Selling out Health Care Reform to the Insurance Industry
68It's a drag being sick without health care!
Books on Amazon!
|
Health Care in America: Separate and Unequal
Price: $28.99
List Price: $29.95 |
|
Health Care Reform Now!: A Prescription for Change
Price: $9.25
List Price: $27.95 |
|
|
The Healing of America: A Global Quest for Better, Cheaper, and Fairer Health Care
Price: $14.06
List Price: $25.95 |
|
FRONTLINE: Sick Around America
Price: $13.49
List Price: $24.99 |
|
|
Howard Dean's Prescription for Real Healthcare Reform: How We Can Achieve Affordable Medical Care for Every American and Make Our Jobs Safer
Price: $5.53
List Price: $12.95 |
"Exercise freaks ... are the ones putting stress on the health care system." —Rush Limbaugh, June 12, 2009
The forever brave Dennis Kucinich nailed it, “Is this the best we can do?”
Dennis Kucinich always tells it like it is, “Providing health care to all Americans is the moral responsibility of our government, consistent with the Preamble in the Constitution. Yet we are being told that it is not possible to have the kind of single payer health system which every industrialized democracy in the world has.
“We compromised on single payer by backing a public option, and now we are being asked to compromise the public option with negotiated rates. In conference, we will likely be asked to compromise negotiated rates with a trigger. In each and every step of the health care debate, the insurance companies have won. If they get hundreds of billions of dollars in new taxpayer subsidies, they get to raise their premiums, and increase their co pays and deductibles, while the public is forced to pay for private insurance, then the insurance companies win big.
If this is the best we can do, then it is time to ask ourselves whether the two-party system is truly capable of representing the American people or whether the system has been so compromised by special interests that we can’t even protect the health of our own people. This is a moment of truth for the Democratic Party. Will we stand for the people or the insurance companies?”
I think Kucinich has followed the money—Democrats have lost control of the health care issue, failed to stand up for the American people, and caved in to the pressure of their largest contributors, the insurance industry.
Where's the Real Change we can Believe in?
What is the public option?
A public option is simply a government run plan that would create competition in the marketplace and offer Americans alternative health care options. Of course the insurance companies are fighting to continue monopolizing an industry that now has power over who gets health care—they determine who lives or dies. The public option could be a monopoly-buster.
Since when is competition un-American?
Who opposes the public option?
"What we have to do today is make a covenant, to slit our wrists, be blood brothers on this thing. This will not pass. We will do whatever it takes." –Rep. Michele Bachmann
There is some fear because in the House bill, there is counseling for end-of-life. And from that standpoint, you have every right to fear. ... We should not have a government program that determines if you're going to pull the plug on grandma." —Sen. Chuck
"We're gonna have a government rationing body that tells women with breast cancer, 'You're dead.' It's a death sentence." —FOX News Channel's Sean Hannity, June 19, 2009
Conservative Democrats; Independent turned Republican Joe Lieberman—the Senator from Aetna; the Bluedogs; and the usual obstructionist Republicans, owned by the insurance industry, have been fighting against a public option and meaningful healthcare reform as if they’re trying to stop the sky from falling on their best buddies in the insurance industries whose profits have skyrocketed in the last decade. Joe Lieberman says he’d just as soon give the good ol’ boys in the insurance industry a few more years to clean up their act and be a bit nicer in their dealings with the public before rushing into anything as rash as a government run health care program like Medicare. We have all the time in the world to give them the chance to be real patriots. Of course, Republicans fought Medicare every step of the way until it eventually passed, and now they spread misinformation to their constituents raising fears the pubic option will be the first step toward taking away the very Medicare they opposed.
I recently heard the Bluedog caucus managed to get a health care bill that will cost even more than the public option proposed by the house would have cost. It has a watered down public option that has been criticized by Progressives who favor a robust public option.
The Congressional Budget Office is now saying the government option will actually cost more than private insurance. Michele Bachman, Representative from Minnesota, is praising Joe Lieberman for fighting healthcare reform and standing up for what she calls “freedom.” Apparently her idea of “freedom” is giving insurance companies complete power over who deserves to live, who should be left to die, who should be covered, and who should remain uninsured. The reasonable and pro-public option Senator Tom Harkin from Iowa recently reminded Lieberman that he is only in his current role as head of Homeland Security due to the generosity of Democrats. Remember, he backed McCain and Palin in the last election and has been fighting the administration’s attempts at reform ever since. Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi have been dealing with resistance within their own party, while Kucinich calls out the naysayers, insisting the current bill simply fails in so many ways, it’s a gift to insurance companies. How could premiums in a public option cost more than premiums in the insurance companies?
I’m afraid we’re about to get a watered down version of health care reform that allows the insurance industry to continue price gouging, denying services, and raising rates whenever they feel like it. Our government has supported obscene profits for CEO's of health insurance companies in exchange for campaign contributions. Our representatives fight against a health care public option because they are recipients of the enormous campaign contributions from a “for profit” industry. We have been conned into fighting against our own best interests once again, told we shouldn’t have access to a public health care program like other people living in western democracies. Our representatives have used propaganda to frighten the people they are elected to serve into believing socialized medicine is communism, fascism, anti-freedom, and anti-American.
The real death squads spread anti-heath care reform propaganda
Anti-public option propaganda is calculated to spread fear that choice will raise the deficit, take health care decisions away from people and their doctors and give “Big Brother,” the power to pull the plug on grannies nationwide, tell old people they are too old to get a flu shot, and make us un-American Nazi fascists. Since when is fighting for the rights of everyday people to have health care un-American? When it threatens the obscene profits of the insurance monopolies.
Where is the real change we can believe in?
What is President Obama’s mission statement on health care, and why hasn’t he pushed forward a strong public option or Medicare, a single payer system, for everyone. Why does he seem more concerned with bipartisanship and getting buy-in from those whose agenda is to “just say no,” defend the unsatisfactory status quo, and work with groups who use their power to see his Presidency fail? I campaigned for the President, made phone calls and knocked on doors for real change—you know, the kind we can believe in. Along with other Obama supporters, I believe real change means real health care reform. We want major health care reform; we need major health care reform. Has the President actually stepped up to the plate in the spirit of the late Senator Kennedy? Do we even know where he stands? Has he been clear he will do everything in his power to support health care for every single American man, woman, and child? Has he thrown the full weight of his office against the corrupt insurance industry with carte blanche decision making power over who lives and who dies in America—the real death squads?
While Americans are lined up at free clinics, ending up in emergency rooms across the country for services that will cost them more for one visit than they make in a month, while uninsured Americans are fighting to get the insurance benefits they’ve paid for, while over 40 million Americans have no insurance, I say, “You are either with us or against us. You are either for us, or for the insurance companies.”
The French can afford to get sick!
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
hey kartika,
what a mess. like you, i voted for change, hoping things would be different. what a relief to have bush gone. yeah, right. everyone says give the guy time, he's only been in office six weeks, three months, four months, six months, almost a year now. still no change. hope, like my patience, wears thin.
and about liebermann, don't even get me going.
great job, kartika. again.
hi blue dog, it will be fascinating to see the outcome - we could use a miracle right about now! thanks for your comments!
I fear that the worst is yet to come. If change does come, it will come with many disgruntled Americans. Remember, we as a country were founded by traitors, rebels, and idealists. In the words of Jeff Lewbowski, "This will not stand, man!" (The Big Lewboski, directed by the Cohen Brothers).
Good point, dohn121! I hope this melting pot of traitors, rebels, and idealists wises up and starts supporting change that is in their best interest for a change! Too many people have fallen for the con game that you have to get screwed to be free! Best, Kartika
Hi and thanks. You know I simply can't understand it. Aren't there enough smart people in this country to see what's happening? One out every four people in Florida has no medical insurance of any kind. But no -- everything is working just fine, so many say. Last year 27,000 people died as a direct cause of not having access to simple check-ups, screenings, preventative care. That's twice as many as died from homocide, although if you ask me, it is homocide.
Great hub, if a bit depressing. I too voted for Obama, with the hope that he would represent US for a change. But I know, so far big business and lobbiest are still running the country. Are we giving up hope too soon? Or did we get our hopes up for nothing?
Hi Patrice, hope springs eternal, as they say! Obama is so much better than the previous nightmare, I'm thankful for that, but as you say big business and the lobbiests seem to still run the show - but the opposition is even scarier, I guess we are all waiting to see what the final health care bill is and then we'll be writing more hubs on the outcome! Kartika
Kartika, obviously, as a Brit, I'm not up to speed with everything that goes on in the States, but the other day I came across a mention of an independantly funded health-care access scheme which (apparently) by-passes the insurance companies. This was on the Ithaca Hours web-site BTW. Maybe that's the best way forward. Set up small, co-operative schemes on a community by community basis and when enough have sprung up they will supercede the insurance companies altogether. If government isn't taking the action the prople need, then the people must get more pro-active.
Amanda, thanks for leaving this comment - I'm really interested in this - fascinating - will check out the website ASAP! Best!
The Big Bad insurance companies average about a 2% profit margin. That means that spend 98% of their gross income on health care. How evil!
Well done kartika.
There is NOT a two party system in amerika kartika. There is, in fact, no government at all. There is instead a korporatocracy controlled by a small plutocratic ruling class. They have virtually taken complete control of what was once America and are not far from accomplishing the same globally.
The bankers, korporatists and politicians are all on the same team. The illusory political process is naught but a dog and pony show presented solely for the purpose of distracting the masses and keeping them divided.
“Fascism should more appropriately be called Corporatism because it is a merger of state and corporate power”
--Benito Mussolini
The information provided by Amanda is very significant. There seems to be a growing sub-culture that is simply refusing to participate in the consumer madness any more. The profit machine that now owns this country is pushing us into a corner and it seems to be waking some people up. Some but, obviously, not all.
"The men the American people admire most extravagantly are the most daring liars; the men they detest most violently are those who try to tell them the truth."
--H. L. Mencken
If enough people simply walk away from the system and start living and working together and actually behaving like human beings instead of consumer zombies, there may be some hope yet for the future.
CWB, yes, we are the united states of corporations! With a Democratic president and congress who's trying to get permission from Olympia Snow for health care reform, I'm afraid it's time to face this inconvenient truth!
“Fascism should more appropriately be called Corporatism because it is a merger of state and corporate power”
--Benito Mussolini
This is right on, I'm afraid, and is the sad state of our current affairs. I think many of us really believed we were about to have real change and now we see how truly entrenched we are in corporate America.
We are as you say, a nation comprised of many who have no time to think and lack the ability to think critically and sadly, are pawns in the game and continue to support the system that exploits us all. As long as these people support the powers that are hurting them, we are all held back and these obstructionists of change keep us locked in a toxic status quo. I'm sure we will be continuing this conversation another day! Thanks for your comments!


















lmmartin says:
2 months ago
Hey, great hub. I'm currently working on one about health care myself triggered by a couple of comments left on my these foolish things hub. The arrogance of some just floors me. I am not surprised in the slightest. It was doomed from the beginning. How sad. Look for my new hub when I get it finished. It's requiring a lot of research. And check out the comment left on that hub these foolish things -- and the answer by pgrundy, and my own.
Oh and case I forgot -- great job. And by the way, Canadians can afford to get sick, too.