create your own

Writing requires reading

72
rate or flag this page

By Storytellersrus


Chicken or egg?

Readers are writers

"They're burning tires in the pits again. I can't see them cause I'm hided, but I can smell them all thick and hot and fiery like pepper and smoke and wet thunderhorses mixed together." From Copper Elephant by Adam Rapp

Sometimes life isn't intense chaos and fear. Sometimes life is small moments: hands holding hands across the dinner table.

My characters are not Adam's characters but I participate in a writing practice as I read his work. Both reading and writing require deep linguistic processing. There is an entire body of study within the field of education studying the reading-writing connection and a few basic hypothesis as to how these two disciplines interact.

First, there is the directional model which suggests that concepts a student discovers in the reading process may be applied to writing, i.e., if I read Adam Rapp prose, I might apply his sophisticated use of language to my own writing. If I focus on nursery rhymes, my writing will reflect this achievement. Therefore, reading quality writing is a must for a writer who wishes to grow her work.

The underlying assumption in the directional model is that reading and writing are separate systems rather than one cohesive whole. Reading skills inform writing like walking skills inform snowboarding prowess, i.e., a good walker doesn't necessarily snowboard well and a handicapped skier might win trophies but isn't a good walker, even though both disciplines involve the lower extremities.

This model is called directional because the transference goes in one direction- from reading to writing. Some theorize it works in the opposite direction. These academics suggest that studying sentence, paragraph and discourse structure aids reading. I think a better name for this theory is The Linear Method.

The second model proposes that transference of information occurs in both directions and is called the nondirectional hypothesis. Whoever came up with these names is void of imagination. Couldn't they at least call the second a partnership?

Because both writing and reading require an "interactive and dynamic activation, instantiation and refinement of schemata" researcher Shanahan reports, "it is possible that instruction in one would lead to improvement in the other."


Subtext

You are writing a conversation back at me as you read.  Admit it!
You are writing a conversation back at me as you read. Admit it!

I digress

What I am really interested in is the LATERAL method. As Wikipedia says, "Critical thinking is primarily concerned with judging the truth value of statements and seeking errors. Lateral thinking is more concerned with the movement value of statements and ideas. A person would use lateral thinking when they want to move from one known idea to creating new ideas."

So here is my theory. Well, maybe it isn't my theory. Maybe I read it somewhere but just can't pinpoint it in the World Wide Web. Or maybe I expanded on it. Either way, I am going to have to wing it here because I can't find anything in this moment that backs up my lateral movement to a concept called Readers ARE Writers.

Consider what happens when you read the paragraph above, written by Adam Rapp. Well, I will reprint it to make things easier.

"They're burning tires in the pits again. I can't see them cause I'm hided, but I can smell them all thick and hot and fiery like pepper and smoke and wet thunderhorses mixed together."

When I read this opening paragraph, my imagination kicks into gear and I begin to write a subtext.

I have spent most of the morning searching for abstracts like, "Reading is rocket science" and my intellect is fried so I am going with Wikipedia here, okay? Wikipedia says "Subtext is content of a book, play, musical work, film, video game or television series which is not announced explicitly by the characters (or author) but is implicit or becomes something understood by the observer of the work as the production unfolds."

If it is something understood by the observer, then the observer plays a part in writing this subtext.

Shelly Lowenkopf wrote this poem on the subject:

Subtext

What is said is up here.

What is meant is down here.

Way down. Like about here.

That about sums up my Readers are Writers theory.

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

Ralph Deeds profile image

Ralph Deeds  says:
7 months ago

Writing certainly does require reading. Writing something that's worth reading requires knowledge acquired by reading and observing the people and things around you that provide something to write about. I've found also that writing comes easier about something I care a lot about and something in which I have more than a superficial interest.

Learning to write then requires practice, and a good teacher is helpful. I wrote for my high school paper. It was edited by Miss Mary Loup who must have felt considerable concern that any shoddy grammar, construction or misspellings would reflect unfavorably on her. Neither before nor since have I experienced such vigorous editing of anything I've written. In college I wrote a lot of papers which usually were graded with a letter but with few constructive comments on the quality of my writing. This was true in nearly all courses except for one in expository writing in which the comments were detailed and constructive. I recall one exercise in which we were assigned to write a short essay perhaps of a couple or three pages followed by a coherent paragraph composed of the topic sentences of each paragraph in the essay. I've also found White and Strunk's "The Elements of Style" helpful.

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus  says:
7 months ago

Hello Ralph and thanks for your suggestions! Reading and writing go hand in hand in my book.

Editing is a tough job and I don't envy anyone the task.  I edited an innovative church magazine for three years and it was personally painful to have to send something back for revision.  I'd much rather revise my own pieces and receive constructive comments on my work than send feedback in red ink. 

In graduate school we had workshops where we sat face to face with fellow students.  There we were able to ask for clarification from those who critiqued us and watch the faces of those we critiqued for signs of distress or confusion.

Writing is such a personal experience.  Professionals will say, "it's not personal" when they rip your piece to shreds, but novices like me have invested so much of ourselves in a piece of writing that this separation of person from product must be practiced before the concept penetrates!

BirteEdwards profile image

BirteEdwards  says:
7 months ago

As you said there are different types of writing. You are the story teller, but others are the analysts.

In both cases, reading is necessary. However, you can be a story teller without being a writer, as it was done for thousands of years before writing was invented.

I liked very much the information on subtext. This is a subject not many know about, but I believe it is extremely important in all forms of writing

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus  says:
7 months ago

Birte, I agree totally that storytellers in the past weren't writers.  I didn't even think of this when I was writing my Hub, so thanks for bringing it up! 

I am a member of a local chapter of storytellers in my area called Spellbinders.  Have you heard of it?  The entire purpose of the group is to keep oral tradition alive.  I find when I tell stories directly to the children, I embellish according to their responses.  It is very interesting.  I haven't been available to do schools, but I did do a very cool park event recently and told a Zuni legend about ants. 

uzamaki  says:
7 months ago

Well my teacher recommends that we read several books before writing a story about the cetain topic especially if there are metaphorical writing.

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus  says:
7 months ago

uzamaki, sounds like you have a wise teacher! is this background information to help flesh out the story?

JPSO138 profile image

JPSO138  says:
5 months ago

Very interesting indeed. I agree that reading can certainly improve the writing skills. It will also give the writer more ideas on different topics. Great hub.

loua profile image

loua  says:
3 months ago

I like your analogy of the myopic vs the open-mindedness of one who focuses on the linear equation rather than the sum of the parts. To read is to grasp the writers intent; and its not in the words its between the words ~ something a writer knows...Some people don't like to digest more than they can comprehend so they do not write nor do they venture far in their minds...

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus  says:
3 months ago

JP reading does expand writing as it expands horizons- great point.

loua you are so right about the meaning between the words! i wrote a piece in graduate school about how the meaning was in the negative space rather than the black type. thanks for your deepened insight into this matter.

tonymac04 profile image

tonymac04  says:
3 months ago

Thanks for this interesting Hub. I love writing and reading and would fully support your hypothesis. I love this quote from Stephen King (though I'm not really a great fan of his, but this quote is great):

“You can approach the act of writing with nervousness, excitement, hopefulness, or even despair; the sense that you can never completely put on the page what’s in your mind and heart. You can come to the act with your fists clenched and your eyes narrowed, ready to kick ass and take down names. You can come to it because you want a girl to marry you or because you want to change the world. Come to it any way but lightly. Let me say it again: you must not come lightly to the blank page.”

Love and peace

Tony

Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus  says:
3 months ago

Coming lightly to the blank page might add a bit of openness and whimsy, don't you think?

I have to say this, as I also am not a fan of the heavy handed King of horror, though I respect him.

queen cleopatra profile image

queen cleopatra  says:
10 days ago

I am not much of a writer but I am a voracious reader. I read anything even when I couldn't understand sometimes. Reading sharpens the mind. Thank you for this enlightening hub about writers and readers. The comments are all informative, too. :)

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working