create your own

Right or Priviledge? YOU Decide Which is it- Health Care in America

67
rate or flag this page

By RKHenry


Health Care

Is Health Care in America right or privilege?

  • Right
  • Privilege
See results without voting

How about it America??????

Is health care a basic right or is it a privilege? I'd like to hear your points of view.

The side of the health care professional.

  1. The health care industry is a business. The bottom line is profit.
  2. Taking care of people is expensive.
  3. It is not the fault of Doctors, Nurses, Pharmacists, etc., that the cost of health care is rising. It is the insurance companies fault. The way items have to itemized to even collect the going rate from an Insurance company is the cause and effect.

From the side of the Patient.

  1. Please help me my child is dying.
  2. I live in America, what do you mean I'm denied.
  3. I need medicine.

True Story:

A man enters a Walgreen's. He goes to the back of the store to where the Pharmacy counter is located. He informs the Pharmacist that he has cancer and is in terrible pain. When the Pharmacist tried to calmly explain to the man that he was sorry and could do nothing for him, the cancer patient tells the Pharmacist he has a gun. The gun man, told the pharmacist how he recently lost his insurance, since his former employer obligation to continue coverage on him had expired. Already thousands of dollars in debt, he could no longer get his medications. The gun man asked if everyone, except for the pharmacist, to leave the store. He then explained his intentions were not to harm anybody. He just needed something for the pain. When the employees made it out of the store, they swiftly called 911. In the meantime, the man demanded Oxycontin and Lorasapan. [Two common medications used in cancer hospice care. Oxycontin is for pain and Lorasapan is for vomiting after chemotherapy.] The pharmacist supplied the man with his demands and was released by the gun man. After a 15 minute stand off, where the man had his fingers pointed to his head to imply he might kill himself, the police gave him some room. The police watched the man take the necessary amount allowed the man for his condition. Once the man became more subdued and relaxed, the police immediately placed him in the ambulance to be taken to the Hospital. The man ended up in the Intensive Care Unit. Where the news then said he was in critical condition. He's dying from cancer. Apparently, this man's only remaining option, was to become a ward of the county and state as an inmate, to live out the rest of his days without unbearable and horrific pain.  Now,you tell me because I want to know, is health care a right or a privilege in America?  Is this what you would want for a love one of yours or perhaps even you?

I am not sure where I stand on this issue. Maybe I'm not wise enough to contemplate all the outcomes. My heart conflicts with the practical side of my mind. How can anyone let this man suffer? Why should he have to commit a crime to get the painkillers he needed? Is this what its come too? What can be done or should anything be done to fix this system? Many health care officials I meet, think the health care system isn't broken. So why fix it?

In order to fix the system or not fix it, someone needs to decide if health care is a right or a privilege.




(AFP/Getty Images/File/Mario Tama)
(AFP/Getty Images/File/Mario Tama)

A homeless man with no health insurance, who is suffering from an overactive thyroid which causes the muscles behind his eye to swell, collects change on a subway platform in New York City. President Barack Obama will Tuesday give Americans an honest assessment of their grim economic plight but conjure up hopes of a brighter future on the grand stage of his debut address to Congress.

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Teresa McGurk profile image

Teresa McGurk  says:
9 months ago

Feel free to delete this comment, but I couldn't help noticing you've misspelled privilege -- you might want to go back and fix it (and I think there are a -- yes, healthcare is a typo, too). All the best, Teresa.

RKHenry profile image

RKHenry  says:
9 months ago

THANK YOU!!! Always good to see you around!

Teresa McGurk profile image

Teresa McGurk  says:
9 months ago

I'm looking forward to people's responses here, as it's a great question. It's a right to have healthcare!

RKHenry profile image

RKHenry  says:
9 months ago

If you voted in my poll, I'm sorry if I messed it up by editing the hub. I debated adding the information on the Missouri man, but in the end I felt it was a needed addition.

Sounds like to me, that the USA, might be in need of more Teddy Kennedys. This is a very tough situation for America's leaders. But I do think that someone needs to decide either way- whats to done. The sooner the better for the people on the edge. My heart goes out for this guy. Both of them. Thanks Teresa!

Peppermint Thrift profile image

Peppermint Thrift  says:
8 months ago

I most definitely think that healthcare should be a right of every individual. I have gone without insurance for a few years and luckily have not been injured or seriously sick, but it could happen and I would have no idea what to do. I feel that the pharmaceutical companies and insurance bigwigs work together just to make the most money they can, meanwhile, there are sick children, elderly and people who have worked hard their whole lives who are turned away at the door because they do not have any money. It is disgusting. Every person has the right to be treated and helped when they are ill. I think Dante would agree that there is a special layer of hell for anyone involved in the way that our healthcare system is managed. Also, a MUST SEE is Michael Moore's "Sicko." I know he is not everyone's cup of tea, but this movie focuses on people with insuance who have not been adequately cared for and compares other countries' healthcare systems to our own. It is definitely an eye opener. But the question remains, how much longer do we, as citizens, turn a blind eye to this problem and do not demand that it change?

GeneriqueMedia profile image

GeneriqueMedia  says:
8 months ago

RK--

Teresa made the observation first, but you've still not fixed the second mention of "privilege" on the poll. Just so you know. =)

I don't know where I stand, but I do know the government is not a hospital and I don't want to see some sort of national health care system.

I would, however, like to see lots of benefits and good reasons for doctors and insurance companies to provide benefits to people at low costs when they can.

Sincerely,

G|M

livewithrichard profile image

livewithrichard  says:
6 months ago

This is a huge topic RK and I wish more people would take part in this discussion. I am of the opinion that healthcare is a privilege. You pointed out an extreme situation, though probably not that uncommon. However, you fail to mention the enormity of people that abuse the medicaid and medicare systems that we have and how much worse it could become. Right now, if you have a cold or flu, you probably suck it up and get some OTC meds, but if healthcare was paid for by the taxpayer, then what would stop you from running to the ER. I can't locate the stats right now but I seen a report that a handfull of people in LA county accounted for nearly 1/4 of all ER visits.

Yes, it comes down to money. Who and how is it going to be paid for? I know that sounds cold and heartless, but as long as we live in a capitalist society with limited resources and as long as we want to retain what little freedoms we have left, we have to think about the money. IMO

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working