Maruti Swift versus Hyundai I-20 –5 lacks segment cars
89Maruti Swift ROCKS
Hi friends,
You people might have heard a lot of hoo-haa going on in the motoring press about Hyundai I‑20 these days.
Recently, I had the opportunity to drive one for an extended session.
LOOKS (EXTERIOR): I 20 has good paint work. "I have tried too hard to copy Peugeot 307" headlights, the belt line is nice, side profile, especially rear window reverse angle C - pillar harks back to Swift, wraparound tai lights - again very Swiftish touch.
INTERIORS: Good. Plastic quality pretty good, some bits shiny, huge glove box.
SPACE: Found the seats to be a bit on the flat side. Rear under thigh support could be better.
PERFORMANCE: Weird. Hyundai claims 80 odd bhp. Car I drove was new but even allowing for the new ones of the engine, the engine's reluctance to freely rev beyond 4500 rpm was disappointing. Until 3500 rpm, I 20 pulls decently, but beyond that you can sense a strain on the power plant. It is not that I-20 does not want to rev, but that it os better that you do not. Compare that to the Swift's turbine smooth "revvability" till the 6600 rpm limiter and you'll understand what I mean.
HANDLING: Lousy. Simply lousy. I 20 rolls and wallows in a corner. There is way to much understeer so much so that at modest speeds, say as low as 60 kph in a tightening bend. The nose starts washing out. Compare this to the Swift's razor sharp turn in, flat cornering, resistance to understeer and "throttle adjustability" the swift simply pummels the Hyundai into submission.
FUEL EFFICIENCY: I 20 : 9.8 hard driving, tankful to tankful in Delhi traffic Swift VXI with 185/70 - R14's: 11.82 same route, tankful to tankful, same traffic conditions.
SUMMARY: I 20: spacious hatch if you want to pootle around town.
SWIFT: The vehicle to own if you love driving, love cars and want to put a smile on your face when you are driving down that long and winding road, where ever it is.
It is good despite after three years of launch, Swift still rules and Hyundai despite doing a calculated effort not even coming closer to the performance of Swift.
Truly Swift is a revolution.
The funny thing is that if you drive the I 20 - drive it for an extended session, if possible, and you will also feel it - the engine does not behave as if it has got 80 odd bhp on tap - as claimed by Hyundai.
Initially it feels peppy, but when you extend it over the rev range, then the limitations come up.
If f you guys have driven the old Hyundai Accent and remember how the engine used to run into an "imaginary wall" after 4500 rpm versus the then free revving Esteem engine, you will have a very good comparison.
In terms of safety stakes, I-20 has the Swift licked what with 6 airbags, etc, but then again the price is also whopping enough.
Moot point is: FRILLS and niceties go for the Hyundai
For driving pleasure and depth of engineering, I would recommend MARUTI SWIFT.
So What do you say? Maruti Swift or Hyundai I-20
See results without votingHyundai products on sale
|
Scosche HY1618B 2000 -Up Hyundai Double DIN Kit
Price: $15.98
List Price: $19.95 |
|
Scosche HY1612B 2007 Hyundai Santa Fe DIN/ISO and Double DIN Kit
Price: $20.00
List Price: $29.95 |
|
Made in Korea: Chung Ju Yung and the Rise of Hyundai
Price: $61.10
List Price: $130.00 |
|
Sunshade for Hyundai Sonata 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 HEATSHIELD Windshield Custom-fit Sunshade
Price: $33.95
List Price: $39.95 |
|
Metra 70-7301 Radio Wiring Harness for Hyundai/Kia 99-Up
Price: $5.75
List Price: $0.00 |
|
Hyundai Elantra 1996 thru 2006 (Haynes Repair Manual)
Price: $15.80
List Price: $24.95 |
|
Scosche HY03B Speaker Connector for 2000-Up Hyundai Sonata/Accent
Price: Too low to display
List Price: $12.95 |
|
K Source 65520Y OE Replacement Mirror 06-07 HYUNDAI Sonata 2.4L/ 3.3L Engine, black, Driver, Side, Power
Price: $65.99
|
|
Metra 99-7315 Hyundai Tucson 2005-UP Dash Kit
Price: $11.49
List Price: $29.99 |
|
Hyundai Santa Fe 2001-2006 (Haynes Repair Manual)
Price: $15.88
List Price: $24.95 |
Some more hubs written by me on Indian cars
- Is Maruti Ritz a serious blow to Hyundai i10?
I test drive Maruti Ritz in a Maruti showroom in Delhi yesterday and here is my review on that. Ritz versus i10 Maruti Ritz is a very cool and nice car but, I do not feel that Maruti Ritz has given a... - New Maruti Alto vs Chevrolet Spark - Below 4 lakhs INR Cars
Ownership I own a November 2003 model Maruti Alto and my cousin brother has a Chevrolet Spark. Alto's advantage is fuel economy and ownership experience. As I am an Alto owner, please do not think that I... - A nice Fiat Linea with smooth engine in 7 lakhs INR
Hey friend. I am also looking to buy a new car in the same budget and I had some questions a few days back about some different types of car models and makes. So I visited the showrooms of Hyundai, Ford, and... - Car Cleaning Tips - How to clean your car and save money?
Hi car lovers, I drive my car 80 to 90 kilometers per day and clean it daily with a feather stick daily and with shampoo and wax polish on a twice-weekly basis. Here are some tips on how to clean your... - How to get a dent repaired on my new car in Delhi?
Original hub request: How to repair a dent just above the wheel on my Maruti Swift car? How I can talk to my car insurance company so that they replace it? The Maruti Service Center in Delhi did a good job... - Is it time to say good bye to Maruti 800 after Nanos launch?
Maruti Suzuki says goodbye to Maruti 800 after Nano's launch. What would be the possible reasons for that and what do you think will be the effect of that? Do you agree that it is production life cycle and... - How to check and increase mileage of your car?
As you know, mileage is a prominent aspect when using any automobile, so you must know how to check your car for mileage and how to increase it, as increasing the mileage will save you money. 1. Get a full...
Indian Car Maruti Swift
Read and join more discussion on car forums here
- Maruti Suzuki Swift vs Hyundai i20 and image gallery - All World Automotive - Zimbio
Hyundai has released i20 this year to shakeup the market and bring some sleepless night for Maruti Suzuki Swift sales team. Lets look how these two compare. When it comes to looks Hyundai 120 is... - http://www.autocarindia.com/new/autocar_forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=3237&PN=11
- i20 Magna vs Swift Vxi 2009 Model | Buying a Car | Car Forums - CarWale.com
- http://in.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090226021439AAV7Hyz
- Swift Dzire or Hyundai i20 ??? - Team-BHP
For quite sometime i've been searching cars which would fit my budget of 6 lakhs. The car should be able to accomodate 5 people easily. With not much options left i thought SwiftDzire would be the
Maruti Swift versus Hyundai I-20 –5 lacks segment cars in the News
- Hyundai mulls new diesel engine manufacturing unitBusiness Standard India2 days ago
The Indian arm of Korea’s Hyundai Motors is doing a study on the viability of a diesel engine unit in the country, which could help it reduce its dependence on Korea and gain a pricing advantage with increased localisation.
- Hyundai to invest Rs 800 cr on small car for Indiarediff.com4 days ago
The firm, which has operations in India through a wholly -owned subsidiary, Hyundai Motor India Ltd, will manufacture the car, which will be smaller than the Santro, at its plant in Chennai.
- The Hindu Business Line : GM India will not cede ground in Chinese allianceThe Hindu24 hours ago
Mumbai, Nov. 20 Mr Karl Slym, President and Managing Director of General Motors India, is categorical that the proposed alliance with SAIC Motor Corporation of China for light trucks will in no way compromise his company’s position.
- Slowdown in developed markets to impact exportersBusiness Standard India24 hours ago
The slowdown in developed markets is having an adverse impact on export oriented and transnational companies. There is no doubt that the world economic outlook has turned unfavourable.
- The Hindu Business Line : JSW in pact with Japanese co for auto-grade steelThe Hindu2 days ago
Mumbai, Nov. 19 JSW Steel has entered into a technical pact with JFE Steel Corporation of Japan to produce auto-grade steel at its Vijayanagar plant in Karanataka.
- Auto Industry Summit Tackles Practical Constraints to GrowthThe Auto Channel3 days ago
PUNE, India, November 18 -- Key executives from India's carmakers are meeting in Pune in two weeks time to address some of the hard practical issues which constrain the growth of the country's automotive production capacity.
- School boy kidnapped in Madhya Pradesh townCalcutta News4 days ago
Four unidentified gunmen kidnapped a school boy Tuesday when he was on his way to school in Madhya Pradesh's Mandsaur district, police said. 'Four people came in a Maruti van and stopped the child on the pretext of asking for some one's address.
- India driving global auto majors’ growth wheelThe Economic Times3 days ago
India driving global auto majors’ growth wheel India driving global auto majors’ growth wheel
Maruti Suzuki products on sale
Hot and sexy Indian economical and luxury cars reviews from carwale.com
- 3M launches Dry Interior Car Detailing Service
3M has launched India’s first ever ‘Dry Interior Car detailing services’. The service was launched by Mr. Shawn Crosby, Global Business Development Manager and Mr. Adam J Wilt, APAC Business Development Manager, 3M Car Care along with Mr. Ninad Gadgil, General Manager, Car Care Division, 3M India.  The new service provides for a premium, foaming [...] - 2 days ago
- Rolls-Royce Ghost Launched
Rolls-Royce Motor Cars previewed its new model, the Ghost, for the first time in India which will cost approximately Rs 2.5 crore. The car is the first in a new Rolls-Royce model series, separate from the Phantom family which comprises Phantom, Phantom Extended Wheelbase (four door saloons), Phantom Drophead Coupé (convertible) and Phantom Coupé (fixed [...] - 2 days ago
- Nissan India Inaugurates Corporate Office in Chennai
Nissan Motor India Pvt. Ltd. (NMIPL) today inaugurated its Corporate Office at T Nagar, Chennai, at the hands of Mr. Kiminobu Tokuyama, Managing Director and CEO, Nissan Motor India Private Ltd (NMIPL). Also present were colleagues and officials from the Renault Nissan Automotive India Private Ltd (RNAIPL), Renault Nissan Technology and Business Centre India Private [...] - 6 days ago
- Audi Inaugurates Service Facility in New Delhi
Audi India has announced its state-of-the-art service facility in Delhi that has the capability of repairing aluminum and steel. It is located at Mathura Road and is spread over 20,000 square feet. The new service facility has the capability to service 16 cars daily and has an additional eight bays for accidental care. This is a [...] - 6 days ago
- Michelin Signs MoU with Tamil Nadu Government for New Facility
The Michelin Group and Tamil Nadu government have signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) for Michelin’s tyre manufacturing plant, 50km north of Chennai at Thervoy Kandigai in Thiruvallur district. With a committed investment of Rs. 4,000 crores, the plant will be spread over an area of 290 acres and will absorb 1,500 workers locally. At the [...] - 6 days ago
- Mahindra Xylo now with airbags
After launching the Mahindra Scorpio with airbags, now Mahindra has introduced airbags even in its MUV the Xylo. The January 2009 launched Xylo, got ABS as an add-on some months back and now the MUV gets airbags. The airbags on the Xylo are available as an option on the E8 variant. In October 2009, Mahindra sold [...] - 9 days ago
- Mercedes E-Class Diesel Launched
Mercedes-Benz India has launched the E350 CDI BlueEFFICIENCY, the diesel variant of the new E-Class, at a price of Rs 48.08 lakh, ex-showroom, Delhi. The E350 CDI sports a 2987cc six-cylinder twin-turbocharged engine that produces 228bhp and 540Nm of torque, and will be available initially in Avantgarde trim. BlueEFFICIENCY technology in the new E-Class includes light, [...] - 9 days ago
- Volvo S60 first official photos
The S60 is Volvo’s sedan that will compete with the likes of BMW’s 3-series, Mercedes-Benz’s C-Class and Audi’s A4. A new model will be put on display at the Geneva Motor Show in March next year, and Volvo has released the first official images of the sedan. Production of the S60 will commence next year at [...] - 10 days ago
Comments
Thanks for the comment Rakesh.
Hi. I love this car, "Maruti Swift". Thanks for the informtion and pics.
It's my pleasure car lover.
Thank for the best content.
It's my pleasure topwords.
Excellent article again. The words are used in a perfect sense as to match the mentality of Indians.
Thanks Rashmi for your detailed reading and review of this hub.
Good review. But Hyundai i20 has been launched recently. Its too early to decide the success of this i20.
Yes i20 has been launched recently but then also, it will not be able to beat Swift, always remember it is India and we follow the rule of "watching others and buying something" and Swift has already been purchased by a lot of people in India. It is really tough for i20 to beat Maruti Swift in sales and service, but then also time will tell what will happen next.
What other cars are big in India? Are most people buying compact cars? Are there any Indian car plants for Toyota / Ford etc?
Hi thaninja, thanks for asking these good questions. Here are you answers:
What other cars are big in India?
There are many big cars in India like Mercedes Benz, Lamborghini, and Rolls Royce.
Here are some links as evidence:
For Rolls Royce in India, visit http://www.rolls-royce.com/india/default.htm
For Mercedes in India, visit http://www.mercedes-benz.co.in/
For Lamborghini in India, visit http://www.lambocars.com/new/india.htm
Are most people buying compact cars?
Yes maximum number of people are buying compact cars in India due to parking problems, etc. but at the same time, there is a lot of demand for big luxury cars also for example Skoda Laura, Toyota Corolla, Honda Civic, and Honda CRV to mention a few.
Are there any Indian car plants for Toyota / Ford etc?
Yes there are Indian car plants for Toyota and not only one but there are more, read these latest news, http://www.team-bhp.com/forum/indian-car-scene/212
For Indian Ford car plants, visit http://www.ford.com/about-ford/news-announcements/
Its been about 20 days since I bought my i20. My experience has been great till now. I’ve bought Magna petrol. Bought it from Trident Hyundai, Bangalore.
Congratulations for buying Hyundai i20 Magna Petrol from Trident Hyundai friend. Please let us know about your driving and other experiences you have.
Rakesh Thakur says:
7 months ago
A great article with nice comparison between Maruti Swift and Hyundai I-20. I would prefer Swift instead of I-20 because it is of much less cost than I-20 and covers the Maruti guarantee and because serviceability of Maruti company is much more better than Hyundai.