No Brainer: Small Cars Are Dangerous

58
rate or flag this page

By Automotive_Help



It shouldn't take a government or industry study to prove the obvious, but a report from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) has confirmed what mostly everyone already knows: small cars can be dangerous to your health, even deadly. Yes, if you took physics then you know that when two objects moving at the same speed hit each other, the one that weighs less will suffer more damages.

The IIHS study comes just as some consumers are considering moving to smaller vehicles in a bid to save on gas and/or to reduce their so-called carbon footprint. Smaller, lighter vehicles can return improved fuel economy, but those changes could come at the expense of occupant safety.

"There are good reasons people buy minicars," says Institute president Adrian Lund. "They're more affordable, and they use less gas. But the safety trade-offs are clear from our new tests. Equally clear are the implications when it comes to fuel economy. If automakers downsize cars so their fleets use less fuel, occupant safety will be compromised. However, there are ways to serve fuel economy and safety at the same time."

The IIHS did not pair up small cars with pickup trucks and sport/utility vehicles when conducting their study nor did they choose vehicles from different manufacturers. When a subcompact car was chosen from one manufacturer the IIHS chose a slightly larger vehicle from that same car company.

For example, the IIHS crashed a Toyota Yaris into a larger Toyota Camry; a smart fortwo into a Mercedes-Benz C-Class (both made by Daimler); and a Honda Fit into a Honda Accord. Each vehicle was traveling at 40 miles per hour. All three small cars performed poorly, while the larger vehicles were rated good or acceptable. The small cars tested, however, receive good ratings in government-conducted crash tests with fixed barriers.

All three small cars performed well in government barrier tests where they are rammed into a stationery object. However, when meeting “head on” with a larger vehicle, the results were obvious and would be catastrophic for human occupants.

What should the IIHS study do for people shopping for a new or used car? Consider the law of physics, that's what. Short term savings in fuel economy could prove dangerous in a crash, even deadly.



Print   —   Rate it:  up  down  flag this hub

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Hawkesdream profile image

Hawkesdream  says:
8 months ago

How very true , from experience in a Talbot Samba, these small cars are deadly, have ever since had and driven large cars and always with a bonnet and boot.

IslandVoice profile image

IslandVoice  says:
8 months ago

As much as i love another convertible Beetle, had one many moons ago, small cars are too too dangerous. You are right, this is a no brainer! Timely!

Lisa HW profile image

Lisa HW  says:
8 months ago

Good Hub and matter after my own heart. Aside from fuel efficiency, I think small cars are adorable - but they can be death traps. When I was a kid my father had a big, old, 50's Buick Roadmaster. Some teenage kid (driving less than a month) hit our car at 70 mph. The Buick was sent up on two wheels but bounced back down, and none of the adults or children in the car (including a baby) were hurt. I've known other people in bigger cars who have had accidents with similar outcomes. As you said, nobody needs a study to have noticed that if they've lived more than sixteen years. When my children were little I would never put them in a small car. I'm sure, too, it's why so many people disregard fuel inefficiency and aim for bigger vehicles.

About ten years after my father's car was hit I was in a small car and again hit by someone coming 70 mph on the wrong side of the road. One friend and I survived. The other did not. We, two survivors, had plenty of injuries. The young woman who hit us was in a big, old, Oldsmobile and walked away with a bumped head. I still say there's something to be said for big, old, GM cars.

eovery profile image

eovery  says:
8 months ago

You're right it is a no brainer. People who want these tiny cars are no brainers! Keep on Hubbing!

Ralph Deeds profile image

Ralph Deeds  says:
7 months ago

Your logic is backwards. The huge gas-hog SUVs harm drivers of small cars, but the small cars are dangerous? That's like saying that the person shot by a drug gang member is dangerous. Moreover, small cars can be designed to be quite safe in crashes. As fuel efficiency standards are increased the number of huge cars will and the number of non-commercial cars will increase and safety will be improved. Here's a link to a study that shows that fuel economy can be improved without sacrificing safety.

http://www.theicct.org/documents/ICCT_SippingFuelO

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working