create your own

The Cardiff Giant - the Greatest Hoax of All Time

82
rate or flag this page

By Dolores Monet


The Cardiff Giant


One lazy summer afternoon in upstate New York, my family visited the Farmers' Museum in Cooperstown. We strolled past the barn and into the museum itself. We saw an old loom where a woman demonstrated that skill of yesteryear; a butter churn and other features of past domestic arts. Then, wandering on, I heard my husband call me in an excited whisper - the kind of whisper elicited by awe, the whisper that seems louder than a shout, the one that say's, 'come quick!'

I rounded the wall to enter a dimly lit room. And there, my heart caught with the shock of spotting one of the famous celebrities of my youth - ridiculous, mysterious, and somehow beautiful. It was the Cardiff Giant!


In the 19th century, shortly after the end of the Civil War, an atheist named George Hull got into an argument with a fundamentalist minister named Turk.

Turk believed in a literal interpretation of the Bible. He did not believe in metaphor, or allegory, or explanations based on partially unknown factors. He did not believe that Bible stories became confused over the years, or exaggerated, or that translations may not have been exact. He insisted that a race of giants once roamed the Earth.

Hull thought that the idea of giants (also reported in other ancient tales) was absurd. His disbelief led to inspiration.


In 1868, George Hull hired some stone cutters to chop a hunk of gypsum into the rough shape of a very large man. He then moved the stone and hired a German sculptor to carve the human likeness of a giant. The stone man was artificially aged by the application of corrosive liquids, then beat with knitting needles.

Next, Hull transported his stone man to the farm of his cousin, William C. Newell. The stone statue was buried on Newell's property in Cardiff, New York and left to age in the ground for one year.

On October 16, 1869, men hired to dig a well in a specific location on Newell's land, discovered something very unusual. It was a petrified giant!

Despite the lack of sophisticated communication devices, word travelled fast. Before long, neighbors and local residents swarmed to the Newell place for a look at the remarkable discovery. Newell charged inquisitive visitors 10 cents a peek. It was a sensation! At the height of the Cardiff Giant craze, Newell hosted 500 people a day.

They came in carriages, and omnibuses from the city. They loaded themselves into lumber wagons. They coughed up 2 bits when Newell raised the price. Eventually, the gawkers who loved the Cardiff Giant earned the cousins $30,000.00. A lot of money in those days.


A syndicate form Syracuse led by David Hannom offered over $35,000.00 to purchase the Cardiff Giant. The offer was accepted.

Moved to Syracuse, a city with a more sophisticated populace, the Cardiff Giant became an object of doubt. Someone noticed chisel marks. A Yale paleontologist called the Cardiff Giant 'humbug.' And Newell and Hull admitted to the hoax.

But people still wanted to see the Giant, who had, after all, been a huge sensation. The famous showman,  P.T. Barnum offered $60,000.00 for the Cardiff Giant but was rebuffed. Barnum then commissioned a plaster replica to display, and claimed that his was the real Cardiff Giant. Hannon was mad. The two hurled suits and counter-suits at one another until a wise judge decided that since they were both fake, any suit was irrelevant.

In a snit over the behavior and practices of P.T. Barnum, Hannom uttered the famous phrase 'there's a sucker born every minute,' which is so often attributed to Barnum.


P. T. Barnum: America's Greatest Showman P. T. Barnum: America's Greatest Showman
Price: $28.98
List Price: $45.00
The Colossal P. T. Barnum Reader: NOTHING ELSE LIKE IT IN THE UNIVERSE The Colossal P. T. Barnum Reader: NOTHING ELSE LIKE IT IN THE UNIVERSE
Price: $12.72
List Price: $19.95
P. T. Barnum P. T. Barnum
Price: $2.62
List Price: $6.99
The Art of Money Getting (Webster's Spanish Thesaurus Edition) The Art of Money Getting (Webster's Spanish Thesaurus Edition)
Price: $16.95
List Price: $16.95
The Life of P.t. Barnum The Life of P.t. Barnum
Price: $27.14
List Price: $27.14
P.T. Barnum: The Legend and the Man P.T. Barnum: The Legend and the Man
Price: $23.85
List Price: $29.50

The Cardiff Giant Lives On

In 1870, Mark Twain penned 'A Ghost Story,' which featured the Cardiff Giant.

Shortly after, L. Frank Baum wrote a poem called, 'The True Origin of the Cardiff Giant,' in which he tells the story of how the Cardiff Giant jumped ship against the advice of Noah.

The Cardiff Giant also appeared in Stephen King's 'From a Buick 8.'

The Cardiff Giant was passed around, sold and resold. He was a flop at the 1901 Pan American Exposition in Buffalo, New York.

Eventually, the Cardiff Giant was purchased by the New York State Historical Association and in May of 1948, moved to the Farmers' Museum in Cooperstown where he can be seen today, and where he is still a sensation. At least for me.

Farmers' Museum

5775 State Highway 80

Cooperstown, New York 13326












Pan American Expostion 1901 Illuminated


Young Mark Twain by Matthew Brady

(US Library of Congress)
(US Library of Congress)

From a Buick 8 From a Buick 8
Price: $0.97
List Price: $7.99
From a Buick 8 (AUDIOBOOK) (CD) From a Buick 8 (AUDIOBOOK) (CD)
Price: $222.00
Weird New York Weird New York
Price: $10.80
List Price: $19.95
Off the Beaten (Subway) Track: New York City's Best Unusual Attractions Off the Beaten (Subway) Track: New York City's Best Unusual Attractions
Price: $11.43
List Price: $16.95

Maybe Turk Knew What He Was Talking About

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

dohn121 profile image

dohn121  says:
6 weeks ago

I remember hearing about the Cardiff Giant years ago and although I read just about every Stephen King book, I have yet to read, "From a Buick 8" for some reason (I really liked his older works more). I remember P.T. Barnum's "Pet Rock" that was a huge hit. I wonder what trickery he'd unleash today were he alive?

Tatjana-Mihaela profile image

Tatjana-Mihaela  says:
6 weeks ago

You wrote this story on so interesting way.

But I am very courious about giant skeletons in India, they do not see to be fake.

Thank you for this Hub.

juneaukid profile image

juneaukid  says:
6 weeks ago

This article was very well written with a good bit of literary history as well as the history of a hoax.

Lisa Luv profile image

Lisa Luv  says:
6 weeks ago

Very Interesting, and yes very well written=)

Olive P  says:
6 weeks ago

Never heard of the giant until now. Good story, well written. Loved the history behind it all. And to think it resides in Cooperstown.

Hmrjmr1 profile image

Hmrjmr1  says:
6 weeks ago

Great Job! Enjoyed the read...

Dolores Monet profile image

Dolores Monet  says:
6 weeks ago

dohn, I think the Stephen King book, From a Buick 8 is an old one. Maybe you just don't see it around anymore. I seem to remember seeing PT Barnum's 2 headed calf too. Those were the days. Glad you stopped by.

Tatjana, while looking around for some more information on the Cardiff Giant, I bumped into the giant skeletons in India. I have no idea what they are all about. Thanks for commenting.

juneakid - I am glad you enjoyed the writing. I love all the old hoax stories. Thank you.

Thank you, Lisa Luv, I appreciate it!

Olive! You've never heard of the Cardiff Giant! I thought he was so famous! I almost had a heart attack when I saw him for real. He was quite popular in his day. Thanks!

Hmrjmr- Glad that you enjoyed the hub. It was great to share the Cardiff Giant with everyone.

habee profile image

habee  says:
6 weeks ago

Another thumbs up! Great story!

Nemingha profile image

Nemingha  says:
6 weeks ago

I had never heard of the Cardiff Giant before - excellent story!

Dolores Monet profile image

Dolores Monet  says:
6 weeks ago

habee - thanks for the thumbs and the comments. I'm glad you enjoyed meeting the Cardiff Giant.

Nemingha - I am so surprised. I thought everyone knew and loved the Cardiff Giant! I'm so glad to share. Thank you.

Catherine R profile image

Catherine R  says:
5 weeks ago

Well - this was news to me too. I have also never heard of the Cardiff Giant - maybe cos we are not Americans. I loved the story though. What a shame it is not so easy to make $30 000 these days!

Dolores Monet profile image

Dolores Monet  says:
5 weeks ago

Catherine - I don't know why I am surprised people have not heard of the Cardiff Giant, after all, this hoax was back in the 1860's. And, hey , $30,000 was a lot more money back then too! Thanks for stopping by.

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith  says:
4 weeks ago

Interesting and totally new subject hub to me. Thanks

Dolores Monet profile image

Dolores Monet  says:
4 weeks ago

Thanks, ethel. I've loved that old Cardiff Giant since I was a kid. He was quite the sensation way back when.

Gypsy Willow profile image

Gypsy Willow  says:
4 weeks ago

Hi Dolores, what an interesting story. It caught my attention as I was born in Cardiff, Wales. Quite a different place!

Dolores Monet profile image

Dolores Monet  says:
3 weeks ago

Gypsy - well, lots of places in New York are named after other places - Rome, Russia, Poland, Phoenecia, etc. Thanks for stopping by!

robie2 profile image

robie2  says:
3 weeks ago

Wonderful hub and well written too-- I've been to Cooperstown and the Farmer's Museum( which I liked a lot better than the Baseball Hall of Fame) and don't know how I missed the Cardiff Giant-- but I did. Thanks for a great read

Dolores Monet profile image

Dolores Monet  says:
3 weeks ago

robie - isn't it great up there? Such a wonderful area of the country. Anyway, the Cardiff Giant was really tucked away in a dark corner and very easy to miss. Sorry you missed it. They had PT Barnum's 2 headed calf as well.

Smireles profile image

Smireles  says:
3 weeks ago

Wonderful hub and videos. Thanks.

Dolores Monet profile image

Dolores Monet  says:
3 weeks ago

Glad that you enjoyed it, Smireles. Thank you for leaving a comment.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working