(Don’t) Let Them Eat Cake
67New Zealand primary school principal bans birthday cake
I was really impressed with Oteha Valley Principal Megan Bowden and her decision to ban birthday cake at her school in order to bring it into compliance with national healthy eating guidelines established in New Zealand which will be enforced in June of this year. It must have been an obvious but difficult decision. When I was young, there weren't as many treats in the classrooms and I don't remember that many children who struggled with obesity. The peak year for me for eating junk in school was fourth grade, and all that meant was that once a month, an assigned parent brought in cupcakes, meant to cover all birthdays for that month. My birthday is in July, so I never had much in the way of a four star celebration or cake. When I was 10, I was thrilled to have a strawberry flavored cake, complete with strawberry-flavored red fleck of apples in the cake batter. Being a simple chocolate or vanilla cake man, my father hated it.
The other thing that was different for me was that there were no vending machines in elementary schools, no snack times (I remember being hungry), and absolutely no candy. In a study published in Pediatrics, Gary Foster and colleagues found that, using the following tools--school self-assessment, nutrition education, nutrition policy, social marketing, and parent outreach--it was possible to affect the number of children who became obese (7.5 % in the intervention schools vs. 14.9 % in the schools where no intervention was in place). Which school would you want your child to go to?
With Tad, I don't think I brought anything in for his kindergarten class, but after that, I have to confess that brought a succession of heavily frosted cakes into the classroom. Tad loved them. He loved the little toys on the cake and he loved the two or three day binge of cake eating that followed when we brought the cake home. MIndful of my own problem with managing my weight, I'd suggest taking the remnants to Skip's work (also known as caloric redistribution), but Tad refused. I remember rebelling one year, when Tad was in fourth grade, I held my sensible nutrition ground and brought in fresh fruit, which was considerably more expensive than a sheet cake from the store. One of the more popular boys, looked at Tad and said, I don't eat this. Tad didn't care too much.
I noticed that even though the other mothers were health conscious, they were also bringing in doughnuts or cake, sometimes even cake and ice cream. Ice cream cakes. We're kind of a different family as it is, so I worried about having Tad stand out from the crowd. Last year, I took cookies in for his birthday. Let them eat sugar, but not as much.
In the United States, and in Alaska, a lot of this is based on a culture of sharing. We couldn't quite manage to have a birthday party at the local roller rink for Tad, but we did want to share with others. But, over all, availability of junk foods and junk drinks has increased, putting our children at risk not only for obesity, but for future illnesses associated with obesity-hypertension, hyperlipedemia and diabetes-as well as bathing their teeth in a constant stream of sugar, setting them up for cavities. We don't have dental insurance and I've spent the last six years begging Tad to brush after every meal or snack or drink (that isn't water).
So, Principal Megan Bowden, my warm winter hat goes off to you.
Exercise with your children
Helping your children
|
Super Size Me
Price: $3.76
List Price: $9.95 |
|
|
Please Mum, Don't Supersize Me
Price: $11.99
List Price: $11.99 |
|
Weight Management Children and Adolescence FAQs (Faqs)
Price: $13.71
List Price: $15.95 |
|
|
Best Hikes With Children: Western Washington & the Cascades
Price: $8.71
List Price: $14.95 |
America On the Move Family Program
New Zealand Healthy Eating Guidelines for Schools
- Primary school bans birthday cakes
New Zealand Herald article by Martha McKenzie-Minifie--read the article that started it all and weigh in on the controversy
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
I'm a baby boomer, and I think during the late 50's and early 60's in our rural New Mexico town, we began to have refreshments in school on special dates. My mom always made homemade fudge and divinity for the teachers at Christmas and I know our class exchanged Valentines with candy on the side.
Our school had a cafeteria, but every bite was made there. Homemade fried chicken, meat loaf, and burgers with fish on Friday was very common. Yeast rolls would make your stomach ache during the morning and by the time lunch rolled around, everyone cleaned their plate. You could go back for seconds after everyone was served - no one left hungry.
P.E. became required and soon we were running off fat. I'm afraid it was the beginning of the bad, but I remember the meals with fondness. My aunt was one of the cooks when I was in High School, and her rolls were light as feathers and the homemade cobbler was scrumptious. Food was plentiful until the government stepped in and made everything equal.
At that time the food became cardboard and plastic. Nutrition was on a tablet somewhere but it sure wasn't in the food. Kids were limited in quantity, went home hungry and yet gained weight. Vending machines were brought in because lunches weren't eaten and kids needed "choices." Bon Appetit was only on TV, it left the school lunchroom.
When I taught school, I always had crackers and peanut butter, (good thing I didn't poison any child allergic) as many kids came to school too late for the instant eggs and lukewarm milk that was served, until Reagon decided he needed to cut the budget. That left many kids whose families made a tiny bit too much, hungry.
Sigh, progress. I miss the homemade food, didn't want the vending machines, hated the plastic nutritionally correct food, and did not want gooping and gomping in my class.
good hub -- brought back many memories. =) Marisue
Sally's Trove--you bring up some great points. In Alaska, most of our cows are at least 1500 miles away--in Washington, Oregon or California. Alaska used to have a thriving dairy industry in the Matanuska Valley. One of the brands was Matanuska Maid--it may still be around. But on the Kenai Peninsula, our milk and much of our food travels 1500 miles to get to us. Hard to believe--but it sure explains the lettuce! As for kids, I read somewhere that walking as little as one mile a day is enough to stave off obesity. Almost no children walk to school in Soldotna. Most of them take the bus or are driven by their parents. I don't mean to be critical of the parents--most of my friends and neighbors are doing the best they can.
Hi Marisue--I too have fond memories of growing up in the South where the food was cooked at the school. It was so good--simple, small servings. Then we moved to another state and I had my first experience with food made off site. It was spaghetti and tomato sauce. The spaghetti had been overcooked to an unnatural consistency and the tomato sauce didn't seem to have any seasoning in it. Funny how I can remember the disappointment I felt when I got that meal. I wonder how we can get back to the real food--your aunt's cooking sounds delicious.
Here in Soldotna, the best food is the food we grow. I have a nice big rhubarb plant in the front of my house that provides pie & cobbler fixings all summer long, and we have herbs and lettuce in the greenhouse. There's nothing like fresh and local!
Changes we can make for our children
- A policy-based school intervention to prevent overweight and obesity.
This article could pave the way for a new generation of what is being done in our schools.












Sally's Trove says:
2 years ago
When I went to school, food was never an issue.
I lived in a community where all the kids walked to school, back and forth in the morning and the afternoon and also at lunch time, so, there was no lunch room or cafeteria, and there certainly were no vending machines. There was a water fountain.
There was also daily milk, delivered by the local dairy, at 2 cents for an 8-ounce container. We were expected to bring our 10 cents in every week. For those who couldn't afford it, the school took care of it to make sure every child had milk.
Birthdays were not celebrated. Everybody had a birthday, of course, so why make a big deal out of it? This lack of birthday celebration meant that children who had birthdays in the summer, children such as yourself, were never left out. It was understood that the birthday celebration belonged at home and with friends, not at school.
When there was cake in school, it was because there was a play or a recital in the the evening. Parents would bring cupcakes and cookies and make coffee to have a little social time after the performance.
Please, let them eat cake. Just not in the classroom.
Great hub, Minnow!