What To Do When Social Welfare Comes Calling
64It Usually Starts With A Visit
But this particular incident started with a phone call.
The social worker and I had met before so when she called I was not overly alarmed this time until she told me that they had received a report of domestic violence and she asked if I was able to talk.
That got my attention.
If you are being abused, what are you meant to tell them?
Naturally enough I denied the claim.
Then she told me she needed to speak to my at the time husband.
Now, if you suspect there is domestic abuse, why would you antagonise the person that you suspect of doing the abusing.? Wouldn't that just make him mad and then act out at the others in the house?
I tried subtley to dissuade her from doing that as I knew what the consequences would be but she was not to be deterred. She insisted on talking to the man himself.
So, I braved up and went to tell him that there was a call from Social Welfare on the phone and that they had a report of domestic violence and she wanted to speak to him.
His response was colourful and he asked me what I had told her. I told him that there was no problem that he just needed to go and talk to her.
He waited a while before going over to the phone and then walked out of the room with it so I couldn't hear.
When he came back I hesitantly asked her what they had discussed and he told me that he had told her to f#$% off.
Well, then it was interrogation time as I knew that it would be.
He asked me who I had been talking to and what I had said.
He quizzed me as to who I thought may have done this.
For him it was all about revenge. He was angry and he wanted to take it out on someone. I was the likely scapegoat as I was the one at hand.
One can only wonder why the Social Welfare dept whose job it is to help protect those who are unable to help themselves, would even consider putting an abused spouse in that kind of position.
They call and wind the spouse up by telling them of the allegation and then leave them to take it out on the very spouse that Social Welfare alleges that they are trying to protect.
Did they come to visit the next day to see if I was alright? No!
I don't get it. I didn't get it then and I still don't get it.
Who makes these rules up? Definitely not someone who has been on the receiving end of a hand or a boot or an object.
It bothers me cause I am sure that there are many women out there living in far more violent situations than I did and some of them may end up dead as the result of one of these phone calls.
I had to give them the names of three friends who had been in our home and knew us well and I had to pick carefully as I didn't want any of my close friends slipping up and telling her yes.
She also called my next door neighbours so I had that shame to live with too.
He was careful and never did it when others could see.
I paid for that phone call over and over again for a long time to come.
Finally after a couple of weeks we received a letter from the social welfare Department telling us that they could find no evidence of Domestic Abuse but they made a recommendation that my now ex-husband go for anger management (no shit!)
I hid that letter and never showed him. I sure didn't want a tangible reminder for him.
A While Later
Within the next 8 months, I had my husband arrested and charged with aggravated terrorising.
He pled guilty after the initial arraignment and I was happy about that as it meant that I did not have to go to court and face him again. The first time was hard enough.
I met up with the Social Worker who had made the phone call when I was down at the local Social Services Dept. so I stopped in and had a chat with her.
I asked her why they had to talk to the spouse and she replied that it was so they had a chance to defend themselves as it was a serious allegation.
I said, then if you suspect that they are already abusing the woman, why would you wind them up and leave the woman in the house to bear the brunt of his anger and she told me that it was the rules that they had.
She said, "You had denied that there was any abuse going on"
And I answered, "What the hell else could I have said? What were you going to do for me? You called me on the phone and ask me this and I am still there. If I had said Yes, what would you have done"
And she said, "Well then we would have had to do something".
I could have been dead, my children could have been dead by the time they had done something.
All I can say is that the people making the rules need to wake up.
If there is a suspected domestic violence case, then support systems should automatically be put in place to safeguard the woman and her children if any.
Not just a phone call that was destined to make the woman's life a nightmare for some time to come.
Related Titles
|
Why Does He Do That?: Inside the Minds of Angry and Controlling Men
Price: $7.36
List Price: $16.00 |
|
Black and Blue (True Stories Collection TV Movie)
Price: $4.98
List Price: $9.98 |
|
Healing the Trauma of Domestic Violence: A Workbook for Women (New Harbinger Self-Help Workbook)
Price: $13.51
List Price: $21.95 |
|
|
Surviving Domestic Violence: Voices of Women Who Broke Free
Price: $17.00
List Price: $17.95 |
Related Titles
|
|
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE / SEXUAL ASSAULT Awareness Bracelet
Current Bid: $6.50
|
|
|
Avon STOP Domestic Violence Bracelet & Necklace NEW
Current Bid: $9.99
|
|
|
1 Domestic Violence ANGEL AWARENESS RIBBON TOKEN COIN
Current Bid: $3.99
|
|
|
Stop Domestic Violence, Handouts And Homework
Current Bid: $9.23
|
|
|
NEW The Blood & Tears of Domestic Violence: A Surviv...
Current Bid: $14.99
|
|
|
NEW The True Face of Domestic Violence - Fandrick, Ron
Current Bid: $11.62
|
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
Lol. I read your first line and my heart stopped as I had just finished reading one of your hubs and I thought that you meant my hub was idiotic. Then I kept reading and figured out what you meant.
All this happened right here in the USA.
Thanks for stopping by Lissie, I am sure my heart will stop beating erratically any time now.
I don't know what makes some men feel the need to beat on women. As a man, I am ashamed for what others of my gender do.
What is it in the life of anyone that makes it necessary to exploit someone else?
Worse yet, what is up in the agencies that are supposed to HELP people? They often do more harm than good. When someone needs help, they are slow to respond. When you no longer need the help, they are there with smiles and hands outstreched, begging to help.
What can we do to make this better, Donna Lee? Has anyone started a movement to make changes? If so, maybe you can write a hub informing others of where to find REAL help when they need it.
This kind of situation is intolerable, Donna. It's very sad that some government agencies are more interested in protecting their own interests before taking care of the people they are designed to serve. I had a friend who was being abused by her husband. She was at a loss as to what she could do or where she could go for help. She was even fearful of going to a "safe house" because she felt sure it would infuriate him and that he would find her no matter where she went. I don't think this is uncommon. I believe the only way to resolve this is to put a public spotlight on this iissue. If there is not a support group for women who fear to leave their abusive husbands, there certainly should be. Thank you for spreading the word on the need to do something about victims of abuse.
I am afraid that part of the problem is that a lot of people adopt the "I don't want to get involved attitude". I can understand that they are maybe afraid for themselves but I have found that when a group band together, these so called brave and strong people that hurt others are not quite so brave and strong.
I have offered my services to Domestic Crisis to either house any woman who needs a place to stay but is afraid to go to a safe house and have also offered to give talks at schools or any groups where they wish to learn more about domestic violence.
I also will not turn my back on a friend who is in need. At this time, I think that is the best I can do. Change my corner of the world, one baby step at a time and hopefully others will do the same in theirs. Maybe one day all these corners will join together.
Thank you for your comments Jeff and William, appreciate the support.
wOW AM SAD THAT YOU WENT through so much my dear..I have a daughter that went through it too for several years...and I do understand the feelings of terror. As a Mother I went to classes to learn how to help her...but honestly they said to support her and the it was ultimately up to her. It was a very difficult situation for the family. And her children suffered too...
It is sad that the very laws that are for our protection hurt us....and we get lost in their stupid idiotic systems. I have had first hand experience with this through child care adoption area's. Discusting and poorly exicuted...My best to you and good that you are open and offer help..You are an Angel...G-Ma :o) hugs and prayers
Thanks G-Ma, appreciate the kind words.
donna,
I can only say, I am glad you are safe, and that he is out of your life. I can't even imagine the fear you must have lived with. Your courage to leave is applaudable. Stay strong, even in the midst of governmental blunders. Great information. Thanks.
Thank you In The Doghouse.
Same here Donna - I'm glad to see that you're safely out of that nightmare.
Personally, I can't envision what goes through a "Man's" head when he feels the need to strike out at his family. As I'm sitting here typing this I'm also watching my kids out of the corner of my eye and thinking to myself, "What could they ever possibly do to make me so angry?"
Nothing of course, but then I thought, "What could ever possibly be so bad in my life that I would take it out on them or my wife?" The answer of course is nothing.
We're so much more than just a family - we're friends and soul mates and we work together to solve our problems.
As to the absurdity of Social Services – back about 8 or 9 years ago I was in my office holding a small meeting. In glancing out the window I had a clear view of a man who had stopped his car in the middle of the street of beating the hell out of the woman with. There was blood everywhere – and it took all of 2 seconds for me to decide to step in, right wrong or indifferent.
To make a long story short I got him off his (wife it turned out to be, who was 7 months pregnant), and while two of my employees went to help the woman, he and I duked it out. I ended up getting arrested, the woman refused to press charges against her husband, but due to the laws in the state at the time, the police were allowed to arrest him as well.
After two months of lawyers, hearings and the usual B.S., the charges were dismissed. And then I got a visit from a Social Worker to check on the living conditions in my home. I guess I was fortunate to be single at the time and my housekeeper (who was mortified) was questioned by this gal.
In the end, the Social Worker, who was misinformed about my marital status couldn’t do anything, although she tried to intimidate me into anger management and counseling (do they get a kickback?) sheesh!
And then I read stories about Social Workers who just shuffle paperwork until some poor little kid goes missing.
Then I need anger management!
Stuff like that ticks me off too. It is just a job to some, it was nice of you to try and help the woman.
Incidently, it is his birthday today and I hope that he is spending his time in his cell reflecting on what he screwed up. I also hope that one of the other inmates remembers to give him a Birthday kiss. LOL.
Oh
My
God.
I can not believe that social worker put you in that kind of danger! WTF!! I'm glad you're out of that situation, that the felon is behind bars, and that you at least got to tell that social worker the situation she put you in.
I'm all for people geting a chance to defend themselves, but NOT at the risk of the victim. I realize the system is taxed for good, smart, quality welfare workers, and the few that exist have huge caseloads they can't possibly handle well. There are alot of things wrong with this situation. But damn, to call like that, and then leave you hanging, has got to be the dumbest thing I've ever heard!
Great Hub, Donna: Important, personal, and really well written. Thanks so much for sharing this. Good luck to you.
Thanks Veronica, I think my first words were OMG, WTF. Lol.
You are a brave and strong woman! Thank God you made it out alive along with your children. Social Services mess up so many times in this kind of situation. They should be trained in this sort of situation...its like dealing with a kidnapper. You have to gain their confidence until the victims are released. TG he is in jail for now. Let me know if you should ever need anything.
Thanks Cailin.
Donna Lee,
I just read this hub for the first time. You are a brave woman! It gives me alot more compassion for women I know that are in a similar position.
Keep fighting the good fight.
Tom
Thanks Tom.



















Lissie says:
2 years ago
Totally idiotic! And the Woman's Refugees in NZ don't even get government funding! You obviously have to get out first before you can take him to court or get any sort of retraining order