create your own

Scary Halloween Treats & Cool Halloween Monster Cookies

89
rate or flag this page

By RedElf


"From ghosties and ghoulies and long-legged beasties and things that go bump in the night..." The next phrase of this well-known prayer calls upon a higher power for deliverance, and normally, I would be right in line for that, but on this singular occasion all bets are off. On All Hallows Eve, every shape and size of ghost and ghoul and beastie is free to roam the streets, begging for all manner of Halloween treats, chocolates and monster cookies - playing Halloween trick-or treat.

My own little Halloween beastie adored trekking from house to house, up and down the streets, ringing our neighbors' doorbells and shouting "Halloween apples, trick-or-treat" at whoever answered. Fortunately we lived in a small town at the time, and knew all our neighbors well, but most years our child's candy predations were constrained to house parties, or the Halloween Spook Fest - a great night of spooky family fun in the school gym.



One particular Fall, when it was my turn to provide treats for our weekly coffee party, I decided to try my hand at Halloween-themed goodies. I have a super recipe for crust-less pumpkin pie, that I baked in ramekins and then carefully decanted onto oak leaf-shaped desert plates, topped off with a generous dollop of whipped cream.

The black-tinted bat and black cat shaped cookies were rich, dark chocolate, decorated with piped-on orange icing details. The goodies were a hit, and one idea led to another. Ultimately, we decided to offer a kid's activity at the up-coming Halloween party at school - Design Your Own Monster Cookie.

Our booth did a roaring business. We charged fifty cents a cookie and advertised that all the proceeds would go to buy new books for the library. At that time, the town library shared space in the school, and relied on donations of pre-owned books. Its inventory was in dire need of replenishing.


A bunch of teachers got together to build and run a Haunted House. They were terrifically creative, right down to the bowl of peeled grape "eyeballs", and spaghetti "earthworms" swimming in lukewarm, slightly runny tapioca pudding - now there was a disgusting texture.

The high school science teacher volunteered a pickled calf's brain, but the smell of formaldehyde was a bit too strong so we passed on that one.

Shortbread Witches Fingers


Wilton 12 Cavity Halloween Cookie Pan Wilton 12 Cavity Halloween Cookie Pan
Price: $9.89
List Price: $11.99
No Amazon results found

My favorite cookie for decorating is a plain sugar cookie recipe.

It can be rolled out nice and thick and tinted a variety of lovely Halloween colors - pumpkin orange, witch black, graveyard brown, and bright, slimy green.

I usually make a double recipe and divide the dough into three or four batches, depending on how many colors I want to use.

Some of the cookie dough may be left plain and covered with a white icing glaze for a ghostly effect.


Wilton has a great line of chocolate and chocolate making accessories. I wish they had been available when I was in Halloween party mode.

I have used them as a product demonstrator, though, and I can vouch for the quality of their cany melts. They melt smoothly and quickly in the microwave, and come in a wonderful variety of Halloween colors.

Usually around Halloween, we would feature a series of "kids' clubs" activities at the front of the store. The kids and the customers got a big kick out of them, and they were great for business.

One of the kids' favorite activities, next to making chocolate lollipops in Halloween shapes and colors, was decorating a monster cookie to eat there or take home. Our Wilton instructor would set up her display, and demonstrate decorating cupcakes with scary Halloween faces.

Halloween Spider & Bug Themed Cupcakes


To save time, we used slice-and-bake refrigerator sugar cookie dough, and brought them fresh from home to the event. We always had several flavors and colors of icing for spreading, as well as supply of Wilton tubes of thin decorator icing.

Even though the children's parents were required to sign waivers and guarantee their children were nut-allergy free, we stayed away from any kind of nuts to decorate the monster cookies.

Instead we laid in a supply of M&Ms, seedless raisins, candy fruit slices (great for mouths and ears), candy corn, and colored sprinkles.

The kids used a dab of Royal Icing to secure the candied fruit-slice ears. Some cut off the "rind" and used that for wiggly eyebrows, preferring M&Ms or Skittles for the mouth.

One creative young soul used a piece of "rind" to make a wavy mouth and arranged an uneven row of Skittles "fangs". She had bitten off one end of each candy, and the broken ends protruding from the gaping mouth added a funny, snaggle-toothed look to her monster.

For a home party, barring allergies, you could also add toasted and tinted coconut, halved peanuts, and slivered almonds. Slivered almonds make great scary teeth.

Haystacks, or unbaked chocolate drop cookies, made with rolled oats, coconut, cocoa, and sugar, can be quickly patted into bat shapes for a great variation on the Halloween theme.

You have to work fast though, as the cookies set up quite quickly once they cool. Older kids can help with this activity, but the dough is quite hot at first so care should be taken with little fingers.

Happy Halloween!

More tasty Halloween treats

Meatball Spiders with shredded cheese "hair" and dried Chinese noodle legs
Meatball Spiders with shredded cheese "hair" and dried Chinese noodle legs
Thinly sliced ready-made refrigerator dough wraps up these cute hot-dog "mummies"
Thinly sliced ready-made refrigerator dough wraps up these cute hot-dog "mummies"
Chocolate cookie dough balls and hat shapes are baked and combined with mint icing to create cute witches hat cookies
Chocolate cookie dough balls and hat shapes are baked and combined with mint icing to create cute witches hat cookies
Adorable paper goody bags, Make the brooms by first wrapping up the goodies, then carefully, with very sharp scissors, "shredding" the tiny paper bags so that they resemble brooms
Adorable paper goody bags, Make the brooms by first wrapping up the goodies, then carefully, with very sharp scissors, "shredding" the tiny paper bags so that they resemble brooms

Wilton Halloween Cupcakes N More Dessert Stand Wilton Halloween Cupcakes N More Dessert Stand
Price: $14.67
List Price: $19.99
Wilton Purple Cake Sparkles Wilton Purple Cake Sparkles
Price: $3.29
List Price: $9.99
Wilton Orange Cake Sparkles Wilton Orange Cake Sparkles
Price: $2.61
List Price: $9.99
Halloween 12in x 15in Cupcake Stand Halloween 12in x 15in Cupcake Stand
Price: $8.94
  • Halloween Costumes for Baby and Toddlers

    Halloween is just round the corner and you want to make the first Halloween for your baby more than an experience to cherish for a long time. With the available options in the market today you can dress up your baby and make him the Star he was born to be in this Halloween. Read on to know the most cutest and adorable Halloween costumes for your baby and toddlers. - 3 months ago

  • Scary Halloween Treats & Cool Halloween Monster Cookies

    halloween cookies, halloween chocolate, halloween trick-or-treat, wilton halloween cookies, "From ghosties and ghoulies and long-legged beasties and things that go bump in the night..." The next phrase of this well-known prayer calls upon a higher power for deliverance, and normally, I would be... - 3 months ago

  • How to Turn a Pumpkin into a Jack-O-Lantern

    Utter the word Halloween and the first image that comes to most people's minds is a Jack-O'-Lantern - a pumpkin with a face carved on it. The practice of celebrating Halloween with Jack-O'-Lanterns is an... - 3 months ago

RSS for comments on this Hub

kartika damon profile image

kartika damon  says:
3 months ago

adorable!

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

thank you!

judydianne profile image

judydianne  says:
3 months ago

I especially like the brooms. So cute! Great ideas!

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks so much, judydianne - I love them too - they are a little tricky but oh, so cute when they are done!

dohn121 profile image

dohn121  says:
3 months ago

These are awesome ideas! Way to think outside-the-box! Thanks for sharing this wonderful hub, RedElf!

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith  says:
3 months ago

Good foods but love the Witches Fingers. Don't think they look very appetising though but I guess they would to children

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks so much, dohn121. You are most welcome! Some have been around for a while but now they're all new again.

Taste great, they do, ethel, but you have to close your eyes. I haven't met a kid yet who didn't like to crunch them up.

Enelle Lamb profile image

Enelle Lamb  says:
3 months ago

Wow another great hub with amazing ideas! You certainly do your homework Red - I must remember to book you for my next party LOL...

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Hey, thanks Enelle! You and me and 15 haloween kidlets! Happy days, LOL

Candie V profile image

Candie V  says:
3 months ago

Num!!! Ok, so looking at the pictures is calorie-free, but darn it, I'll only have 1 cupcake.. oh and a hotdog mummy, and 2 witches fingers with a glass of milk.. to start with..

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

OK, Candie V - but don't forget, there's always a caramel apple or two stashed away somewhere, LOL...and you simply must decorate a monster cookie before you go :D

Candie V profile image

Candie V  says:
3 months ago

oooh! Where are the caramel apples? I'll take one! It does totally count as a 'fruit'! I would love to decorate a cookie! I love it here in your home!

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks , Candie, so glad you could make it to the party! ...and of course, the caramel apple counts as a fruit for any diet plan! Cookie decorating is in the back parlor, and don't forget your goody bag. We have a little special something for special guests ;)

Paradise7 profile image

Paradise7  says:
3 months ago

Hey, RedElf, good hub! I especially liked the witch fingers and the mummy blankets. The meatball spiders weren't bad, either. Have Fun! A great HubMob topic hub.

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

The witch fingers are a hoot, aren't they! The meatball spiders are great, too Paradise7, but if you serve them too hot, they soften the taco chips quite a bit. Glad you enjoyed the hub.

febriedethan profile image

febriedethan  says:
3 months ago

Wow..the witch fingers seem scary :) I love it! Love the goody bags ideas. Thank's what a great hub.

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks so much. The goody bags are cute, aren't they. Nicew to meet you, febriedethan!

Princessa profile image

Princessa  says:
3 months ago

LOL I love those hot-dog "mummies" they are so cute and so easy to do. I also like that Halloween Spider & Bug Themed Cupcakes do. These are fantastic ideas, thank you so much for them!

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks, Princessa. Kids love to wrap up their own "mummies", too! You are so welcome.

KyonSOS23 profile image

KyonSOS23  says:
3 months ago

I like Shortbread Witches Fingers ,it very horror.

ThePartyAnimal profile image

ThePartyAnimal  says:
3 months ago

Love it - my favorite are the Witches Fingers - Those are just too much fun - what a great read.

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks so much, KyonSOS23. They're great fun!

Thanks so much PA. So nice of you to stop by.

mith_moral profile image

mith_moral  says:
3 months ago

These treats are too cute! They look so yummy. I'm going to have to try these this Halloween!

Thank you for this.

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

You are most welcome, mith_moral. Thanks so much for stopping by and commenting.

KevCC profile image

KevCC  says:
3 months ago

Excellent stuff, I love the witches fingers.

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Hey, KevCC! Glad you stopped by! They are fun, but I think I like the yummy "mummies" best ;)

Naomi R. Cox profile image

Naomi R. Cox  says:
3 months ago

Excellent goodies for the little goblins.The Witches Fingers and Witches Brooms caught my attention. My granddaughters will love them. Thanks for sharing this post.

Bobalooba profile image

Bobalooba  says:
3 months ago

These treats are so creative, what a fun lens.

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks for your comments, Naomi. I'm glad you like the kid goodies - they are great fun to make, too.

Greetings, Bobalooba. Glad you enjoyed it.

stephhicks68 profile image

stephhicks68  says:
3 months ago

I love Halloween - my oldest child's birthday is Oct. 31. We'll enjoy making these treats.

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Oh, how lovely! My birthday is on Christmas Day, according to the Orthodox calendar. We grew up knowing it as Twelfth Night, traditionally the night when the Magi arrived. I didn't realize until I moved here that some people celebrated Christmas on that day. But your child is so lucky to have such a GREAT day for a birthday! What fun to be able to dress up every year for your birthday!

mjt122649 profile image

mjt122649  says:
3 months ago

The eve of all Saints Day,falling on October 31 and celebrated by children who go in costume from door to door begging treats or playing pranks.

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Yes indeed, and according to tradition, the evening before All Saints Day, known as All Hallows Eve, is the night when the sacred dead are remembered.

In some traditions, it is the one night of the year that spirits are allowed to roam free.

This tradition was adopted and gradually grew into our current traditions, wherein our own live goblins and ghosties roam free, begging treats in return for no tricks being played.

Lloyd Christmas profile image

Lloyd Christmas  says:
3 months ago

I can't believe how disgustingly cool the Witches fingers are, the hotdog mummies are really cute, brilliant Hub. I am not that great in the kitchen but i think i will try these. Thanks. i love Halloween.

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks so much, Lloyd Christmas - love your avatar, by the way. The hot dog mummies are a snap with refrigreator roll dough. Enjoy!

Mindfulness profile image

Mindfulness  says:
3 months ago

I was going to say that I love the Shortbread Witches Fingers but then I saw the next image and wow these are works of art! Great, great, great post. Wow!

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks so much, Mindfulness. I agree - the Wilton treats are fantastic!

Jozjoz profile image

Jozjoz  says:
3 months ago

These treats are so adorable, and creepy at the same time!ALL IN THE SPIRIT OF HALLOWEEN! :)

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks so much, Jozjoz. So nice to meet you - glad you like Halloween too.

HEATHERH91 profile image

HEATHERH91  says:
3 months ago

These are great. I have our annual Halloween party next week and was looking for a new creative idea. You gave me plenty to choose from. Thanks for the hub.

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks, HEATHERH91, glad I could help out. I'm sure your party will be great!

Zsuzsy Bee profile image

Zsuzsy Bee  says:
3 months ago

Another great hub. Love the pictures especially the witches fingers. Will make these for sure this Halloween.

regards Zsuzsy

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks so much ZsuZsy Bee - I am sure they will be much enjoyed! Cheers!

jbryant22  says:
3 months ago

Going to make some of this for sure. great hub.. thanks !

Margaret Morris profile image

Margaret Morris  says:
3 months ago

Nice hub and good ideas. Very creative. I noticed the picture of the finger cookies, which I've made a couple of times. They're satisfyingly gross.

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

jbryant22, glad you found something useful! Thanks for visiting.

Greetings, Margaret! I've met very few kids that didn't say "eeewww" and gobble them down!

Paid Surveys Online  says:
3 months ago

wow, the Shortbread Witches Fingers look so cool and creepy, lol. that's a great Halloween treat.

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks - I really appreciate your commenting, PSO.

majehe09 profile image

majehe09  says:
3 months ago

Love the treats and gift bag ideas. Must use them for my grandkids!

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Thanks so much - I'm really pleased you like the gift bags.

Enelle Lamb profile image

Enelle Lamb  says:
3 months ago

Don't think I could manage the cookies - at least not blindfolded LOL...

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
3 months ago

Hey, Enelle! Why blindfolded - they can't be that scary, lol!

tiffany and co  says:
2 months ago

hehe

samanthagardner profile image

samanthagardner  says:
2 months ago

Thank you for all the great ideas! My son will love some of these.

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
2 months ago

Greetings, samanthagardner. You are most welcome - glad you enjoyed the Hub.

jbryant22  says:
2 months ago

great ideas... Thanks for hub

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
2 months ago

You are most welcome, jbryant22!

Ladymermaid profile image

Ladymermaid  says:
2 months ago

Beautifully done...I love the little mummies!

Best wishes to you

Ladymermaid

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
2 months ago

Thanks, Ladymermaid. The mummies are my fav, too!

Deborah-Lynn profile image

Deborah-Lynn  says:
2 months ago

Hub-Treats to you Redelf, love the witches finger cookies, and the paperbag brooms, a great addition to our family neighborhood gathering! I made sure to rate this one UP!

Manatoba  says:
2 months ago

I like the cookies!

usauthor profile image

usauthor  says:
2 months ago

yummy mummies.... looks delicious!

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
2 months ago

Thanks so much Deborah-Lynn! So glad you enjoyed this. Hub treats to you, too.

Greetings, Manatoba! So glad you liked the cookies.

Welcome, usauthor. I love them too! Thanks so much.

Lisa HW profile image

Lisa HW  says:
2 months ago

Great Hub and great ideas. These are all adorable (except, of course, for the unpleasant witch fingers - but to each own own).

Lee Thacker profile image

Lee Thacker  says:
2 months ago

I like the way your brain thinks, makes me feel alive listening to what your thinking, very cool...Keep it up ...PS Now I Know Why I bookmarked your page ;-) ...Hope you are doing well,

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
2 months ago

Thanks, Lisa. Glad you enjoyed everything (except the witches fingers).

Greetings, Lee - thanks so much. Always nice to meet someone new - and thanks so much. I often put people to sleep, or so I'm told, LOL.

Craftsmith profile image

Craftsmith  says:
2 months ago

Witches fingers almost look real and really scary. Great hub !!

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
2 months ago

Thanks so much, Craftsmith. They are pretty great. The kids really love to crunch them up - especially those 8 or 9 years old.

ianbrad55 profile image

ianbrad55  says:
2 months ago

hot dog mummies are so cute!

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
2 months ago

Greetings, ianbrad55! I like them too!

eyeofh profile image

eyeofh  says:
4 weeks ago

Very nice hub! My daughter (5) loves to cook and she is going to love this...especially the shortbread witches fingers!

RedElf profile image

RedElf  says:
4 weeks ago

Greetings, eyeofh! They are great fun to make - I hope she enjoys them!

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working