create your own

How to Raise an Outlier

64
rate or flag this page

By Rabbit Reviews


Outliers: The Story of Success Outliers: The Story of Success
Price: $11.25
List Price: $27.99

A Non-Book Review

Malcolm Gladwell’s best-selling Outliers: The Story of Success presents evidence for a simple yet shocking thesis. Individuals that are truly outstanding in some way did not become so by virtue of their own virtues. Rather, their success depended upon their own virtues combined with a whopping dose of luck.



Hockey Gear for Christmas

Consider the Canadian hockey machine. What do high-ranking junior and professional hockey players have in common? Nearly all of them were born in the first three months of the year. Why? Because the cut-off date for peewee hockey leagues is January 1. That means the kids on the team that were born in January, February, and March are bigger and more coordinated than the late-year birthdays. So they get more attention from the coach, more encouragement, and more playing time. They may be tagged for an elite team, where they get even more attention, praise, and practice. And so on. Now, elite hockey players work very hard, to be sure, and they certainly have plenty of natural talent, but without the lucky break of the right birthday, they’d be slinging burgers instead of pucks.

Just Do It

Overall, the cultural background of the individual has just as much if not more to do with a successful person’s success as their own talent and effort. In a chapter titled Rice Paddies and Math Tests, Gladwell explains why Asian kids always get the highest math scores: they work harder. Consider: schoolchildren in the United States attend classes a mere 180 days per year. In high-achieving Asian countries, the number is larger—220 days in South Korea, 242 days in Japan. Not only do Asian kids get more schooling, they put more effort into it. Studies show that Asian kids will persist in trying to solve a math problem much longer than the average American kid.



The Hurried Child-25th Anniversary Edition The Hurried Child-25th Anniversary Edition
Price: $9.73
List Price: $16.95

American Doughnuts

Gladwell relates the difference to cultural heritage. Asian cultures view success as a direct outcome of hard work, and teach that ethic to their children. In contrast, Americans fiddle and fuss over our poor, harried, over-worked, stressed out children. Remember The Hurried Child? David Elkind's 1981 call-to-arms warned us about the dangers of expecting too much, too soon from our delicate darlings. But as far as I can see, they're mostly in a hurry to turn on the television lest they miss the latest episode of Zach and Cody.

Now I’m worried. I want my American children to grow up with the cultural advantage of a hard work ethic. Look all around you to see the result of the American ethic of “rest easy, quit early.” Go on, look. Lazy, fat, underachievers as far as the eye can see.

So I went to the bookstore to find some guidance. Something titled How to Teach Your Child to Work Hard and Not Give Up On Math Problems, or just How to Raise an Outlier. What did I find? Bupkis.


Underachieving Babies

The first book that caught my eye, It Sucked and Then I Cried, covers the standard ground of the traumas of early parenthood. Been there done that. What I want to know is, did she teach the baby to try harder to get its own damn pacifier from between the couch cushions?



Play Nice

Taking Back Childhood advocates creative play opportunities, positive relationships, and modeling cooperative behavior.  Hello?  I'm not looking for a preschool teacher training program.  Next.


Make Them Behave

The Bright Child Challenge sounded promising. Turns out smart kids are a huge pain in the rear, especially when they're smarter than their parents. The psychologist author teaches the reader how to work around the kid's efforts to manipulate you out of disciplining them. So they can fulfill their amazing potential and alleviate your need to run screaming into the woods. I can see how it could come in handy, but doesn't address my concerns.


I Love You, You Love Me

I knew Full Esteem Ahead would be a Fail, but I couldn't resist looking. Kindness, respect, nurturing environment, blah blah blah. Does self-esteem lead to world-class mastery? I don't think so.


Stress Therapy

The Resilient Child: Seven Essential Lessons for Your Child's Happiness and Success. Now we're talking! Lessons for success! But it turns out the good doctor wants us to teach our kids how to handle "stress." What stress? The stress of deciding between a Whopper and a Big Mac? Where's the lesson on having the resiliency to turn in your homework, bring home some A's, and work your way up the corporate ladder to the top, baby, the top? Not in this book.


You Want a What?

I thought The Entitlement-Free Child might discuss the hows of raising kids to work toward their goals rather than expecting handouts of Krispy Kremes. But it is more about teaching parents to grow a pair and say "no" once in a while. Not a bad lesson, but only turns out confident and respectful children, not stand-out winners.

No Help to Be Had

No doubt about it, the American Parenting Industrial Complex is dedicated to keeping our kids french-fry-fed dullards. My advice: stock up on flashcards and rent some Chinese grandparents. And if you can arrange to give birth in January, so much the better.

Print   —   Rate it:  up  down  flag this hub

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Tiff  says:
7 months ago

Love the reviews! I recently found another book called, "Bringing Up Geeks," which is interesting but also falls short of explaining how to raise super SUCCESSFUL geeks (as opposed to just geeks for the sake of geekiness)!

madhousewife  says:
7 months ago

I have often wondered where all these stressed and overscheduled children are hiding themselves.

I also think parents take too much responsibility for how successful their children are. Not that parents shouldn't teach their children to work hard and blah blah, but most successful people are ultimately self-motivated. I wouldn't expect a book to help me out there. Chinese grandparents, however, are a different story.

Eva  says:
7 months ago

Hey, if you want a book about how NOT to let your child turn out lazy, fat, blah blah blah, read Mel Levine's Ready Or Not Here Life Comes. It is a really fantastic book - I need to get another copy b/c I gave mine away - and I plan on rereading it a few times as my children grow up to point them towards self-sufficiency (which, come to think of it, is probably my definitely as successful child-rearing for the most part).

ordinarybutloud  says:
7 months ago

On the one hand, I want my children to be hard-working and successful and educated. On the other hand, I get a little disgusted by the over-competitive, helicopter parenting style I see all around me which is certainly focused on getting the "goods," the right education, the right job and the right house in the right neighborhood, but not really focused on developing any deeper values. In my opinion.

kindersczenen  says:
7 months ago

Heh. A professor lent me Outliers because he thought I'd be interested in it. Since he's a psychiatrist (and my interests lie in that arena), I figured it'd be good. Oddly enough, it was, for the reasons you mentioned, but also for a reason that the sociologist in me noticed. The author had an "in" in the fact that not only was he the product of hard working ancestors, he was also a very, very, very pale black man who lives in a culture where light bright and damn near white still carries quite a few privileges. Not to take away from his work, but come on, most of us have something that works for us--whether it's connections, skin tone, gender, affluence, etc. Gladwell himself mentioned it, so at least he isn't like some folks (Clarence Thomas, anyone?) who gets a leg up due to affirmative action (not like he needed it--he's hardly stupid, but there was no way that he would've gotten where he is without it. There were plenty of blacks and women who benefitted from affirmative action, even though they were often better educated and prepared than "the man.")

As for your search for "guidance" books--I can't help but think about my mother. She thumbed her nose at all those books by the "experts" because they didn't seem to know children very well. Nothing wrong with kids toiling at an algebra problem until 3 in the morning. Nothing wrong with studying for fun during summer vacation. So where in the hell did this crap come from about the "poor poor children" who are (somehow) working too hard? Dammit, I walked uphill to school both ways, didn't have the luxury of air conditioned classrooms, and had homework the first day of school. I (and my fellow school chums) turned out just fine. I don't know why there are so many complaints about too much homework, what in the hell do they think's going to happen once they step onto a college campus?

All right, I've written a small book here, but this is a subject that always raises my dander. I see the results of kids whose parents and teachers thought they shouldn't have too much homework every day--it's all I can do to not laugh in their faces when they come in and complain about their professors being too "difficult."

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

How to Raise an Outlier in the News

  • The best of our Q-n-Aâs: He said, She saidReal Change News17 hours ago

    “Faulkner was asked what a writer needs to create what he had done. He said, “It ain’t talent.” I agree with him. Talent doesn’t hurt, but the main thing, he said, was “curiosity, insight, to wonder, to mull and to muse why it is man does what he does.”

working