Customer Service is a Waste: Just Give Us Your Money

57
rate or flag this page

By pgrundy



Warning: This Hub Contains Sporadic Ranting

I am sailing into my seventh year as a 1-800 number customer service representative. That's right, this Hub is a horror Hub. So if you are squeamish, please leave now. Management will not be held liable for heart attacks, strokes, vein popping, or any other physical or mental impairments resulting from attempts to get, give, or talk about customer service.

My rants have become so famillar I can pretty much turn them on at will and go do something else. I can rant about this topic in my sleep now, but what motivated me to write this particular hub was a golden moment in a meeting yesterday, where a not-so-innocent question (from me, bitter longtime CSR) provoked the following exasperated answer from managment:

"Look, from a management perspective, taking care of the customers we already have just isn't profitable. We want new customers and that's all we want. If you start taking the time to solve one existing customer's problem, pretty soon they are all going to expect it. Just get them off the phone unless they are going to buy something."

I've been waiting seven years for someone in management to say it just that plainly. I mean, we all KNOW it's true, right? But I wanted them to say it, admit it, blurt it out, tell the truth!!!!

For a moment I was in shock. I wasn't sure I'd heard what I'd heard. But as it began to sink in, I felt this wave of satisfaction sweep over me at the final truthiness of it all. Persist, and you will one day succeed. It only took me just under seven years to succeed at getting a corporate management drone to say it out loud.

I rock.


Yes, That Phone Menu is There to Discourage You

At my current CSR job, we have the phone menu from hell. It goes on for five minutes, asking you to punch in everything from your blood type to your grandmother's maiden name and then giving you inadequate time to enter this info via your dial pad. Because of this, many customers have to hang up and start over as many as four or five times before they get to a CSR, at which point there is a good chance they will be immediately transferred to another phone menu and eventually, another CSR. By the time they get to me, they are generally a tad cranky.

Here's a sample conversation, one I had just yesterday:

"Thank you for calling Behemoth Bank, my name is P Grundy, how may I not help you today?"

"Hold it right there! I want to ask you a personal question before we go any further!"

"No problem. Shoot me."

"Have you ever personally called this bank and tried to navigate your own goddamn phone menu???"

"Yes sir, it's truly hideous sir. A masterpiece of passive-aggressive torture disguised as convenience."

"Well then how the hell..."

"Excuse me for interrupting you sir, but you can bypass the entire menu by hitting *0 at any time. Just a head's up for future calls. And, you're welcome."

"It doesn't tell you that! How the hell am I supposed to know that!?!"

"You're not supposed to know that. I'm telling you that for future calls. Also, I'm hoping this call is recorded so I can get fired for telling you that, and collect unemployment insurance, something I've never received in 37 years of working hard constantly. Help me sir. Please. Help me escape."

Customers Impede the Natural Flow of Money Upward

How, you may well ask, did we ever get to this sorry state of affairs? You may have heard stories about a long-ago time in America when business was conducted by 1) providing a service or a product that 2) customers then purchased and 3) the merchant, who was 4) a human being 5) encouraged the customers buy more of, enriching 6) the merchant and making 7) the customers 8) happy.

Any fool can see that this is way too many steps.

President Ronald Reagan (also known as Saint Ronald of Our Most Holy Supply Side) certainly saw it, which is why back in the 1980's he cleared away lots of pesky regulations that limited the size and the activities of money-making corporations. By instigating these changes, President Ron made it possible for corporations to become large enough and strong enough to cut this antiquated business model down to only three simple steps: 1) Customer needs product or service, 2) gigantic corporate entity promises to provide product or service and takes lots of customer's money as an electronic debit from customer's bank account, then 3) customer futilely calls worthless 1-800 customer service number over and over again trying to get promised product or service or refund or whatever (Does it really matter what these silly customers want? Do we even care?) until customer dies or gives up or both.

This direct flow of customer money away from their own personal bank accounts into the bank accounts of corporate CEOs has created millions of new jobs for people with advanced degrees, thus transforming our country from a gritty, 19th century manufacturing economy, to a sleek 21st century service economy, where even the most impractical, over-educated PhD has the same opportunity as any recent high school graduate to protect corporate CEOs from customers by forming a human phone-answering shield and not helping anybody.

For example, in November of 2007 our bank's CEO left the company with a severance package of $240 million after making decisions that took the bank's stock from $38.74 per share last summer down to $5.25 per share as of this March. He did this, I am certain, to set an example for the rest of us. He wanted to show that, contrary to all the recent negative press, there is no double standard in corporate America. Every single overpaid CEO is as committed to not helping anyone with anything as any lowly CSR. We are all equals in this brave new business model. His work done, he has moved on, passing the torch to his successor, who is trying hard to surpass his achievements.

Only in America.


Now What?

Hey, if I knew would I be working in a call center?

Seriously though, stop dealing with corporations, if possible. I mean period, ever. Anytime you can buy from or deal with a real human person whose name you know and who you can go see, live, when you need something, do that instead. Write to your congresspersons and let them know that you don't appreciate 1) being charged $300 for a cell phone termination fee when your contract has long run out and you don't owe this fee, 2) being charged hundreds of dollars in bank fees because your bank did not make the paycheck you've been depositing for 20 years available for three days after you put that hard-earned money in the bank, 3) fill in your own horror story (I know you have one so come on, let it rip) here, and 4) watching CEOs make millions of dollars for running corporations into the ground and losing your hard earned money, without apology.

Make noise. Speak up. Smash that phone.

And oh yes, dial *0 to get right to a live human being (who can't help you either)!

Video: How To Get Better Customer Service

Print   —   Rate it:  up  down  flag this hub

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Hoodala profile image

Hoodala  says:
2 years ago

Very Very well said.

robie2 profile image

robie2  says:
2 years ago

oh pg--you have done it again. Wonderful. When are you going to turn all these rants into a book and make some money on them?St. Ronald of our Most Holy Supply Side-- I just love it --the patron saint of trickle-down, isn't he? I must remember to light a candle ROTFL. Seriously, your frustration leaps off the page along with your humor and you have put the entire modern American working dilemma in a nutshell--the anonymity of the big box store, big bank and the telephone tree....equally bad for consumers and providers. The corporations have eaten our souls--CEO souls get eaten too. Bravo--oops I mean Brava:-)

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
2 years ago

Thanks guys!

Rob Jundt profile image

Rob Jundt  says:
2 years ago

Outstanding! That's all I have. Thanks and have a nice day! :)

marisuewrites profile image

marisuewrites  says:
2 years ago

been there...done that. I hate automated phone calls; we answer our business line as a priority -- personally, every day every time. Most companies phone skills either don't exist or are so rehearsed you want to scream.

From my insurance company, the phone company, the cable, and even WalMart or any other dept store....get ready for 15 transfers, 50 questions, and no satisfaction. Ain't got no satisfaction...!

SirDent profile image

SirDent  says:
2 years ago

I laughed, I cried, and got mad also. Great hub.

francetales profile image

francetales  says:
2 years ago

It would be funny if you cold record some of those calls, maybe unethical, but funny nonetheless.

marisuewrites profile image

marisuewrites  says:
2 years ago

Well, they say they're monitoring the call; tell them so are you. LOL

ColdWarBaby profile image

ColdWarBaby  says:
2 years ago

It only took five years for me to hear a district sales manager tell me “the kind of service you are giving your customers is something we just can’t offer any more.  It’s just not practical or cost effective.”

It’s OK.  These corporations are killing themselves by killing the rest of us.  I guess that’s small consolation for those held in debt bondage by a bunch of psychopathic money worshippers. Excellent HUB full of very sad truths.

amy jane profile image

amy jane  says:
2 years ago

LOL, you do rock! Rockstar! :)

Andy Xie profile image

Andy Xie  says:
2 years ago

Great hub! What I personally hate most is when you get the computer person that tries speaking to you. Instead of a phone menu, it's just a robot that goes "please tell me what you are inquiring about" and you have to say "customer service" over and over again.

Satori profile image

Satori  says:
2 years ago

This is beautiful! While many might assume that it goes too far, I would pointedly ask them to take a look around at the situation and eveluate instead whether it goes far enough. With the advancing decay, would writing ones' Congressperson actually do anything? But again, what candor! If, like your job, people accepted that they really don't have anything of value to lose - despite new, useless models of business and politics pretending to be the old worthwhile ones - we might take the initiative and actually get somewhere.

VioletSun profile image

VioletSun  says:
2 years ago

LOL! Enjoyed reading your rants; I can identify as I worked in International banking in NY and it was hell in the end.   I agree with Robie's comment about writing a book.  I was thinking a few minutes ago about you, and was wondering if you have a book in the making. I would be one of the first ones to purchase it from you!

I handle customer service by email and my partner handles the phone calls... we get the occasional nut,  but luckily not too often as we are not a huge company as this is a home business but we are busy, we work 7 days a week, sometime late until the night; however, its amazing how when not dealing with the corporate BS  and lack of ethics, there isn't that stress that makes one sick in body, mind and spirit! We actually love what we are doing!

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
2 years ago

Thanks guys!

I hate those pretend computer-people too Andy! One service we had for awhile, it was just comical calling them--I'd be SHOUTING into the phone "CUSTOMER SERVICE" and the automated computer voice would start again, "I'm sorry, I didn't get that..."

Coldwarbaby--Good on you! You beat me by two years! Whoo hoo! Actually, the thrill is already wearing off for me, but it was a special moment for sure.

Satori, it goes not nearly far enough. If I said what I really think I'd be locked up.

Violet Sun--what kind of book? Robie2 said this to me too. I'd love to publish a book before I die, but it's hard to imagine anyone reading a whole book full of my rants. I trust your intuitions though, I know you have a gift for that.

I know what you mean about this stress--I have been putting in lots of hours writing, and it doesn't have the same negative effects as just four little hours at the bank does. Part of it is I've been at it so long--5 years at a big insurance company call center, into my second at the bank, and I know from several supervisors that these jobs were designed to turn people over in two years. They plan on that. So 7 is way too long.

Chef Jeff profile image

Chef Jeff  says:
2 years ago

As a nation we bought the idea that those phone menus would make it easier for we, the Consumers of the Nation, to get BETTER customer service.

I agree that they have just made it worse.  I credit you with a lot of guts for sticking around there for so long, just another testimony about how we, the working class, have again been raked over the coals by big corporate & governmental interests.  We are trapped in our jobs, jobs which ofter nothing but frustration, anger and a sense of "Is this REALLY worth it?"

I shop local, small and when I can, I also bank local and small.  I hated the philosophy of Reagan and his cronies - just another bunch of pigs hogging the trough - and they don't even realize that one day they will be send to the rendering plant!

But just try to find a bank that is local any more - they are being gobbled up by larger banks with only one reason for existence.  Money, fueled by greed, fueled by "I don't care" attitudes that make the phone lady character from Laugh In just that much more scary!

People, how much more of this are we going to accept?  It is in OUR power to put an end to tis - when will we see this scam for what it really is?

2patricias profile image

2patricias  says:
2 years ago

Aha! This is just what I suspected. Thanks.

meansdavid profile image

meansdavid  says:
2 years ago

I loved this article. You said it all perfectly!

VioletSun profile image

VioletSun  says:
2 years ago

Violet Sun--what kind of book? Robie2 said this to me too. I'd love to publish a book before I die, but it's hard to imagine anyone reading a whole book full of my rants. I trust your intuitions though, I know you have a gift for that. >>>

Thank you! I think a book in the style of Emma Bombeck or Andy Rooney's wit, while telling like it is, would fit you.  You are able to be blunt while being funny and making  very perceptive observations. And of course a book on a spiritual topic will also fit you,  but the better seller is always the ones folks can identify with, like the rants. LOL! Just my thoughts. :)

cvaughn570 profile image

cvaughn570  says:
18 months ago

Those fake computer people drive me crazy too! They say "you can speak to me like a normal person" and then you hear sounds like the computer is typing and then they repeat it again because they can not understand you.

Just try the word manager, it's actually kind of comical because the computer has obviously been taught not to recognize the word.

Great hub!

Carol

Linda_Lou profile image

Linda_Lou  says:
10 months ago

Great Hub! I also have done this type of work for many years and you have a great way of telling the world what it really boils down too!

Resilience2Spare  says:
6 months ago

Spot on PG; Customer Service has become a cleche, an elegant scam around the world. It does not stop with the retail industry you know! I applied for a Social Work position as an Intake Worker. The person on intake receives calls from people who are often in crisis and requiring support. During the interview, whilst I was articulating my understanding of the position I was told "Oh no, the objective of this position is to keep people out". You have no idea how comforting it is to realise, I am not the only human being walking this earth who finds this attitude totally weird!

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
6 months ago

Hi Resilience--I've been searching government jobs lately, since here in Michigan there's basically nothing in the private sector and I will not work in another call center. To my dismay, the only positions available around here were in a HUD call center--70 miles away. Very discouraging. Hang in there, and thank you for sharing.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working