create your own

Do you agree that domestic science should be brought back in to school( eg;teaching kids about how to do their own...

63
rate or flag this page

By Lisa HW



If There's One Thing I Think Is Best Left Out of Schools, It Is "Domestic Science"

When I went to the school in the 1960's, what would eventually become "domestic science" was called "cooking" and "sewing". Beginning in sixth grade, girls were required to take sewing. Beginning in seventh grade and through eighth grade, girls were (as I thought of it) forced to take sewing for half the school year and cooking for the other half. Boys took woodworking or "shop". (By the time my younger brother hit junior high, which was five years after I did, boys were also required to take cooking and sewing.)

Beginning in ninth grade, it was no longer required that college-bound or "business" students to take "Home Ec". "Home Ec" was for students in the "General" course, and that "course" was essentially seen as one for those kids who were biding their time while waiting to graduate (or drop out of) high school.

One would have thought such courses would have been useful to someone like me. Although I had "the best mother in the world", she had never really spent much time teaching me how to cook or sew. Actually, I don't think she ever told me a thing about either. She did try to teach me how to knit, but I had no patience for that. She did try to teach me to crochet, but I had no wish to make anything that involved yard, thread, or twine. My interests were drawing (particularly figure-drawing), photography, writing, and reading.

In defense of my mother, it seemed as if she spent my entire childhood, trying to teach me about how to be a good mother. My mother (and father too) saw children as the most important people in the world, and she saw childhood as "not for housework". Both of my parents wanted their children to excel academically, and both believed we "could be anything we wanted to be". I suppose my mother's attitude that doing domestic things was part of life but not part of dreams rubbed off on me.

Somehow, though, in spite of my mother's apparent "domestic negligence" when it came to showing me how to wash clothes, iron them, or sew on a button; I just kind of turned into a teenager who could manage doing those things just fine.

Still, one would think that a course in "domestic science" ("Home Ec") would be  great for a kid like me. Well, such courses were useless to me. As young as eleven years old and in sixth grade, I found the sewing class a giant waste of time that could be better spent on academics. Do you want to know what I learned about sewing that year? How to make stupid-looking, elf slippers out of washcloths that were folded in half. They weren't even good slippers because they had no sole in them, so walking around was essentially like walking around in stocking feet - only I was walking around in washcloth feet (and only did that for the purpose of "trying out" the so-called "slippers" I had been forced to make).

Oh - and another thing I was supposed to learn in that sixth-grade class was how to do the "T" stitch. The problem was I couldn't learn it because the teacher had a sing-song thing she did in trying to teach it ("In behind the last stitch and out to form the letter, 'T'.") Well, I never saw "the letter, 'T'." because this grouchy, old, teacher neglected to mention that the "T" stitch wasn't supposed to look like a "T" and that, instead, the "T" was formed by a plain old, regular, stitch and the needle!  (Five years before I was in this class, my sister went through the same "T stitch" issue with the same teacher.) 

Seventh grade brought "Home Ec". I will admit that I was a snob about it, and that I had no intentions of EVER wearing an apron (the way the Home Ec teacher required us all to wear one). I will admit that I tuned out during discussions of how to use an iron or how to select a centerpiece for our tacky-table-clothed Home Ec tables and stupid sit-down eating affairs. (My group never got to eat anything, because we just fooled around during the time we were supposed to be cooking. None of us wanted to know how to make muffins or meatloaf. In fact, one meatloaf made its way out the open, second-floor, window and onto the grass below.)

Eighth grade was no better. Both grades involved grouchy, "old-lady", teachers who acted as if they thought what they were teaching was important. In the meantime, my classmates and I just thought it was stupid that someone thought they needed to teach us how to use a stove, grease a cake pan, or select one of several horrible-looking rags that they were trying to pass off as "tablecloths". Yes, we were snobs. Yes, we thought we were too smart for such "basic" lessons. Do you want to know what I learned in the two years of Home Ec? One very important lesson: Make sure to turn the pot handles so they aren't hanging out over the edge of the stove. (I'm not being sarcastic here. That one, valuable, lesson is one from which I continue to benefit to this day. In fact, each time I turn a handle that someone else in the house left sticking out I actually think of Mrs. Ames' words.)

I was fourteen years old (ninth grade) when my parents gave me a very nice sewing machine for Christmas. I read the book. I bought patterns. I bought a few sewing books. There was a certain type of cotton, short-sleeved, dress that all the girls were making for themselves; and I taught myself to make my own selection of dresses as well.  Some things we tend to learn best outside of school and on our own terms.  It turned out I liked sewing to make dresses for me, my niece, or dolls.  I guess what I saw as "stupid" were things like the washcloth slippers. 

Beginning in ninth grade I had begun a four-year plan to take extra academic courses during high-school, so that I could both get into college but also have business training. The guidance department allowed me to take more classes than was generally recommended because they knew I did well on a number of things. I was so grateful not to have to be required to take Home Ec after eighth-grade, and I was so happy to be able to take advanced English classes, literature seminar, the math courses required for college admissions, but also business math and English. I took psychology, but I also took typing and shorthand. There was chemistry, but there was also an extra reading course. Finally, my time was not being wasted in classes that tried to teach what anyone with a shred of common sense could figure out for himself!

In my late twenties I got married, adopted a child, bought a house, and had two more children. The house was well organized and sparkling clean. I repaired or ironed clothes as needed. When my children needed costumes I made them. In fact, when my two younger children were in an ice show I participating in the making of the costumes.

Somehow, in spite of having a mother who never showed me much about "domestic science", I just kind of discovered that I was completely capable of ironing clothes, washing them (in a machine or in the sink), and removing any number of stains. Somehow, I just kind of knew (or somehow learned) how to unplug a toilet, grout a bathtub, remove wax build-up, and do any number of other things associated with taking care of a family and home.

Like my mother, I have come to view "domestic" tasks as part of life, but not part of dreams. Neither should they be part of curriculum, particularly in view of the fact that so many schools do not offer students the high-quality academic challenges that today's kids need.

More than four decades after being required to endure those boring, "stupid", Home Ec classes, I now see that the "bad attitude" I had at thirteen wasn't a bad attitude. It was seeing domestic tasks for the basic, easily-figured-out, tasks that they are. All these years later, I still resent that even that much of my school time was wasted on those classes. All these years later, I have still never worn an apron - not even once. (Oh, now that I think of it, I made a baby-blue, gingham-check, apron in the half-year of eighth grade that was devoted to sewing. I wonder whatever happened to it.....)

One final note: My first son was in fifth grade when he decided that he liked a certain type of shirt and pants, and that he wanted them ironed in a certain way. I offered to iron them for him, but he said he'd like to do it. With the ironing board safely set up within my view, my son would get up early each school day and iron himself a shirt and pair of pants. I think he liked feeling very grown-up at the time. His younger siblings would not turn out to care about ironing unless necessary, but all three children have grown up to be people who have used a washing machine and repaired their own clothes.

I know that we are not born knowing how to do domestic tasks, but - boy oh boy - sometimes it does seem that way.

Print   —   Rate it:  up  down  flag this hub

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

bevy400 profile image

bevy400  says:
10 months ago

I like this hub and thanks for answering my request.How ever i must be a bit old fashbioned as i feel it should be brought back.When it comes to sewing i think it should be basics eg sewing on buttons etc....I also feel both boys and girls should take part and learn about basic cooking and washin/ironing....To learn how to prepare a simple meal to these teens would be beneficial.....I also feel that girls/boys should be taught how to change a fuse/light bulb etc.,..Some already know the basics but so many don't.Happy hubbing

Lisa HW profile image

Lisa HW  says:
10 months ago

I hope my "bad attitude" came across in the lighthearted way in which it was intended to, and not as the words of a horrible troll who is against knowing how to scramble an egg. :)

People do have individual opinions about things like this, and I do respect the opinions of others. I don't think it's at all "old fashioned" to think people ought to know the basics. It's just that I think kids do tend to pick up much of this stuff just by being around family (especially parents); but also that today people can go on the Internet and ask anything from how to scramble eggs to how get out wine stains.

Also, having been spared a lot of talk about "matters domestic" (and having so managed to tune out of all those "forced" Home Ec classes), I suppose I discovered that it is true that necessity is often the mother of invention (or at least learning). When my father died young, and my mother was left to deal with things like the fuse box for the first time in her life, I was the one who figured out which fuses went to which circuits, drew her up a map of the different circuits in the house, and taped it inside the kitchen cabinet. I don't mean to over-estimate the significance of such a simple thing, and I don't mean to come across as if I think such things are a big deal. It's just that my point is even those of us who were not "formally" taught such things will usually learn what we need to when it suddenly becomes important.

I suppose my thinking is that my mother may have been right: If you teach your child to "be a person" and raise him/her in a way that results in their being responsible, industrious, and curious in life; they will learn what they need to learn about the basics. As someone who grew up resenting what the schools did not offer in terms of challenging academic material, I've come to be someone who thinks education resources would be better spent on academics, which are not so "naturally picked up" just through day-to-day living, challenges, and curiosity.

einron profile image

einron  says:
10 months ago

Good hub. My mother also thought that education was the best for her children. Four of her daughers became teachers, one son is an architect and another is an accountant.

Mother can sew and taught me how to use one, but she never learnt to cook because her mother did not teach her either. The family had cooks. I did not learn cooking when young and still do not like cooking, though I love food.

As for domestic science (cooking), it would be desirable to have some knowledge of cooking for both boys and girls. When children go for higher studies in UK, Canada, and America, they need to have some knowledge of cooking to survive. When I was a student in UK, I wash dishes while my brother and cousin cooked the meals.

justmesuzanne profile image

justmesuzanne  says:
10 months ago

Yes I do! The skills I use and have used every day since I graduated from High School are the skills I learned in Home Ec and the skills I learned in Typing/Secretarial classes.

I can cook - well! Not just microwaving and opening cans. I can sew - not only to mend and sew on buttons, but I can make a garment if I have to. I can plan menus and budget accordingly. I can type 70 wpm - the most valuable job skill I possess!

These are skills that everyone should at least have a basic understanding of. You are at the mercy of the manufacturers of processed food and the employers of the clothing slaves in China if you can't take care of at least some of your own domestic needs.

If you can't type in this computer age, you are severely disabled!

I am astonished by the number of young people today (and by this I mean 20s and 30s with children) who cannot cook anything at all! I was doing all the cooking for my whole family when I was 13! Complete, nutritious meals! Every day! Including home made bread!

I cannot imagine being so helpless that I would have to buy every bite I ate pre-fab from the frozen section in the super market, or even worse, at a convenience store, or fast-food place!

I am a very independent woman. And I believe knowing how to take care of myself makes me that much more so!

Bring back home ec! For everyone!

:D Suzanne

Lisa HW profile image

Lisa HW  says:
10 months ago

Suzanne, thanks. Obviously, your Home Ec teachers/classes were not the obvious waste of time mine were; but my argument is still that most people will learn what they need to learn on their own. (Teenagers don't count. It isn't too many of them who want to take the time to cook or repair ripped clothes.) I'm an independent person too, but it's no thanks to any two-periods-a-week Home Ec classes.

I don't underestimate the usefulness and importance of the skills that Home Ec classes try to teach. I just don't think most such classes do a very good job, and, again, do think most people will learn how to prepare a a healthy on their own.

If someone is in their 20's or 30's (particularly someone with children) and doesn't figure out a way to come up with healthy meals, I don't think their problem is that they didn't take cooking in eighth grade. It's a bigger problem than that.

I kind of think that people who seem helpless often either just prefer to be (because they're "lazy") or else have generally helpless natures (which is the result of their upbringing - not schooling.

Of course, all this is just my own personal opinion, and I don't presume to think I'm right (or the only one with a valid opinion). I honestly do respect and appreciate the opinions of others on a subject like this as well. (It's just that I also like a good debate. :) )

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working