Man confesses fake Sins to 24 Italian Priests to see if they agree

56
rate this page

By cgull8m


The Vatican newspaper denounced an Italian journalist who posed as a penitent and confessed fake sins in order to write an expose on the sacrament of reconciliation.

"Fake confessions in search of a shameful scoop," the newspaper, L'Osservatore Romano, headlined a commentary condemning the cover story of L'Espresso magazine, one of the country's leading weeklies.

"Shame! There is no other word to express our distress toward an operation that was disgusting, worthless, disrespectful and particularly offensive," the newspaper said.

The Journalist of L'Espresso magazine wanted to see, how differently priests respond, to the same questions posed by a Confessor. He acted as a sinner and posed the following question, that he was an HIV Patient and whether he should use a condom to have sex with his girlfriend. One priest said no to this question, the other said just to follow his conscience. Similarly he posed questions to 24 Priests in 5 Italian cities and asked them questions regarding homosexuality, divorce, euthanasia and prostitution etc., He wrote an article discussing the various and different answers in L'Espresso magazine. When the Vatican found about this information being revealed they were outraged and condemned this journalist and said that exploited the good faith of confession and offended the religious sentiment of the people. They said:

"It was a sacrilege, because it violated the sacred space in which a self-recognized sinner asks intimately to receive God's merciful love"

I agree with the Vatican, whatever is revealed in confidentiality should be preserved. What happens if the Priests go ahead and publish the confessions in the magazine it will be an outrage. What is your views on this? Do you think this journalist went too far or he was just doing his job?

  —   Rate it:  up  down  [flag this hub]

RSS for comments on this Hub Small RSS Icon

Iðunn profile image

Iðunn  says:
2 years ago

in agreement with the vatican

cgull8m profile image

cgull8m  says:
2 years ago

Yes, I think the magazine ran out of articles, maybe they should blogs like Hubpages to get more news.

Ralph Deeds profile image

Ralph Deeds  says:
2 years ago

I think the stroy was a legitimate expose.  Although I agree that confessions should remain secret, I don't see why secrecy should be extended to the judgments rendered by priests. Religions, like other social institutions are not off limits to examination and criticism. Intelligence and law enforcement agencies are inflitrating Mosques all over the world, and there is no shortage of criticism of them in the press.

cgull8m profile image

cgull8m  says:
2 years ago

I agree with your Ralph, there is secrecy breach everywhere, we can say ok to this but not ok for others. This expose wasn't bad didn't go too much into their private lives, it is a prank it hurt them I think. The guy could have done differently asked them directly what their views were.

Ralph Deeds profile image

Ralph Deeds  says:
2 years ago

It could be looked at as a kind of quality control for the judgments issued by priests in confessionals. If they are passing out nutty advice to penitents I don't see why they should be shielded from exposure. I'm not Catholic, but my understanding that the purpose of the sanctity of the confessional is to protect the person making his or her confession, not for the protection of the priest. I believe the law affords similar protection of communications from clients to lawyers and patients to their psychiatrists.

jenna  says:
2 months ago

I think that secrecy breeds dysfunction.

cgull8m profile image

cgull8m  says:
2 months ago

Thanks Jenna, it is better to be truthful, then they shouldn't have any worries about the consequences, only falsehood needs to worry.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working