create your own

District 9: The First Level of Hell

67
rate or flag this page

By pgrundy

Courtesy 666ismoney @ flickr.com
Courtesy 666ismoney @ flickr.com

I love alien movies.

Basically I'll go see any movie with a spaceship and/or aliens in it; no matter how badly made, no matter how ridiculous the premise. In fact, the more ridiculous the better.

(I have a special fondness for obscure 1950s sci fi like "I Married a Monster from Outer Space," "Wasp Woman," and "Attack of the 50 Foot Woman.")

So when I went to see the new Peter Jackson movie District 9 this past Friday, I wasn't expecting much. I just wanted some to see me some aliens and some action. I knew Jackson directed the Lord of the Rings movies and that he was a much better than average director, and I knew the movie included a large spaceship hovering over South Africa. That was enough to get me to fork over $5 for a ticket and another $7.50 for popcorn and a Diet Coke.

I wasn't expecting War and Peace or King Lear.

Whatever I wasn't expecting, I got all that and much more, almost too much.

District 9 is a very disturbing movie. I'm giving you this warning straight up: If you're squeamish and lean toward E.T. and Cocoon, you'd better have a session with your therapist booked shortly after you get out. What's more, District 9 grabs you early on and moves along at such a fast clip for the rest of the movie that you never even get a lull for a bathroom break. At no point does it seem like you won't miss much if you duck out for five minutes or even one.

That's really hard on someone with a 56 year old bladder, so trust me on this: If you've had more than one kid, don't get the large size drink.

District 9 starts from a different set of assumptions than most alien invasion movies.

One day a huge spaceship grinds to a stop over Johannesburg and a small chunk of it falls to earth and disappears. When military teams and scientists are dispatched to the ship to investigate, they find a crew of very sick, barely alive alien creatures that look a little bit like human insects. We are told they are drones, and that they lack direction and purpose without their leader, who presumably was lost in the bit of refuse that fell when the ship was disabled.

The aliens are brought back to earth and set up in a refugee camp where they are nursed back to health. Meanwhile the countries of Earth argue about what to do next. Alien technology is of special interest to weapons corporations, since it seems to be based on both organic and mechanical engineering. Only the aliens can fire their own weapons or enable any of the systems on the ship. Their own tissue becomes a part of and interacts with the technology itself. (I thought this bit alone was really fascinating.)

Years later, no decisions have been made, the ship is still disabled, and the alien refugee camp has become a shantytown slum of corrugated metal huts and piles of refuse. Tensions between the quarantined alien population and the surrounding humans have reached a fever pitch. In response to human complaints about the conditions in District 9 (the slum where the aliens are quarantined), the South African government sets itself the task of moving the entire population of aliens to a tent camp far away from human habitation (District 10).

The film is shot in low-budget mockumentary style. Fake news clips are interspersed with interviews in which 'experts' recount the backstory as if it were actual history, and action scenes are shot with handheld minicams. Unlike the Blair Witch or Cloverfield (movies which also used these gimmicks), these techniques are handled well enough to be convincing and the camera shots are steady enough that you don't get sea sick just from watching people walk around.

You will get sick though. Count on it.

The gore in District 9 is different both in quantity and in kind than that of stock horror films in that it is believable and unrelenting. The imaginary human/alien DMZ soon feels all too real and comforting thoughts of corn syrup vanish like the lap belt on the Tilt O Whirl. I personally think this believability is one of the strengths of the film, but I also know more than one casual movie goer who left the theater in disgust, overwhelmed by the violence and the general 'OMG' factor. I watched several segments through my fingers.

The protagonist is a nerdy little bureaucrat named Wikus (pronounced vy-kus) Van De Merwe, the kind of guy you'd take the stairs to avoid having to chat up in the elevator. Wikus is slight, goofy, and dresses in the unintentionally retro way that all annoying little guys who carry around clipboards and pocket protectors seem to dress: way too much polyester, not nearly enough common sense.

Wikus condescends to the aliens in the most fawning, irritating way; and it's clear from the very first scenes that none of his coworkers have the slightest respect for him. We find out shortly that Wikus has been put in charge of moving the alien population to District 10 via his politically connected father-in-law, a Dick Cheney sort of guy whose Vader-esque persona only makes Wikus look like an even bigger patsy. He's hard to like, and his idiotic devotion to what is by any measure a horrible, immoral job makes him seem like a jerk as well as a fool.

As the film opens, Wikus and a team of international mercenaries (which very much resembles the Blackwater team in Iraq) is going door to door in District 9 in giant white HumVee-type vehicles, procuring alien signatures on eviction notices which some South African bureaucrat has determined to be a legal prerequisite to relocating the aliens to District 10.

Almost all the aliens tell Wikus and the mercenaries to stuff it or worse (they speak through a series of clicks and odd insect-like noises), and we see the mercenaries in action, blowing some aliens to bits with zero remorse. Finding contraband weaponry in one metal hut, Wikus inadvertently sprays himself with some fluid from a scrap of the alien technology, and from that moment forward Wikus begins to slowly change form, both inside and out. It's a testament to the skill of the writers and directors that the more alien Wikus becomes, the more we start to care about him: that's a tough reversal to pull off, but they manage it.

District 9 has a lot in common in look and feel with zombie flicks. The tone and the scenery is gritty, dirty, scary, apocalyptic, and filled with extreme violence and dark viscous fluids that are sickening even when you don't know what they hell they are. The mercenaries blow the aliens away with the same over-the-top zest that zombie killers do, except that, unlike zombies, the aliens gradually become more sympathetic as the film wears on, the humans less so, until by the end you definitely see people as the bad guys, the stranded bugs as galactic antiheroes.

Reviewers are making a big deal out of District 9 as a metaphor for South African apartheid. You can certainly take that from the film if you want to, but I saw in it a much broader and much darker metaphor about the increasingly militarized relationship between the developed world (especially the U.S.) and the Third World (especially Africa and the Middle East). It's not a comfortable metaphor, and you never get to rest your hopes anywhere for more than a nanosecond. District 9 is a dark vision of the level of hell we currently inhabit on Planet Earth in real life. It's credibility and familiarity are what make it most terrifying.

The film works on several levels, the most shallow being that of a well-made action flick. By the middle of the movie lots of stuff is blowing up pretty regularly and we get cool technology and chase scenes and so on and so forth. Supporting that level is good writing and really good directing and editing. But the film hit me hardest where I least expected and in a way that left me sickened and disturbed: as real commentary on real world politics.

Alien movies are always about the Other. In the 50s the Other was Communism and the fear of mind control and invasion by an alien political sensibility. In the 70s and 80s, with the publication of books like Communion and Fire in the Sky, the Other was more personal, more immediate, and more spiritual--something in our own dreams and nightmares--some banished part of ourselves come back to push its way into shared consciousness and damn the consequences.

In District 9 the Other is portrayed as the most human and most humane part of us, the part that has been cordoned off at the point of a lot of weaponry and barbed wire all for the sake of maintaining the status quo, no matter how toxic that status quo might be.

In my favorite review of the film, NYT critic A.O. Scott writes:

At its core the film tells the story — hardly an unfamiliar one in the literature of modern South Africa — of how a member of the socially dominant group becomes aware of the injustice that keeps him in his place and the others, his designated inferiors, in theirs. The cost he pays for this knowledge is severe, as it must be, given the dreadful contours of the system. But if the film’s view of the world is bleak, it is not quite nihilistic. It suggests that sometimes the only way to become fully human is to be completely alienated.

District 9 features no hobbits, no unicorns, no rainbows. It's an important and disturbing film, one that I predict will take its place besides classics like Night of the Living Dead as a daring, genre-busting first.


Print   —   Rate it:  up  down  flag this hub

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Steve Rensch profile image

Steve Rensch  says:
4 months ago

I'm going asap. But where the heck did you find a movie ticket for $5??

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
4 months ago

Hi Steve! We have an older theater in a strip mall here, right next to a Target store. If you go to a show before 6:00 PM, it's only $5. But they get you with the popcorn. :)

Duchess OBlunt profile image

Duchess OBlunt  says:
4 months ago

LOL Pgrundy, they always get you with the popcorn no matter what you pay for the movie!

I gotta send this hub to a friend, who will be dying to see it!

Thanks

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
4 months ago

Hi Duchess--Anybody who likes sci fi, zombie, and/or or horror will be impressed but some people I think will be overwhelmed. Sometimes I sneak crackers in my purse, but that popcorn smells SO GOOD! lol!

easy1 profile image

easy1  says:
4 months ago

Hi, very good review, seen the movie last night as well.

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
4 months ago

Thanks easy1. :)

e cigarette  says:
4 months ago

Great review. I just saw the preview for District 9 and wasn't sure if I wanted to see it or not. You helped me make up my mind. I'm putting this on the must see list!

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
4 months ago

Hi e cigarette--Thanks for stopping by. I hope you like the movie. :)

JEROMEO  says:
4 months ago

The read was cool but the clip, I'm there.

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
4 months ago

It's good Jeromeo. I think you'll be blown away by it, seriously.

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
4 months ago

Sounds scary. I'm such a wimp, that I might not have the stomach for it, but this is a cracking review. Thanks Pam.

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
4 months ago

Thanks Amanda! (It IS gory. But I got through it--and I'm quite a wimp myself!)

Mighty Mom profile image

Mighty Mom  says:
4 months ago

Thanks for saving me the $30 it would have cost to see this movie -- with popcorn and Hubby.

Not my genre. But I love your review!

How about one on Julie and Julia:-)?

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
4 months ago

Hi MM--I haven't seen Julie & Julia yet, but I'd like to. I'm also looking forward to Ang Lee's movie about Woodstock later this month. If I see Julie & Julia I promise to write a review. :)

dohn121 profile image

dohn121  says:
4 months ago

I'm into it. Maybe this summer won't be such a downer after all.

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
4 months ago

Hi dohn! Well, don't look for an uplifting message here. I mean, in a way there is one, but it's not happy camp or anything. You have a point though about this summer--it's been pretty darned depressing. :)

Nancy's Niche profile image

Nancy's Niche  says:
4 months ago

PG, hummmmmm I usually like this type of movie but I may skip it considering you had to watch it through your fingers. Thanks for the warning!!!

SweetiePie profile image

SweetiePie  says:
4 months ago

I liked the story line, but the gore did sort of gross me out a little. I feel like my stomach might be weaker than others though. I do think I want to try and watch the movie again when it comes on cable.

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
4 months ago

Hi Nancy & Sweetie--Yes, it IS really gory and upsetting. Usually I don't like movies that are that gory but I thought it was really well done. I don't blame anyone for passing on it due to the splatter factor. :)

ocbill profile image

ocbill  says:
4 months ago

gore and splatter, eh. I'll have to avoid it then. I am not into seeing cadavers beng cut open, Texas chainsaw massacre type movies, or news clips of people being eaten by wild animals. But I do like Alien realish type movies.

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
4 months ago

Hi ocbill--I feel the same way. To tell you the truth, if I'd know it was that gory, I would not have gone, but I'm glad I didn't know because I really did like the film. :)

Teresa McGurk profile image

Teresa McGurk  says:
4 months ago

what an intelligent review. I have not seen the movie, but will -- some movies have a social or human consciousness far above the normal plot-by-committee fare that is doled out usually; this sounds like one of them. I like your allusions to Blackwater and the international implications of the movie, although setting it in SA was a real good call. Perhaps Peter Jackson, now that he's made all that money off The Lord of the Rings flicks, is going to wow us with the movies he REALLY wanted to make all along?

The original Night/Living Dead was a compelling story; District 9 sounds compelling, too. Perhaps the folk who know most about humanity are those who have seen the worst case scenarios play out with the inevitability of bad bureaucracy. And what separates movies like this from, say, Starship Troopers is the attempt to understand why humanity is worth saving.

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
4 months ago

Teresa--Thank you! I had that thought about Jackson too--that maybe now that he's made his money, the 'good stuff' will start coming out. Not that LOR wasn't good, but you know what I mean--the stuff he couldn't get made before LOR.

The original Night of the Living Dead was really groundbreaking, but since then it has kind of devolved into camp. What ties the District 9 to Romero's first living dead movie is the punch-you-in-the-gut social commentary. Romero saved that for the last scenes, in District 9 you get it throughout.

SolarGoddesss  says:
4 months ago

I LOVE ALIEN MOVIES TOO, even a bad sci-fi with aliens flick is better than a good western. lol

stuart747 profile image

stuart747  says:
4 months ago

Thanks for the information about the film, I'll probably watch it now I know more about it,

Alastore001 profile image

Alastore001  says:
4 months ago

Yeah, gotta love those matinee prices :)

I recently saw this movie, and absolutely LOVED it.

Your review is pretty spot-on in my opinion.

deestew profile image

deestew  says:
4 months ago

Wow, did we watch the same movie? You make the movie sound way more interesting than I thought it was...lol. I found it very slow in the beginning and it was difficult for me to get into it. I did finally start to care when Wikus escaped and became a fugitive. I did not like the ending! But I won't ruin it for others. :-) Honestly, I think I would have rather went to see G.I.Joe. :-( But it wasn't a total bust.

Mr. Seesareu  says:
4 months ago

I have something to say, I saw this movie and this movie was indeed crap. It was horrible. If you want to watch a interesting movie, go see Plan 9 From Outer Space because this movie was really horrible and crappy. You have dropped the ball with this review pgrundy. You have published a hub dedicated to one of the worst movies ever made!

turtle101 profile image

turtle101  says:
4 months ago

This looks amazing however I'm afraid I may be slightly put of by the fact that it looks like its shot in a sort of documentary style on the trailer but I don't think its going to be anything like that, I hope at least.

Lindi Charles profile image

Lindi Charles  says:
4 months ago

Your review of District 9 has to be the most entertaining and imformative I've ever read. Marvelous job!

We look forward to seeing this on the weekend for 5 bucks a ticket at our local drive-in. An affordable night out with popcorn, sodas, and a movie for two for under 15 bucks.

ColdWarBaby profile image

ColdWarBaby  says:
4 months ago

Great stuff pgrundy! I love it. I've just found a torrent and started downloading. Hopefully it will be in english.

Catlyn profile image

Catlyn  says:
4 months ago

Excellent review! Saw the movie last weekend and thought there was some between-the-lines political satire to it. I am expecting a sequel in the future, when Christopher Johnson returns in three years, as he promised!

scoobyscottie profile image

scoobyscottie  says:
3 months ago

This review makes me want to see it even more than i did before i read it, my only issue appears to be what role you think Peter Jackson had in this film. He is only the Producer (given in the credits when it says Peter Jackson presents) its like Quentin Tarantino in Hostel, it's just their money involved.

The real credit must go to Neill Blomkamp, who wrote and directed it.

pgrundy profile image

pgrundy  says:
3 months ago

Hi Scoobyscottie--Thanks for pointing that out. I appreciate it. Hope you enjoy the film. :)

abbas73 profile image

abbas73  says:
2 months ago

i saw the movie one week ago and it exceeded my expectation and i immediately wanted to see it again. i like alien movies too but this movie was so realistic and i think Sharlto Copley was very good. really i donot know how a movie like this was done with a budget of only 30million$.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working