create your own

Hoovervilles

77
rate or flag this page

By Chef Jeff


 

By Chef Jeff

I am a veteran, and a historian. I often have read lots of pages on various subjects and I often formulate my own opinions about things. In this article I do not pretend that I am not biased in favor of vets. This is a story of how if we, Americans, do not keep a close eye on our public servants, they may begin to believe that we serve them, instead of the other way around.

This article is not meant to make you angry at the government; after all, we are the government. Or, at least, that is how it is supposed to be!

So, here is the story of Hoovervilles and the Veterans and their families who dared to demand better of their elected leaders.

A proud veteran knows what he fought for.

One of millions of veterans who fought for your rights to live as a free American, to speak your peace and elect whom you wish.
One of millions of veterans who fought for your rights to live as a free American, to speak your peace and elect whom you wish.

In 1917 American entered The Great War, also called The War to End All Wars. About 4.3 million U.S. soldiers entered the ranks, and of that, around 126,000 were killed and 234,000 were wounded. When the war ended, some veterans were psychologically damaged and seldom recovered. But America was entering The Roaring Twenties, and few people noticed the daft or crazy old vets who were shoved aside because people wanted to have a good time.

Long about October 1929, however, things went sour, and our nation, along with the rest of the world, entered what we now call The Great Depression. Herbert Hoover was president then, and people had elected him in a time of prosperity. His greatest attribute, they believed in 1928, was that he kept government from meddling in things, and that was OK at the time. No government regulations meant that people were free to win or lose fortunes in the stock market and in speculation.

World War One - The War to End All Wars

Men of many nations fought each other to the death for what they believed.  At the end of that conflict Woodrow Wilson tried his best to assure that no such conflict would ever be seen again.  He was betrayed by his allies in Europe, and by Congress
Men of many nations fought each other to the death for what they believed. At the end of that conflict Woodrow Wilson tried his best to assure that no such conflict would ever be seen again. He was betrayed by his allies in Europe, and by Congress

However, as factories closed and people lost their jobs, Americans started to get worried about the basics. How could they buy food for today if they had no paycheck? Were there jobs somewhere else, because there sure as heck weren't any here! Farmers lost their land to foreclosures; people living in cities lost their homes to the same. Banks closed; savings were lost, and just about everybody suffered.

America was as close to anarchy as it had ever been, and with the rise of both Communism and Fascism, was also ripe for these "new" philosophies of government to take root, shoving Democracy aside. There was truly a battle for the hearts and minds going on here, and a lot of people were quite ready to abandon what we had for that which looked oh, so good over in Italy, Russia or Germany.

Mussolini in Italy had brought about a Fascists revolution, was bringing prosperity to his people, while the propaganda from the Soviet Union spoke of bread, jobs and work, as if they had a surplus of each of these. Americans were naïve about other nations: we had spent the better part of our existence avoiding foreign entanglements, so most people didn't see the warts inherent in fascism and Communism. But they did know that something was wrong here in the United States, something the government seemed unwilling or unable to fix.

People were hurting in large enough numbers that danger loomed around the corner.

Veterans, and their families, felt the most betrayed. After all, they had gone to war to end tyranny, to bring Democracy to the world, and now they were being forced out of their homes, they lost their jobs, and they were angry - very angry, and they remembered how to unite. So, unite they did.

Hooverville

There were many Hoovervilles across the U.S, and in other nations veterans and others built similar places to beg, plead and demand better treatement by their governments.
There were many Hoovervilles across the U.S, and in other nations veterans and others built similar places to beg, plead and demand better treatement by their governments.

Hoovervilles were shanty towns, made from whatever materials people could scavenge. They sprang up all over the nation, but in Washington D.C., right in the heart of our nation's capital, the most noticeable Hooverville, with the most vocal leaders, grew on the flats of Anacostia. Here, in 1932, the Bonus Army of veterans gathered, at first to seek and later to demand, relief that had been promised by the government. Altogether about 15,000 people were camped there.

These were men with skills, who were organized, and they made their little Hooverville into as comfortable a place as they could, but they were also desperate people, starving save for what they could scavenge, unclothed except for what they could find tossed aside by others, and without means, hope or a voice.

We Americans love to say that we are the government, that the people we elect serve us, at our pleasure, but this is rarely so. People in power tend to look down upon us, unless there is an election looming, in which case they are out there shaking hands and smiling at us. I dare say that few, if any, politicians set foot in a Hooverville, unless they had armed guards close at hand.

Now imagine a situation where more than half the people in the nation are either or both homeless and jobless. To my mind it is a testament to We, the People that there wasn't violent revolution seen in the streets. Perhaps people didn't want trouble; they merely wanted jobs.

Whatever the case, the government leaders decided that this was Communism rearing its ugly head right in the heart of the nation, and they did as governments usually do: they sent in the troops.

How do you "Respect Our Troops"???

While veterans make up 11 percent of the population, 26 percent of homeless people are veterans
While veterans make up 11 percent of the population, 26 percent of homeless people are veterans

Douglas McArthur, Dwight Eisenhower and George Patton were amongst the military men who led troops into the Washington D.C. Hooverville and evicted every man, woman and child there. The buildings were torn down, the entire flat was leveled.

Troops were used to evict veterans. I can only imagine that in the minds of those troops, who had to do their duty, were the thoughts that someday this could be their fate.

Today we hear a lot of talk about supporting the troops. That idea came at a price. Outside the Hoovervilles of the past, there was little talk about supporting the veterans. Congress delayed, talked, and did little.

Meanwhile the nation starved, froze and grew angrier. Hoover Blankets, newspapers, were all that some people had to keep them warm in winter. Hoover Flags were pockets symbolically turned inside out to show that you had absolutely nothing. Hoover Leather was a bit of cardboard shoved into your shoe to cover the holes in the leather. People who still possessed a car called it Hoover Wagon when they tied a horse to pull it along, since they couldn't afford gasoline.

And then on top of all this came The Dust Bowl. It was the ultimate adding of injury to insult, and people had had enough. From 1919 to 1933 the Republicans had controlled the Senate, and in the eyes of many Americans, they had done little to alleviate the crisis. From 1917 to 1933 Republicans controlled the House of Representatives, and they also were perceived as a do-nothing Congress. People voted in change.

Department of Veteran's Affairs

The V.A. has what some consider to be a spotty record of protecting Veteran's Rights.  But it is a step in the right direction when compared to how things were in 1933.
The V.A. has what some consider to be a spotty record of protecting Veteran's Rights. But it is a step in the right direction when compared to how things were in 1933.
 

There are many pundits today who knock the change people demanded back then, who now say that it really wasn't Hoover's fault, and that he tried to do things to make the situation better. Some even say that Roosevelt established Socialist Ideology into American government, and that we still suffer from that today. People who forget the misery and suffering of millions of ordinary Americans, people who sit in luxury while others starve, are often prone to saying such things.

And people like us who forget the lessons of the past are always subject to reliving them again. Veterans and other people of the 1930's were children of the horrors our nation went through, and that is why, I believe, programs such as Social Security and health care were not seen as Communist plots or Socialist programs. They were viewed by a great many Americans as promises fulfilled, American reaching once more for greatness instead of basking lazily in laissez faire policies that tended to favor the already wealthy.

Over the next decades people with short memories and other agendas would knock the New Deal programs, rename them under the banner of Socialism and try to make them look evil. And they would convince many of these things. We have, after all, short memories ourselves.

But the Generation of the Hoovervilles, the Generation of the Dust Bowl, could see through the propaganda of the leaders and pundits who wanted to return everything to the way it was before the government remembered that it is Constitutionally "of the People, by the People and for the People", would not allow it to perish beneath the tirades of those who would divide us, create artificial barriers between us, and give us the trickle down droppings from their table of plenty.

The baton in this race has passed to a new generation. I can only hope they realize how precious, how rare is this gift we have given them, and that they will work hard to keep it noble, to keep it pure and to keep it going. I pray so in order that: "...that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth."

Bing Crosby -Brother can you spare a dime?

A Veteran's View of "Respect the Troops".

Veterans - Fair Shake or Not?

Do you believe Veterans are getting a fair shake in the U.S.?

  • Yes, they are getting a fair shake right now.
  • No, we could do more for them.
  • No opinion.
See results without voting

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

marisuewrites profile image

marisuewrites  says:
18 months ago

Our government is quick to call it foreign aid if we help another country and socialism if they help their own.

Soldiers truly fought out of love for this country, not always for what it was, but what it was to be in the future, for what it could and should be. 

I'm amazed at this information, some of which I have vague memories as my grandparents and parents and great uncles talked.  I remember CC camps, my dad worked in during the depression...(waaaay before I was even thought of...)they were work camps  - tent cities for people moving around where the work was...

How sad that our government is and was so slow to react but this information sure brings a lot to light...old habits die hard.

Very interesting Chef and worth several reads to soak up!!  

I am sickened by our lack of help to those who give so much...not to mention the lack of aid to the aged, the uninsured, the homeless, and on it goes.

I'm scrolling back up to read more.  Marisue 

Chef Jeff profile image

Chef Jeff  says:
18 months ago

Glad you are reading it - I wrote this over several days to cut it down, believe it or not!

ColdWarBaby profile image

ColdWarBaby  says:
18 months ago

Thank you Jeff, very much. You and I are of such like minds. You just speak yours so much more diplomatically. There are many isms and most of them could be perfectly viable social models. The problem is the big stank fly of corrupt, greedy, ruthless individuals in the ointment that always infects ANY variant of "society" with their terminal diseases of oppression and exploitation.

I think the wheel must turn again now. We’ll just have to go back Jack and do it again.

blangrehr profile image

blangrehr  says:
18 months ago

Veterans of the First World War in the United States had been promised a cash bonus payable in 1945. Beginning in 1931, veterans organized to get full payment immediately. Congressman Wright Patman and Senator Huey Long were the leading proponents. Presidents Herbert Hoover and Franklin Delano Roosevelt strongly opposed the payment. 45,000 veterans calling themselves the Bonus Expeditionary Force or Bonus Army marched on Washington in 1932 and were driven out by the Army. Congress passed several bonus bills that were vetoed and finally overcame Roosevelt's veto in 1936 (Adjusted Compensation Payment Act, 1936, January 27, 1936, ch. 32, 49 Stat. 1099). The Treasury distributed $1.5 billion in cash to the 4 million veterans.

Our brave heroes have never been properly appreciated.

I truly enjoyed this article and this history lesson, thank you.

Chef Jeff profile image

Chef Jeff  says:
18 months ago

Thank you blangrehr for additional information - you rounded out the story nicely, and I thank you!

The entire cause of the Great Depression was, of course, far beyond the control of either the president or the Congress, but the willingness to help was sadly lacking in our government at the time.

Even Roosevelt did not fully appreciate the dire nature of the situation, in my opinion.  There was a growing Fascist league in the U.S. throughout his presidency, and they built their propaganda on the ability of Hitler and Musollini to create working states, where unemployment was almost unheard of, the railroads operated on time, and this beautiful new highway in Germany was under constrution.

Also, German auto makers were creating the People's Car, and putting Detroit to shame by making it accessible to ordinary Germans at a cheap price.

And in Russia, the news spread by the growing Communist movement in America was that Stalin had taken control of the farms in the Ukraine and had turned them into models of Soviet Communist efficiency.  More than that, he had modernized the Soviet factories into working models of what Marx had predicted once the Proletariat took control from the greedy capitalists who had ruled Russia under the Czar.

Of course, all this was merely propaganda, and the People's Car was never delivered, the Soviet model ruined farming in Russia for decades to come and Musollini's trains ran on schedule, but were soon loaded with soliders instead of civilians going to work, and were eventually bombed into ruin.

But the fact that Fascists were growing in strength in the U.S. speaks volumes to me about where we were headed, and I think it was Roosevelt, either through plan or just by sheer luck, who changed things.

He had his warts, to be sure, and some of them were very ugly and had to be carefully covered; yet he remained like Bill Clinton until now, a popular man all the days of his life.

I've said it before and I think it bears repeating - we don't elect saints to political office - we elect politicians, and they come in all stripes - some ugly, some less ugly, but all of them sugar-coated in ambition, promises and lies.

blangrehr profile image

blangrehr  says:
18 months ago

That should be your opening statement in Government 101. I think that exactly, you just express my thoughts so much better. Finally an article without a political slant, it is refreshing and real thanks again.

In The Doghouse profile image

In The Doghouse  says:
18 months ago

Chef Jeff,

What a great refresher course in some US History. Oft times history does repeat itself, hopefully we have learned a bit from the past. Thank you for this wonderful teaching Hub.

marisuewrites profile image

marisuewrites  says:
18 months ago

We need you chef to be a commentator on the common-tator shows...You'd give Bill O'Really and Lou Doubt a run for their money!!

Chef Jeff profile image

Chef Jeff  says:
18 months ago

Well, if you know anyone looking for a common-tator, I am looking for work, so keep those cards & letters coming, my friends!

Yes, I am about as common as they get - I had to literally claw my way up and around a lot of obstacles. I don't know if I have "common sense" but my wife notes that I am often "commonly senseless".

And seriously, if you know of anyone looking for a person with a clear-cut "radio-face"' let me know!

Smiling Cat profile image

Smiling Cat  says:
18 months ago

Very good! Excellent hub!

Chef Jeff profile image

Chef Jeff  says:
18 months ago

Thanks, Dog House, as you know I enjoy your hubs as well, and I highly recommend them to anyone seeking out what is good about the world. 

You wrote a great hub about how people are helping to stamp out measles and how wheel chairs are being brought to people who otherwise couldn't get around.

For every bad thing being done in the world I hope and pray someone is doing a good thing.

  And yes, I also love "It's a Wonderful Life." and try to also see things from the "bright side" at times!

Thanks to all.

Sally's Trove profile image

Sally's Trove  says:
18 months ago

Extraordinary hub, Chef. I am speechless, except to say that you encapsulated a time in our history by framing it with intelligence, grace, and hope. And you smacked us all in the face that things are not so different today. I have nothing to add to that. You said it all.

robie2 profile image

robie2  says:
18 months ago

Well said chef--well said indeed. Bravo!

Chef Jeff profile image

Chef Jeff  says:
18 months ago

I find that most of history is really not a partisan adventure, and when one group or political party falls down in one era, their opposite number manages to repeat the error in another.

I am working on another era that piques my interst - the Johnson Years. I have kind of a love-hate relationship with the middle and late 60's, an era that saw huge leaps in Civil Rights but was marred by our adventures in Viet Nam.

It parallels, in my mind at least, the current era - arrogance coupled with noble aspirations, rampant corruption coupled with extraordinary efforts to clean up government. It was a time, I believe, when the best of intentions truly did lead us down the road to Hell.

sixtyorso profile image

sixtyorso  says:
18 months ago

Hello Chef This piece of American history has amazing parallels here in South Africa.Change a few names substite the ANC for the Party concerned and look at Sqatter camps in around the Major South african cities where the rank and file live mostly on or below the breadline. The masses have put the ANC in power some 14 odd years ago and the arrogant politicians have greedily lined their pockets coorruptly by BEE and other self-help intiatives but the lack of service delivery, housing and basic health care are painfully obvious. Now we have a humanitarian crisis exacerbated by the influx of 100's of thousands of migrants from surrounding countries which have created more anger and frustration giving rise to xenophobic attacks on the migrants by the locals. Great hub!

sixtyorso profile image

sixtyorso  says:
18 months ago

As you so aptly point out - history certainly seems to have a pattern repeating itself. different places different names different times but once again we seem to be on the brink of a world wide economic melt down which could have some interesting consequences

JazLive profile image

JazLive  says:
18 months ago

History has help repeating itself, like currently, in the United States, we are in a period very much like President Herbert Hoover thanks to the current Republican administration.

mikeq107 profile image

mikeq107  says:
14 months ago

Great Hub....I love History..and You nailed it on the head..Bang,Bang...keeping Shooting..lol

MikeQ:0)

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus  says:
13 months ago

Hey Chef, I checked out some of your Hubs that I haven't read and this one interested me. I remember the horrible situation at home when the guys returned from Vietnam- was that the worst of all times for vets? Seems like it must have been. That was truly a hard lesson for me to discover- I was pretty young and thought the government was for the people, not for using the people- my male peers. And so it continues...

Katie  says:
12 months ago

Hi. I actually live in the UK and i am in year 8, but we are studying homeless people, and when i heard about the Hoovervilles i decided to find information about it and to show my english teacher, and possibly my history teacher as well, for we need to listen to the past to figure out the future. I just wanted to say that my heart goes out to all those people who kept their hope and didn't give up but kept trying. I just hope that this doesn't happen again, but it seems inevitable at the rate everything is going right now, and this time it is global.

britneydavidson profile image

britneydavidson  says:
10 months ago

its really really great hub..i salute that people...

thanx for such a nice hub....

Chef Jeff profile image

Chef Jeff  says:
10 months ago

Thanks to all who are still responding to my hub. I have been recently hired by the State of Illinois to work in the Illinois Department of Employment Security, whichmeans I help recently unemployed people find either work or receive benefits for unemployment. How ironic that I was unemloyed for s long, but now have work helping people, which of course I love to do!

I have every faith and confidence that Presdient Obama (It still feels soooo good to be able to say that!!!) will do his best to turn around the situation we as a nation, and as a world, now find ourselves so deeply stuck in.

Keep the faith and hang in there - a better day is coming!

Cheers!

Chef Jeff T.

unknown  says:
8 months ago

i think that that old man is soooooooooooooo cute!!!!

Ivan the Terrible profile image

Ivan the Terrible  says:
5 weeks ago

That old man was once a young man, and he had his dreams, or so say I. A veteran is often neglected even after he or she comes home, but all of us who are vets remember our comrades and our experiences and most of us will be the first to tell anyone that war should never be the first answer to any problem.

Great hub and I hope more people read it!

Degree Online  says:
4 weeks ago

Old man feature are much attractive

ALMA  says:
10 days ago

DIS IS STUPID

Chef Jeff profile image

Chef Jeff  says:
10 days ago

One man's stupid is another man's intelligent, ALMA.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working