What's all the hubbub about Sacramento's Tent City?
76
The scene
A few weekends ago, my girlfriend and I took a long run down the American River Bike Trail in Sacramento. It's one of the most beautiful adornments of the region - a paved bike trail along a greenbelt that follows the winding passage of the Sierra-snow fed river as it makes its way down through the valley to meet up with the Sacramento River.
I normally jog several days a week, but because we were so lost in conversation, I was unaware just how far we'd run. We stayed on the trail until we crossed over the river on a footbridge near Del Paso Boulevard, teasing and chasing each other along the way. Suddenly, as we came to the City side of the bridge, we saw the sea of tents splayed out beside the river and north of the cityscape. It was an interesting site, and initially disarming. We just kept on the trail (actually I did my tough guy stance while she laughed and said she'd protect me!)
It was midday on a Sunday, and I didn't feel particularly unsafe. But I did suddenly remember this was an area that had been in the news sometime in the recent past. It actually looked at least as nice as many of the camping areas I've paid good money to stay in - the only concerning thing was passing a couple arguing about who was the bigger druggie.
The news
For some reason, Tent City suddenly attracted widespread media attention, as an emblem of the economic downturn. Oprah decided to do a segment on Tent City to "humanize" the challenges people are facing in our harsh economy and former Sacramentan Lisa Ling came to town to interview some folks: http://www.oprah.com/article/oprahshow/20090218_tows_lisa-ling/1.
I didn't see the story, but following the Oprah report, news stations from around the globe immediately jumped on the salacious story. I have read several news feeds on prominent news channels explaining how the economy has gotten so bad it's forced homeowners out of their homes into the homeless camps. Reports throughout the globe are reporting upward of 1,200 people at the encampment, and images are being splashed all over the news, comparing this with the shantytowns of the Great Depression (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/worldnews/article-1159677/Pictured-The-credit-crunch-tent-city-returned-haunt-America.html).
It's really interesting to see your city in an international context with comparative photos like the one on the below.
Is it real or is it Memorex?
Pretty dismal stuff, huh? My parents were raised during the Great Depression, and the impact of this terribly sad time lasted throughout their lifetimes. I've seen photos, I've heard the descriptions, and I've gotten a sense of what it was like during that time. I'm reminded of the imagery from the movie, Cinderella Man, which I felt captured the desperate feelings of that time. Back then, none of our economic systems that we enjoy today were in place. AVERAGE people were living in shantytowns, not just the occasional person who had a string of bad luck. That doesn't make it right, but it does bear some reflection.
Things aren't great right now. Many people - myself included - have had to give up their homes and find other arrangements. It's not good, and I am in no way minimizing that. I think the key here; however, is not to automatically assume everything you hear, in the way you hear it, is completely accurate. We love to be shocked, and there is a proliferation of alarmists in our midst who are anxious to be able to report on the Story of the Century (which changes each week.) I enjoy briefly scanning the collection of headlines of the gossip magazines as I check out at the grocery counter. It's entertaining, but I've learned to discern that some images are real, and some are, perhaps, a little colorized . . .
Like all major cities, Sacramento has a grand plan for dealing with homelessness, which isn't perfect, and clearly isn't error-proof. News reports say there are from 1,200 to 2,000 people at the camp, when in reality there a mere fraction of that, even less when the cameras aren't there.
Here are some local sources that give some perspective on the issue:
Some news organizations are erroneously portraying the tent city "as a refugee camp" for formerly middle-class people who have been hit by the recession, said Tim Brown of the Sacramento Ending Chronic Homeless Initiative.
"While it's very true that we are seeing increasing numbers of middle-class families hitting the streets, it's still a very small percentage," Brown said. "At tent city, 90 percent of the people are chronically homeless."
- Sacramento Bee, March 14, 2009
"Sacramento is the best place to go to get from the gutter on up," said Charles Washington, a recent tent-city resident who is from Vacaville. Over lunch at Loaves & Fishes, he said: "There are a lot of resources here. That's why I came."
- Marcos Breton, Sacramento Bee, March 15, 2009
UPDATE MARCH 20, 2009: Homeless campers to be moved out of Tent City: http://www.sacbee.com/ourregion/story/1714909.html
UPDATE MARCH 25, 2009: Sacramento City Council OK's $1 million for homeless beds: http://www.sacbee.com/ourregion/story/1726620.html
UPDATE APRIL 3, 2009: Bedding sought for Tent City campers moving to Cal Expo (new housing): http://www.sacbee.com/ourregion/story/1751944.html
UPDATE APRIL 14, 2009: Dismantling of tent city begins: http://www.sacbee.com/ourregion/story/1778031.html
So, what now?
Clearly, the story has struck a nerve. It just seems a little specious, when looking at it from a local angle.
So, putting aside the rhetoric, I decided to provide some real resources here, so that anyone who is truly interested in the issue can take action and not just put their faces to the window pane and gasp:
1. Go straight to Sacramento's Loaves and Fishes, which operates a generous campaign to feed and shelter the homeless and donate time or money: http://www.sacloaves.org/
2. For a truly impactful donation, make one to the Mustard Seed School for homeless children here: http://www.sacloaves.org/programs/mustardseedschool/
3. Review and support Emergency Shelters in Sacramento at http://www.communitycouncil.org/level-4/InfoLine-Sacramento/lists/emer_shelters.pdf (or locate them in your own community and steer your energies there.)
4. Don't perpetuate the problem of alarmist overreaction to the problems of our economy. Start by reading here: http://hubpages.com/hub/The-Economics-of-Happiness
5. As long as you're interested, buy some real estate here - we can use the economic stimulation!
6. Be well ~
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
Thanks, AEvans - I sincerely appreciate your comment, though it wasn't really what I wanted to draw attention to! I was fortunate to be able to negotiate a wise and fiscally-responsible solution in my case, and I'll be fine as well! The big thing for me is just for all of us to keep focusing on solutions and not fan the flames of the problem. Consumer confidence is a real phenomena that we need to respect, which was the focus of my "economics" hub! ;-)
It angers me, as well, to insinuate that tent cities or homeless camps are the result of our current economy, or that they are filling up with middle class Americans who have recently lost their homes or jobs. These homeless communities existed long before our economic downturn, and will remain the result of chronically homeless people, a majority who are mentally ill and/or addicts of one kind or another.
The attempts of the media to sensationalize and connect the challenges of our middle class, with the horrors faced by the people in homeless camps, is outrageous and wrong. It minimizes the severity of both problems, as well as the attention and services needed to correct them. The recovery of our economy alone will not do that.
These are difficult times, no doubt. We all want an effective way out of this recession, hopefully with a more solid solution than consumerism.
Thanks for the comment, Midtown Girl!
You're right the story has been sensationalized to some extent; for instance, there are only some hundreds of people there at the most. I know; I've been there and have written a short hub about it. Yours is much more comprehensive than mine. Good job, local yokel!!!
Hey there Kosmo - thanks for chiming in! You're not related to Kramer from Seinfeld, are you? ;-) Yeah, you may have noticed I put in the hub a bunch of nice pics from the Sac area, the bike trail, etc. I, like many Sacramentans don't like our city disparaged, especially all the way across the world! Thanks for commenting - for anyone else who may be reading this comment, here's a link to yours: http://hubpages.com/hub/Depression-Blues-Tent-Citi
G













AEvans says:
9 months ago
You are the first that has openly admitted that you had to give up your home, believe me I am second to what you have said. However we are surviving I had told my husband just the other day, if we won the lottery I would purchase a few homes from the auctions and give them back to the people. If they lost vehicles same thing as they entire situation is horrible. :(