What is Plagiarism
74Plagiarism in the Middle Ages
Plagiarism is defined as stealing or passing off ideas or words without crediting the source (Merriam-Webster, Inc, n.d.). Plagiarism comes in many forms, the most obvious being not citing sources. A less obvious form of plagiarism occurs when sources are cited but plagiarism still exists. Understanding when citing references is not required is also an important skill. This article focuses on written words, but as the Clinton-Obama plagiarism charges (Cox, 2008, February 18) show, it also occurs in speech.
Rutgers University's Great Video on Plagiarism
Sources Are Not Cited
Copying someone else's work without giving any citation is possibly the worst and most obvious form of plagiarism. This seems to happen more frequently in the Internet era. The Internet makes it very easy for someone to find what they consider is an obscure article, copy it and call it their own. Many tools exist which can find this form of plagiarism easily. Many articles have been found on article websites without the courtesy of attributing the author. This is an egregious form of plagiarism.
Another common plagiarism technique occurs when an author takes a large amount of text and pastes it into their article. Proper paraphrasing takes an idea and restates it another way. This means using an existing idea or ideas in an original format. Paraphrasing does not contain any original thoughts or ideas. Northwestern University (2007) points out that even a properly paraphrased idea has to be attributed. Without this attribution paraphrasing is still plagiarism.
Many times an author will simply use fragments of different articles slightly changing the sentences. Again, this is plagiarism. The key point here is that the formatting and phrasing of the article is basically the same as the originals. A Similar form of plagiarism occurs when an author changes some key words to make the paper appear to be original.
A less obvious form of plagiarism occurs when an author paraphrases large portions of the paper. Paraphrases still need to be cited and correctly attributed. Depending on the project type, an author who uses his or her own work when the project requires original thought is also plagiarizing. Technically an author cannot plagiarize themselves so this is more a violation of a contract or classroom expectation.
Sources Are Cited
Several ways to plagiarize exist even though the sources have been properly cited. Sometimes this form of plagiarism is an oversight which should have been caught in the editing process, and other times this is a deliberate act to deceive the audience.
Forgetting a footnote or citation is a common source of unintentional plagiarism. Proper editing and proofreading should prevent this type of plagiarism from occurring. Using many of the computerized citation generation programs will all but eliminate forgotten citations.
An article which is close to 100% paraphrase or cited, can also be plagiarism. This is also an ethical problem since putting a byline on an article with absolutely no original content is deceiving the audience.
Attributing some ideas but not others is another form of deceit. Here the author is attributing certain parts of an article but not attributing other parts. This is almost never accidental since the author knows to attribute some parts and is purposely not citing others.
Links to Help Prevent Plagiarism
- Plagiarism.org : Learning Center : Plagiarism Definitions, Tips on avoiding Plagiarism, Guidelines f
Welcome to Plagiarism.org, the online resource for people concerned with the growing problem of internet plagiarism. This site is designed to provide the latest information on online plagiarism and explain how Turnitin and iThenticate are now being u - Turnitin
The worldwide standard in online plagiarism prevention, Turnitin helps educators and students take full advantage of the internet's educational potential. - EVE2 Plagiarism Detection for Teachers
EVE2 is a very powerful tool that allows professors and teachers at all levels of the education system to determine if students have plagiarized material from the World Wide Web. EVE2 accepts essays in plain text, Microsoft Word, and others. - Google Scholar
Submit distinctive phrases to see if they match any documents indexed by google. - Live Search
Submit distinctive phrases to see if they match any documents indexed by microsoft.
When Citations Are Not Needed
Attribution is not necessary when writing about personal experience, observation, or insight. Personal thought and conclusions are also exempt. If an experiment is involved, the results do not need citations. Personal work of art, including photos, recordings, and diagrams do not need credits (Purdue, n.d.).
Common knowledge and generally accepted facts usually do not need citations. Facts like "global warming is ruining the environment," even though controversial are still considered common knowledge. Historical documents and other public domain articles, while free to use and copy, still need to be cited.
Why Do Authors Plagiarize
Authors plagiarize for many reasons. The most common reason may be laziness. Not having to cite sources is much easier than having to go through the motions of citing and attributing someone else's work. Ignorance, while not an excuse, can also be blamed. Some cultures do not consider plagiarism and copying works from experts is a form of respect. As mentioned above, not proofreading and leaving out vital information is another reason. Waiting to last possible minute to finish the assignment can also lead to voluntary or involuntary plagiarism.
Preventing Plagiarism
Probably, the most important way to prevent plagiarism is through education. Educators need to make sure students understand what plagiarism is and how to cite references properly. Try to break assignments into smaller pieces this will allow the student adequate feedback before the final grade is submitted. Another tactic having a student turn in the research and an outline first. This forces a student to gather research and citations before they began writing. Other useful techniques have included peer critique, personalizing assignments, having a workshop on taking effective notes, and pointing students to various online tools.
Writers can educate themselves. Many websites exist which have examples and tests an author can take which explain plagiarism in more detail. Online research tools and community and university library staff, most of whom understand plagiarism and citations extremely well are great secondary resources.
Editors and proofreaders should not only understand the definition of plagiarism, but also how to reduce or prevent it. Have a sample sheet with specific examples and advertise the consequences of not properly attributing work. Set the tone at the start, plagiarism will not be acceptable under any circumstance. Refer new authors to case studies or possibly a workshop so that they understand what plagiarism is as well.
Conclusion
Plagiarism can be prevented simply by understanding the rules. Notwithstanding cultural differences, following the mantra of "when in doubt, cite it" goes a long way towards prevention of plagiarism. Educators can modify lesson plans and emphasize student awareness of plagiarism through exercises and examples. Many online resources are available for authors, and publishers can invest in commercial services to help detect plagiarism and educate authors.
References
Cox, A. M. (2008, February 18). Barack obama's "plagiarism" - swampland - time. Retrieved February 19, 2008, from http://www.time-blog.com/swampland/2008/02/barack_obamas_plagiarism.html.
Merriam-Webster, Inc. Plagiarized - definition from the merriam-webster online dictionary. Retrieved February 19, 2008, from http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/plagiarized.
Northwestern University. Avoiding plagiarism. Retrieved February 19, 2008, from http://www.writing.northwestern.edu/avoiding_plagiarism.html.
Purdue University. Avoiding plagiarism: is it plagiarism yet? - the owl at purdue. Retrieved February 19, 2008, from http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/589/02/.
Links to Plagiarism Resources
- UNLV Library Site
Tutorials, and resources for both students and instructors to avoid plagiarism. Also discusses the two most common academic formats, APA and MLA. There is also a citation generator for those who need it. - Avoiding Plagiarism - The OWL at Purdue
This is one of the top sites regarding plagiarism. Several sections for students (writers), instructors (editors), and an exercise to test your knowledge. - Plagiarism in Colleges in USA
Plagiarisms realities and legalities. Geared towards college professors, but relevant for any writer. - PlagiarismToday Website
This website targets webmasters and other copyright holders. It discusses online plagiarism and other new media issues. - Anti-Plagiarism Strategies
This article discusses strategies for preventing student plagiarism and detecting its occurrence. It is also useful for anyone interested in preventing and detecting plagiarism. See the reference to his book as well for more in depth coverage of plag - clarfying issues on plagiarism
Fun little animated tutorial on plagiarism. - Glatt Plagiarism Self-Detection Program (GPSD)
This is a free service to check your own writing. There is also a paid portion for those who want to check for plagiarism. - Plagiarism
Another good site with a great set of examples. - Duplication vs Plagiarism
There seems to be some confusion, especially in the community here at HubPages, as to what duplication really is. And to be quite honest, when you look at all the facts it can become quite confusing. All...
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down [flag this hub]
Comments
There are no real rules for citations. It depends on the format you are using. I happen to use APA because that is what my journal articles are usually written in.
You can hyperlink, but it is considered bad form to only have a link. The reason being is a website may not exist in the future. By having the full citation, the proper attribution is on the page. Ideally use a tool like zotero and capture the page in your offline library.
I have a couple of other hubs I am working on, but I will add citations on to my list.
There are no real rules for citations. It depends on the format you are using. I happen to use APA because that is what my journal articles are usually written in.
You can hyperlink, but it is considered bad form to only have a link. The reason being is a website may not exist in the future. By having the full citation, the proper attribution is on the page. Ideally use a tool like zotero and capture the page in your offline library.
I have a couple of other hubs I am working on, but I will add citations on to my list.
Good article.
It reminded me of an experience I had In my American lit class in college years ago when we were assigned to write a short paper on Emily Dickinson. I didn't have much time for the assignment and didn't have any particular inspirations for the assignment. So, after reading the Dickinson poems in the text I read the half page of material about her which appeared in the text just in front of her poems. I used that material as the basis of my short paper but didn't copy any sentences from it. Probably I paraphrased or rephrased a fair amount of it. A friend by the name of Brian Carmody also had trouble coming up with an inspiration for his paper. So, I told him that I got my ideas from the material in the text. Several days later at the beginning of a lecture the professor announced said "Someone had seen fit to submit work on the Dickinson assignment that was not his own." By then I'd forgotten about my suggestion to my friend Brian and I sweated until the end of the class when the papers were handed out. I got mine with a grade of B. However, Brian wasn't so fortunate. Apparently he had copied quite a bit of his paper straight out of our text book. He got an F on the paper and was lucky he didn't get an F for the course. I felt lucky, too, because it could well have been me because I of course hadn't cited the text as the source of the ideas I expressed in my paper, either. It was a good lesson which I've never forgotten.
Ralph,
Believe it or not, even juniors and seniors in college plagiarize. I just graded the first batch of papers for my class and rejected about 80% for not using citations properly.
There is much emphasis right now on stopping plagiarism, and I can't just let it go like I used to. It is also a disservice to the students who think they can get away with it. It is almost all just laziness.
Great hub - very informative and clearly set out. Sounds like you're a good, tough instructor.
This hub has both inspired and challenged me. When citing the References would it be along the lines of: Author, Date of Publication, Article Title/Magazine/Book, Retrieved Date, URL ?
Darkside,
It really depends on which format you are using. I am using APA. There are several formats. I am going to write another hub on citing references, so hold on a bit.
For now though, I would make sure, name, title, and source are included. There is no law regarding this, just convention.














darkside says:
17 months ago
This is an excellent article.
So, when are you going to publish a hub on "How to properly cite your sources and avoid plagiarism"? :D
Should References be hyperlinked if they're attirbuting a webpage? I'm just curious about how better to educate online content producers and what rules apply and if there's no specific rules what guidelines would you recommend?