Do kids even read classics?
52Books mentioned here and graphic novels from Dark Horse
|
The Twilight Saga Collection
Price: $44.99
List Price: $83.00 |
|
|
Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West (Harper Fiction)
I am not recommending this book. I loved the musical but found the book a bit whacked at times-b
Price: $4.22
List Price: $7.99 |
|
|
Watchmen
Price: $10.35
List Price: $19.99 |
|
|
The Umbrella Academy Volume 1 (v. 1)
Price: $8.43
List Price: $17.95 |
|
Buffy Graphic Novel (Eros Graphic Novel Series No. 34)
Price: $14.95
|
|
300
Price: $4.41
List Price: $30.00 |
|
Macbeth (Graphic Shakespeare) (Shakespeare Graphic Library)
Price: $4.95
List Price: $12.95 |
|
|
Serenity, Vol. 1: Those Left Behind
Price: $5.19
List Price: $9.95 |
|
Tangerine
Price: $2.59
List Price: $6.95 |
|
Tiger Eyes (Richard Jackson Books (Atheneum Hardcover))
Price: $10.98
List Price: $18.99 |
Jan's Pick for 5-8th graders
|
Because of Winn-Dixie (Newbery Honor Book 2001)
Price: $6.98
List Price: $15.99 |
|
Hatchet: 20th Anniversary Edition
Price: $9.95
List Price: $19.99 |
|
Hatchet
Oops, go with this one. Kids do judge books by their covers!
Price: $3.16
List Price: $6.99 |
|
|
The Beasties
Price: $280.65
List Price: $6.99 |
|
Shadow Children Boxed Set: Among the Hidden, Among the Impostors, Among the Betrayed, and Among the Barons
Price: $13.53
List Price: $24.99 |
|
The Ranger's Apprentice Collection
Price: $12.99
List Price: $23.97 |
|
Percy Jackson and the Olympians Paperback Boxed Set (Books 1-3)
Price: $11.29
List Price: $19.99 |
|
The 39 Clues Book 1:The Maze of Bones
Price: $4.95
List Price: $12.99 |
|
|
I,Q (I,Q The Series)
Price: $4.85
List Price: $8.95 |
|
Make Lemonade
Price: $3.85
List Price: $7.99 |
Definitions have changed
My sister is a librarian in Missouri and so I picked her brain on what books kids check out of her library. Her kids run up to 8th grade and so her list did not include any of the current books labeled Young Adult.
Kay E. Vandergrift of Rutgers University writes, "What might once have been thought appropriate for a fourteen-year-old is now appropriate for a considerably younger reader. Often, however, what is perceived as knowledge or maturity is only at a surface level, and young readers need a great deal of time for the distancing and reflection possible through literature. Nicole St. John wrote about teenagers as inexperienced adults, and literature provides a safe haven to accrue experience."
Contemporary YA are books like Twilight and Wicked. Books that give boys ideas about girls that their parents don't find edifying.
Vandergrift continues, "Through story a reader can confirm one's own life experiences, illuminate and gain insight into those experiences, and vicariously expand and extend them. Although each of us must walk alone, authenticate our experiences, and make our own meanings and sense of truth in the world we know; there is always that tension between the uniqueness of the person and the commonalties of the human condition. This tension is evident in everyday life but revealed most fully in story. Story has always been a very powerful way of venturing beyond the scenes we know to connect with people, places, ideas, and events beyond our normal range."
Some kids might think any book that appears in a library is edifying which is a bad thing. They look online for information about what's hot and what's not.
Twilight- a book that easily rose to number one while publishing houses were still seeking the next Harry Potter fantasy- went World Wide Web. And Publisher's Weekly reports, " when it came time to revamp the Web site for Stephenie Meyer's Twilight saga, Little Brown included message boards to give teens a place to converse, as well as a blog for reviews, media appearances and photographs. A poll on the boards about the heroine's romantic dilemmas that asked, Who should Bella choose? racked up more than 6,000 votes."
Comic books are making a comeback with this set. Evie Nagy of PW reports, "One project supported by this belief is the original graphic novel The Last Dragon by Jane Yolen, bestselling author of hundreds of stories for children and young adults, to be published by Dark Horse in 2010. The action-fantasy, with art by Rebecca Guay, will join other titles that the publisher says have successfully attracted a large young female audience, such as Gerard Way's Umbrella Academy and Joss Whedon's Buffy the Vampire Slayer."
Jeremy Atkins, director of publicity for Dark Horse says, "Teenagers more than any other audience realize when someone is directly trying to get their attention, and usually they're going to resist that," he says. "It's going to be the things that appeal to them naturally that they're going to get into."
Still, my sister is pretty connected to her kids and what they like. So I opened the door to her favorite subject and she strode right in, loaded with goodies. "Tangerine," she said. "And they still like Tiger Eyes."
I asked about dog books. My skunk stinky dog was at my feet begging for the scoop. Winn Dixie and Hatchet," she said. "In fact nothing by Gary Paulson is ever available. They love Gary Paulson.
"Remakes of fairy tales continue to go out as soon as they are returned. Beastie for one.
"Then there are all the series, like Ranger's Apprentice and all of Haddix Among the Hidden; Lightining Thief. One of the big names in this age group is Roland Smith. I heard him speak and he packed the auditorium. His I.Q... well all his books fly off the shelves."
"And of course my favorite, Touching Spirit Bear," she added.
Touching Spirit Bear
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
Tom, thank you for this bit of insight. I am going to look further into this concept. Let me know what you experience as time goes by. Thanks.
think its all over the globe the same tom. I think if you ask a 5th grader what a classic is they'l probably say: "something old perhaps, why worry about old things"
Anything backed up by film or TV goes down well with my kids. I read them A.A. Milne when they were little, as well as C.S.Lewis's Narnia books, but kids these days want instant gratification, and can't tolerate a slow burn style intro. Consequently two of my own childhood favourites, 'Treasure Island' and Rosemary Sutcliffe's 'Eagle of the Ninth' were discarded after only a page or two.
I really appreciate your comments, m are d and amanda. so would they watch an old classic on tv or in movies? what about graphic novels? that's my next hub-graphing up the old classics. But maybe the question is, does it matter? are there contemporary bits that replace those old classics and appeal?
no, never, its too boring for them. They want blood and gore(sorry Al), sex and loud unbearable music...
haha, i believe i would like to read your hubs. sounds as if you have a great deal of personal experience and strong opinions on the subject, lol
One of my hobbies is introducing people to the classics. I work at a boys ranch, and I often give them classic poetry and short stories to read :) Sometimes they like them, sometimes not :) The classics are the best though. As always, "They don't make em like they used to anymore."
Well, im actually a 4th grade kid and i do see a lot of classic reading in 6th and 5th But twilight series have been insanely more popular after the movie after the novel. also more books written by avi if you heard of him have became a highly popular book now at least 35% of books ive seen this school year are at least written by avi.
wow uzamaki, 4th grade-- good for you! i appreciate you being on hubpages and really appreciate you stopping by to answer my questions. i do know avi. in fact, i LOVE The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle. which is your favorite?
i also read the Twilight series, but i haven't seen the movie. i don't want to yet. sometimes movies ruin the images i have in my mind about the book :). do kids read the classics like frankenstein in graphic novels? what do you mean by classics, as in what books do kids read in 5th and 6th grade?
benj, i'm not sure i agree that classics are the best. i mean, look at uzamaki, reading avi. avi is tomorrow's classic so where do you draw the line? anyway, what classics do your boys actually like??? thanks for the feedback!
well my sister complains about the Twilight series and i might be reqading that in a year but i really read a lot classics i actually dont think i have a classic cause i think there some pretty good books!
Yeah, you're definitely right -- tomorrow's classics are being written even as we speak, so it would be foolish to neglect newer books and only read the old ones. I don't usually recommend classics to the boys until they're in high school, so they definitely get the chance to read lots of old and new. The main reason why I love classic books isn't necessarily for the literary value, but more because it's so cool to read a book written over a hundred years ago, yet still can evoke feeling and emotion when read. It makes one feel connected to the grand scheme, which is a difficult feeling to get from newer books :) As for the boys, they like Rober Frost a lot, Agatha Christie, and Henry Wadsworth Longfellow. Thanks for asking, and for the thought-provoking hub!
uzamaki, what books do you not consider classics that i might call classics? give me some titles or authors! thanks.
benjimester, yes, i completely agree with your comments and i am totally inspired by your suggestion that reading books over a hundred years old connects you to that time period. way to go!
Oh well sorry but i do have a favorite classic, I forgot the author but i do know the name Little House On The Praire i think it is my favorite i know its probably not the best classic but when i read it three years ago. I like iit because it is sort of like my familys history... some other are Nightmare Moutain it is a Sort of scary type classic but it still its very good, and with a satifying ending. im actually not that big of a classic reader so those sre just some on the top of my mind at the time..
And sorry im not feeling so well right now i didnt mean to confuse you i think this cold and headache is probably confusing me about this but i felt better and i asked my teacher this morning that she thought is that not not many kids read classics much but they are more intrested in modern Science Fiction than most classics...
i think that that i guess is good advice..
oh, hmm i know the Little House books and i can relate because i grew up not that far from you! but i will have to get nightmare mountain. i wonder about your teacher's comment. is she saying she doesn't think you would like classics? or that most kids prefer science fiction? because you seem to like Little House books and they aren't science fiction. have you read "Wrinkle in Time?" what science fiction have you read?
I am going to be at my daughter' s graduation for a couple days, so don't expect to hear back from me until Sunday unless I find a computer in New Jersey, haha. Have a nice week!














Tom Rubenoff says:
7 months ago
I don't know how it is elsewhere, but here boys seem to be taking an interest in girls at a much younger age and girls' conversation at 12 and 13 seems to be often about who is "dating" whom whereas in recent years past this was not the case. Certainly we are finding an increased need for conversations of a more mature level than we anticipated. It seems that this age group is now reading books that reflect this trend.