create your own

Kelly Clarkson VS. Leona Lewis

68
rate or flag this page

By Tater2tot


Kelly Clarkson VS. Leona Lewis

Kelly Clarkson, the original American Idol winner, as her final song on American Idol finally. she sang the song "A Moment Like This". Then it later came out as her first single then eventually on her debut album called "Thankful". Which sold over two million copies. In 2006, Leona Lewis won The X Factor UK (which is similar to American Idol, another show searching for telent). As her winning song she sang "A Moment Like This" and it became her first single. It was downloaded over 50,000 times in 30 minutes. Breaking the world record.

Leona Lewis has a unique, yet amazing voice. In "A Moment Like This" she does incredible! Although, I think she doesn't hit every note quite right, I enjoyed listening to it. I didn't like the official music video of this song, she didn't sound that great. But when I watched the live version of Leona on The X Factor UK, she gave me chills. Her voice sent chills up my back and onto my neck. Which (incase you are confused) is a good thing. I was stunned because after hearing her on the music video, I thought it wasn't going to be good. I think that most artists sing worse when they have to sing live. But not Leona! Well not in this case, she sang better live.

Kelly Clarkson has a beautiful voice. She surprised me during the first American Idol competition, she truly has powerful vocals. In my opinion, she nailed this song! It was right up her alley, and she did it almost perfect. I liked the official music video for this song better than Leona's. I mean they are the exact same video, (except different people) but Kelly Clarkson sounds better in hers. She also gave me chills, when I heard this song. But she gave them to me many times in the song and Leona only sent chills a couple of times.

As for who did it better, Kelly Clarkson. Maybe I am biased because she did it first. But from what I hear, she did it a lot better. Besides the lyrics, they seem like completely different songs, because they are different artist. I'm not saying Kelly is the better artist. I think I would pick Leona Lewis as the better artist because she has such a unique voice and it is new. Kelly Clarkson has been around longer, so you can grow tired of hearing her. I am very fond of both. Both are amazing but this specific song was perfect for Kelly!

Kelly Clarkson - A Moment Like This


Leona Lewis - A Moment Like This Live

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Hoodala profile image

Hoodala  says:
2 years ago

Well i like Leona a lot better but you are right. After listening to both versions this song was perfect for Kelly and she also gave me chills.

Tater2tot profile image

Tater2tot  says:
2 years ago

Thanks, I am glad you agree with me.

compu-smart profile image

compu-smart  says:
2 years ago

I still think Leona Lewis can sing much much better than Kelly who herself is a beautiful singer too.....

If you like Leona, heres more;)

http://hubpages.com/_www/hub/Leona-Lewis--first-Br

In The Doghouse profile image

In The Doghouse  says:
2 years ago

I think Kelly Clarkson has an amazing voice! I am not familiar with Leona Lewis, except the Footprints in the Sand video you posted on your other Hub, but unfortunately this video of Leona is not working either. Sorry to tell you the bad news...

Tater2tot profile image

Tater2tot  says:
2 years ago

I am fed up with videos on hubpages. They all work for me but not for anybody else. Thank you for telling me.

I agree with you, Kelly Clarkson has an amazing voice, I am not familiar with Leona, I just know a couple of songs, like Footprints in the sand, Bleeding Love, and A Moment Like This.

Thank you for your comments.

Tayler!

Eunice Apia profile image

Eunice Apia  says:
2 years ago

I personally am a fan of both. Kelly does sing the song better and Leona is still new but I love her voice. All of Kelly's songs are commercial making it more enjoyable. Leona, you can pick and choose.

Tater2tot profile image

Tater2tot  says:
2 years ago

True True. I am a fan of both as well. They are both amazing. Leona does have the better voice but your right about Kelly's songs.

Tayler!

ddd  says:
9 months ago

Kelly's voice is much better. Leona frequently can't sustain vibrato and her much weaker voice breaks down. Her voice is a whisper but Kelly's is powerful.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working