create your own

Is The Great Recession The Same As The Great Depression?

74
rate or flag this page

By Chad Mackey


The Forgotten Man: A New History of the Great Depression The Forgotten Man: A New History of the Great Depression
Price: $8.73
List Price: $15.99
The Great Depression The Great Depression
Price: $6.75
List Price: $12.95
Rethinking the Great Depression (American Ways Series) Rethinking the Great Depression (American Ways Series)
Price: $9.06
List Price: $12.95
The Great Crash 1929 The Great Crash 1929
Price: $8.50
List Price: $14.95

The Great Depression

The Great Depression began in 1929, and did not end until 1941. It was caused by, two key factors. The first being, that European Countries were in debt from World War One. And tariffs were set so high, that Americans could not afford to buy foreign goods. The second being, that America had over produced. By 1930 there were more goods produced, than Americans could buy.

Many consider October 29, 1929 to be the day the Great Depression started. That day is referred to as, Black Tuesday. It is the day the Stock Market crashed. The Great Depression, is still considered to be the greatest economic turn down in U.S. history. It lasted longer than any other economic turn down, to date.

During the Great Depression, the economy was utterly obliterated. The GNP fell from $104 Billion in 1929 to $58 Billion by 1932. Stocks fell from an average $375 per share in 1929 to $75 per share by 1932. Much like today, many Americans bought goods on credit. When they lost their jobs, they defaulted on their loans. In fact, so many defaulted on their loans that banks all over the nation went bankrupt. Many citizens lost their savings due to these bank closures. 25% of all Americans were unemployed. Unemployment had never reached this height, nor has it since.

By 1932 the suicide rate had increased by 3%. Those who lost their jobs fell to despair, as they were unable to find work anywhere. Some cities had to layoff their Fireman, Police and Teachers. Nearly a 1/4% of Americas citizens were homeless. Breadlines and Encampments were popping up all over the country. These were truly desperate times for all Americans.



The Great Recession

In 2008, fifteen Financial Institutions failed. Many more would have, if not for the Government stepping in. On October 11, 2008, the International Monetary Fund warned, that the Global Economy was about to experience an economic meltdown. Dubbed the Crash of 2008, by the London Times, the stock market fell 21% the week of October 6, 2008. Causing most countries to halt trading. By October 24, 2008, most of the worlds markets had experienced the worst drop in stock prices in their history.

United States home foreclosures are on the rise. Some states are reporting that one in every 440 homes are in foreclosure. By the end of March, many experts agree that home foreclosures will increase by 30% over last year's numbers. Over 200,000 residents received foreclosure notices in February of 2009, alone. Despite the fact that President Obama announced a $275 Billion Housing Stimulus Plan, those in the housing market are weary, due to falling home prices and the dismal employment conditions.

The number of unemployed Americans, grew by 851,000 bringing the total number of unemployed in the United States to a grand total of 12.5 million by the end of February, 2009. The current unemployment rate in the United States is 8.1%. Manufacturing remains the hardest hit industry.

The United States current GDP is $14,218 Billion. As of March 13, 2009 the GDP was down 6.40%.

According to an article by, http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu, the collapse of the United States economy is very different than the rest of the world, mainly due to the fact that it began with the Financial Institutions, and then spread out to the rest of the economy. Many experts agree, that the forecast for 2009 will continue to be negative, as many companies struggle to find signs of recovery. Most believe that unemployment will continue to rise, and the economy will remain weak. This trend will likely continue, until Americans stop fearing the loss of their jobs and homes.


Are They The Same?

According to much of my research, the Great Depression and the Great Recession have many similarities. Admittedly, I am no expert on financial matters. However, as I see it, it is way to early, to answer whether or not they are the same. My thoughts are, that while we may experience some of the same ailments as our Great Grandparents, we will not experience the same out come.

Many hard lessons came out of the Great Depression. In the end as a society, I believe that generation came out for the better. Many economic changes were made after the Great Depression. However, I do not believe that today's society will come out smelling like a rose. Our Recession has not come upon us because of Financial Ignorance. It has been because of the constant greed of corporate hogs and politicians, that we are in this situation. Our world is far more complicated financially than that of the 1930's. We are all inter-connected Globally now, and we face an abundance of perils our Grandparents never even dreamed of.

The economy is only one of the many difficulties this world faces. When you combine the Recession with the threat of Terrorism, The Oil Crisis and Global Warming, things seem far worse for us than it did for those who lived through the Great Depression. Today we seem to be literally falling apart on a Global Level never seen before. We have depleted the World's resources so much that many of us do not know whether there will be anything left for our Grandchildren.

While things are bleak, I try to remember that it is always darkest before the dawn. Throughout the history of mankind, somehow, someway we have always come through in the end. I would like to think that there is a Rainbow on the horizon. But there may not be this time.

Please Participate

Are They The Same?

  • Yes
  • No
See results without voting

Print   —   Rate it:  up  down  flag this hub

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

SirDent profile image

SirDent  says:
9 months ago

Thanks for answering my request. I would like to point out that things seem much worse for us today because we have everything so easy. Lots of luxury times that we use today that no one had beck in the 20's and 30's.

Things certainly are different now than they were back then.

Reg  says:
2 months ago

Know one really knows what will happen but a wise person

will revert to survival mode, that is: be prepared and be

able to grow food, get a little gold and silver coins, have

on hand a years supply of food, know how to do more than

one thing, be a jack of all trades. and above all else get

out of debt. Always show compassion and kindness to others.

Brianbwb  says:
3 weeks ago

Just as there are many ways for a human to die, there are also many ways for an economy to collapse.

What happened in 1939 has more than a few similarities to what is happening now, currency manipulation, speculation, and simple greed created a vicious cycle that caused massive unemployment, and the reduced spending power of the reduced working class caused further contraction.

Government inability to take the measures necessary to put money into the hands that would drive the economy, is prolonging the recession.

Also WW2 played a role in the recovery, almost eliminating unemployment, as the manufacturing sector exploded into a frenzy of building war machines.

It won't happen this time, America does not manufacture the war machines for the current two conflicts, and the large number of enlisted for WW2 is not matched for today's two wars.

The tactic of "bailing out" corporations and banks causes money to be printed, but it does not go into public circulation, instead the banks speculate on the international exchanges, or use it to pay up on lost bets in the derivatives market. Much of it goes to upper management "bonuses" and gets locked away in overseas banks.

Comparing now to 1939 is like comparing swine flu to pneumonia, the end result is that the subject is very sick, lungs filled with liquid, and very well could die, but how it got there, while bearing more than a few passing resemblances, is still not exactly the same.

The more important consideration is modern day's America's tendency to be more readily excited to acts of anarchy because of the existence of an instant mass media, where demagogues can spew hate, and advocate violence and other forms of inhumanity. It is destined to be a factor in the total collapse of American society.

Once it is "in the streets", there will be no return.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working