Why Christians and Muslims Can't Get Along
80What do I know?
Like most other American Christians, I can't claim to know much about Islam. I took a two-month class on the religion in college, and learned a bit about it in high school, but other than that, I have had no immersion into the religion, and only see it through the lens of the war.
But let's focus on what we do know. Muhammad was a normal and pious man, born around 570 C.E., married to an older woman, living his life when the angel Gabriel came to him and ordered him to recite. The Qur'an is the result of this recitation from illiterate Muhammad. The Qur'an is the living word of God, similar to how Christ is the living word to the Christian God. Muslims worship only God, Islam means "submission to God," and Muhammad was a prophet, just as Abraham, Jesus, and all the Old Testament prophets were.
Out of the Qur'an comes the Five Pillars. They are 1) Confessing faith in one God, 2) Prayer five times a day, 3) Alms-giving, 4) Fasting at Ramadan, and 5) hajj, which is a pilgrimage to Mecca, a historically relevant city to the Muslim faith.
Sunnis follow Muhammad's example. Shiites follow Muhammad's example but also, long ago, chose to follow the example of Muhammad's descendants, like Ali, Muhammad's son-in-law.
Jihad means "struggle." It is not holy war, but it can be. It puts a name to the inner struggle each Muslim goes through to submit to God rather than follow their own ego.
Muslims believe that humans were created with fitra--a good framework everyone is born with, but that many people forget and get distracted from the true path. This negates the need for a Savior, unlike Christianity, which is a religion based on the saving blood of Christ. All one needs to do to be saved in the Islam faith is to follow the Five Pillars.
Treatment of Women
We look at Muslim women covered head to toe, living under strict rules and say the religion and culture is oppressing them. Muslims look at American women wearing next to nothing on TV and billboards, putting all their worth in their bodies, and say American culture and Christianity are objectifying and oppressing their women. Both sides argue that their women are better off.
These differences will always bother the modern, democratic West as well as the traditional, Islamic East. It overlaps into all the question both religions ask: do we move forward with our ideas and technology, or do we try to go back to the way things were in the Bible or in Muhammad's time? No text or living example can tell us what to do about stem cell research. The ambiguity in both Christian and Islam doctrine create unanswerable questions and unnegotiable relations between nations.
But we look at the stories of Muslim men killing their sisters because they were raped, or seen with a man who wasn't part of the family, and we Westerners cannot condone it due to cultural difference. How can two civilizations agree to disagree when innocent people die? It is difficult to know when to intervene with another nation.
Yet, many Muslim women feel hopeful that they will attain more freedoms as time goes by. Only a hundred years ago in the US, women weren't allowed to vote. How can we rush other cultures to catch up to us?
Violence and Jihad
Another reason Christians and Muslims can't get along is violence. The unforgettable attacks and counterattacks of the last decade have shown us that people will fight and die for their religion. Christians and Americans question Muslims: how is your religion peaceful when so much war and killing has happened since its beginning?
Muslims turn around and ask us the same thing. Christianity has a history of violence, too. The US has turned to violence to get what it has wanted.
But why did Islam extremists attack us? As Western thought and modernism spread, along with American culture, to almost every nation, Muslims cannot help but see these new ways of thinking and living as imposing on their religious tradition. When we try to make their religious governments into democracies, they don't see it as a gift of freedom, they see it as an attack on their religion. When the World Trade Centers fell down and fingers were pointed to Al Qaeda, Christians too felt their religion was being attacked. Christians tend to tie up their religious conviction with patriotism, and freedom has become a synonym for the American way of life.
The majority on both sides want peace. But both sides are also called to spread their religion to all nations. Dedicated Muslims and Christians alike will fight for what they believe is right. This is the cause of the clash.
What Can We Do?
We have only dipped into this topic, and have already found material for endless debate. What can we do with this rising issue?
- For now, the best thing to do is to learn as much as we can about Islam. We must stay updated on what is going on in Islamic countries and we must hush our assumptions and listen for awhile.
- Understand and remember that there is fear on both sides. Western culture has become a force, a blind pillar of great evil to many other cultures in the world. Muslims also understand little about us. They fear us as much as we may fear them.
- Find the beauty in Islam. Instead of looking for its faults, look at it for inspiration for your own faith. How do Muslims find happiness? Looking for the positive aspects, we will have more than enough to love about this other culture.
- Talk about it with as many people as possible. Really listen to what other people are saying, and be respectful while still arguing your point. Communication is always the first step, and most of the time, we cannot even manage that. Let's start the discussion.
Start with These Books:
|
|
Islam and the Muslim Community (Religious Traditions of the World)
A comprehensive introduction with which to learn the bare bones of Islam.
Price: $5.90
List Price: $15.95 |
|
|
Islam (Opposing Viewpoints Series)
A good resource for exercising debate skills: see both sides and ponder with this easy-to-read book.
Price: $22.95
List Price: $34.95 |
|
Islam: Religion, History, and Civilization
Nasr is a wonderful writer and knows his stuff. He has a profound understanding of Islam.
Price: $6.15
List Price: $13.99 |
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
Thank you for your comment! It was very enlightening. I hear you saying that the oppression that happens to men and women (really anywhere) is strictly cultural. I think that's a good point. But culture cannot be without religion and vice versa. They affect each other--deeply.
As for the counter-example of Catholic nuns, I wasn't speaking negatively from a personal standpoint about modesty. I think modesty is extremely important and empowering for women. I admire Muslim women who make the choice of modesty just as I admire Christian women who make that choice.
Lastly, THANK YOU for the point about our media. It tries to breed fear in Americans and is no help in understanding other cultures. I'm glad you commented on my page and are working to break misconceptions Americans have.
Interesting opinions.
We can go along in certain areas such as trade and education. However, there are some Western values that we cannot accept at all.
For your information, the Holy Bible and Holy Quran both prohibits Interest charges (usury) on loan. Commandment that we can agree on.
According to the Jewish Torah and Christian Bible (Old Testament),
The second book of Moses, Exodus Chapter 22:25 stated that charging of interest on loans is strictly prohibited by God:
“If thou lend money to any of my people that is poor by thee, thou shalt not be to him as a usurer, neither shalt thou lay him usury.”
Deuteronomy 23:19-20 :
“Thou shalt not lend upon usury to thy brother; usury of money, usury of victuals, usury of anything that is lent upon usury. Unto a stranger thou mayest lend upon usury; but unto thy brother shalt not lend upon usury…”
Surah Al-Baqarah verse 278 - 280
278. O you who believe! Be afraid of Allâh and give up what remains (due to you) from Ribâ (usury) (from now onward), if you are (really) believers.
279. And if you do not do it, then take a notice of war from Allâh and His Messenger but if you repent, you shall have your capital sums. Deal not unjustly (by asking more than your capital sums), and you shall not be dealt with unjustly (by receiving less than your capital sums).
280. And if the debtor is in a hard time (has no money), then grant him time till it is easy for him to repay, but if you remit it by way of charity, that is better for you if you did but know.
Whether you want build a bridge or wall it depends to the individual themself and also the goverment policy.
At least we can get along in writing hubpages :)
TurnipTornado has written the above articles, evidently, after a lot of hard work and research, however sister sumaiyah's observation is due to her personal experience, which is hard to ignore, which is the reason why I am sure that TurnipTornado, got the message and thanked her. I think this, exchange of ideas, refutes the Caption of the article
"Why Christians and Muslims Can't Get Along".Let us go on ...
Oh yes, my title is a reverse-psychology title. Of course we can get along!
This is a good and nice hub. You tried to be as controversial as possible. In as much as one should undersand each other's religion, it should be not be forced on anyone. I have nothing against the muslim religion but the fact remains that there are certain things they do that are inhuman. Most of them are extremists. The way their women dress makes me sick. Recently in Nigeria, a certain muslim group woke up one day that they were against western education. They succeeded in killing 1000s of innocent citizens, let alone the properties that were destroyed. Imaine someone with such thinking in this modern world.
Thank you for sharing this story and of course your sincere approach on the religion of Islam. After forty years as a devoted christian I embraced Islam after studying it for two years, am I peace with my decision and continue to love all of God's creation as a white American Muslim I have truly found my place among the Muslim Community. It's been a rough road no doubt, but my love for Kingdom of God moves me beyond words. I send my Salam to you all and hope and pray that we all find some common ground. Peace and Blessing you and all who read this.
You are an intelligent, writer of excellence with a sharp eye. Bully for you! I enjoyed your work here. And I am originally from Michigan, too. St. Joseph.















sumaiyah says:
6 months ago
You spoke of a Muslim woman's dress as being "covered from head to toe" in the same sentence/paragraph denoting oppression and strictness from the religion. Yet there are Catholic nuns who wear a habit, who are also "covered from head to toe" because of their religious beliefs and no one calls these Catholic nuns oppressed. Yes, I know the habit is now optional. I was still Catholic when the ruling came down that relaxed a nun's attire. However, there are many nuns who still wear the habit due to their beliefs. Why are they not spoken of in terms of oppression? And we won't even begin to discuss the strictness of this Christian faith...
Islam is a religion that is equally strict on men and women. Anything that you see in the media is a combination of only what the media wants you to see (the hype) and believe of Islam as well as a depiction of oppressive cultural habits that are blamed on Islam. Any form of oppression against men or women in Islam is strictly cultural. It has absolutely nothing to do with the religion of Islam itself.
Nuns can't marry. They wear a habit (or at least dress modestly). They live in a convent (or other group living situation). They work where the archbishop tells them to go work. Muslimahs can marry. They wear clothing that is not revealing or tight fitting. They live where they choose. They marry who they choose. They work where/when/if they choose. Their husbands are required by Allah (swt) to support the household -- which includes them, the kids, and all the bills -- even if the wife works. Who appears to be oppressed?
I enjoyed the article. My views on the insinuation that Muslim women are oppressed are a little deep-rooted because it's very tiring to believe that grown folk are still believing the hype that the West calls news...