create your own

The Best Martial Arts For Self Defense

89
rate or flag this page

By kephrira



Martial Arts Comparison

If you are thinking of taking up some kind of martial arts training then it is really important that you pick the right style for you. There are literally hundreds of different martial arts around, and they all have different qualities, strengths and weaknesses, and suit different people. Sometimes people will ask, what is the best martial art? But the fact is that there is no answer to this question, because the best one will depend on the kind of person you are and what you hope to get out of your training. There many different reasons to begin training in a martial art, from sport and competition, to health and fitness, to improving confidence, discipline and self control, but the one that I want to concentrate on here is self defense. But even if you refine the question to the one in the title of this hub - what is the best martial art for self defense - there still isn't a single answer, so to be fair and accurate whilst giving visitors to this page the information that they came here looking for what I am going to do is to go through a list of the most common martial arts and look at the pros and cons of that style for self defense, and what kind of person they might and might not suit,


MMA / Mixed Martial Arts

Mixed martial arts, abbreviated to MMA, is actually a combat sport, which began life pitting the practitioners of different martial arts styles against each other. But it has gained such popularity in recent years that there are now many dedicated MMA gyms which run classes teaching the particular mix of Jiujitsu and Muay Thai, with other bit and pieces thrown in, that has proved to be most successful for the majority of fighters in MMA fights.

Of all combat sports MMA is the closest to a real fight, starting out as it did as a 'no holds barred' fighting competition. But that doesn't mean that what works best in a cage fight necessarily works best in a street self defense situation. Although the kind of martial art taught at most MMA gyms will hold you in good stead if you ever need to use it to defend yourself, more so than other martial sports (like boxing for example) it is not ideal. For a more detailed article on why this is the case take a look at Why MMA Doesn't Work On The Street, publised on the street-fighting-techniques.info blog.


Kung Fu

Kung Fu is actually the most difficult one to asses, because there is a huge variety in the different styles and traditions. In actual fact kung fu is not a martial art at all, but a name which is given to any martial art from China, all of which share common elements, but have major differences to.

This variety is also the great strength of kung fu. Many styles of Chinese martial are developed with a particular end in mind, or a particular kind of person to whom they are best suited, rather than as a general purpose art for all people. So, for example, Wing Chun kung fu, one of the most popular styles in the west, was developed by a women to allow a smaller and physically weaker fighter to be able to beat larger and stronger opponents. So if you are either a women, or a short slim built man, then I would say that Wing Chun kung fu is the best martial art that you can do for self defense. If you are thinking of going to a kung fu class then it is well worth speaking to the instructor and doing some research on the internet before hand to find out about the particular style taught at that class. Here is a list of Kung Fu Styles


Jiu Jitsu

Jiujitsu has a heavy emphasise on grappling and on restraint techniques, rather than striking and so on. It is used by police and military trainers in many countries and is probably the ideal martial art for bouncers, security guards and so on.

Whether this is the best method of self defense for you probably depends on what kind  of situation you are most likely to find yourself in, and what kind of person you are. Someone with average or above average strength might find jiujitsu good against a lone mugger, or to deal with a drunken idiot that decides to have a pop at you. Grappling and restraint, however, are not ideal against multiple opponents, so if you are worried about gangs of neighbourhood youths attacking you then this may not be the best choice. Also you do need a certain amount of strength to be able to control people in this way, so smaller individuals may not have as much success with it.

Muay Thai

Muay Thai is another martial arts that is primarily a sport rather than a method of self defense, but a good class will include some self defense applications, and if you want a good balance between fitness and self defense then this may be the one for you.


Karate

As a traditional martial art, like kung fu, karate does have much more of an emphasis on self defense than many modern martial arts. One of the great things about karate is that most clubs do include plenty of sparring to give you a feel for what it is like to be in a real fight, as well as teaching you the traditional 'katas'. You are sure to get a good all round training from karate, and it is also very good for building both discipline and confidence, so if you  think of yourself as a bit of a wimp, or perhaps a bit of a coward, and you want to toughen up and learn how to look after yourself then karate is a good choice.


Taekwondo

The Korean martial art of Taekwondo is best known for its flashy kicking techniques. This can make it a high risk style of fighting in a real life situation, because big powerful kicks are very effective if they hit, but they are often easy to dodge and leave you dangerously open to a devastating counter attack. For these reasons most people would say that Taekwondo is perhaps not the best martial art for self defense. But showy techniques do have their place. When I was a young teenager, when the only martial arts I had done was a year or so of Judo, I was out with a friend when some older teenagers came over and tried to mug us. My friends did at lot of very impressive jumping spinning kicks into the air and then said o.k., lets have a fight then. They all ran away without a single punch begin thrown.


Krav Maga

This is a modern martial art developed by Israeli special forces by studying many different martial arts traditions and picking out what worked and throwing away the rest, so it is clearly a 'reality based' martial art to be used for self defense rather than sport. The only thing is that clearly the Israeli army face different challenges to the ordinary person in the street, so what they have created is very good indeed for defense against weapons attacks, but although it does also work very well for hand to hand fighting, it is perhaps not the best.


Ninjutsu

Another traditional martial art with a strong self defense component, ninjutsu, the martial art created by the ancient Ninja clans, is one of the most fluid and creative martial arts I have experienced. You probably will not get the military style drilling that you might expect from Karate, but ninjutsu can be very good at teaching you the principles of self defense and then how to apply them in your own way. So if standing in line doing the same simple drill over and over again doesn't appeal to you, then this could be an effective alternative.

Print   —   Rate it:  up  down  flag this hub

Ask a Question

Your Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Murilion profile image

Murilion  says:
6 months ago

I never heard the krav maga,before but once it is come from israel I think that is something should be inovated,but I hope they not using it to kill the son of gaza

selfdefenseclique profile image

selfdefenseclique  says:
5 months ago

great.... you have done a marvelous job. the ideas of learning self defense is really terrific. i am really impressed by your work.. good going all the best, keep it up

jrosemond profile image

jrosemond  says:
5 months ago

http://hubpages.com/hub/shorinryukarate hey if you dont mind could you take the poll on my hub i really would like to know what people think

Sam_Kenny  says:
5 months ago

great hub!! Its so informative and I learnt so much in just a few mins :)

dohn121 profile image

dohn121  says:
5 months ago

As a one time student of judo, I'm a bit hurt to you didn't shed light on it, as Royce Gracie did win the first two ever UFCs, that is until you know who took him down. But then I'll argue that Royce Gracie was past his prime by the time the big match took place.

kangro jack  says:
5 months ago

i think kung fu, karate, krav maga, and ninjutsi are the best.

Bbudoyono profile image

Bbudoyono  says:
4 months ago

Very impressive. Have you heard about Indonesian martial art called Pencak Silat ?

kephrira profile image

kephrira  says:
4 months ago

I've seen demonstrations of Pencak Silat and it looks very impressive, but I thought it was mainly stick fighting which is why I didn't include it here.

Craig  says:
4 months ago

The best martial arts is not the issue. If you are not willing to spend the time to master the art you are in you will always be wondering. You also have to find out who are the best sifu's in your area. I teach combat style Tai Chi, to me the best art in the world. But if you don't live near me in Las Vegas, you would have to learn it someplace else. Unfortunatly, there are few who teach it. If you are you can contact me at craig@drsoostraining.com

dawit  says:
4 months ago

my comment is that the best art for self defence is ,i don't want to compare but international taekwon-do is the best and effective when you do with brave teacher why i am say that i saw it in experiance . NOTICE- not world taekwon-do .they have same name but world taekwon-do is for show. so itf is the best and the other is AIKIDO .both art are effective for women and men so select good master and join one of them

smellypunks profile image

smellypunks  says:
3 months ago

I have just taken up Kung Fu and it is the best exercise I have ever done. I love it.

Jarn profile image

Jarn  says:
3 months ago

I find Pankration and Combat Sambo works best for me. It uses a good mix of leverage, striking, grappling, and joint breaks if you've got hip trouble and poor leg flexibility like me. The best part is that both forms were designed as military training before they were adapted for competition, so if you can find trainers who focus on the combat versions, it's about as close to practicing for life and death situations as you can get.

Robert  says:
3 months ago

I practice Drunken Monkey. It was taught to me in my youth by Shoalin Monks high in the Nepali Mountains. It requires concentration, strength, and flexibility. The only thing, it is embarrassing sometimes to go "eh-eh" like a monkey.

kephrira profile image

kephrira  says:
3 months ago

wow robert, you are very lucky to have some great teachers!

Robert Wary  says:
3 months ago

i practise karate and kungfu , but i dont know the effectiveness of karate as i find that it is not so good for self defense.

please advice me.

kephrira profile image

kephrira  says:
3 months ago

I guess it depends on finding a good dojo Robert, I haven't actually practiced Karate myself but from other people I've met I think that it can be effective if you have a good teacher.

John Ray  says:
2 months ago

Like craig said it takes a lot of time to get to the point where you can use a Martial Arts for self defense. The systems such as krav maga and Defendo are much more effective for self protection. They were designed specifically for teaching military personal hand to hand combat in the shortest and most effective way.

tksensei profile image

tksensei  says:
2 months ago

My two cents for freestyle wrestling, Japanese Kempo, and Taijiquan!

Martial Artist profile image

Martial Artist  says:
5 weeks ago

Good article, why did you leave out combat sambo?

johncheung profile image

johncheung  says:
5 weeks ago

Great Article. I feel that to be a complete street fight its best to combine kali, MMA/BJJ/Sambo/Freestyle Wrestling and Muay Thai

kephrira profile image

kephrira  says:
5 weeks ago

I guess I left out combat sambo cos its not very common and there are too many martial arts in the world to put hem all on one page so I just picked the most widely taught ones to include that most people would be able to find a class for. But feel free to post another comment about it to say why its good, or include a link to any hubs you've written about it.

Martial Artist profile image

Martial Artist  says:
4 weeks ago

Didn't think about it that way, you're right. No it's a good article..I'm not going to hijack your hub. Regards

andy  says:
4 weeks ago

hello i recently started kali an after looking into jkd have decided to start that as well gonna keep up kali though use the jkd concept why fight with hands an feet when you can fight with weapons check it out on wikpedia theres good advice for an martial art like use whats useful no rules sparring not kicking higher than the enemies waist cause its to far although it gos on to say if u see an opening well wish me luck anyway i use do thai boxing an am definatly gonna use the hooks an low kicks from that but anyway although i hav,nt started it jkd looks like the best cause theres no bullshit just fight an win as quickly as possible with as bruce lee put it no flowery techniques which look nice but are pointless check out the kaia master against the mma fighter on youtube

The_wise_fool   says:
3 weeks ago

Think Japanese, traditional ju-jitsu, judo, karate. These are the best self defense martial arts. In this day and age its all about combining arts, one just is not enough to learn such skills. I pratice shodokan karate and traditional ju-jitsu. MMA fighters dont have a look in and as for street punks there just asking for pain !!

rahul  says:
3 days ago

kalari is the best

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working