Hubpages- Need for more quality hubs in general, and from India in particular
70
Recently there have been 2 discussion theads in the Hubpage forums about the quality of hub contents from Hubbers from India.
Jyothi Kothari, a popular Hubber from India has been actively discussing about identifying quality Hubbers from India; his very genuine concern was to remove a general perception amonst Hubbers that a lot many Indian hubbers are only fit for posting "sexy Bollywood babes", "Hot mallu actresses", "Sexy Indian aunties" picture galleries in their Hubs.
Please see these two discussion board threads on this issue:
Are there any Hubbers from India who don't have 'hot babe' hubs?
It is really a matter of concern to many hubbers that several Hubbers from India are
posting lots of "hot babe" picture galleries. In practical reality, such a stuff cannot be
totally avoided in Internet arena where good, bad and ugly things are
made available free for all. But large number of hub-postings predominantly with semi-clad Indian women pictures, is not going to auger well for any decent website in the long run. I am afraid it is Hubpages' administration
too to blame, in not putting a curtain or atleast some sort of restriction to such hubs.
Why such sleazy contents are not frowned at? The reason is obvious. Sites like Hubpages take pride in the "volume"
of visitors too, because it counts on the popularity of the site.
(Recently Hubpages has entered into top 100 popular websites in USA).
The "hot babes" hubs too contribute immensely to the traffic (though
they may not contribute to to earnings proportionately) and perhaps that's one of the reasons
why sub-standard content is tolerated.
Web content site Helium (where there is no
scope for posting photos) had been accepting content left and right
from anyone above 13 years of age with word limits less than 400 words
too, earlier, during growing stages if the site. Result? Plenty of substandard stuff in the site,
seriously affecting the image and respectability of the site.
Helium web site has woken up to the reality of the need of improving the
quality of contents all around and it is gradually bringing in more and more measures in
that direction.
A huge volume of old and sub-standard articles are getting deleted in the site now.
Helium banning Indian writers now
Unfortunately, the cleansing exercise at Helium resulted in getting several Indian writers too banned and entry of new Indian writers got restricted in the site.One of the reasons suggested by helium was that "Indian English" as written by many new and young entrants to the site was below standard, particularly not suited to the predominantly American readers visiting the site.
Is Indians' writing standard so low?
The question is somewhat difficult to answer. There is no doubt India has a very large pool of English literate, educated people. Owing to British rule in the past, English has become one of the mainstay languages of India and the importance of having English knowledge is deeply drilled into every child by the parents.
But as regards quality of written English, there is a vast difference. Though there is a large pool of English writing talent available in India, perhaps this talent pool is somewhat middle aged, not too familiar and comfortable with computers and Internet.Even if the exposure to Internet is available, this talent pool may not be widely aware of the widespread opportunities available for making some nominal to decent side-Income through serious web-content writing.
At the other end, there are countless computer savvy Indian youngsters with "working knowledge" of English, for whom, casual "e-mail English" and "blogging English" (writing sentences without capitalization, with scant respect for grammar, use of abbreviations like LOL, IMHO, "be4", ASAP, mixing Hindi, Tamil and other local languages freely with English etc) are acceptable English styles for communication.
These youngsters do not mind jumping in to the bandwagon to write too casually in websites to make some quick-bucks for pocket money. Perhaps it is the deluge from such writers that made Helium to ban writers from India. Unfortunately, by this extreme step, Helium has blocked entry of good and talented writers too from India.
Need for quality in websites in the long haul
Just like Helium getting awakened to the reality of the basic need for overall quality, many other websites, which are not too quality conscious so far have got to grow mature and look for quality content and filter out sub-standard stuff sooner or later.
The website Associated Content, has the policy of accepting articles to the site only after evaluating the first 3 submissions of a new writer.
The web-content site Suit101, apart from strict evaluation of a new writer at entry level, is extremely rigid and has military-like systems to editorially evaluate the submissions and to filter quality content. The site has very rigid writing standards, demanding a high degree of SEO disiplines in addition to several formatting and submission guidelines.
Suite101 is least attractive from design and
presentation points of view; it has very limited scope for adding
pictures and no scope for adding videos. It just can't stand beside HubPages
in terms of looks, features and technology. But the site seems to have
a very prestigious position in the Web world and a very high ranking in
Google's search engine.
So, quality pays in the long run. Let us hope Hubpages too will start
taking conscious action to weed out "sexy aunty hubs" and the like and
start encouraging truly quality content.
Good Hub-writers from India have the added responsibility of pumping in quality content in the site in order to project the right image about India to the world.
Knowing about other online writing sites
Here is a comparison of two popular sites where freelance writers can contribute and earn money:
Comparing Helium and Associated Content
Are you from India?
Do you have good writing skill in English?
How about earning a side income by writing articles at Hubpages?
I welcome you to join Hubpages now
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
Hi Hello, hello,
Thanks a lot for visiting all my hubs and offering your encouraging comments.
CVR
Thank you for a very well written hub and I hope your concerns are met with. thank you for sharing. creativeone59
I am glad to see this Hub.
It is a positive and enlightening carry-over from the two forum threads you mention. I hope the issues you illuminate about writers from India are seen by many.
I have been blessed with wonderful writing friends from India who have been generous not only with their support, but also with their sharing of their heritage and experiences. Each of them has as good a command of the English language as I, and often better. I have learned and am continuing to learn a great deal from them.
It concerns me that Helium is banning Indian writers. I don't have any writing experience with Helium, so I can't speak from a direct relationship with them, but if that is so, then this policy of theirs is discriminatory and racist in the worst way.
Thank you for bringing to light the difference in generations. The more mature contingent is eloquent in their speech and writing...maybe there's work to be done by them to bring the younger generation up to the standards we all value.
You raise many important issues here. First, I think quality is always a concern where ever the writers come from. It does distract from the perceived quality of any site if lots of writers are using poor content and don't use proper grammar, etc., just to "make a few pennies" as you say. I just don't read those hubs or topics I'm not interested in. Also, how can that be regulated? On the other hand, hubpages is a great resource for excellent material on a variety of important and interesting topics--I have learned so much reading other people's hubs, and also appreciate the freedom to write about whatever inspires me. In the case of Helium, I don't think the answer is to ban all writers from India - that would be ridiculous! On a personal note, some of my favorite authors and film makers are Indian, and I would love to read more hubs by Indians, like yourself, who will share the history, the culture, the arts, the spirituality, and the traditions of India with the world! Best, Kartika
Thank you Creative, Sally and Kartika.
I agree entirely, though I am not opposed to anyone who is sincerely trying to improve their imperfect English skills. One of the positive things about this site is that they give people a chance to improve.
Serious subjects, well researched or well thought out, are always welcome. So are clever and entertaining ones. High quality hubs reflect well on all of us who participate.
I know it takes a lot of attention from the Hub team to review the huge number of submissions they get. They do a good job of sifting through them, but I already know more about Indian actresses than I really want to.
As Indonesian, I realize that my English is not good enough. But I think Hubpages give a chance for me to learn here. Actually I still learn and learn. This is kind of dilemma in the country where an English is not a major language. I also like receive any critic for my writing. thanks for sharing about this topic
There is no dearth of quality hubbers from India. One can assume that it takes good amount of time to post a quality hub. Time taken in posting a good hub is equal to time taken in posting several picture hubs. There are not many hubbers who are posting picture hubs. I think the same hubber have different identities to ensure if one account is deleted other will do.
Excellent hub, sir...it troubles me that the general perception of Indian English is frowned upon apart from the sleazy content... but in the end, it's a matter of maturity regardless of where you come from. I face the same problem while writing for 'phoren' employers... and it's really annoying. Dan.
I like this. I'm not from India, but I think your point about quality content is important for anyone writing for the web to remember.
Hi CV Rajan,
Thanks for an excellent hub. I am also thankful to you for mentioning my name and link to my profile.
It is really a matter of concern that Helium is banned Indian writers. However, it is their business and we have nothing to do with it.
I believe that they will realize soon that they have done a blonder. Soon, there will be more Indian readers. Number of Indian visitors may exceed that of Americans.
English is not the first language of general Indians. We are proud of our knowledge in English language. Can Americans write good Hindi or Tamil?
There are many American and English hubbers who appreciate Indian hubbers. One of them is in this comment section. They know the reality. They know the value of quality content and knowledge. I am thankful to them and appreciate their efforts.
Regards,
Jyoti Kothari




















Hello, hello, says:
6 weeks ago
A well written hub and I can see you are concerned and care. I agree with banning all these picture hubs of beautiful women. That is not what this is all about. I know that there are very good schools in India, even better than in England. It is a shame not to use the knowledge. Thank you for writing this hub.