create your own

History Often Depends On Who Writes It

66
rate or flag this page

By William F. Torpey


William Francis Hogan, My Uncle
William Francis Hogan, My Uncle
USS Gregory in Port Circa 1942
USS Gregory in Port Circa 1942
Raising the Flag on Iwo Jima, Famous photo by Joe Rosenthal (The Associated Press)
Raising the Flag on Iwo Jima, Famous photo by Joe Rosenthal (The Associated Press)

From as far back as I can remember, I have been fascinated by history.

For this, and many other things, my gratitude goes out to the good Sisters of Charity of St. Peter's grammar school in Yonkers, N.Y. They helped bring alive, for me, many of the figures and events of history, for example, George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, Patrick Henry, Pope Pius XII, Henry Hudson and Napoleon Bonaparte as well as the Civil War and the French and Indian War.

Unfortunately, World War One was always one of the last chapters in the textbooks we studied, and we seldom got far enough back in the book to study that important part of our history. We knew a lot more about World War II in those days, but the war wasn't history as much as it was current events.

While my interest in history continues to this day, it was in those early formative years that I developed a passion for the subject.

I was only a child when Allied soldiers were dying on the beaches of Iwo Jima, where an uncle was wounded, and German U-boats hunted their prey in the Atlantic. Another uncle, William F. Hogan, for whom I was named, was lost near Guadalcanal when his ship, the USS Gregory, (a fast transport APD, converted from an obsolete destroyer,) was outgunned by Japanese destroyers and sunk early in the war.

But, as young as I was, I remember my feelings about that war very well. I recall the feelings of pride I had when my older brother, Don, started a Victory Garden in the backyard of our apartment house. Although I have no artistic talent at all, I used to try to draw airplanes and tanks; I learned how to make paper airplanes; I was eager to see the patriotic designs -- airplanes, tanks, etc. -- on the ration stamps we received.

And there was a darker side, no doubt influenced by many of the double features I watched in Yonkers movies houses, including "Destination Tokyo," "Sands of Iwo Jima," and "Back to Bataan." Not only was I fearful that Frankenstein, or the Wolfman, may have been hiding under my bed, but, occasionally, I would have nightmares of Japanese Zeros attacking New York along the Hudson River, where an outcropping of vegetation created what looked like a perfect picture of Hitler's face on the cliffs of the Palisades during the war.

All these images resurfaced in my memory in March while I was editing a story about Yuko Tojo, granddaughter of Gen. Hideki Tojo, the object of American hatred from Pearl Harbor to V-J Day and beyond (My grandmother refused to buy anything marked "Made in Japan" for more than three decades.)

Yuko Tojo sought to honor the general's wish to hold a memorial for the war dead and to rehabilitate the memory of Tojo, who was hanged after the war for crimes against humanity.

This incident gave me pause. It's been said that the history of the world will be written by the victors; if the Axis powers had won World War II, what would the history books say about us then?

In my history book, George Washington really did cut down that cherry tree; Errol Flynn was an American hero, not a Nazi spy; and, as I'll always believe, Bing Crosby was truly a nice guy.

I wrote this column as a "My View" for The Hour newspaper of Norwalk, Conn., on Aug. 5, 1999. I now write my views on a wide variety of topics on HubPages. You can, too. It's easy, and free! Get paid for writing about what you love, or whatever interests you!. HubPages makes the technical part easy. Make friends and get help on its active forum. Take a quick tour to see how easy it is to get started today Here -- My HubPages Profile Here

WW II U.S. Troops Rest in the Field During Guadalcanal Campaign
WW II U.S. Troops Rest in the Field During Guadalcanal Campaign

The Fighting Hogans

The story of Seaman William Francis Hogan, my uncle, who died in World War II when his ship, the USS Gregory, was surprised by a superior Japanese force of destroyers near Guadalcanal.

Hitler's Face on the Palisades During WW II

The "Hitler" face, c. 1941. See upper left side of slide. Another rockslide obliterated the face after WW II. (Photo by the Yonkers Ferry Corporation).
The "Hitler" face, c. 1941. See upper left side of slide. Another rockslide obliterated the face after WW II. (Photo by the Yonkers Ferry Corporation).

Lost Fleet of Guadalcanal -- Part One

Lost Fleet of Guadalcanal -- Part Two

Lost Fleet of Guadalcanal -- Part Three

Lost Fleet of Guadalcanal -- Part Four

Lost Fleet of Guadalcanal -- Part Five

Lost Fleet of Guadalcanal -- Part Six

  • Monessen native receives Naval Academy recognitionPittsburgh Tribune-Review31 hours ago

    James R. Frezzell, a 1963 graduate of Monessen High School now living and working in Albany, N.Y., dropped out of the United States Naval Academy in Annapolis, Md., because of discrimination and harrassment, but is the recipient of an honor chair in Alumni Hall for his efforts on behalf of the academy.

  • Naval Academy Professor Challenges School's Push for DiversityWashington Post3 days ago

    Of the 1,230 plebes who took the oath of office at the U.S. Naval Academy in Annapolis this week, 435 were members of minority groups. It's the most racially diverse class in the academy's 164-year history.

  • Naval Academy admits most diverse classUPI3 days ago

    ANNAPOLIS, Md., July 3 (UPI) -- The U.S. Naval Academy has admitted a freshman class with the highest percentage of minorities in its history, 435 out of 1,230 plebes.

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub Small RSS Icon

ColdWarBaby profile image

ColdWarBaby  says:
10 months ago

Even before reading Orwell I knew this, if enough people believe something is true, it becomes the "truth".

William F. Torpey profile image

William F. Torpey  says:
10 months ago

History is always fascinating to me, ColdWarBaby, but it's always wise to take it with a grain of salt. It's much too easy for historians to "accentuate the positive and eliminate the negative." Thanks for commenting.

Bob  says:
10 months ago

Bill, as you know I'm a histroy nut too.Liked your column. Now to business, I was always taught in school that the USA were the good guys. Movies from Hollywood during WW2 made the enemy , the ememy, and we were the good guys. Along come the 60's and things start to happen with our education.movies and media. Krushev said back in the late 50's that the commies would bury us from within.I believe he was right. Movies today portray our troops as the bad guys. Educators have rewritten our history books to where our fore-fathers should have stayed in Europe.The early Americans cheated and stole the Indians lands. Never a word about the massacres of the settlers by the indians. I won't even mention the so called main stream media as you know my feelings well about them. Yep, I guess history depends on who writes it. As for me , I like the old history better.

ColdWarBaby profile image

ColdWarBaby  says:
10 months ago

Old or new Bob, I prefer a history that's accurate.

William F. Torpey profile image

William F. Torpey  says:
10 months ago

The good guys and the bad guys is a comic book approach, Bob. During WW II we were all (with only a few exceptions) gung-ho against the Japanese and Germans, but there was no had no choice but to stop their encroachment on us and the rest of the world. That's a lot different than what the Bush Administration is doing today. People are people everywhere, both good and bad. History books will always be written from the point of view of the survivors, but it's important to own up to one's own mistakes. It's never the messenger's fault, but he's the one who usually gets blamed. Very convenient.

William F. Torpey profile image

William F. Torpey  says:
10 months ago

Accuracy in history, ColdWarBaby, is ideal, but I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for it.

ColdWarBaby profile image

ColdWarBaby  says:
10 months ago

I hear that!

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working