create your own

Hole in the Wall Computers for Underprivileged Children

72
rate or flag this page

By Iphigenia


An Extraordinary Experiment

This experiment is 10 years old and ongoing. It is directed by Professor Mitra of Newcastle University and Delhi. In India in 1999 Mitra and his researchers installed computers in ‘holes in the wall’ in villages where literacy levels were low, underprivilege was the norm and nobody had ever encountered a computer.

Curious children were immediately attracted to the strange new machine and were delighted when they were told that it belonged to them. Within minutes the children figured out how to point and click.

Initially the stronger boys and maybe the bullies of the community dominated the space in front of the computers. But they soon got bored and eventually the natural geeks emerged.

They worked out how to use the Paint program to make pictures – and more amazingly learned how to save the pictures that they created. By the end of the day they were browsing and within a week were regularly logging on to the MTV website. Within a month of interaction, children were able to discover and use features such as new folder creation, cutting and pasting, shortcuts, moving/resizing windows and using MS Word to create short messages even without a keyboard.

All this in villages with no television and the nearest telephone a few miles away (it was 1999 remember). Also the computer interface was in English – a language unknown to these children.


The NIIT experiment in a South Delhi slum that inspired Vikas Swarup to write Q&A which, in turn, led to Danny Boyle creating Slumdog Millionaire.


India : Children, Villages, Culture

Going to School in India Going to School in India
Every school day millions of children go to school in India in city classrooms, mountain fields, desert tents, and glowing temples.
Price: $14.16
List Price: $21.95
Women, Family, and Child Care in India: A World in Transition Women, Family, and Child Care in India: A World in Transition
Succeeds in giving the reader the feel of the culture and the people described.
Price: $19.63
List Price: $43.00
Learning from Children What to Teach Them Learning from Children What to Teach Them
This enriching book explores quality education at the grassroots level for disadvantaged children.
Price: $20.97
List Price: $42.95
Child Rights in India: Law, Policy, and Practice Child Rights in India: Law, Policy, and Practice
Arguably the first comprehensive modern study on child rights in India.
Price: $30.51
List Price: $49.95
Geeta's Day: From Dawn to Dusk in an Indian Village (Child's Day) Geeta's Day: From Dawn to Dusk in an Indian Village (Child's Day)
A joy of a book, capturing the diversity and dignity of rural life in a distant location.
Price: $5.41
List Price: $9.91
Socrates In An Indian Village Socrates In An Indian Village
A lucid and forceful book which lets the daylight into many a dark corner of village life.
Price: $24.61
List Price: $26.95

Children were able to learn to use computers and the Internet on their own, irrespective of their social, cultural or economic backgrounds. Adults on the other hand did not make any attempt to learn how to use the hole-in-the-wall computers but were delighted that their children had this opportunity.

At first only about 30 percent of the users were girls but then the researchers said to all the children that the computer was for girls and boys alike. The girls proved to be as enthusiastic and as adept at computing as the boys. A big plus for getting the girls involved was they organised the use of the computer setting a timetable for use and a rota of names.

Children formed impromptu classes to teach one another and invented their own vocabulary to define terms on the computer. For example, some referred to the cursor as a 'sui,' Hindi for needle, while the hourglass that appears onscreen when a computer is busy became the 'damru,' after Hindu god Shiva's hourglass-shaped drum. Web sites were referred to as "channels".

Painting and games were favourites with younger children, while those aged 12 to 13 read newspapers, browsed cinema sites and occasionally accessed educational material.

This is how the children taught each other in computer usage:

One child made an accidental discovery eg : they find that the cursor changes to a hand shape at certain places on the screen. Several children repeated the discovery for themselves by requesting the first child to let them do so. Then more accidental or incidental discoveries are made as a result of the first. All the children repeated all the discoveries made and, in the process, make more discoveries and started to create a vocabulary to describe their experience.

The vocabulary encouraged them to perceive generalisations (“when you right click on a hand shaped cursor, it changes to the hourglass shape for a while and a new page comes up”). They memorised entire procedures for doing something, for example, how to open a painting program and retrieve a saved picture. They taught each other shorter procedures for doing the same thing, whenever one of them found a new, shorter, procedure.


Younger Kids Teach Older Kids

Sharing a Computer
Sharing a Computer
Teaching Each Other
Teaching Each Other

The groups in each village naturally divided itself into the “knows” and the “know nots.” It was realised that a child that knows something new would part with that knowledge in return for friendship and exchange as opposed to ownership of physical things where they could use force to get what they did not have.

A stage was reached by most groups of village children when no further discoveries were made and the children occupied themselves with practising what they had already learned. At this point the researchers introduced a new “seed” discovery eg : “did you know that computers can play music? Here let me play a song for you” – but without showing the children how it was done. Usually, a spiral of discoveries followed and another self instructional cycle began.

It is much more amazing than I can make it sound. For more information : a 15 page paper about the genesis of the experiment and a discussion which was written in 2001. The second is a 20 minute video of Professor Mitra in 2007 discussing the ongoing results, implications and applications of this experiment.

This experiment inspired the Oscar Winning "Slumdog Millionaire"

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Julie-Ann Amos profile image

Julie-Ann Amos  says:
9 months ago

What a great idea - I had no ides this existed

Elena. profile image

Elena.  says:
9 months ago

Hi Iphigenia! I knew about this but on a general level, wasn't privy to the details and the learning process you describe. It's wonderful. Actually, this hub is amazingly moving --I know, that sounds a bit odd, but I am moved by childrens' curiosity, their wish and will to learn and share the knowledge, to experience stuff by themselves.... it's extraordinary and gives me hope and a fuzzy feeling. Thanks for writing this article!

Teresa McGurk profile image

Teresa McGurk  says:
9 months ago

I LOVE this -- love, love, love it! Kids are such wonderful innovators and adaptors -- teaching each other -- this is just BRILLIANT. I am constantly delighted at how quickly younger kids soak up new information, and constantly appalled at how little is demanded or expected of American kids by comparison.

Great article: I had no idea this was happening, and wish I had known about it years ago. It does my heart good. Thank you so much for writing it (gee. can you tell I'm an educator? Does it show? :) )

Elena. profile image

Elena.  says:
9 months ago

Nah, Teresa, it doesn't show at all. Trying to keep a straight face here... ahem

Laugh!  But see here, I am equally excited and I'm not an educator!  Isn't it just amazing!!  I actually came back to re-read some parts of this!

Mr Nice profile image

Mr Nice  says:
9 months ago

Hi Iphigenia!

Very interesting & amazing project. Computers & internet changed the educational awareness, communications & cultures around the world.

justmesuzanne profile image

justmesuzanne  says:
9 months ago

Interesting and inspiring concept! Thanks! :)

Cris A profile image

Cris A  says:
9 months ago

I've never heard of it until now. What a wonderful experiment the results of which are fascinating and very interesting. Really, when you have the passion of learning, you'll learn! Thanks for sharing. :D

Iphigenia profile image

Iphigenia  says:
9 months ago

Isn't it just amazing ? All aspects of this experiment - the social interaction between the kids, the respect they show for the computer (no vandalism !) etc. For me as an Applied Linguist I was fascinated by the way the children adapted the language they already knew to concepts that had been completely alien to them a day or s earlier - and then how this shifted their perceptions.

I came across this via BBC radio a couple of months ago (can't remember if it was Radio 4 or World Service) - anyway Prof Mitra was interviewed about his work and I just hda to find out more.

Rik Ravado profile image

Rik Ravado  says:
9 months ago

Amazing stuff - thanks for sharing this!

iabecker515 profile image

iabecker515  says:
9 months ago

Very interesting! I am really glad i read this!

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working