create your own

The 10 Greatest Race Horses of All Time

86
rate or flag this page

By JohnnyComeLately


Needless to say, this list represents one man's subjective opinions as to the greatest of all time, and the horses represented here are only those who have raced on American soil. Those who argue that many non-American horses deserve inclusion will get no argument from me. I've tried to include the very best of the best without regard to gender or racing surface. Great fillies like Personal Ensign and Ruffian did not make the list simply because I don't think that on their best day they could beat any of the horses on this list on their best days (see also my article about Rachel Alexandra, about whom I would say the same.)  Without further adieu, the 10 Greatest Race Horses of All Time:

  1. Secretariat - 16 wins from 21 starts. The greatest of the great, his triple crown campaign, during which he set official track records at Churchill Downs and Belmont Park, and an unofficial track record at Pimlico, will never be exceeded or even matched. Pity poor Sham, an outstanding race horse in his own right, who was a game second in the Kentucky Derby and Preakness before being annihilated with all the rest in Secretariat's incomparable Belmont Stakes win, during which he set a world record for 12 furlongs that still stands to this day.
  2. Man o' War - 20 wins from 21 starts. Man o' War was the first great race horse to really capture the public's imagination and raise horse racing in the public consciousness. His lone loss, ironically to a horse named Upset, came during his 2-year-old season in the 1919 but hardly mars an otherwise dominating career.
  3. Seattle Slew - 14 wins from 17 starts. Undefeated as a 2-year-old, Triple Crown winner at 3. His Kentucky Derby win, which came despite being rushed to the lead by Jean Cruguet after an awkward start, may be the greatest ever. Crushed Affirmed in their two meetings a Belmont Park in the fall of 1978.
  4. Spectacular Bid - 26 wins from 30 starts. Champion two and three-year old. Only denied a Triple Crown by a poorly judged ride in the Belmont Stakes by Ron Franklin. A threat to break the track record every time he stepped on the race track, his astonishing 1:57.4 in the 1980 Strub still stands as the record for 10 furlongs at Santa Anita
  5. Kelso - 39 wins from 63 starts. The only gelding on the list, "Mighty" Kelso, as he was inevitably described, was named Horse of the Year an incredible five times from 1960-1964, a feat that will surely never be matched. Perhaps not as consistent as others on this list, but his durability and willingness to take on all comers more than compensates.
  6. Native Dancer - 21 wins from 22 starts. Only a narrow loss to Dark Star after a rough trip in the 1953 Kentucky Derby blemishes an otherwise perfect career
  7. Dr. Fager - 18 wins from 22 starts. There's fast, faster, and Dr. Fager. Twice named champion sprinter, and once Horse of the Year, he was among the best from 7 furlongs to 1 1/4 miles.
  8. Miesque - 14 wins from 18 starts. The only filly, the only foreign-bred, and the only turf horse on this list, which says something about her greatness. 15 of her 16 starts came in Group 1 or Grade 1 races, but her crowning achievement is surely her back to back victories in the Breeders Cup Mile, both in utterly dominant style.
  9. Holly Bull - 13 wins from 16 starts. Brilliant, precocious, altogether the greatest horse of the 1990's (only Cigar can rival him). He might rank higher on this list if not for an unaccountably disastrous performance as the 2-1 favorite in the 1994 Kentucky Derby.
  10. Affirmed - 22 wins from 29 starts. His Triple Crown battles with Alydar will never by forgotten. His heart and intelligence combined with speed and stamina to make him one of the all time great champions. Beat Spectacular Bid in their only meeting, but was beaten handily by Seattle Slew in their two races.

Honorable Mentions: Sunday Silence, Easy Goer, Buckpasser, Ghostzapper, Count Fleet, War Admiral, Seabiscuit, Damascus, Cigar, Personal Ensign, Ruffian, Risen Star, John Henry, Swaps.

Other Horse Racing Articles By This Author:


Print   —   Rate it:  up  down  flag this hub

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

MrCoote123 profile image

MrCoote123  says:
6 months ago

Nice post. Made for entertaining reading!

Rinzou  says:
6 months ago

Ah yes, the seventies was the greatest decade in horse racing. I completely agree with your list.

Rinzou  says:
6 months ago

Wait a minute...are you crazy?? Where is CITATION?!?

JohnnyComeLately profile image

JohnnyComeLately  says:
6 months ago

Yes, I think you're right. Citation does belong on the list. Won 19 of 20 starts in an amazing three-year-old year. I would point out, though, that he beat a total of 15 horses on his way to the triple crown.

blue dog profile image

blue dog  says:
4 months ago

Citation, yes. At least an honorable mention for Forego, no?

teriscott profile image

teriscott  says:
4 months ago

Hmm...what about the Quarter Horses. My dad owned Old Doc King Bar back in the 60's. I was the proud owner of one of the grandson's of Easy Jet.

antony  says:
3 months ago

those are greats but what about shergar seabiscuit and even red rum who won 5 british grandnationals in a row and seabiscuit who beat man o wars son war admaral came back to win santa anita after a two year injury in doing so beat the defending champion sure secretariat great horse but seabiscuit i think only lost one race

Hoss  says:
3 months ago

How could the list possibly miss Citation?? He won the Kentucky Derby, 32 of 45 races in all, including 16 stakes races in a row!!

triplecrown  says:
3 months ago

Citation won 27 of 29, sixteen in a row at three including the Triple Crown. Citation was a 93% winner, Man O War 95%, and if he ran 29 he would have been a winner of 27 to 28 based upon perscentages. Secretariat lost 24% of his races. If you consider racing record, stud record together Man O War wins. Citation was ranked the best three year old ever by Eddie Arcaro, two time Triple Crown winner and the multiple time winner of all three triple crown races. I think all three horses were great in their own unique way, but Citation could be the best three year old ever as Arcaro said.

snibar  says:
2 months ago

Yes, but you also have to take into account background factors. Almost every time Secretariat lossed a race he was sick or had a mouth problem. You would be surprised what an impact mouth problems have on horses. I had a mare that could not outrun a cold blood until we took a few teeth out and then she won 50,000 in one year! Secretariat raced in some of the most competitive competition of all time. He raced with greats such as Riva Ridge, Dr. Fager, etc. Secretariat won the race which was considered to have the greatest compilation of race horses of all time. Man o' War never faced any of the greatest horses of his day. He never raced against Sir Barton or Exterminator. I don't doubt Man O' War was a great race horse, but he has always placed second in my mind because he never proved himself against other greats. Many of the people who had seen both Man O' War and Secretariat race called Secretariat the greatest race horse they had ever seen.

ruffian345 profile image

ruffian345  says:
2 months ago

ummm that great what you had as secratariet and i love what you did with the other horses that are honorable like ruffian and seabiscuit but you did leave out in secratairiet had a heart twice the normal size lol

lisakprice profile image

lisakprice  says:
2 months ago

Thank you so much for placing Ruffian on the Honorable Mention list. She has a special place in my heart.

Dean  says:
4 weeks ago

Some great champions in that list.

All were second though to Australia's champion Phar Lap.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working