Leaving Constructive Comments on Hubs.
62Comments can make or break any day for a serious writer depending on their tone and diction. Everyone has varying opinions and it's important the your opinion comes across as constructive rather than a blatant criticism. By following the below advice you will find your comments well received. A heated debate can be great, but if it turns into mindless name calling it becomes a waste of everyone's time.
Don't point out problems unless you have an alternative solution.
It's easy to say someone else is wrong simply because they don't agree with your point of view. When explaining your theory/belief be sure to elaborate on why you feel the way that you do. Just like you may find in your career, don't being a problem to the table unless you are ready to present a viable solution.
Remember that the article was not written by a machine, the person who wrote it has feelings too.
It is easy to attack someone verbally when you do not see the face to face, the internet has a way of disconnecting you personally from another party, but keep in mind there is a real person on the other end just like you. Try to imagine yourself in a situation where you put forth effort to write a article and were proud of it. Then you get ripped apart by another's words. Keep in mind that the author of that particular article may feel very strongly about their topic, therefore, make sure your comments are respectful.
Use specific examples.
Rather than blatantly commenting on an author's grammar, diction or spelling give advice on improvements. Here is an example of a specific example. "There is grammar mistake in your third paragraph at such and such a word. That is why I had a hard time following your point. I would recommend using this instead of that." Of course you will want to insert the specific words or sentences, but I think you get the idea. Also, be sure you are correct when you do criticize someone's grammar. I have observed instances where the grammar was indeed correct, but the critic was misinformed. You certainly don't want to put yourself in that embarrassing situation. You will instantly lose credit with your fellow writers and commenters.
Start with a positive.
If an article affected you enough that you felt the need to comment be sure to start off on a positive note so it does not seem like you are just "bashing" the article. Keep in mind the positive aspects of the writer's viewpoint, express your view in a courteous manner, and then try to end on a positive note. That way your view is well received and more likely to be taken constructively.
Only say something that you would want said to you.
The golden rule of life also applies on the internet, although it is often overlooked. Leaving a comment can have an effect just as powerful as a conversation. Before posted a comment read it out loud to yourself and ask, "Would I be offended if someone had said this to me?" If you found it spiteful or offensive, you should probably rethink your comment.
This advice is not meant to discourage anyone from leaving constructive criticism as comments, as that is what makes the world so interesting. We all have different background, views and opinions. If everyone thought the same way then wouldn't the world be a boring place? Express yourself freely, but do it in a way that is courteous, intelligent, and cordial. You will find that your views will be received much more positively then than if you were to write a critical comment.
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub








