Killer Sudoku. No Paper no Board No Maths

77
rate or flag this page

By MrMarmalade


Killer Sudoku

Sudoku – The new Brain Bending Additive

Puzzle Game taking the world by storm!

Are you ready to become a Sudoku Master?

An Interesting Number Game, You certainly do not have to be good at mathematics, not even passable. this is a game of logic, that even children will be able to play.

This is a a game of logic and Val has informed me for the last 50 years that she is more logical than me. I have never had the courage to dispute this fact.

If this is true! All ladies, will ourshine partners, spouses even their children. I can not enter that discussion, of who is the most logical of us people. There is some talk that Chimpanzee are more logical and intelligent than human beings. That not could possibly be true.

Should that horror of the inability be creeping up on you, there is some considered belief 'that the constant and methodical use of the brain cells could stem the tide here. This is the subject of Alzheimer's disease.

A game for all ages and no luck or knowledge of mathematics, to enable you to win.

Killer Sudoku is a game of logic played with the use of the CD Rom or on a magnetic board with numbers in two colours, Red and green, ranging from one to nine.

CD ROM Features: Unlimited puzzle variation

Play as often as you like!

Play on Screen or board. Five levels of difficulty, easy, harder, difficult, diabolical and Killer Sudoku

Multi-level ‘undo feature

Beat the clock and record fastest time.

Save or print unfinished games- solve at your leisure, solutions may be printed

Handy hint feature (just in case)

Easy to Play.

No messy rubbing out if a mistake is made.

Book features1, 000 Sudoku puzzles with Solutions and rules

Remember there is only one unique solution for each puzzle.

killer sudoku

Killer sudoku (also killer su doku, sumdoku, sum doku, addoku, or samunamupure) is a puzzle that combines elements of sudoku and kakuro. Despite the name, the simpler killer sudokus can be easier to solve than regular sudokus, depending on the solver's skill at mental arithmetic; the hardest ones, however, can take hours to crack.

A typical problem is shown on the right, using colors to define the groups of cells. More usually, puzzles are printed in black and white, with thin dotted lines used to outline the "cages" (see below for terminology).

History

Killer sudokus were already an established variant of sudoku in Japan by the mid 1990s, where they were known as "samunamupure." The name stemmed from a Japanized form of the English words "sum number place." Killer sudokus were introduced to most of the English-speaking world by The Times in 2005.

Traditionally, as with regular sudoku puzzles, the grid layout is symmetrical around a diagonal, horizontal or vertical axis. This is a matter of aesthetics, though, rather than obligatory: many Japanese puzzle-makers will make small deviations from perfect symmetry for the sake of improving the puzzle. Other puzzle-makers may produce entirely assymmetrical puzzles.

Terminology

  • cell — a single square that contains one number in the grid
  • row — a horizontal line of 9 cells
  • column — a vertical line of 9 cells
  • nonet — a 3x3 grid of cells, as outlined by the bolder lines in the diagram above
  • cage — the grouping of cells denoted by a dotted line or by individual colours. It is a convention of killer sudokus that there are no duplicate numbers within a cage, with the implication that no cage can include more than 9 cells.

Rules

The objective is to fill the grid with numbers from 1 to 9 in a way that the following conditions are met:

  • Each row, column, and nonet contains each number exactly once.
  • The sum of all numbers in a cage must match the small number printed into it.
  • No number can appear more than once in a cage.

In 'Killer X', an additional rule is that each of the long diagonals contains each number once.

Solving strategies

Fewest possible combinations

Generally the problem is best tackled starting from the extreme sums — cages with the largest or the smallest sums. This is because these have the fewest possible combinations. For example, 3 cells totalling 23 can only be 6, 8 and 9.

In the early stages of the game, the most common way to begin filling in numbers is to look at such low-sum or high-sum cages that form a 'straight line'. As the solver can infer from these that certain numbers are in a certain row or column, he can begin 'cross-hatching' across from them.

The 45 rule

A further technique can be derived from the knowledge that the numbers in all rows, all columns and all nonets add up to 45. By adding up the cages and single numbers in a particular row, column or nonet, the user can deduce the result of a single cell. If the cell calculated is within the nonet itself it is referred to as an 'innie'; conversely if the cell is outside the nonet it is called an 'outie'. Even if this is not possible, advanced players may find it useful to derive the sum of two or three cells, then use other elimination techniques (see below for an example of this). The '45' technique can also be extended to calculate cells from two or more connected rows, columns or (most commonly) nonets, in which case the solver has to refer to the multiples of 45 accordingly.

Initial analysis of the sample problem

Fewest possible combinations

The two cells in the top left must be 1+2. The 3 cells to the right totaling 15 cannot therefore have either a 1 or a 2, so they must be either 3+4+8, 3+5+7 or 4+5+6.

The two vertical cells in the top left of the top right nonet cannot be 2+2 as that would mean duplicates, so they must be 1+3. The 1 cannot be in the top line as that conflicts with our first 2 cells therefore the top cell of this pair is 3 and the lower cell 1. This also means the 3 cell cage 15 to the left cannot contain a 3 and so is 4+5+6.

Similarly the neighbouring 16 must be 9+7.

The four cells in the top right cannot include both 1 & 3, nor both of 9 & 7; If any of 1, 3, 7 or 9 are present then they must be the lone square in the nonet below. Therefore these 4 cells are one of 1+2+4+8, 1+2+5+7 or 2+3+4+6.

The 2 cells in the middle of the left edge must be either 1+5 or 2+4. And so on.

45

Looking at the nonet on the left hand side in the middle, we can see that there are three cages which do not cross over into another nonet; these add up to 33, meaning that the sum of the remaining two cells must be 12. This does not seem particularly useful, but consider that the cell in the bottom right of the nonet is part of a 3-cage of 6; it can therefore only contain 1, 2 or 3. If it contained 1 or 2, the other cell would have to contain 11 or 10 respectively; this is impossible. It must, therefore, contain 3, and the other cell 9.

Duplicate cell ambiguity

By convention in Japan, killer sudoku cages do not include duplicate numbers, even if they crossed nonets. When The Times first introduced the killer sudoku in 2005, however, the newspaper did not make this rule explicit. Even though the vast majority of sudoku puzzles followed the rule anyway, English-speaking solvers scratched their heads over appropriate solving strategies given the ambiguity. Within a month, though, the Times clarified the rule, and now the world standard is no duplicates within cages.

Solution to sample problem

Cage total tables

The following tables list the possible combinations for various sums.

2 cell

03: 12

04: 13

05: 14 23

06: 15 24

07: 16 25 34

08: 17 26 35

09: 18 27 36 45

10: 19 28 37 46

11: 29 38 47 56

12: 39 48 57

13: 49 58 67

14: 59 68

15: 69 78

16: 79

17: 89

3 cell

06: 123

07: 124

08: 125 134

09: 126 135 234

10: 127 136 145 235

11: 128 137 146 236 245

12: 129 138 147 156 237 246 345

13: 139 148 157 238 247 256 346

14: 149 158 167 239 248 257 347 356

15: 159 168 249 258 267 348 357 456

16: 169 178 259 268 349 358 367 457

17: 179 269 278 359 368 458 467

18: 189 279 369 378 459 468 567

19: 289 379 469 478 568

20: 389 479 569 578

21: 489 579 678

22: 589 679

23: 689

24: 789

4 cell

10: 1234

11: 1235

12: 1236 1245

13: 1237 1246 1345

14: 1238 1247 1256 1346 2345

15: 1239 1248 1257 1347 1356 2346

16: 1249 1258 1267 1348 1357 1456 2347 2356

17: 1259 1268 1349 1358 1367 1457 2348 2357 2456

18: 1269 1278 1359 1368 1458 1467 2349 2358 2367 2457 3456

19: 1279 1369 1378 1459 1468 1567 2359 2368 2458 2467 3457

20: 1289 1379 1469 1478 1568 2369 2378 2459 2468 2567 3458 3467

21: 1389 1479 1569 1578 2379 2469 2478 2568 3459 3468 3567

22: 1489 1579 1678 2389 2479 2569 2578 3469 3478 3568 4567

23: 1589 1679 2489 2579 2678 3479 3569 3578 4568

24: 1689 2589 2679 3489 3579 3678 4569 4578

25: 1789 2689 3589 3679 4579 4678

26: 2789 3689 4589 4679 5678

27: 3789 4689 5679

28: 4789 5689

29: 5789

30: 6789

5 cell

15: 12345

16: 12346

17: 12347 12356

18: 12348 12357 12456

19: 12349 12358 12367 12457 13456

20: 12359 12368 12458 12467 13457 23456

21: 12369 12378 12459 12468 12567 13458 13467 23457

22: 12379 12469 12478 12568 13459 13468 13567 23458 23467

23: 12389 12479 12569 12578 13469 13478 13568 14567 23459 23468 23567

24: 12489 12579 12678 13479 13569 13578 14568 23469 23478 23568 24567

25: 12589 12679 13489 13579 13678 14569 14578 23479 23569 23578 24568 34567

26: 12689 13589 13679 14579 14678 23489 23579 23678 24569 24578 34568

27: 12789 13689 14589 14679 15678 23589 23679 24579 24678 34569 34578

28: 13789 14689 15679 23689 24589 24679 25678 34579 34678

29: 14789 15689 23789 24689 25679 34589 34679 35678

30: 15789 24789 25689 34689 35679 45678

31: 16789 25789 34789 35689 45679

32: 26789 35789 45689

33: 36789 45789

34: 46789

35: 56789

6, 7 and 8 cells

It is easiest to determine the combinations within large cages by means of complements. The table for 6 cell cages is the complement of the 3 cell table adding up to "45 - listed value"; similarly the 7 cell table complements the 2 cell table. An 8-cell cage is of course missing only one digit (45 - the sum of the cage).

See also

  • Cross Sums, or Kakuro, is a set of puzzles solved using similar techniques.

External links

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

aman  says:
2 years ago

Thanks a lot for sharing your information.I am a true fan of this game.I like it very much.

www.dentisthere.blogspot.com

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade  says:
2 years ago

That is great news

I trust you will prove your good at logic

Paraglider profile image

Paraglider  says:
2 years ago

And you said my Black Holes game looked difficult ??

I'm not a great Sudoku fan, but indulge occasionally (if there's nobody toplay chess with!)

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade  says:
2 years ago

I was only kidding, I do play chess, I inclined to think I should not offer to play with you, I think too slowly these days.

Thank you for the compliment

Kat07 profile image

Kat07  says:
2 years ago

GREAT post - it is a wonderful game, wonderful brain exercise - I wish more people would catch on to it.

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade  says:
2 years ago

Well some one did say Rome was not buit in one day

gabriella05 profile image

gabriella05  says:
2 years ago

I will definitely try it sounds interesting

Thank you for sharing

cgull8m profile image

cgull8m  says:
2 years ago

I love this game, I am slowly mastering it all the various combinations. Here are some free Sudoku games online you can play.http://www.menneske.no/sudoku/eng/

Cheers.

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade  says:
2 years ago

That is what really counts.

Commitment

thecounterpunch profile image

thecounterpunch  says:
2 years ago

Great article though Sudoku is not for me It gives me headache :)

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade  says:
2 years ago

I guess those people who produce these puzzles will make some non headache one's up when the need is there

Thank you

compu-smart profile image

compu-smart  says:
2 years ago

I love mind games just as much as physical.

..I have yet to play but it sure looks tempting!

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade  says:
2 years ago

You can probably buy a list of high quality games at low premium prices. Most of these are eay games and take vey little mimmagination.

Treat the exercise like feeding a new baby. Feed the baby mush until its time to feed the oats

Hope you participate

Kenny Wordsmith profile image

Kenny Wordsmith  says:
2 years ago

The figures boggle my mind, Frank. But since you so nicely asked us, I'll try it.

sandipan profile image

sandipan  says:
2 years ago

Nice information. Thanx for sharimg. Seems you are a master of this game.

If you have liked my post on Indian film actress, then you must visit the following link as well:

http://sandipan-adhikary.blogspot.com/

caspar profile image

caspar  says:
2 years ago

Thanks for the tips - I love Killer Su Doku. In the Times, they start off with an easy one every Monday, then they get harder each day until Saturday's which is impossible (for me anyway). I think I'm doing well if I complete a Wednesday, but last week I did the Thursday one!

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade  says:
2 years ago

I am certainly not a master, I like it, and am not into Killer Sudoku class where I can navigate my way through. I am impressed that you can do Thursday's one.

As usual time is the worse enemy I have, lots of minor irritations. At the end of the day I seem to have more to do than I have achieved. I have even cut down on my one hour of book reading when I go to bed. I find I must have fours of sleep per night.

Congratulations to caspar and sandipan

WordPlay profile image

WordPlay  says:
2 years ago

Wow. I can't imagine having what it takes to master this game -- or even write about it! Great hub. :-)

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade  says:
2 years ago

I suggest you look for Carol Vordeman's s Book on How to do Sudoku.

She was the one that gave me some clues and I did benefit from them. Easy to read and if your desire is to move the brain and leave the TV, this is the way to go.

Thank you for your kind words.

Rudra profile image

Rudra  says:
2 years ago

this game sounds interesting although havent tried it. must give it a shot.

omdelhi profile image

omdelhi  says:
2 years ago

Its looking interesting. I'll try it.

thumbs up.

OPSINGH

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade  says:
2 years ago

thank you for all the kind observations

NOW for a huge surprise

Please look forward to KAKURO, Hot on the heels of Sudoku comes kAKURO. a Fiendish and Highly Additive new Puzzle game from Japan.

Beware it's coming.

Zsuzsy Bee profile image

Zsuzsy Bee  says:
2 years ago

MrM! Good article. I just love Sudoku. My daughter just gave me a book for my birthday, a collection of sudoku. It has 4 puzzles for each day of the year, an easy, medium, hard and a challenging one. I just worked my way up to hard (most of the time) but the challengers are still beyond me...

Great HUB

regards Zsuzsy

Abhinaya  says:
2 years ago

Our whole family is involved in sudoku solving in the national daily.We have it every day and there is a fight for who is going to solve it.But killer sodoku?Never tried it.Great information!And looking forward to KAKURO.Don't forget to publish it here.Thumbs up!

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade  says:
2 years ago

I have not forgotten

Would have posted the hub last night. Computer down switched onto errorsmart. Started at 5.00 Am this morning and 2.45 mins still not fixed. I have rebooted four times and they want to think.

Anyway less of my issues and thanks for you comments to Abinaya andZsuszy

I will feed more and more

libra profile image

libra  says:
2 years ago

I got somewhat addicted to sudoku (the basic version) a little while back, and drove myself and my wife mad! My brain just couldn't get around all those numbers - but sometime perseverance paid off. I am not sure I am ready for your Killer Sudoku any time soon.

Great post - now I need to take a rest for my head to clear.

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade  says:
2 years ago

I understand you. Please give yourself a little more time. You may find one day in the long distance future, you were pleased that you put so much effort into it.

If you reach 110 and have not suffered from Alzheimer's, you will be pleased.

Thank you

AuraGem profile image

AuraGem  says:
2 years ago

I have laughed my way through article + comments! Lovely dry wit Mr Marmalade!

And yes! I am a great Sodoku fan! At first I had a mind block because Maths just could not come up to par with English! Then I had a rude shock! At Uni when I chose Geography, waiting with evil grin was a compulsory Maths component - Statistics!

Since those ignorant days, I have cultivated a healthy respect for Maths, and paid my back debts by playing Sodoku! Now please don't tell me it's not really Maths! LOL!

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade  says:
2 years ago

My son was around for Christmas Dinner last night. He sat down and did an easy one in 7 minutes.

He then asked for a harder one. val cuts them out of the paper everyday.

gave him a hard one and his 10 year old daughter took an easy one she took about 20 mins. She is no good at maths. Whilst her father is not bad.

My shock was when I found out he did Sudoku.

You certainly do not need an ability in maths. Pays to be logical

Thanks for you comment.

When will I learn.

SuDoKu Puzzle Fan  says:
7 months ago

Thanks for this excellent article!

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade  says:
6 months ago

You may know more of this than I do, thank you anyway

Ron  says:
4 months ago

On the topic of Sudoku, check out http://www.Sudoku-Puzzles-Online.com - there are 10 new Sudoku puzzles every day.

You can play online, or print them out and solve them later.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working