at a flea market. They go to a nice home and you get some of the money you spent on them back -- so you can buy more books! Thanks!

Sally's Trove profile image

Sally's Trove  says:
16 months ago

Thank you for an excellent, and rather shocking, overview of hoarding.

I would like to add another thought about what can underlie this behavior. We baby boomers watched many of our parents turn into clutter bugs in their later years. During the Great Depression, when our parents were children and very poor, they had nothing. As times improved and they moved into a better financial picture, accumulating "things" seemed to become very important, especially after their own children were grown and on their own. Now, it's almost as if the "things" our parents could not have during the hard times are stock-piled to fill an empty nest. I have seen drawers and closets crammed full of used plastic bag twist ties ("You can never have enough."), broken utensils and china ("I just need to sit down one day and fix these things with some glue."), clothing and accessories collected over thirty or forty years ("They'll be valuable on the vintage market one day."), and of course, the balls and balls of string, aluminum foil, and rubber bands, and covered jars full of match books, buttons, and used paper clips. Not to mention huge volumes of useless bric-a-brac, used linens, and paper goods picked up at yard sales and liquidations because they were so cheap.

Not only are these situations frightening for all the reasons you mention in your Hub, but they are also very sad.

Jerilee Wei profile image

Jerilee Wei  says:
16 months ago

Thanks! You raise a very good point that I meant to include and as an observer of this behavior all my life, my gut feeling is it has a lot to do with "control" when our lives feel out of control and "fear" of being without.

hot dorkage profile image

hot dorkage  says:
16 months ago

This hub touched many buttons for me.  My mother in law and her sister are both hoarders, her thing is magazines and books & knicknacks.    I myself have lots of books and music but I do actually refer to them from time to time and at least mine are organized.   I just ditched a couple boxes of ones I knew were not useful to me any more and it felt good.  Last year I also took a whole shitload of old computer bits and pieces down to a place in Eugene that takes them, tests them and sells them if they are marketable at all and renders them if not.  Soo much better than the landfill.     It is so nice that a new  goodwill store is 2 blocks from me, now any time I want to walk the dog and ditch a few things I just do it before I have regrets and get into that "Oh I might wear this" trap. 

I have found that the best way to not hoard stuff is just don't buy it in the first place. I buy pretty much food and new socks and underwear these days.

Jerilee Wei profile image

Jerilee Wei  says:
16 months ago

Good suggestion on the old computers and I agree, it's best just not to buy "things" in the first place. As to the buying, I have a rule with myself -- if I buy a new piece of clothing for instance, I get rid of something old, something I don't wear anymore, or that is starting to get frayed. Thanks!

DarleneMarie profile image

DarleneMarie  says:
16 months ago

Great Hub Jerilee! It is a sickness that many did not know existed utill recently. Shedding some light on the subject I think helps people who have the disorder know that they are not alone and that there is hope.

I especially like your suggestions on living a less cluttered life :)

Jerilee Wei profile image

Jerilee Wei  says:
16 months ago

Thanks! If any hub I write helps, I'm all for it.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

Check Out The Latest!

  • Choose Your Garden -- The Roman Herb Garden

    Perhaps my most favorite garden design of all, is the Roman Herb Garden. It reminds me of a translation from a recipe book written in the first century A.D. Now, there is a lot of misinformation when it... - 26 hours ago

  • Choose Your Garden - The Witch's Herb Garden

    What do you do when your best childhood friend announces late in life to you, that she is a practicing witch? Well, if you are me, you back peddle in that conversation and take it in stride. You have to... - 3 days ago

  • Choose Your Garden - The Monk's Herb Garden

    The ancient practice of maintaining a small distance or separation from the outside world, makes a monk's garden design one that works well as a garden of reflection, meditation, and a testament to... - 4 days ago

  • Choose Your Garden -- Native American Herb Garden

    It stands to reason that those who were here first should know the most about the native plants of this continent. It's believed that Native American used more than seven hundred and fifty documented native... - 6 days ago

  • Choose Your Garden - The Literary Herb Garden

    There are times when I think modern man and woman might not be as smart as people from the past. When you think about it, the Bible and the works of Chaucer and Shakespeare are rich in references to herbs.... - 7 days ago

working