Electric Heaters – The Differences Between Convection Heaters And Conduction Heaters
90Choosing from amongst the huge array of electric
heaters can be extremely difficult, especially with the vast array of available
options. The price and the operating costs are important considerations, but
finding the optimum type ultimately depends upon your specific needs. This
guide will help you to sift through the various electric heater options, and prevent
you from spending more than you need.
The majority of electric heaters use one of two
processes to heat a room, namely convection and conduction. Convection heaters
heat the air and circulate it around the room, providing gradual heat. Many
convection heaters use a fan to physically push air around the room, whilst
others rely upon rising hot air to circulate warmth.
Conduction heaters, conversely, uses radiant heat to warm objects directly, rather than indirectly heating the air. This direct heating action, provided by exposed elements, ensures that conduction heaters are unaffected by drafts, and provide focused and intense heat.
|
DeLonghi TRH0715 Oil Filled Radiator Heater
Price: $49.99
List Price: $49.99 |
|
|
DeLonghi EW7707CM Oil-filled Radiator with ComforTemp Technology
Price: Too low to display
List Price: $79.99 |
|
DeLonghi TRN0812T Portable Oil-Filled Radiator with Programmable Timer
Price: Too low to display
List Price: $119.99 |
Convection Heaters – The Gradual And Efficient Electric Heater
Oil heaters
This familiar style of electric heater uses
electrical power to gently heat a sealed oil reservoir. This liquid releases warmth
into the atmosphere gradually, slowly heating the entire room. It takes a
little time to heat the oil and circulate warm air around the room, but oil
heaters are by far the most economical electric heater; it takes little extra
electricity to maintain the temperature after the initial heating. Oil heaters
tend to fall into the mid-price range, and the lack of moving parts ensures
that they are sturdy and durable.
The economy and gentle heat generated by oil heaters makes
them into a great option for providing permanent heat throughout the day and
night. Oil heaters are the safest option, and can be left to run overnight with
no more danger than any other electrical appliance.
Oil heaters do have some disadvantages, and are not always the best solution. The main downside is that they do not deliver instant heat, and need to be turned on an hour or two in advance. In addition, oil heaters heat the entire room so, unlike conduction heaters, everybody has to endure the same temperature. Finally, larger oil heaters are heavy and cumbersome, so are best used as a static heat source.
Fan Convection Heaters
Fan convection heaters use an inbuilt fan to force air over an element, providing quick heat and good air circulation. Fan convection heaters are available in a range of sizes and capacities, from the small desktop heaters to larger freestanding types. Many natural convection heaters give the option of using a fan, and this hybrid type provides the best of both worlds.
However, fan convection heaters have some major drawbacks, and should be used sparingly The inbuilt fan means that they need a lot of electricity to operate, and fan convection heaters are a poor choice for heating large spaces; they are best used for delivering quick heat.
The most serious disadvantage of fan convection heaters is that they are prone to overheating, especially when the element accumulates a covering of dust. Higher quality fan convection heaters contain inbuilt safety cut out switches, and these are worth the extra cost.
|
Eco-heater 602 High-Efficiency Electric Panel Whole-Room Heater
Price: $115.09
List Price: $119.95 |
|
|
Honeywell HZ515C Low Profile Silent Comfort Heater
Price: $59.99
List Price: $129.99 |
|
DeLonghi HHP1500 Mica Panel Heater, Black
Price: Too low to display
List Price: $126.00 |
|
NewAir AH-400 Portable Space Heater With Adjustable Temperature Control
Price: $42.75
List Price: $69.95 |
Natural Convection Heaters
Natural convection heaters heat up the air, via an
element, and allow natural circulation carry the heat around the room. Natural
convection heaters draw cool air into the bottom of the unit, heating it as it
passes over an exposed element. Warm air rises from the top of the natural
convection heater and circulates around the room, gradually heating the entire
space.
Natural convection heaters are cheaper to buy than
oil filled radiators, and they heat the room much more quickly, reaching
operating temperature in a couple of minutes. The downside of this is that they
use much more electricity, and natural convection heaters do not deliver
instant heat as quickly as conduction heaters.
Natural convection heaters are much less liable to overheating than fan-assisted convection heaters, although it is vitally important to keep the air vents clear of any obstructions. Like most convection heaters, they struggle to heat large spaces, especially when there is a door to the outside, constantly mixing warm and cold air and disrupting the circulation. Natural convection heaters are a good compromise between the various factors, a natural balance between economy and quick heat.
|
Optimus H-5210 Infrared Quartz Radiant Heater
Price: $27.73
List Price: $29.99 |
|
Lasko 754200 Ceramic Heater with Adjustable Thermostat
Price: $19.80
List Price: $29.99 |
|
SPT SH-1508 Tower Ceramic Heater with Ionizer
Price: $63.00
List Price: $98.00 |
|
Lasko 5435 Max-Endurance Oscillating Ceramic Heater with Digital Thermostat Control
Price: $39.99
|
Conduction heaters
Radiant heaters
Radiant heaters are the use an exposed element to
directly heat an object, through conduction, rather than heat the surrounding
air. Old-fashioned electric bar heaters, and halogen heaters, are the two most
common examples of radiant heater. Radiant heaters provide instant and intense
heat, so are a godsend if you have just come in from the cold. Radiant heaters
provide directed heat, so are a great option where only a few people feel the
cold.
Conduction heaters are not designed to heat up large spaces, and are limited in range. In addition, they are extremely uneconomical, especially when compared with oil heaters. Conduction heaters are best used for a quick blast of instant heat rather than to provide permanent heating. Finally, radiant heaters can be extremely unsafe, easily causing burns or electrocution. A model with robust guards and an anti-tip cut off is the only safe option.
Electric Heater Summary
For quick, direct heat, radiant heaters are the best
option, but they are too uneconomical to provide permanent heat. Oil heaters,
by contrast, are an economical and efficient way to heat up large areas.
Natural convection heaters are the best compromise option, providing a great balance between economy, efficiency and practicality. Fan heaters are the worst option, and are the most inefficient and uneconomical of the electric heater types.
- http://www.energy.unsw.edu.au/HeaterTutorial.shtml
The University of New South Wales personal heater program. - Energy Efficiency in Australia
- Energy Savers: Space Heating and Cooling
- Electric heating | EECA ENERGYWISE™
Different types of electric heaters, their running costs, and what they are best used for - Comparison of the various electric heater options
- How Do Convection Space Heaters Work? | eHow.com
How Do Convection Space Heaters Work?. Convection space heaters generate heat in the same way that an electric range or electric oven does. Electricity flows through a resistor--a material that resists the flow of electric current. The... - Energy Smart Homes - Home Heating - Portable Heaters
- CARRIER or CONTACT.(comparison of conduction and convection heater manufacturers) | Process Heating
CARRIER or CONTACT.(comparison of conduction and convection heater manufacturers) from Process Heating provided by Find Articles at BNET - Robertdyas.com - Electrical Resources and Information.
- Comparison of Electric Heaters
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
I enjoyed this article because it breaks down the options really well. For me personally, I like the gradual oil convection heater because it's more economical, and yet powerful enough to run you outta there! Thanks for a well written hub.
Thanks, dohn. Glad that you found the information useful. It is summer here, too, so maybe I should write about air conditioners.
Enjoy the summer - it is always over too soon :)
Thanks, thefount. I prefer the oil heater, too. Believe it or not, it gets very cold in Greece over the winter, and we have no central heating. Our oil heater warmed the bedroom nicely and didn't pump up the electric bill too much!
Hi Sufi, cold in Greece! I dont believe it. Last time I was in Crete it was so hot even the locals were complaining! (Mind you that must have been 20 years ago). I find all forms of heating work well in summer over here but in winter beds the best place!
Speak soon, Dave
Thanks, Dave - it is very hot here at the moment, pushing 40 degrees! It is cold in the winter, and we often have snow. The problem is that many old houses do not have double glazing or insulation, so winter is spent huddled around the stove :|
Take care
Hook it up to alternative energy source and the bills drop big time :) great info, Sufi.
Thanks for the information. I;ve used several different heaters, but I like the oil heaters best. Keep warm.
Hi Dame Scribe - I apologise for missing your comment. Always good to see you :)
That is a little further down the line - we would love to have solar panels, one day, but we will wait until the price drops.
Thanks for the great advice, BCB - The oil ones are excellent and extremely economical.














dohn121 says:
4 months ago
Thank you sufidreamer for this useful and resourceful hub. Being that it's summer here, I'll definitely have to bookmark this hub and re-analyze everything in a a couple of months! Good to see you're still hard at work! Talk to you soon.