On the Streets of Shenzen China
83
Shenzen, China Fast Facts
- Until 1979, this was once a sleeping fishing village with less than 20,000 residents, close in proximity to Hong Kong. It now has over, 4.7 million residents.
- It is China's major financial center and home to the Shenzen Stock Exchange.
- It is the second busiest port in China, second only to Shanghai.
- Major tourist attractions: (1) Window of the World; (2) Happy Valley; (3) Splendid China; (4) Shekou; and Minsk World.
- The difference between the rich and the poor in this city is one of the world's most shocking.
- Average age of residents -- 30!
- This area of China is fenced off and immigration is strictly enforced.
Â
The Man Without A Name Who Stalks My Dreams
My calloused heart, soul, and mind are obsessed with the memory of a man, whose name I will never know. Our eyes once locked on a human being jam-packed soiled street in Shenzhen, China. There were no words between us, as we both gawked at each other. At the time, I had no idea this seconds long encounter, would change my perspective on life forever.
We were in a part of Shenzhen, where news of executives and sightseers being robbed and kidnapped, are not exceptional reports in Hong Kong newspapers. Some say it is a lawless place, comparable to the old days in Wild West. It has an element of modern day treachery, with pickpockets and con artists in full force.
The millions of people and the gangs (syndicates) who live Shenzhen, which is one of the world's fastest growing cities, make the rules. This is not to say Shenzhen isn't modern, exciting, and a wonderful place to visit. It is all of both, and more.
Here, as in any place in the world, including the United States, you see pockets of heart wrenching poverty. As a veteran international traveler, I am not easily shocked. I've seen extreme poverty and even in Central Florida we deal daily with the homeless and begging (although we refer to it as panhandling).
Nor, am I unusually sympathetic or not compassionate to the homeless, knowing the issues of homelessness are endlessly complicated, no matter where you travel or live. There are no easy answers to global poverty and the plight of the homeless.
Sometimes Your Heart Will Ache
In Shenzhen, drug addict mothers approach foreign visitors, begging for money while toting half-alive, belly swollen babies, with limp sausage thin arms. Starving children looking very much like in ads run by charitable organizations fighting global poverty. If you give anything to these women, it is not likely you'll be helping the child and it is likely that you'll be targeted for robbery in certain sections of this city. None of this is what the Chinese government wants for outsiders to see, especially with the upcoming Olympics activities.
If you stay in the tourist areas, you'll see less of this. However, as you make your way down certain streets littered with trash, mucked by gum and tobacco spit, beggars reach out from their sidewalk seats, silently extending their begging bowls. Among the throngs of people, you notice whole families in roofed lean-to shelters against buildings, that serve as their both their homes and places of business. The elderly gesture with their hands to their mouths and then hold their hands out, indicating they are hungry. All of this can immensely hurt your heart.
Throughout Asia, there are many beggars with wounded or amputated feet, hands, or arms, making it grim to ignore them. Surprisingly, a percentage of them are professional beggars. Even more disheartening, is the knowledge that there is a large element of "professional beggars," to be found everywhere in the world, not just in Shenzhen.
Singing Chinese Beggar
Where I Met A Stranger
In parts of China, sadly, some of these wounds are self-inflicted. Far worse, the observant traveler will be taken aback, when realizing that able-bodied men accompany some beggars. You'll notice they'll be sitting a distance away, while the amputees beg. These amputee beggars and their keepers are part of organized gangs and syndicates working together.
In Shenzhen, at all times, you are tremendously aware, that every Asian mind around you, is actively witnessing any exchange in human understanding. More importantly, as a Westerner, you absolutely know that any gesture of compassion, paints a bulls-eye of potential theft and victimization upon you. So you learn, sometimes the hard way, that even though life has been cruel to them, as a foreigner in a far away land, you generally don't or shouldn't give to beggars.
Before our eyes locked, I stared at him as he inched along on his forearms down the sidewalk, just ahead of us. He seemingly never looked up. Yet, the moment anyone came parallel to him, he bowed his head ever closer to the sidewalk, and stretched out his begging cup.
The stumps of his legs that had been amputated just at the knee, weren't particularly shocking. However, the remaining back portions of his upper thighs had been savagely gnawed upon, no doubt by either feral dogs or the city rats. Large infected, oozing, and visibly bleeding chunks of his flesh hung from the missing portions. Neither years of working in a medical center, nor even the most graphic of U.S. medical reality shows could have prepared my eyes for his doomed truth. I forced myself to avert my eyes and hurried along towards my destination, as did everyone else on that busy sidewalk.
Tell Me Why?
What I Cannot Forget
It was over three years ago that the visual image of this unfortunate soul touched me. I couldn't help him that day because of the neighborhood I was in and how far I had to travel to get out of it.
I could not help him then. I cannot help him now. It doesn't matter how he came to be in that condition. That brief encounter with this stranger was a pivotal point in my understanding of how I really felt about global poverty. It was one that will last my entire life. It has brought me to a full comprehension, that no matter what problems my daily life might bring - I have choices and the ability to exercise them in ways that he, and the other human tragedies around him and in this world don't.
Therefore, since that encounter, whenever I struggle with life obstacles, worries, and problems - I remind myself how lucky I am to be alive. I reflect upon how blessed we are to have choices in how to solve life's problems. Lastly, I think of him, this stranger whose name I'll never know, and I whisper 'xie xie' (thank you in Chinese) and say a prayer for him and all of those just like him.
True Beggars
Definition: True Beggars -- These are the:
- Disabled
- Children
- Elderly
- Crippled
- Blind
- Deaf
- The abandoned
Professional Beggars
Definition: Professional beggars (aka fake beggars) -- Not just found in China, the ones who work every day on the same streets, the same hours. Some earn "wages" from others. These are organized groups. Their wages are determined by their daily contributions to the group or gang. They can often be very aggressive. Tactics include:
- Blocking you
- Jumping on you
- Holding your legs
- Grabbing your clothes
- They will change into old dirty clothes and come and go by cab
- They will often demand more money, if you give them a smaller amount
Child Beggars
Perhaps the most heart breaking sight of all, is that of child beggars. Some of these very young children are taught to be a beggar. There will usually be an adult or older child sitting somewhere nearby that they bring the money to.
Some of them have been taught to grab onto your legs, while crying out to you. Some will actually try to reach in your pockets. Others stand quietly with cups and begging bowls pleading with their eyes. Still, in other areas, you can find youself surrounded by hoards of small children all begging simultaneously.
What becomes of them? Do they ever escape this lifestyle? Is there any solution for them?
Elderly Beggars
Perhaps one of the most shocking sights to Western visitors, is the reality of elderly beggars throughout China. I've never encountered a lot of them. Generally, if they don't have family who can take care of them, there really isn't the infrastructure in place to assume this role.
However, you'll see many elderly picking up trash, cardboard, and recyclables. Sometimes you see them, along with the disabled cleaning the parks and streets.Usually, above the the recycling centers are dormitory type areas where they live at night.
I don't know about anyone else, but I have a tremendous sadness whenever I encounter poverty stricken elderly both here and abroad.
Child Beggar in Shanghai
Harassment of Beggars and the Homeless
Harassment of beggars and the homeless is nothing singular to China. It even happens here in the U.S. in the most appalling growing numbers. Just like misguided teenagers and young adults often harass and beat-up the homeless here in America -- there have been reports of teasing and harassing of the elderly and homeless in China.
The taking of their belongings is a frequent tactic. This especially sad, when a homeless person has spent their day collecting recyclables to earn a little money.
Attitudes Towards Beggars and Begging
In China, like other rapidly developing countries, beggars are a reality. Due to China's extreme population, it is more obvious there. Now, with the tragedy of recent earthquake, there are so many people in need in China. So many that may not have any choice but to beg.
The gap between the rich and the poor is tremendously magnified compared to that of other countries -- and this problem is only growing. I believe the attitudes towards beggars and begging, reflect us as a society and mirror what is happening today within our hearts and minds.
There is an attitude among the locals that there would be no beggars if no one gave them anything. This is particularly a true sentiment among the young professions working so very hard in China to better themselves. Their hearts are sometimes hardened towards those with begging bowls.
Living in Central Florida, I can understand this. Here, we have hoards of homeless men, a majority of which, who simply chose panhandling as a lifestyle. Perhaps they are unwilling to change, give up their freedom, are mentally ill, or are ill from drugs and alcohol. You get tired of them harassing you at stop lights and outside of Wal-marts.
How to Help Them - A True Moral Question
We all want to help those so less fortunate than us, but this not an easy topic to address. For some that you will encounter, the answer is a "no brainer" you give what you can. You don't look away or step around them.
This is my rule -- If they are disabled, elderly, or children and the location that you come across them is somewhat safe, then give them what money you can. Deliberately carry some small amounts of money. always keeping it separate from your wallet or purse for this purpose.
Additionally, for some of them, even if you suspect that they aren't truly in need and may be posing as panhandlers -- do the same. It's better to error on the side of doing what's right, regardless of who ends up with the bulk of the money earned at the end of the day.
It's not about them, it's about you and how you view your role in this world. I think along the lines of, if someone had to stoop to the level of pretending to be poor and use a begging bowl -- it might not really be about choices.
Is the answer here and abroad, government programs? We've certainly been dealing with the issues of homelessness for decades here in the U.S. Is it any better than it was in 1970s when Mitch Snyder and Carole Finnley (Community for Creative Non-Violence) were making headlines? Perhaps, it is worse. This isn't Shenzen problem, this isn't China's problem - the plight of the homeless and poverty belongs to the world.
Bottom Line -- There Has to be a Better Way!
- A Day In The Life Of A Homeless Man
Homeless People in America get a bad rap. Urban Myths , Legends and a attitude by most Americans - Activist Mitch Snyder
Do we go to extremes to get people to care? Or do we accept that some problems in life will never change? - Google Gives Homeless Free Phone with Voicemail Serv...
Google will provide free voicemail service including a virtual personal phone number for all the homeless people in San Francisco. The homeless can use this number to receive calls from their loved ones,... - Homeless People
Homeless people are here they are a reality. They are homeless for different reason drug abuse,alchol abuse,losing a job. No matter what the reason these people are human beings and should be treated as such.... - Homeless shelters
In reality the homeless shelter do not cure homelessness. At best, homeless shelters are bandages on a social wound. Sometimes the bandage provides a healing environment for the obvious wound, but it does not... - How I am surviving being homeless
Most people in the world today don't under stand exactly what being homeless is. I for one do know and am homeless. I have been homeless for about 1 and a half years now and I am surviving. I don't stink I... - Poem: Homeless
Homeless Fairy tern borrows the branch of a tree. She lays her egg at the edge- carefully! Then when her chick hatches it scritches, it scratches and tries not to fall from its no-nest-at-all. - Preventing Homelessness
A growing problem in troubled economic times.
The High Cost of Cheap Goods
- Branded Goods for Safety and Advantages
Branded goods seek to increase the product's perceived value to the customer. Increased interest in strong Brands is the accelerating pace of globalisation. A customer-focused, organization first determines... - Dangerous Goods Storage
Dangerous Goods refer to substances that pose a high level of danger and health risk to both humans and the environment. They are usually classified with reference to the immediate hazard they pose rather... - Etiquette In China
Educating yourself on the customs and etiquette in China is an important part of preparation for an enjoyable travel experience. China is the oldest continuous civilization on the planet encompassing more... - Homelessness in China & the U.S.A.: A Brief Abstract
- Learn Chinese Language
Undoubtely, Chinese language is one of the most difficult to learn. However, lots of people are starting or want to learn chinese language. What is the reason for this ? There can be a lot of answers, but... - The High Cost of Low Price
Link to a DVD depicting the high human cost our big box stores provide us with cheap goods. - U.S.International Goods and Services Trade Deficit R...
The Nation's international deficit in goods and services increased to $62.2 billion in July from $58.8 billion (revised) in June, as imports increased more than exports...
On the Streets of Shenzen China in the News
- China’s Rapid Reactor Expansion Raises ConcernsNew York Times1 second ago
China’s aggressive expansion of nuclear plants could cut carbon emissions, but the pace could lead to shortcuts.
- China: Asylum Bid by 22 Uighurs OpposedNew York Times1 second ago
China said Tuesday that 22 Uighurs who fled to Cambodia after deadly ethnic rioting this summer were criminals and should not be granted asylum.
- In 2025, India To Pass China In Population, U.S. EstimatesNew York Times64 minutes ago
India will become the world’s most populous country in 2025, surpassing China, where the population will peak one year later because of declining fertility, according to U.S. projections.
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
What Do You Think the Solutions Are?
Aya! Had to laugh, I read and approved the comment but had it in my stubborn head that it was on the other hub. Since another comment also disappeared at the same time I was certain the computer Gods were out to get me today. LOL
I too am conflicted about this topic, since every day it is in our face here in Central Florida.
Jerilee, I just now checked my email and was a little confused myself. Glad nothing was lost.
Thanks Aya! It was one of those days with the computer here.
Check Out The Latest!
- Choose Your Garden - Astrological Herb Garden
A lot of people when they plan a garden forget that you can build your entire garden around a theme. You'll find that having a theme for your garden makes it the most interesting to plant and can be real... - 16 hours ago
- The Joys of a Moonlight Garden
The daughter of Madame Butterfly, Akina, once invited me to visit her moonlight garden. Now at the time, I couldn't imagine that seeing someone's garden in the light of the full moon, but then I'd already... - 2 days ago
- Making Herbal Papers
I have to admit that I came to making herbal papers at a late stage in life. The first time I came home to my step-daughter using my new blender to prepare plant pulp, I wanted to beat her to a pulp for the... - 4 days ago
- What Happens To All The Gold
At least once a day, my husband feels the need to inform me of the price of gold. It's part of his daily witnessing and running commentary on how much this world is going to hell-in-a-hand basket, with the... - 2 weeks ago
- Let Us Show Our Kindness Now
In today's times of troubles, it is easy to forget that each and everyone of us has the capacity to be pilgrims of mercy and make a difference in the world around in both big and small ways. In thinking about... - 2 weeks ago






Aya Katz says:
11 months ago
Jerilee, I did read this hub before, just didn't what to say! Like you, I have mixed feelings about professional beggars.
I think the solution, both here and abroad, has to be organic -- not government made. I have the same feelings about stray dogs. Nobody owes them a handout, but if they bother no one, then must we bother them?