create your own

Schools Going to a 4-Day Week

79
rate or flag this page

By JanieWrites


Shortened School Weeks

 There are many reasons to shorten the traditional school week, most of them related to budgets and facility use. From a school administrator's point of view a four-day school week makes sense in these days of budget shortfalls, but is this really the best solution for our children and their teachers? I am a grandparent of a first grader (she lives with me so I am involved in her daily schooling issues). I am also a member of the Board of Directors for her school (a small charter school district with 2 schools). I am also a teacher in the local community college down the road as well as a faculty trainer for faculty in elementary, secondary as well as post-secondary schools, both public and private.

From a parent's point of view:
The first thing that comes to mind is the extra day care costs involved with having an elementary school student home one day a week while parents are at work. This could strain already tight budgets. The next thing to consider is the legislative requirement that schools be open 180 days a year. A four-day school week would extend the normal school year from 36 weeks to 45 weeks a year. This could cause some scheduling problems with family vacations, etc. Or it could make it somewhat easier for the parents as they would now only need day care 7 weeks a year instead of 16 weeks. Summer vacation would become much shorter, especially with Spring, Fall, and Winter breaks. (school districts already on year-round calendars would have to make adjustments, too.) It could end up being a wash on day care costs, but would create scheduling problems at the same time.

From a teacher's point of view:
Teachers would like this for a number of reasons. They are already overworked with unpaid lunch room and playground duties on top of their teaching duties, An extra day a week for working on lesson plans would benefit them. It would also give them a day to do personal errands, schedule doctor appointments, etc. so they did not have to take time off their regular teaching schedule to do these kinds of things. Payroll would be adjusted to cover the longer contracts, resulting in lower paychecks, but more of them, something the teachers may or may not like. 

From an administrator's point of view:
The administrator would probably be the one who would benefit the most. The school would be closed one day a week - thus eliminating any overhead costs for one day a week, which could result in huge savings for the school. BUT, the school would have to be open longer (45 weeks instead of 36 weeks) so in the long run, it might cost even more in overhead. The teacher's salary should not change as they would still be teaching the 180 days required each school year -- they would just do it in 45 weeks instead of 36. This might result in some monthly savings on taxes, etc, but an overall savings would be negligible.

In Conclusion
As I wrote this, I came to the conclusion that it would probably not be a benefit to anyone to shorten the school week to four days, There are too many variables to consider, and it would cost too much money to implement such a plan. Does anyone else have any ideas on this topic?

 


Print   —   Rate it:  up  down  flag this hub

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Pete Maida profile image

Pete Maida  says:
8 months ago

I agree. I don't see how a four day week would benefit if schools are still required to be open for 180 days. It seems to mess up everyone's scedule for no good reason.

IslandVoice profile image

IslandVoice  says:
8 months ago

I can see what this will do to my daughter's life and schedule. We'll probably be called in to baby sit more, ooh! That sucks!

Three-Legged Dog profile image

Three-Legged Dog  says:
8 months ago

I saw on the news that several schools in Colorado are already doing this, mostly to save on transportation costs from keeping their school buses going!

With all of the budget cuts everywhere, there's always rumors of ways districts will try to cut costs and although I won't believe it until it happens in my area, I was just curious about both sides of the idea.

Great pov's, though. Especially the point about teachers being able to schedule doctor's appointments... haha. Something other people might not consider, but it's nearly impossible to always get the last appointment of the day, or at least one after 3:30 when the school day has ended!!! And I hate having to miss a day of school unless I'm really, terribly ill and contagious!

Raven King profile image

Raven King  says:
8 months ago

They are considering the 4 day school week here in Nevada too. I am not sure if it will pass. I had been wondering about the pros and cons and it seems like an unlikely solution.

Good hub!

JanieWrites profile image

JanieWrites  says:
8 months ago

It will be interesting to see if it does pass -- and how it works if it does.

Tom Rubenoff profile image

Tom Rubenoff  says:
8 months ago

I love a good analytical essay - and who betta to write one than you? Very nice read and food for thought.

JanieWrites profile image

JanieWrites  says:
8 months ago

Thanks, Tom!

mulberry1 profile image

mulberry1  says:
6 months ago

As you point out there are some pros but (and keep in mind I have no kids or grandkids) I wouldn't personally think a 4 day week is the best option either. I think a long summer break allows kids a time to just be kids. I would think the costs of running the facilities through the summer would increase too.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working