Does raising Cattle harm the environment or even (GASP) humans?
78
Do people really know the facts?
I decided to review articles on this site, gain some insight, and maybe get ideas. Well, I got an idea. I noticed that people on this site have a MAJOR problem; you need to site your sources. You aren’t doing all this research yourself so you need to give credit to the people who did. So, because of this, I’m going to separate fact from fiction.
America is OVER-REACTING!
While reading the article “Seven Ways to Change the World”, I noticed that the structure of the article is great; everything flows and it’s very informational. However, is the information correct? I’m very open minded so I agree that everyone is entitled to opinion. On the other hand, reading that food with pesticides is harmful to humans and the environment is not necessarily correct. The sources to the article were all promotions for organic food. There are many studies that defend both sides of the argument. Do some research and see for yourself. Why do I make this suggestion? I grew up in a small town in the Midwest and my family made a living by farming. YEP. Didn’t see that one coming did you? So, when I read in this article that, and I quote:
“One hamburger causes 55 square feet of rain forest destruction (for tropically raised beef) and 12 pounds of livestock feces and other pollutants. Worldwide, livestock now produce 130 times as much waste as people do. Livestock waste disposal is often unregulated or unenforced and improper disposal of livestock waste has been linked to many human and environmental health disasters.”
OKAY! Let’s analyze this step by step. FIRST OFF, I understand that tropic beef more than likely exists but according to angus.org, because angus’s have the ability to calve with almost no complications, can easily cross bread with a variety of cattle, and have an amazing coat to protect the meat and skin, angus meat is the market choice. But the truth of the matter is that you cannot find Angus in a tropical environment. They are bread to be big and lean, not to mention, the build of an Angus is very square which would make living in the tropics very difficult; they just wouldn’t survive. So, in all reality, sure, tropical cattle are more than likely shipped to the U.S. for the market, but they aren’t worth anything and aren’t grade choice. Maybe Wal-Mart sells it. However, most restaurants and grocery stores will only sell Angus meat.
SECOND, livestock waste disposal… oh dear. So, we have this machine called a loader and a spreader. The loader is a tractor with a big ol’ bucket in front. We take the loader and scoop up all the, ehem, waste and put it in a spreader. The spreader then grinds up all the, ehem, waste, and proceeds to spread it as a fertilizer before we plant. You like organic foods, honey, well, this is as organic as it gets. As for being harmful to humans, according to the Lincoln journal star:
“The Environmental Protection Agency does not even list livestock as a concern in the United States with regard to carbon dioxide emissions. That EPA report also shows that, by far, the largest emitter of methane gas is solid waste landfills, which account for 24 percent of all methane emissions.” Personal note: maybe we should worry about how well we manage our waste before we start chewing the cattle out, if cattle produce 130 times as much waste as we do but our waste outshadows theirs, well, that’s a problem… let’s continue… “ The National Cattlemen’s Beef Association [says] that Environmental Protection Agency data show the entire U.S. agricultural sector contributed only 6.4 percent of total U.S. greenhouse gas emissions, with all livestock contributing only 2 percent.”
I’m sure there are no health disasters. What’s your source of information?
The point I’m making today is that if you would like to express your opinion on subjects like this, that’s great but don’t create an informational article without all the information. It’s one sided, and you’re portraying your opinion as fact. That’s not correct and it gives people a false insight. Happy hubbing!
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
I cant say that i really agree with much of this. Cattle does take up tremendous amounts of resources. I cant say for sure but im guessing that you did not grow up on a factory farm type feedlot operation that are prevalent today.
http://www.earthsave.org/environment/rxenviro.htm
8 ounces of beef can require up to 25,000 liters of water
http://www.worldwatch.org/node/819
The same amound of land that produces 250 pounds of beef can produce 40,000 pounds of potatoes or 50,000 pounds of tomatoes. i dont feel like citing that one because its from a book but just because you were raised farming cattle does not mean that is how all cattle operations are set up. and citing information about beef from angus.com is about the same as looking up abortion information from the popes homepage. from everything that i have read i have certainly come to the conclusion that the current state of the meat industry is bad and growing worse. I read in one place that if the entire world followed the same diet as the average american then the entire worlds oil reserves would be depleted in 10 years. i just dont see a way how the meat industry could not have a negative effect on the environment.
Honestly, That's an acceptable argument. That is something I can agree with. I merely covered two points I had read that I thought seemed a bit rediculous but your side, however, has a better argument. Thank you :)
how does a cattle hep people
Help people? Like, economically, or nutritionally? That's another article in itself
After reading this, I do not believe, that it is possible for anyone to write all that I read about cattle harming the environment, I am lost for words.
on another note, angus beef can't survive in warm places... only in northern midwest states are they bred. The heat would kill them, the cold will kill them... and the midwest is the happy medium... Did you know that Nebraska is #3 for the state that contains the most angus beef. Angus is what american's eat. cattle bred in the tropics, well, I'm not certain but I'll take a wild guess and say americans aren't the ones eating 'em... talk to some south american countries, they they can tell you how they are starving and its they only way to make a living.
I wrote this, like, a year ago. I'm surprised people still read it.
you still havent answered my question though
Confused... What question? You mean Kj's question? Sure I can answer it. I was looking for a topic more specific and that's why I responded to kj's question with another question. Are you kj, Chloe?











Nymphadora says:
7 months ago
Very nicely written I'll keep that in mind next time I go shopping for meat. Thanks!