create your own

Should you opt for a Real or an Artificial Christmas Tree?

87
rate or flag this page

By ethel smith

Artificial Christmas Trees have come a long way in recent years.


Just one variety of a real Christmas Tree
Just one variety of a real Christmas Tree

 

Having been married for nearly 37 years we have had various Christmas trees over the years.Sometimes the smallest tree can be the most memorable. This was certainly true of our childhood Christmas Tree. Tiny and unpretentious it may have been but it still has a special place in my Christmas memories half a century later.

Artificial and Real Christmas Trees are both great in their own ways but you need to find the perfect tree for you and your circumstances.

Here are some tips, and pros and cons which may help you decide which is right for YOU.


As I have already said Real and Artificial Christmas Trees both have pros and cons. It will inevitably be down to personal choice. Here are some hints and tips, as well as a few pros and cons, which may help you choose the right tree for you.

REAL CHRISTMAS TREES

Negatives

  • Real trees can be expensive
  • They are often only used for one Christmas
  • Real trees sometimes drop lots of needles
  • They can be a pain, in lots of ways.
  • They may be sharp when you are decorating the tree.
  • Depending on the retailer your real tree may not be environmentally friendly
  • Disposal after Christmas
  • Occasional allergic reactions
  • Not everyone loves the smell.
  • Choosing the best tree.
  • Transporting your tree home.

Positives

  • Traditional
  • Smell very seasonal.
  • Individual
  • Authentic
  • Can look great
  • Help the atmosphere in your home.

Still Fancy a real Christmas Tree?

Many years ago when we had real trees we would always buy them locally. Hubby and I would trudge out, no matter what the weather or size of tree, and walking, carry our Christmas Tree home. In some ways it was fun and part of our Christmas festivities. Inevitably though tempers would fray and we would both get stabbed with the pine needles. By the time we arrived home we would be covered with pine needles. So if you really want a Real Tree check out delivery options when you purchase. If you transport the tree in your own vehicle be prepared to find pine needles in your vehicle well into the New Year.In fact maybe even in the summer.

This may also be true of your home especially if you still have carpets around your home.

Try wearing thin cotton gloves when you decorate your tree in order to prevent scratches and pricks.

Make sure that your tree has a regular supply of water through the Christmas period to prevent it drying out.

Shop around and research for the best price and the variety of tree which will last the longest.

Consider buying a tree that can be planted out into your garden once Christmas has gone for another year.

ARTIFICIAL CHRISTMAS TREES

Negatives

  • Some look very artificial
  • No aroma
  • Initially may seem expensive
  • Size may be regimented.

Positives.

  • These days there is so much choice. Black, silver or green trees are just a small example of those available.
  • Good value in the long run.
  • Will last for years.
  • Do not need to shop for a new tree each year.
  • No messy pine needles
  • Do not have to dispose of each year
  • Easy to store and assemble
  • Easier to decorate.

Artificial trees have come a long way in recent years. There are so many colours and sizes to choose from. There are even upside down trees for those who have little space and want to be a different. Some are already decorated or incorporate lights.

If money is tight consider buying an artificial tree that is pre-lit and already decorated. You can save up to buy a more expensive tree in a few years time.

Buy your tree on-line in order to get the best value and have your artificial tree delivered to your door.

Remember that a classic artificial Christmas tree may have more longevity. Fashions change and if you opt for a contemporary black tree it may look hideous in a couple of years time.


Environmentally friendly tips

  • Celebrating Christmas in a Foreign Land

    In my whole life (so far, all 34 years of it), I have spent just one Christmas in another country. That was in the last quarter of 2004. I was one of the lucky ones chosen by my former employer to... - 6 weeks ago

  • How and Why Do We Decorate Christmas Trees

    Christmas tree is an icon of celebration. Christmas decorations are never complete without a well ornamented Christmas tree. The kids and grownups are all fascinated by Christmas trees. Almost... - 6 weeks ago

  • Free Christmas! A Christmas Gift Idea For Families On A Tight Budget

    My wife Christy is the sweetest, most loving person I know. She lives for Christmas every year, and when I say she lives for Christmas, I mean that boxes, and boxes, and boxes of Christmas... - 2 months ago

  • White Christmas - A Carol that Evokes Fond Visions of Christmas and Snow Everywhere

    Having grown up in upstate New York, I have always believed that Christmas and snow go together. Not that Rochester, New York, my hometown, is known for white Christmases. Cold and overcast is... - 6 weeks ago

  • Tips for Decorating a Christmas Tree

    When decorating a Christmas tree, you'll find that it really becomes a challenge to create a tree that is going to be pleasing to the eye versus a complete eye sore. You want a Christmas tree that... - 2 months ago

  • How We Celebrate Christmas in the Philippines

    Being a predominantly Catholic nation, Christmas is our most celebrated holiday. Traditions abound in various parts of our country during this time. This is the time when Filipinos working in... - 2 months ago

  • Christmas Gifts In A Jar

    Christmas Gifts in a Jar are fun, unique and an economical gift to give. Gifts in a jar are great gifts for anyone in your family, your friends, teachers, Sunday school teachers and those hard... - 6 weeks ago

  • Christmas Crackers

    Cracker is a cardboard tube covered in a brightly colored twist of paper, creates a small explosive 'pop' produced by a narrow strip of chemically impregnated paper. Invented by Tom Smith,from London... - 2 months ago

Well what will it be for you?

Will you opt for a real or an artificial Christmas tree.

  • Real
  • Artificial
  • Don't have a Christmas Tree
  • Both
See results without voting

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Hello, hello, profile image

Hello, hello,  says:
6 weeks ago

I think this question pops up every year like Christmas. I still love a real one. The very smell of it. Thanks for the hub.

Amanda Severn profile image

Amanda Severn  says:
6 weeks ago

We used to have a real one growing in a pot, but it gave up the ghost after a few years, and now we have an artificial one. I don't know which is best from an environmental perspective. Obviously an artificial tree is not easily recycled and will almost inevitably end up in landfill, but we're likely to use our tree for a few more years, whereas the real trees can be a pain to dispose of, and generally only last one Christmas.

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith  says:
6 weeks ago

Thanks for the visit hello and amanda. I guess a good artificial tree can last up to 20 years but as you say sooner or later you will have to buy a new one.

I am considering a real tree this year but have not quite decided yet. With two dogs wagging their tails all over the place the needles will go everywhere.

Danielle Farrow profile image

Danielle Farrow  says:
6 weeks ago

We sometimes consider an artificial tree, but always go for a real one - the smell plays a strong part here, and nostalgia / sense of tradition.

We keep a damp cloth wrapped round the base, which does well, and the council arranges pickup for real trees after 12th Night, so there's no problem there for us.

Size varies, though - sometimes a smaller one on a table. We like to go for a walk around the block and see our tree from the Mews behind our terrace - one of our many Xmas traditions. :)

Not always fun trying to get rid of all greenery before end of 12th Night, though, as superstition requires! LOL

Well, you've actually got me in a Xmassy mood - that's not supposed to happen till after my birthday!!!

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith  says:
6 weeks ago

Thanks for your input Danielle. Have a very early birthday wish then :)

Lee Thacker profile image

Lee Thacker  says:
5 weeks ago

REAL!!! :) Wow! You really put a lot of thought and positive thought into your hub article! Honestly I think I need to re-read it again to pick-up all the gems that you shared, as always...THANKS! Keep writing...you know I'm a fan!

tonymac04 profile image

tonymac04  says:
5 weeks ago

Aesthetically I would go for a real one, but I wonder about cutting down a tree for a short time.

Environmentally I also have problems with the artificial sort because they are definitely not environmentally friendly!

I think actually I would prefer not to have a tree at all if it were up to me - but I have a wife and child to contend with in this regard! They won't let me not have a tree, so we have an artificial one!

Love and peace

Tony

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith  says:
5 weeks ago

Thanks Lee :)

No Christmas Tree Tony!! Whatever next lol

Peggy W profile image

Peggy W  says:
5 weeks ago

We have had both through the years and now just put out smaller seasonal decorations. No big trees for us anymore. Still pretty and SO MUCH EASIER! One of the real trees that we used for years was a potted Norfolk Pine tree. Each year as it grew we added a few more small ornaments.

In our area we have pre-arranged dump sites (generally in parks near a parking area) where real Christmas trees can be placed. They are then transported to the coast where they are dumped along the beach. Sand collects in them helping to preserve the sand dune areas thereby helping the environment at the same time. Some people take advantage...and others just put their trees out by the curb to be picked up by the garbage collectors. Too bad they don't all avail themselves of this easy way to recycle.

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith  says:
5 weeks ago

It sure is Peggy. Thanks for dropping by.

apricot profile image

apricot  says:
2 days ago

Ah! The scent of a real Christmas tree! It's the most beautiful thing - they do so say smell is the most evocative of all the scent and I can believe it! I would plump for the real one every time but I've had to change to beech twigs now as my rabbit would munch away at a real tree and they're poisonous for her. Sigh! But the scent of the Christmas tree..! I always got out of carrying home though as I was little - perhaps I wouldn't have such good memories if I had!

Nice hub!

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith  says:
2 days ago

Thanks apricot

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working