create your own

I Saved 200K —Is Refinancing to a 15-Year Mortgage Right for You?

78
rate or flag this page

By wannabwestern


I didn't sell a kidney, any part of my self, or my soul. What I did took a bit of research and time, and a decent credit score. What did I do? I refinanced my family's biggest asset, our home, to a very conservative 15-year fixed rate mortgage. Was it worth it? Definitely! Do I recommend for everyone? Of course not!

But I figured that through this move, we would free up an extra 5-years of my husband's annual income for use in other things.Obviously, your circumstances may be quite different. Many people will disagree with our move.

Suze Orman says in her books that for a middle-income family, owning their home free and clear can have an emotional and psychological effect beyond the money savings. I agree.


I am Not a Mortgage Agent

I am not a mortgage agent, nor do I work in any part of the housing industry. I'm a stay-at-home mom, and was looking for a way help my family get ahead. I discovered that after being in our home for almost 5 years, we had accrued VERY LITTLE equity on our house.

Why? Because our 30-year loan was set up to pay most of the interest before we paid off principal (the part we get back, counted as equity.)

Out of curiosity, I began doing some comparison shopping online. Using interest rate calculators and loan-comparison wizards, I was able to determine that if we refinanced our home and paid a higher mortgage payment, we would be able to build equity much faster.

In a traditional 30-year loan, during the first 15 years you build little equity as you pay off the interest due. Meanwhile, from day 1 of a 15-year loan, your loan pays approximately half interest and half principal.

Here is a rate comparison for a $100,000 mortgage. In today's rate environment, most Americans would be thrilled to pay on "only" a $100,000 mortgage, and it seems like an easy round number to work with.

Typically, the point spread between a 30-year and a 15-year loan is about 1/2 of a percentage point. I chose to compare:

  • A 30-year, 100K mortgage at 5.75%
  • A 15-year, 100K mortgage at 5.25%

This is what the amortization table looks like:


30 Year Fixed, 100K loan, 5.75%

With a 30-year loan, in your first 5 years you only build $5000 in equity. If you move during the first 3-5 years, you will have very little to show for it.
With a 30-year loan, in your first 5 years you only build $5000 in equity. If you move during the first 3-5 years, you will have very little to show for it.

15 Year Fixed, 100K loan, 5.25%

The loan payment for this loan is higher, at $803.88. If you don't have room in your budget, this could be a huge financial mistake...but, if you DO have the money to cover the higher payment, you could have $20,000 more equity in just 5 years.
The loan payment for this loan is higher, at $803.88. If you don't have room in your budget, this could be a huge financial mistake...but, if you DO have the money to cover the higher payment, you could have $20,000 more equity in just 5 years.

What Questions Should I Ask Myself?

I would be lying to you if I suggested that refinancing in today's housing environment was a good move for everyone, or even the average person. If you have credit card debt, student loan debt, or other personal circumstances that make this move an unwise choice, then don't do it! Maybe you stretched quite a bit to get into the house you bought and could only afford a 30-year payment. In an environment with skyrocketing fuel and food costs, you may do better to hold onto your money. Ask yourself these questions and think your decision through:

  • How much will it cost me to refinance? (Ours cost almost $4,000).
  • Do I have good credit and will my rate be lower now if I refinance?
  • Can I afford to be locked into a higher payment?
  • IF you have the self-discipline, you could make an extra payment instead of refinancing. There are online calculators that explain how to do that too...
  • Do I have enough financial reserves to make the payment if I get behind?
  • Does my family plan to stay in the house for about 5 years?
  • Is my house still worth what I paid for it? (Many houses in metro areas are dropping in value so quickly that some lenders won't do a refi right now, even if you have good credit).
  • Could I make more money using the extra payment in a different investment?

Home Mortgages In the News

  • FSA to get powers over mortgagesGuardian Unlimited1 second ago

    • Buy-to-let mortgages to come under FSA remit • Additional moves offer protection against repossessions Buy-to-let mortgages are to fall under the remit of the Financial Services Authority for the first time as a result of plans to be announced by the Treasury tomorrow. The City regulator is also to be given oversight of second charge mortgages – which currently lies with the Office of Fair ...

  • U.S. Treasury to Push Lenders to Finish More Home ModificationsBloomberg1 second ago

    Nov. 29 (Bloomberg) -- The U.S. Treasury Department will step up public pressure on lenders to finish modifying more home loans to troubled borrowers under a $75 billion campaign against the record tide of foreclosures.

  • Rates on 30-year mortgages match record lowAsbury Park Press3 hours ago

    MCLEAN, VA. — Freddie Mac reports that average rates for 30-year fixed mortgages have matched a record low of 4.78 percent this week.

  • Obama to push banks on mortgagesCNN Money1 second ago

    As foreclosure casualties mount, the Obama administration is expected to announce additional steps on Monday to get long-term help for troubled borrowers.

  • U.S. to Pressure Mortgage Firms for Loan ReliefNew York Times5 hours ago

    Only a tiny fraction of mortgages have been permanently reduced under the $75 billion Making Home Affordable program.

  • U.S. Will Push Mortgage Firms to Reduce More Loan PaymentsNew York Times1 second ago

    Only a tiny fraction of mortgages have been permanently reduced under a $75 billion program for troubled homeowners.

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

wannabwestern profile image

wannabwestern  says:
2 years ago

When do you think it's a good idea to refinance to a 15-year loan? Is it ever a good idea? Why or why not?

wisconsin mortgage rates  says:
15 months ago

I always try and talk my clients into a 15 year loan. People just get fixated on the lower monthly payment of a 30 year mortgage for some reason?

wannabwestern profile image

wannabwestern  says:
15 months ago

Thanks Wisconsin,

I believe that a 15-year loan is one of the steps to true financial freedom, and is one of the best ways that an average middle-class person can build security and sometimes wealth. To me, building security is an important part of preparing for retirement. If, like my parents, you're in your late fifties and you STILL owe 15 years on a mortgage, you don't have many options.

That said, our situation suddenly changed and we found ourselves moving. We're not going to make money on our 15-year mortgage, but we won't lose any, either. I strongly encourage people who are considering buying a home to buy less than they can afford so they can pay it off quickly.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working