Public, Private, or Homeschool? How to Choose

57
rate or flag this page

By Marye Audet


Image:Morguefile.com
Image:Morguefile.com

When it is time to start some sort of formal education it can be difficult to decide between public, private or homeschool. How to choose which is right for your family can be stressful, cause marital discord, and even rifts in extended families.

It is, after all, your childs' education that your are deciding on. The decisions you make can have an effect on him for the rest of his life. No parent wants to think that their child is going ot end up on the psychiatrist's couch mumbling about how they were forced to listen to Rosetta Stone language program while they milked the cows.

Yet, the public school system is often in the news, and generally the headlines are not complimentary. Private school is expensive.

And what about socialization?

Understand Your Motives

First of all, if you considering homeschooling then there is a reason you are considering it. It could be:

  • Peer pressure- all our friends do

  • Religious Preferencee
  • Media Pressure-The homeschool kids in the news are all geniuses
  • Academic Excellence- Not happy with the system

There are hundreds of other reasons that people consider homeschooling. Some of them are good reasons but many of them are not. In order to homeschool you must be doing it because you feel that it is the best choice for your family for this year. No one is asking you to sign in blood and commit to homeschooling for the rest of your life.

Most people who homeschool purely because they want their kids to be rocket scientists by age seven generally don't do very well. Academics are an important part of homeschooling but they are only one part.

Homeschooling is a lifestyle of learning with your children, deepening relationship, and discipling them in the fullest sense of the word. If you see academics as somehow separate from the rest of life then you are totally missing what homeschooling is all about.

By the same token, if you want to homeschool but feel that you must send your child to school because of that S word that everyone throws at homeschoolers (socialization) then you are missing the point there too. Socialization is the boogey-man of most parents considering homeschooling, the monster under the bed. Like both of them, the problem is non-existent.

Big, Bad Socialization

What IS socialization anyway?

Have you ever asked yourself what people are so afraid of? In this modern society of Internet, instant messaging, cell phones, and youth groups have you really ever wondered what it would take for a child to NOT be socialized?

Merriam Webster defines socialization as a noun. It is the process that begins in babyhood by which a human acquires habits, ethics, and social skills through education and training to become an adult.

Have you ever been around thirty seventh graders? They are training for something but generally it has nothing to do with being an adult. Thirty seventh graders that spend eight hours a day together every day will elarn to act like ....seventh graders. They will identify with, communicate on the level of, and prefer the company of other seventh graders.

On the other hand, a child that is around all ages of people learns to communicate on a broad level. He learns to value all ages and interact in many different types of situations.

He is socialized in a much more realistic setting:

  • The grocery store
  • Church
  • Neighbors
  • Friends
  • Family
  • Extended Family
  • The library
  • Where ever you go

Know Your Purpose

Whichever educational model you choose you should be aware of your purpose in choosing it.

Fear should not be the prevailing reason that you make your choice.

  • Fear of violence in the school
  • Fear of failure at home
  • Fear of what others will say

Take a few minutes and write two lists. One one write down all the reasons you want to homeschool. On the other write down all the reasons your child should be in public or private school. Which list seems the best to you?


Resources from Amazon

So - WHY Do You Homeschool? So - WHY Do You Homeschool?
Price: $7.23
List Price: $14.99
The Well-Adjusted Child: The Social Benefits of Homeschooling The Well-Adjusted Child: The Social Benefits of Homeschooling
Price: $8.78
List Price: $14.95
Permission to Mother: Going Beyond the Standard-of-Care to Nurture Our Children Permission to Mother: Going Beyond the Standard-of-Care to Nurture Our Children
Price: $26.87
List Price: $29.95

When You Have Chosen

It is important that couples be in ageement when it comes to their child's education. Homeschooling, should you choose to do it, requires both parents to be involved and supportive for the best results. Having arguements over whether or not homeschooling is good for your child is not the way to start the homeschooling adventure.

Realize, too, that you don;t hav to commit to your choice for the rest of your life. If you try homeschooling and it does not work for your family you are free to try public or private school down the road. Likewaise, if you decide to put your child in school you can always pull them out and homeschool.

Whichever decision you make, it has to be right for the whole family. Be sure that it is based on the reality of your life and noton anyone else's opinions of what you should or should not do.

As with everything, do the research, get the facts, and then step ahead with bold confidence.

Famous Homeschoolers

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Lissie profile image

Lissie  says:
17 months ago

Of course the reality is that schools are a relatively new invention of the Industrial Revolution: and the truley rich didn't got to them they were home tutored. That's why Eton etc are called Public Schools: they were intially open to the public so poor boys could get an eductaion: now they are elite! My experience around kids who are home schooled because they live remotely that they are much better at relating to adults and much more mature than those who go to school

solarstories profile image

solarstories  says:
17 months ago

I was home schooled for a year, I was all over the place at that time. Walking in the reeds, making shell candles, being part of a theatre ... when I returned to public school I was ahead of all the others and had to go to a special school for smarter kids.

dsletten profile image

dsletten  says:
17 months ago

Great hub. I think there are advantages and disadvantages to all three choices.  Children can go to public school with their peers and still be mature around all age groups if that is how they are raised at home.  My kids hated Middle School because we treated them like individuals and humans and the school treated all the kids as if they were juvenile delinquents.  High school was better because kids tend to be in all ranges of maturity and you can find your niche better.  Of course, everyone has a different experience.  I think the most important element is that the parents be involved.  Involved at home and involved at school throughout the learning process.  Whether you homeschool, go to private school or public if the parents are involved and active in their child's education you can raise an intelligent, successful child.  My children both went to public school and my son graduated with a 3.9 GPA, my daughter currently has a 4.0 as she enters her senior year.  Both did well despite the pitfalls of a public education.  So, please get involved!

rodney southern profile image

rodney southern  says:
17 months ago

Very well thought out hub. I am beginning to think that homeschooling is a pretty good choice. Especially with the safety issues in some public schools. Hopefully we can get a stranglehold on the crime.

Laurie Stroupe  says:
17 months ago

Some children will do well no matter what schooling choice is made for them. For other children, there really is a best choice.

My oldest barely tolerated home school for two years and spent the rest in public school. She had been in public school the longest when my opportunity to begin home educating the children became available. She was already used to the public school way and never adapted again to being home.

My other three children have spent most of their school years at home, with my youngest never having gone to public school at all. They absolutely love being home for their education. And I've loved the deeper relationship that we all have because of it.

My three home educated children cooperate with each other, like each other, and have learned to work out problems together. They show more respect for people than many other children I've met in my life. They are well behaved, which seems to be a common characteristic of home educated children, from my experience.

i worried at first that I would not have the patience to home school, but it never was an issue. We learn and experience things together. I wouldn't trade all of those experiences for anything in this world.

Uriel profile image

Uriel  says:
17 months ago

i have to say it was really hard to be in school. At a young age you are forced to deal with peer pressure , violence, conflicts based on color religion or even heritage. Even school sounds like a battle field in many cases.And i have to say i wondered about homeschooling and how it would be. But not all parents can handle the new technology and achievments in all fields . Science is always in progress especially these days which makes a parent's job even harder . Yet, with all the problems we face in school, i guess we learn to " suck it up" and grow stronger and smarter when dealing with life "outside school" ie real life.

Aya Katz profile image

Aya Katz  says:
17 months ago

I was home-schooled from age thirteen to sixteen, after which I went to college. There were both good results and bad, depending on the subject. I was able to soar in the subjects that most interested me, but I did not do well in subjects in which I had no intrinsic advantage. Being home-schooled supported my independent thinking, but it hindered my social development.

My own daughter is nine years old and in the public school. The public school is a good way to get your child immersion in a language not spoken at home, if you don't speak the dominant language. It is a good place to learn to deal with bullies and to make friends and it is the best way to learn firsthand about social dynamics in general. It is a very bad place to learn academic skills, so we supplement at home. ;->

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working